HSM-543 Week 4 Discussion: Capital Budgeting
Week 4 – Thread 1 - Capital Budgeting (graded)
Capital budgeting is needed to properly allocate the large dollar amounts for major expansion and equipment purchases. The pro
...
HSM-543 Week 4 Discussion: Capital Budgeting
Week 4 – Thread 1 - Capital Budgeting (graded)
Capital budgeting is needed to properly allocate the large dollar amounts for major expansion and equipment purchases. The process is often perceived by employees as being very political. What procedures should an organization use to eliminate that perception and to provide for a good, consistent evaluation of capital projects?
This section lists options that can be used to view responses. Collapse All Print View Show Options
Responses
Responses are listed below in the following order: response, author and the date and time the response is posted.
Sort by Read/Unread Sort by Response Sorted Ascending, click to sort descending Sort by Author Sort by Date/Time*
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/23/2016 12:19:51 AM
Class, what might be an example of mistakes which are made in capital budgeting? Thanks, Craig.
Class, what might be an example of mistakes which are made in capital budgeting? Thanks, Craig.
Class, what might be an example of mistakes which are made in capital budgeting? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Margaret Daughtry Email this Author7/24/2016 9:22:15 PM
Possible example of mistakes that can be made in capital budgeting is over expenditure of the funds that are available for equipment and such things.
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/26/2016 6:43:14 PM
Margaret, I have also seen that when managers overestimate, they receive monthly budgets that are too large. By the end of the month they find they have not spent their allocations.
Class, what would you think occurs in this situation? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Christina McLaughlin Email this Author7/26/2016 8:35:46 PM
I would think that it doesn't make the manager look good, make them look like they didn't know how to figure their budget in the first place
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Margaret Daughtry Email this Author7/27/2016 9:02:25 AM
I agree with Christina, that if the manager overestimates what is needed for the project he is making a fool of himself and should learn to do his job better or ask for help if he is not to proud to do so.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Neil McCann Email this Author 7/27/2016 9:10:13 PM
Yes, I have seen this with the Pentagon. The generals and staff are like spoiled children that never have to count their dollars and cents. Often times when they get the numbers they will say they don't like them come back with better numbers.
Many of the agencies rush to spend what they have left in their coffers because if they leave monies in their accounts budgets will cut the next cycle. This is counter productive because every quarter they ask for more and more. Many times what they order is just over head supplies that they already have. When I worked there they would always start ordering helicopter blades and truck tires with whatever they had left. The government does nothing to real in spending and it is so difficult to cut the budgets without organizations like the OMB to enforce it. The only way to stop the cycle is to wait for people to retire and not rehire. Many times non productivity is rewarded. When I was a contractor one guy had his office and he would play on the computer and talk with family all week and then on Fridays his big job was to collect time sheets. This took him about 20 minutes then he went back to his routine.
http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/the-federal-government-is-too-big-to- work/article/2567987
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Jennifer Boren Email this Author 7/28/2016 7:10:03 PM
When managers overestimate, they end up starting the next month at a deficit. When forced to start a deficit, the expenses on some items end up getting funding removed or reduced. The act of starting at a deficit shows the manager is not allotting enough funds to enough items or not ensuring enough income through accounts receivables. Managers who don't manage their accounts receivables well jeopardize the health of the company in the long run.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. Health Administration Press, 06/2011. VitalBook file.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Ban Alshahin Email this Author 7/29/2016 12:27:25 PM
I agree with you Jennifer and my other classmates that when managers overestimate they end up looking foolish. It also makes them lack credibility. As a manager, it is their job to make sure that the company's expenses does not go into deficit. If a manager overestimates then they may jeopardize the health of the company as you mentioned Jennifer. That's why it's very important to have a plan and be careful as to how and where money is spent. Overestimating the budget may also lead the company into using funds from other departments which can lead to more problems.
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/30/2016 12:47:46 AM
Good example Ben as when all managers overestimate this has a huge effect on the overall system, regards, Craig
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/29/2016 9:33:25 PM
Too much of a variance in both direction does not look good for the department/manager or the company. We always budget the work on a monthly basis and then when we run short due to higher sick calls/vacation then w have to
find resources to make sure we complete the task and utilize the estimated budget. Positive or negative variance requires explanation to the client.
Thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Steven Shanab Email this Author 7/25/2016 7:01:17 AM
Capital budgeting: the process used to convert the operating plan into budgets for capital expenditures (Nowicki 266)
The article I have attached below explains that there are two types of error: type 1 and type 2, which came from statistics. In capital budgeting, a type 1 error is one where you choose to not partake in an endeavor that would have actually made money, whereas type 2 is one where you partake in an endeavor that turns out to be a dud, making the company lose money. One example of a type 2 error is the company Copa di Vino, which sells wine in single-serve, resealable containers. It was rejected by the show Shark Tank, but it went on to produce $25 million in revenue.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. Health Administration Press, 06/2011. VitalBook file.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/capital-budgeting-concerns-66208.html
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gobankingrates/13-million-dollar- busines_b_7314710.html
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/25/2016 7:37:58 PM
Steven, good summary of your learning and examples. Class, here is a good article which defines some of the terms which we are discussing this week, regards, Craig.
http://cfatutor.me/2013/07/27/capital-budgeting-rules-npv-irr-payback- discounted-payback-aar/
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Ydannie Boncenor Email this Author7/27/2016 9:21:55 PM
An organization should set a criteria for capital projects that all employees will know, understand, and follow. The criteria for the evaluation of capital projects can be divided into two groups. Static criteria that consider mainly cash flows. They consider time in constraint mode and, in principle, they do not deal with risk.
