Cognitive Approach
(Cognitive approach concentrates on how our mind works – looks at internal mental processes such as attention, thinking and
memory. It sees human mind like a computer that receives information, proce
...
Cognitive Approach
(Cognitive approach concentrates on how our mind works – looks at internal mental processes such as attention, thinking and
memory. It sees human mind like a computer that receives information, processes it and gives response)
Andrade Laney Baron-Cohen
Why was carried out To test whether doodling aids
concentration, measured by
recall performance on memory
test (no prior studies).
No previous research has
investigated the false beliefs for
a positive event and explored
consequences; to investigate
positive false memory effects
by suggesting to participants
that they had loved asparagus
as children.
To investigate theory of mind in
AS/HFA. To improve original
study which had problems: only
two options so 50% chance of
guessing; some were too easy,
could have been solved by eye
direction; more females than
males; Only opposite choices;
No glossary.
Aim To see whether doodling
improves or hinders
concentration.
To investigate a positive false
memory effects by suggesting
to participants that they had
loved asparagus as children; To
explore consequences of false
positive memory and its
underlying mechanism.
To replicate previous study; to
test whether there was
negative correlation between
the scores on eyes test and
autism spectrum; to test
whether females scored better
on eyes test than males.
Behavior investigated -Whether doodling affects
concentration
-By hindering or improving it
-Does doodling distract
attention away from task
-Or improve performance by
aiding arousal.
-Whether a memory for false
positive event could be
implanted
-Whether telling a subject that
they had loved asparagus as
children led them to self-report
a belief that this was true
-Theory of mind
-Whether autistic adults can
read emotion in the eyes
-Whether autistic adults score
low in the Eyes test and high on
the AQ test
-Whether there is gender
memory
-Whether a false positive belief
for asparagus led to
consequences such as
willingness to order it in
restaurant.
difference.
Why cognitive approach Andre studies cognitive process
of attention and how a
secondary task such as
doodling may hinder/improve
performance on a primary task,
if doodling will aid
concentration assessed by
memory task.
Laney studies cognitive process
of memory. Tries to implant
positive false memory for
loving asparagus as a child and
the consequences of this in
terms of whether someone
would order it in restaurant
and in exp.2 whether the
picture of asparagus made it
more appealing.
Baron-Cohen is investigating
cognitive process of Theory of
mind in AS/HFA through eyes
test, which measures first stage
of theory of mind – attributing a
relevant mental state.
IV and DV IV: doodling and non-doodling
DV: Mean correct recall, false
alarms and memory scores.
IV: love group and control
group; believers and nonbelievers
DV: ratings on critical items on
both questionnaires in sessions
1&2, comparison.
IV: autistic or not; males or
females
DV: Scores on eyes test and AQ.
Sample Opportunity sampling; 40
subjects, only 5 males; UK.
Volunteer sampling; received
credit for participating; 128
undergraduates 77% females
(exp.1); 103 undergraduates –
received course credits (exp. 2)
Group 1-volunteer sampling via
magazine, 15 males AS/HFA;
Group 2-opportunity sampling,
122 normal adults from Exeter
or Cambridge public library
users;
Group 3-opportunity sampling,
103 undergraduates at
Cambridge university (53
males 50 females);
Group 4-random sampling, 14
randomly selected adults who
were matched for IQ with
group 1.
How was data collected (Quantitative data) By asking
them to listen to tape and write
down the names of ppl
attending party; in surprise
memory test asked them to
recall names of ppl and places
mentioned in the tape.
Questionnaires: FHI;
Restaurant questionnaires and
others; then same
questionnaires again and
others (like food cost
questionnaire; memory or
belief), exp.2 rated
photographs. +Questionnaires.
Some participants were asked
to complete AQ test (self-report
questionnaire), all of them had
to look at pictures of people
and complete eyes test –
multiple-choice questionnaires.
Findings -In number of correct names
written down doodling scored
more (7.8) than control (7.1)
-On memory test on names
doodling scored mean more
(7.5) than Control (5.8).
-In exp.1 subjects in love
condition had higher mean
rating (4.20) for loving
asparagus in the post test
compared to pre-test results
(1.70) in FHI
-In post test FHI participants in
love condition had higher mean
score (4.20) than control group
(2.52)
-In Eyes test AS/HFA group (1)
scored 21.9 wile matched
group (4) scored significantly
higher 30.9
-In AQ test AS/HFA group (1)
scored 34.4 while matched
group scored significantly
lower 18.9.
Conclusions -People in doodling condition
concentrated better on primary
task than ppl who only listened
to tape, nothing else
-Doodling aids concentration
-Doodling may help to stabilize
-Exp. 1 concluded that it is
possible to implant false
positive memory
-Exp. 1 concluded that
implanting false positive beliefs
leads to consequences (e.g.
-AS/HFA group score
significantly high on AQ test but
significantly low on eyes test
compared to general
population
-AS/HFA has difficulties in
arousal
-May reduce daydreaming
more likely to order in
restaurant)
-Exp. 2 concluded that those
who believed false feedback
were more likely to rate
asparagus more appetizing
[Show More]