Balanced Scorecard
The company’s use of Kaplan and Norton’s Balanced Scorecard has been credited with
contributing to its success. The performance of every business division is assessed
from four perspectives (see App
...
Balanced Scorecard
The company’s use of Kaplan and Norton’s Balanced Scorecard has been credited with
contributing to its success. The performance of every business division is assessed
from four perspectives (see Appendix D). This has allowed the business to avoid
short-termism in its approach to decision-making.
A new boss
Martin Smith retired at the end of 2019. He has been replaced by Elaine Filer, Sunport
PLC’s former Chief Finance Officer. Elaine has a reputation as a leader who makes
decisions herself and then tells managers what to do. She is expected to drive through
a strategic change focused on increasing profit margins throughout the business. Her
view is that personal care is the most successful division in Europe. Elaine wants every
division in the business to achieve an operating profit margin of 12%. This should help
to please a small group of unhappy shareholders who are concerned that the
company’s returns could be higher if the senior managers prioritised profit over other
social responsibilities.
A strategy for the future
Although the company is not expected to abandon its socially responsible approach,
Elaine has announced her intention to introduce cost reduction measures including:
• centralising decision-making at Head Office, which would remove some duplicated
activities, such as the selection of suppliers
• changing to cheaper suppliers
• reducing spending on initiatives designed to improve the company’s environmental
performance, including abandoning the company’s current aim of only using
recyclable materials in its packaging.
30
35
40
45
Appendix A Sunport PLC selected financial results
2016 2017 2018 2019
Sales turnover (£bn) 48 51 52 54
Operating profit (£bn) 4.6 4.5 4.8 5.1
Average operating profit margin of major rivals in 2019 = 12%4
IB/G/Jun20/7132/3
Appendix B Sunport PLC market research data on food buying in various regions (2020)
Three most important issues for food
shoppers PLC’s Index food of Sunport prices
First Second Third (Europe = 100)
Europe Taste Recyclable
packaging
Value for
money
100
North America Branding Speed of
preparation Taste 118
Rest of the world Value for
money
Taste Branding 84
Appendix C Quotes from a recent article on the global food industry in a business
magazine
‘food manufacturers who have centralised manufacturing facilities have found any economies of
scale in production are cancelled out by increased transport costs’
‘transporting food products long distances is very expensive as products can be bulky, fragile,
perishable or require refrigeration’
Appendix D Selected data for Sunport PLC – European region, 2019
Perspective Measure Household
cleaning
Personal
care
Food
Financial Operating profit margin (%) 9.7 12.2 8.8
Learning and
growth
Staff retention (%) 88 74 76
% of employees who are proud
to work for Sunport PLC 90 65 85
Internal
processes
% of recyclable materials used
in packaging 100 55 85
New products in development 12 10 12
Customers
% of customers who would
recommend Sunport PLC
products to a friend
90 80 75
[Show More]