Dynamic criteria that take into account all three factors, i.e. cash flows, service life and under- gone risk as well. They involve, for example, net present value, internal rate of return. Using set procedures will remove the politics.
Reference https://www.mruni.eu/upload/iblock/12a/svecova1doc.pdf
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Ydannie Boncenor Email this Author7/29/2016 5:31:02 PM
I agree. While this statement I found is not based on capital budgeting, it gives an example of type 1 and type ll errors. In the criminal justice system, defendants are assumed to be innocent until proven guilty. Thus, the null hypothesis is that the individual is innocent while the alternative is that the defendant actually committed the crime. A type I error would occur if the individual was convicted of a crime they didn’t commit. A type II would presents itself when a guilty man is set free.
Reference
http://healthcare-economist.com/2006/12/22/type-i-vs-type-ii-errors/
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Denise Bailey Email this Author 7/25/2016 11:53:17 AM
Hi All,
I think one example of mistake:
- Overestimating the cost of a project
-Estimating the time it would take for a project to be completed
-projecting what it cost for a project last year and not taking in the economy.
-allow consideration for errors that can which can lead to setbacks.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Bhoomi Shah Email this Author 7/25/2016 4:29:53 PM
Hello,
Capital budgeting means the process of analyzing how we are going to invest in the capital assets.i.e. it provides cash floe benefit for more than one year. As we all know that it has been said for capital budgeting that how we spend our money today determines the what our value will be tomorrow.A common way of looking at the present value for today is discounted cash flows, but we know that this approach is too narrow for evaluating a project properly, So what I understand from this is one should never force the discounted cash flows and should go through decision analysis, option prices and discounted cash flows .And this considered to be the biggest mistake made in financial management.
Source: Capital Budgeting Analysis Prepared by: Matt H. Evans, CPA, CMA, CFM
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/28/2016 7:42:13 PM
Class, also when starting a capital budget one must consider many factors including assumptions and external factors, regards, Craig
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Darla Ford Email this Author 7/25/2016 7:58:17 PM
@Denise! Great list
Increasing the rate of revenue/projected earnings – Sometimes companies become too optimistic in forecasting revenue growth. They tend to take high growth rates in future projections of income. Doing this can lead to the higher expected value of the company and also may exaggerate the value of the current/ future projects. Such inaccuracies are costly in the sense that the display in the area of significant capital or misinterpretation (lying) in such decisions will have an adverse impact on the success of any pending projects as well as the company as a whole.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Desiree Bell Email this Author 7/26/2016 7:25:29 PM
I like the list you have. I think these points are all very pertinent points of mistakes in capital budgeting. I can relate to some of these. Once doing a project, I made an
estimate of the cost of the project BUT did not factor in the rising costs in the economy. Property values were higher than before and this slowed down the completion date of the project because we had to rework the plan to accommodate the economy and the budget. This was a setback, also something that was not expected.
I think another mistake that happens in capital budgeting is ignoring cash flow budgets. Often times it is easy for people that are leading projects to only look at the operations of everything but forget the actual cash flow and to include that into everything.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? L. Alexander Email this Author 7/26/2016 4:05:27 PM
Many nurse leaders feel today that some of the cuts being made in healthcare by organizational leaders are shortsighted. But it sometimes takes a team of researchers outside of health care to paint a clear picture of some of the missteps that are being made to cut healthcare costs. In this month’s Harvard Business Review, researchers Robert Kaplan and Derek Maas do an excellent job of doing just that. Hospital administrators, they contend, typically work strictly from the line items on their profit and loss sheets to trim their budgets. Those at the front line of care are often never involved in decisions about where to cut costs. From their research, they identified some common mistakes.
One mistake is cutting support staff. In an effort to try to keep providers at the point of care, support staff are often the first positions to be cut. These researchers document that a specialist’s time is worth ten times that of support staff yet with the loss of support staff – they often take on clerical tasks that are time consuming and ultimately reduce their effectiveness. These researchers suggest that health administrators should build teams that allow every staff member to function at their highest scope of practice as much of the time as is possible. Arbitrary cuts in support staff results in professional staff becoming overstressed and frustrated – ultimately it is not cost effective.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Mohamad Allan Email this Author 7/26/2016 4:45:34 PM
Capital budgeting involves the outlay of large sums of money on projects to maintain, expand or streamline an organization. Capital projects are infrastructural activities such as building new facilities or replacing primary equipment, but they also include associated activities such as research and development or the stripping down of old equipment for spare parts. Because of the large-dollar nature of capital
projects, it's crucial to have a firm grasp of the financial logic of any capital project before proceeding.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/capital-budgeting-concerns-66208.html
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/26/2016 6:42:00 PM
Mo, class, also a wide range of factors should be examined when doing capital budgeting vs. just looking at last year's results and adding 10% growth :) Regards, Craig
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Neil McCann Email this Author 7/28/2016 8:16:18 PM
Risk planning is a big factor. You have to plan for the risks in the project and the market. For instance, you may want to take into consideration insuring the building project because of the risk to staff. You may also want to gauge the market because you may not want to invest in technology for instance if there is a new trend in technology you may be investing in something that will be outdated by the time you finish implementing it. An example would be the hand held computers that they used have in the 90's would get replaced and double in gigs every month. A lot of doctors rushed to get the latest technology with stencil pins etc. As soon as most of them geared up, cell phones had replaced black berries.
Strategic goals, investment goals, and cash flows should be taken in to mind with every decision.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/factors-increase-riskiness-capital-budgeting- project-15829.html
http://www.investopedia.com/university/capital-budgeting/importance.asp
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Jennifer Boren Email this Author 7/26/2016 7:01:07 PM
Potential mistakes companies might make in regards to capital budgeting for new equipment or property is fair competition of vendors. Companies might accidently show favoritism to one vendor over another or have conflict of interest. A company might also not oversee the process in regards to subcontractors brought in for the
work done at their facilities resulting in a higher construction budget. Companies might also accidently fail to ensure compliance of billing once a new piece of equipment is bought to avoid potential billing spikes. These billing spikes can be seen as potential billing fraud to third party payers.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. Health Administration Press, 06/2011. VitalBook file.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Mohamad Allan Email this Author 7/27/2016 5:48:51 PM
Jennifer just like mistakenly overestimating your cost of capital. Business managers are often conservative, so they want to screen out all but the most promising projects. The consequence of this very conservative strategy is that profitable investment projects aren’t undertaken.
http://www.dummies.com/education/economics/common-pitfalls-in-capital- budgeting/
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/27/2016 7:36:37 PM
Mohamad, post your link so we can view. It is important to have all staff involved and or aware of the financial health and process in the organization. Then in many cases people will spend and monitor the cash like it was their own! Regards, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Mohamad Allan Email this Author 7/31/2016 1:10:38 PM
Here is the link for the previous post: http://www.dummies.com/education/economics/common-pitfalls-in-capital- budgeting/
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Josiah Obonyano Email this Author 7/27/2016 10:31:12 PM
Hi Jennifer,
This is a very interesting perspective to the discussion question. The fact that there are prefered buyers in the procurement department makes it necessary to negotiate and solicit the support of team mates to ensure that the prefered supplier get the job. There may be incentives or just the desire to purchase a better quality equipment. The negotiation is always about convincing the other members on the justification of a specific budget amount over another.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Neil McCann Email this Author 7/26/2016 10:21:29 PM
http://www.dummies.com/how-to/content/common-pitfalls-in-capital- budgeting.html
Being too conservative and not investing in projects that will bring in more profit at a later date. It is also dangerous to assume that without investing that the corporate profits will remain the same for the next year. A lot of managers stick to smaller projects instead of multilevel ones because they do not want to risk their budget or have to get consensus from many departments to finish a project.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Cuong Manh Luong Email this Author7/26/2016 11:44:06 PM
Capital budgeting is a necessity in all organizations. In the article "The top five most common budgeting mistakes" on website Charityvillage.com I found one of them is very interesting. Thats is the fifth reason: "The budget process is not clearly defined". The article stated that there should be a financial policy that determines who is responsible for the development of the budget, who is responsible for approval, and the timeline for this to happen. The budget needs to be developed, approved and entered into the accounting system before the start of the fiscal year accounting. That can be an example of mistakes which are made in capital budgeting if an organization doesn't follow the right way.
Source: https://charityvillage.com/Content.aspx? topic=the_top_five_most_common_budgeting_mistakes#.V5hDwpMrLFQ
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Aurora Velez Email this Author 7/27/2016 11:16:47 AM
Hello professor Nathanson,
Potential mistakes that could be happening in capital budgeting is the underestimation of marketing decision making. Choosing the wrong investments projects and perhaps miss evaluating an investment proposal before thoroughly accepting terms. Hiring more staff than needed and not having enough revenue to pay salaries. Acquiring the latest technology to give prestige to the hospital and not having trained professionals to run the equipment property therefor the items are sitting down in the facility. However, the biggest one I found my self to be the worse of all is the lack of following up with the patient's debts.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Ebenezer Olusanya Email this Author7/27/2016 11:54:59 AM
Professor,
Capital budgeting is the process in which a business determines and evaluates potential expenses or investments that are large in nature. (http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capitalbudgeting.asp)
Hospital administrators overseeing the operation of an hospital in the current healthcare market, have to be very proactive in financial decision making to avoid taking the hospital to a destructive path. Why did i say this? Well, the answer is not too far fetched, we have to recognize that, there are real competition of healthcare organizations/hospitals, who are re-investing their resources in technology and qualified human power. Hence, proper capital budgeting of financial resources, goes a long way to re-establish the confidence of all stake holder that, their hospital will still be in business in the foreseeable future.
No management is perfect, besides, most hospitals doing very well today, have had their own dark days of making bad decisions, which they have learn from and serve as a guide for them going forward in the operation of their business. Mistakes that could be made in capital budgeting includes;
1. Lack of attention to cash flow budget: Before deciding on capital budget, management need to evaluate in its entirety, the hospital total budget cash flows from all units and the expenses that comes with it. This will give a clear picture of the net cash flow available.
2. Lack of proper assessment of current market: Through lack of or improper statistical collection, hospitals often fail to assess whether the population of patients are increasing or decreasing within a reasonable parameter of their hospital.
3. Also, failure to know for a fact, the demography of people patronizing their healthcare services, in other to ensure capital budgeting of their hospital is well appropriated.
Source
Retrieved from http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capitalbudgeting.asp
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Professor Nathanson Email this Author7/27/2016 7:33:37 PM
Ebenezer, on a related note you can tell just by visiting a medical care facility if the staff is working well together by just watching both the customer and staff interactions. Regards, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Ban Alshahin Email this Author 7/31/2016 7:24:12 PM
Professor, you bring up an interesting point. When I was doing my medical rotations at one of the doctor's offices you can immediately notice the disorganization in the office and the miscommunication between the employees and the physician. The physician herself was so unorganized, always late, and lacks communication skills. She always gives everyone else a hard time if they're late or if there's a misunderstanding and yet she is the one who lacks all these things. It's so disappointing to deal with someone who is not responsible and not organized because all her employees hated working for her. She never got her point across clearly and would get upset if somebody else misunderstood her. When working in a healthcare facility and you have a position of that importance you have to be reliable, well-spoken, organized, and clear. Otherwise there will be so much tension and chaos within the organization.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Kildia Martinez Email this Author 7/27/2016 3:29:48 PM
the budget is what control the organization financials, if we order machines that are too expensive like an upscale digital printer without considering the budget and then its not used efficiently can ause serious problems to the finance of the company.
"Capital budgeting involves determining the most advantageous investment options for your small business's liquid assets. Accountants use several complex calculations
to analyze possible investment returns, but many small businesses lack personnel with awareness of the complexity of capital budgeting. Simply estimating yearly returns in cash flow doesn't offer your small business an accurate representation of an investment's real return value.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/definition-examples-capital-budgeting-21948.html
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Monica Ilnicki Email this Author 7/27/2016 5:01:47 PM
One of the bigger mistakes is a disconnect between revenue and expenses. Meaning a company not planning for changes in markets and spending more than their incoming revenue. Companies can get a head of themselves and and start purchasing equipment before they can properly support those purchases. Another problem that they can run into is over staffing, where they end up paying employees more than money coming in.
Source: http://www.bkd.com/articles/2013/most-common-mistakes-made-in- financial-budgeting-forecasting-part-two.htm
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Sanyu Kasalirwe Email this Author 7/27/2016 11:46:09 PM
Modified:7/31/2016 8:46 PM
An example of mistakes which are made in capital budgeting is focusing on accounting results by the company management. A company management may choose to initiate projects that show positive short term accounting results at the expense of long term projects with high net present values. In so doing, they overlook the future returns that would be got from these long term projects and budget for these short term projects that show immediate returns n financial statements.
http://financetrain.com/common-pitfalls-in-capital-budgeting/
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Ydannie Boncenor Email this Author7/28/2016 7:56:56 PM
Mistakes can include type I error and type II. A Type I error (bad investment) and a Type II error (under-investment, i.e., failure to take advantage of a profitable investment opportunity). Both error types reduce shareholder wealth.
Reference http://www.munshi.4t.com/courses/lectures/capbdgtErrors.html
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/28/2016 10:20:10 PM
A good example of mistakes in capital budgeting is overestimating the cost of capital and conservative strategies to not pursue the profitable projects.
Thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Natalie Bonilla Email this Author 7/29/2016 9:36:35 AM
Lack of a Market Assessment: In addition to simply analyzing historical volume trends for the entity, management should complete an overall market assessment of the service area. Knowing the service area’s demographic trends can help management determine volume forecasts. For instance, many rural hospitals face decreasing populations and declining inpatient use rates. To keep patient volumes steady in this scenario, the entity would need to increase its market share. However, the opposite also is true, as an increasing population may help an entity sustain increasing volume levels without increasing market share.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Natalie Bonilla Email this Author 7/30/2016 9:59:51 PM
Ignoring Debt Covenants: Management should ensure required debt covenant calculations, such as debt service coverage or days cash on hand, are incorporated into the forecast. In addition to knowing the minimum levels required, management also should incorporate a higher “target” level for any debt covenants to allow for a safety cushion. If the forecast results approximate the required covenant level, an unexpected event—even if relatively small—could send management reeling for a response.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Mistakes? Khanh Nguyen Email this Author 7/30/2016 11:17:13 PM
Th most common problem would be to overestimate. An occurrence of this might be when a company say a retail store, believes they will make more money than they actually did. They estimate that their daily goal is $100,000 and put forth the effort. The spend more money expecting to meet the goal and fail to achieve it.
Collapse Mark as Unread Capital Budget Nycole Beverly Email this Author7/25/2016 8:11:34 AM
I am currently involved in a project where the organization has decided to move our small office into a larger one. This project is going to cost the company millions of dollars. However, the return on this project will be worth it because currently, my docs make a profit to this organization up to 15 million dollars per year with only 2 docs in the office. Once we move, we will have 10 exam rooms which will increase that revenue so much more. In the new office, we will have at least 4-5 docs in the office at one time.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Margaret Daughtry Email this Author 7/25/2016 6:42:10 PM
What is capital budgeting? Capital budgeting is a process that businesses use to determine, evaluate, and help rank the many possible expenses or possible investments that can make or break a business. The capital budget can be a tool that a business can use to maximize future profits by helping to manage their projects.
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/25/2016 7:35:26 PM
Margaret, class, with any capital budget daily monitoring is key especially in the health care field where revenue varies based on the different ways to pay! Regards,
Craig
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/25/2016 7:36:17 PM
Thanks Nycole. Class, can you give an example of a sunk cost in the medical field? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Veronica Paz Email this Author7/25/2016 11:06:32 PM
I would say an example of a sunk cost in the medical field is a new addition to a facility such as research lab. The expenditure will be made to purchase all the required supplies and necessities. Money must be spent to have the most current technology available to be able to perform the research needed. Unfortunately if the lab is not producing or being utilized as much as the CEO/facility thought they have to take a loss in what was spent to set it up. The bad thing is that all the equipment that was purchased it going to sit in an empty room collecting dust.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Margaret Daughtry Email this Author 7/26/2016 8:21:05 AM
I agree with Veronica but an example of a sunk cost could also be the addition of a specialized radiography suite that performs just angiograms and unfortunately only 2 studies were performed in the past year. This would mean that the specialized suite was not necessary or worth the investment and the equipment purchased can not be used for anything else.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Nycole Beverly Email this Author7/26/2016 8:49:47 AM
It would seem to me that there shouldnt be any such thing as a sunk cost. I am shocked that research was not done to determine the need prior to investing.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Denise Bailey Email this Author7/26/2016 12:03:45 PM
Margaret/Veronica
You both make a great point!
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Darla Ford Email this Author7/26/2016 11:11:15 AM
Within the medical community sunk costs can refer the cost of a building,clinic or equipment, and/or dedicated supplies that were previously procured. Sunk costs also are not lost when as technology is upgraded or components become obsolete. Additional examples include staff training and R&D. None of these items costs are counted in the future budgeting or financial aspects.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Alberto Palacio Email this Author7/30/2016 11:54:57 PM
Darla that is a great grasp on sunk costs. Technology is definitely a factor to have in mind as well as most other depreciating components to the business. Another example is if the clinic/establishment has their own method of transport for personnel/patients it cares for. A fleets maintenance. cycling and replacement over time is another large cost that would affect expenses.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Mohamad Allan Email this Author7/31/2016 1:17:53 PM
Darla, good post. I personally never heard of sunk costs until I read the discussion thread for this week and did my own research and here is what I found:
"Take the current Health Care Reform debate. Some people have so much sunk into the idea that Health Care Reform must be passed that they want to see anything signed, regardless of what is in the final bill. Others have so much sunk into the idea that Health Care Reform can never be good that they don’t want to see anything signed, again, regardless of what is in the final bill.
Both of these groups are basing their positions on their sunk investments into their ideas of Health Care Reform, and not necessarily on the future costs and benefits of what is actually currently being discussed."
http://www.datamachines.com/?p=72
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Bianca Carolina Email this Author7/31/2016 11:20:47 PM
Darlaston I agree with you when you say sunn costs are not lost when you upgrade or get new technology. I also believe that to be true with your other example of staff training . I believe both of these are investments that will help enhance the quality of care and ultimately generate more income.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Bhoomi Shah Email this Author7/26/2016 3:57:36 PM
Hello veronica,
We all know that sunk cost is also called as similar cost. You gave good example here, in adding to your example about research and development, lets assume that a hospital invests $ 50,000 over few years after some instruments or something. Once done, the market is indifferent, and buys no units. The 50,000 development cost is a sunk cost, so should not be considered in any decision to continue or terminate the product.
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/26/2016 6:40:50 PM
Veronica, good example. Also on a related note the dollar amount is important so as to define which equipment has depreciated or not. This can enable a planner to understand whether something is a sunk cost or not, regards, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Veronica Paz Email this Author7/27/2016 9:38:14 PM
Professor Nathanson,
I didn't think about the expenses made on the equipment, that is an important factor when determining if something is categorized as a sunk cost. Organizations make the investment to provide services and in return they hope to be successful. While the ideas of expanding sound good and look good on paper, the success of the plans are not always lucrative as one may think. I never figured that taking the dollar amount of the equipment to see if there was a depreciation or not.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Ban Alshahin Email this Author7/26/2016 10:15:28 AM
Some examples of sunk costs in any workplace organization may include those such as staff training and education. In any organization there is going to be training of any new employees or whenever there is a new change within the company it would require to train current employees as well. The money that is spent on teaching your employees some useful skills or educating them about a new product or service would be considered a sunk cost because it cannot be recovered. Research and development are also considered sunk costs. With healthcare organizations there needs to be constant research and development of new treatments/medications/options of which they can offer their patients. In addition
to the above mentioned factors, equipment is another sunk cost in the medical field. According to this article, "if you have specialty equipment made for your business, specially to create a product or service you offer exclusively, the purchase becomes a sunk cost". I think this exists more often in places such as spas or medical offices which offer services such as laser or other beauty services.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/examples-sunk-costs-workplace-10665.html
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Denise Bailey Email this Author7/26/2016 12:02:14 PM
Hi All,
The text mention that a sunk cost is a cost that already accrued that will not be affected or should not be affected future decision. The book example is opening a clinical is not profitable, the money that was put out to open the clinical is retainable. The that was spend can not be recover but the can still sell the clinical. So I was in the Islands about a month ago and my cousin took me to a new children hospital that the government build costing a few millions, top of the art equipment was put into the facility. The problem was they did not recruit staff before the place was open, so the hospital remained close. The end result the equipment that was put in the facility was stolen and they never hired staff. This was a sunk cost. Now this beatific building is sitting not being utilized.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Aurora Velez Email this Author7/27/2016 11:43:21 AM
Hello Denis and Class
As our text book Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organization fifth edition explains that sunk cost is the money that an organization invest and there is no revenue coming out of it and that sometimes this is contrasted with prospective costs which represent money that the organization will eventually utilize both ways retrospectively and prospectively.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. (06/2011). Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. [VitalSource Bookshelf Online]. Retrieved from https://bookshelf.vitalsource.com/#/books/978- 1-56793-412-0/
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/27/2016 7:35:10 PM
Class, in any capital plan, it is important to also consider what I call the human elements. Can you give an example of which human elements you would pay attention to when developing a capital plan in a hospital? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Denise Bailey Email this Author7/28/2016 11:59:55 AM
Hi All/professor,
Not sure if I am on the right track, but I think the human elements would be
-if there is enough man power
-how reliable the team will be not costing the company more money
-how equipment they are, is training needed
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Bhoomi Shah Email this Author7/28/2016 3:30:48 PM
Hello Denise,
I think you are on a right track and I would like to add more in your post from the article I read on http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1552082/, for developing a capital plan in hospital most of the human elements needs to be focus are size, composition and distribution of the health care workforce, workforce training issues, the transfers of health workers, the level of economic development in a particular country and sociodemographic, geographical and cultural factors.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Denise Bailey Email this Author7/29/2016 11:36:30 AM
Hi Bhommi,
Thank you for sharing that additional information.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Ebenezer Olusanya Email this Author 7/28/2016 6:39:08 PM
Hello Professor,
Human elements are crucial to the success of capital plan. Capital plan of an organization entails the reason for their existence, how they intend to achieve their why and the time frame they expect to achieve it. This also applies to capital plans in the sub units in organizations like hospitals. Every units capital plan determines to a large extend of what the hospital capital plan will look like. The most important element to be considered in capital plan, is the ability to identify at the onset of a project, the time frame needed to accomplished set objectives. This when adhered to, save time, money and needed energy in other areas of the hospital that is yarning for equal attention.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Aurora Velez Email this Author7/27/2016 11:25:50 AM
Hello professor Nathanson,
Examples of sunk cost in the medical field staff training and education. A budgeting must have to be assigned to update all key staff to the organization. Product research, in this case hospitals must invest money in research departments to develop survey for hospital satisfaction about vaccines to customer service.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/examples-sunk-costs-workplace-10665.html
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Nicole Clancey Email this Author7/27/2016 8:09:27 PM
This article that I found on PubMed discusses the reason why so many clinics struggle to keep afloat, and furthermore, the reason why they experience so many 'sunk costs.' The article suggests that many decisions made on a clinical based level are made with cognitive biases, rather than on an evidence based conclusion. They actually coin this as "sunk-cost bias," where clinical professionals feel a pressure to continue with a line of diagnostic tests and procedures, simply because they previously thought it was the correct course of action, even if new evidence leans in
a different direction. It is interesting to read how ven the most brilliant minds among us can have bias, with or without them knowing it, that can truly ruin the businesses they put their lives into.
Reference: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22503839
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/28/2016 7:46:13 PM
Good research Nicole. It is amazing the amount of tests which are done in many cases as just part of the normal process whether or not they might be needed in all cases. Remember to post the link so we can view, thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Steven Shanab Email this Author7/27/2016 9:17:42 PM
A sunk cost is a cost that has already been incurred, and thus will not play a role in future decisions (Nowicki 135). An example of a sunk cost in the medical field would be advertising. Many medical centers are now advertising on TV. Whether or not the center makes money, the cost for advertising has already been paid, and therefore, cannot be returned to the center.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. Health Administration Press, 06/2011. VitalBook file.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Cuong Manh Luong Email this Author 7/27/2016 10:38:52 PM
Professor!
A sunk cost is a cost that an entity has incurred, and which it can no longer recover by any means. A sunk cost is also known as a stranded cost.
An example: A healthcare center spends $20,000 on training its staff in the use of new tablet computers, which they will use to take patient orders and information. The tablet computers prove to be unreliable, and the sales manager wants to discontinue their use. The training is a sunk cost, and so should not be considered in any decision regarding the computers.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Monica Ilnicki Email this Author7/28/2016 5:48:38 PM
One of the sunk cost in the medical field is employee training/education. Often times hospitals and medical organizations will pay partial or full for the further education of their employees. My brother is an example of this, he works for a hospital as a bio-med engineer. He runs around and fixes all the equipment throughout the hospital. The hospital offered to pay for him to go get his certification on how to work on radiology equipment (i.e. x-ray machines, CT scanners, MRI machines etc.), there was a catch however. In return for them offering to pay for the schooling, he is not allowed to leave his job for a full year after the last class ends. This way they in a way are able to use his new skills to benefit their hospital.
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/28/2016 7:44:06 PM
Good example Monica but of course training can pay off later as an investment! Class, what do you think is a good way to make future financial projections? What process would you use? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Steven Shanab Email this Author7/28/2016 9:08:32 PM
One way to make future financial projections is to utilize past financial data and set goals based on that to create prospective financial data. It's extremely important to know your market and how to maximize your company's role in that market by seeing trends in financials. If you're a new company, take a look at the competition from others selling similar products and try to advertise in a way to make your product stand out from the rest.
https://www.sba.gov/starting-business/write-your-business-plan/financial- projections
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Cuong Manh Luong Email this Author 7/29/2016 2:01:29 PM
Hi Steven!
I agree with your point of view on how to make future financial projections. It will be easier for an organization has history data in business but for a business that has not really come into operation that is a big challenge. For that kind of business, we should create our own financial projection from zero. We must gather information,
point out the goals, forecasts for a corporate finance operational preparations, create a sales forecast, create a budgetary cost, and a lot of other steps. By carefully gathering information, understanding of the goals of your finances and balance between optimism and realism, you will create financial forecasts not only guide your businesses, but can help you get the financial resources to launch it. Just something want to share you.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Christina McLaughlin Email this Author 7/29/2016 8:16:25 PM
Cuong and Steven I think you are both correct. It would be important to analyze the past data to look for any trends. It would also be important to see if there are any known changes that are going to be happening- for example the age of the population in 5 years as professor has pointed out. This information will need to be taken into account when they are figuring staff, finances etc in 5 years.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Sawrab Nayak Email this Author7/30/2016 9:20:53 PM
I agree, when we reprice for options years for our contracts we have to keep in mind the rate changes and other increased expenses that will impact the cost of the project.
Thanks Sawrab
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread Week 4 wrap-up and week 5 preview Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/31/2016 5:42:06 PM
Class, we will continue to expand this learning in week 5 which starts on Monday.
One of the most difficult aspects of learning healthcare finance is the lingo. There are many new terms in this field and most of them relate to key ratios or indicators of organizational performance.
This week, you will learn the lingo of healthcare finance with a Study Mate activity. Be sure to devote some quality time and effort into using this tool. It will help you greatly in your medical career (and also on the quizzes and exams in this course, by the way!). Have a great week and let me know how I can continue to assist with your learning in our class, regards, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Week 4 wrap-up and week 5 preview Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/31/2016 9:00:12 PM
Thank you Professor, I am looking forward to learn and utilize the tool!
thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Margaret Daughtry Email this Author 7/29/2016 6:42:47 PM
Sales projections or financial projections are both built on assumptions. Sales or financial projections are difficult to assume or to predict but is very necessary.
Although projections may not be perfect, it is possible to increase the accuracy of the forecasts by using a data-driven, bottom-up approach. Another way is to use the following steps: Use multiple scenarios, predict expenses, identify the assumptions, outline steps in sales process, find comparisons, and regularly evaluate how close operating results are to the forecasts, and make changes to reflect any new information. The more up to date forecasts are, the better prepared will be to make informed strategic decisions.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Darla Ford Email this Author7/30/2016 7:10:19 PM
@ Steven, I agree with your post because in order for a company to determine their true financial standing and projections would be to review previous quarter earnings. Also by reviewing earnings they can pin point if there is a potential problem,errors and even over spending that should be rectified. It is very easy for a facility to loose sight of their budgets based on needs and technology requirements.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Darla Ford Email this Author7/30/2016 7:10:39 PM
Modified:7/30/2016 7:12 PM Error...
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Sanyu Kasalirwe Email this Author7/29/2016 8:20:55 PM
The projections should include an income statement, a cash flow statement, and a balance sheet generated monthly, quarterly, or/and annually. The income statement
projects how much money the organization will generate by projecting incomes, expenses which can be summarized by department or major expense categories. Cash flow statements project the cash inflows and cash outflows to estimate losses and/or profits for the month, quarter, or year, and Cash needs should be clearly identified. Annual balance sheets show the overall financial position of the business and should also be used to project the next periods position.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Natalie Bonilla Email this Author7/31/2016 6:46:50 PM
Use multiple scenarios.
There is a strong temptation to be optimistic when forecasting growth. To counter this, many entrepreneurs end up using extremely conservative estimates. In reality, neither is the only option you should forecast. You should devote your predictive energy to at least 2, one optimistic and another cautious. This is especially true if there is uncertainty surrounding major factors that could impact your business, such as government regulations, new competition, or even overall economic growth.
It can be frustrating to use multiple forecasts. It clashes with the part of our brain that is hardwired to desire certainty and precision. Still, it helps you maintain flexibility in your strategic planning and create more realistic expectations for your investors.
Boinnott.John.(ND) 6 ways to make financial forecast more realistic.Retrieved from https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/246592
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Denise Bailey Email this Author7/29/2016 11:40:05 AM
Hi Monica/Professor
I understand your point but is this really considered a sunk cost? The company is still gaining once your brother finishes his cost.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Sanyu Kasalirwe Email this Author7/29/2016 7:24:23 PM
A sunk cost is also known as a stranded cost and this cost should not be considered when making decisions in investing in a project although in reality, managers and in our personal lives we go ahead an invest since we have already injected a lot of
money in a particular project knowing we will not recover it anyway. Some of the examples
of sunk costs in organizations are medical research and developments, hiring bonuses, and marketing studies of new drugs.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget L. Alexander Email this Author7/29/2016 8:45:09 PM
Nowicki explains in our text that sunk costs are costs that have already been sustained and will not be affected by, and should not affect, future decisions. One example is if a CEO spends $1 million opening a new neighborhood clinic, that money is a sunk cost. If a year later it turns out the clinic is not profitable and should be closed, the CEO should not let the fact that he already invested $1 million affect his decision to close the clinic. The CEO might regret that he spent that $1 million, but there’s no legitimate business reason to keep the clinic open just because he made that unwise decision in the beginning.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Neil McCann Email this Author7/29/2016 9:06:20 PM
A sunk cost that I found is CT scans and accounting for the radiation they put out and taking that into effect with cancer patients especially and insurance costs.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3359514/
Another sunk cost would be if a hospital builds an addition and then when it is close to finishing realizes it does not have the doctors, staff, or patients to make the venture profitable. Everything it has done to that point is a sunk cost. What usually happens with something like this is staff layoffs rather than give up on the building project.
http://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0712/how-to-recognize-sunk- costs.aspx
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Kildia Martinez Email this Author7/30/2016 7:56:12 AM
I can say an example would be a when the hospital spends a really big amount of money advertising a new program and at the end of the trial you see that you only have a few members
Small business owners take on numerous costs and expenses during the start up and growth phases of their businesses. In business, you have to spend time and money to
attract the attention of customers who will buy your products or services. Once time and money are spent, they cannot be recovered. This concept is referred to as sunk costs, and there are many examples in the workplace.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/examples-sunk-costs-workplace-10665.html
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Alberto Palacio Email this Author7/30/2016 11:47:52 PM
Kildia that is a very good point on investments made by companies when establishing their market. Similar can be observed with Research and Development where even once the small business is established they are further challenges to stay successful amongst their potential competition.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Khanh Nguyen Email this Author7/31/2016 10:01:13 PM
A sunk cost is a cost that cannot be recovered at all. An example would training. Regardless of how the employees turn out, that money can not be returned. Another example is medical research. If a facility spends millions of dollars on researching a cure for a disease and fails, the result is a sunk cost that can not be refunded.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budget Sawrab Nayak Email this Author7/28/2016 10:21:57 PM
Great, this is an expensive capital investment for higher rate of return. What is the duration to make the capital back after profits?
Thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread Capital Projects Yachi Marrero Email this Author7/27/2016 8:45:23 PM
The best thing that I believe that they can do is show the employees how the decisions are made. Show them the decision matrix that they use to make their decisions. If they do feel that it is political, tell them to invest money into the project that others have and are awaiting a return. I do feel that in certain organizations people try say that something is political if it does not go their way. That is simply because they do not understand the process as to how decisions are made. Once you educate the people they may feel differently about the issue.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. (06/2011). Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. [VitalSource Bookshelf Online]. Retrieved from https://online.vitalsource.com/#/books/978-1- 56793-412-0/
Collapse Mark as Unread Captal Budgeting Josiah Obonyano Email this Author7/27/2016 10:17:47 PM
The perception of employees that capital budgeting is purely political is a reality in every major organization around the world. The concept of separating capital budgets from recurring expenditure is that it is designed to finance major developmental projects such as new buildings, newer and more efficient technologies and expansion in the scope of operations. It is interesting to note that no matter how great an idea is or how beneficial that new vision may be to the growth and profitability of any organization, the key success health facility budget planning and management is the tough decisions that are to be made. The process of getting a buy-in form the board of directors, management team, medical staff, and general employee is quintessential to gaining the approval and support in the acceptance and implementation of a capital budget. This consensus is hinged on the premise that the vision must be shared by all and participated by all. Such is the nature of politics. The allocation of competing resources must be well articulated in the justification process of opportunity cost.
Norwicki, M. (2011). Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organization. 5th Ed. Health Administration Press. Il. Chicago,
Collapse Mark as Unread Capital Budgeting Terry Smothers Email this Author7/27/2016 11:36:02 PM
I truly feel that at the very beginning of this process it is political driven do a degree. Who needs more, who draws the most income in to a business and so on. The equalizer for this is to make a list of everyone needs and then had an independent panel prioritize them according to the need, cost, duplicity of equipment. When I was active duty, the last job I had was the squadron resource advisor to the commander. We went through this every year end as to who would get the as of the money left over in the current years budget as it was a use or lose type system. I was the one that had to do all of the comparison and then send the funds where they need to go and sometimes it was not always where some of the supervisor though it should go.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Yachi Marrero Email this Author 7/28/2016 8:22:02 PM
I feel that there is no way to really make people not feel that budgeting is political. Someone is always going to have something to say or they are going to feel like their department deserved the money or supplies and not another one. I do not think that certain people will ever be satisfied.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Terry Smothers Email this Author 7/28/2016 11:03:39 PM
Oh man that ain't no lie. The problem is that every unit or section think that they are the most important part of the organization when in fact there is not a single stand alone unit in any company and everyone needs each other to do their part in order for the process to come to a completed stage. Thanks for you comments and your are so very right.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Denise Bailey Email this Author 7/29/2016 11:44:51 AM
Terry,
This true every unit is important to the organization. I think the key is upper management need to stress to the employees that they are a key part of the organization , and show how each department makes a dereference if the organization profits, or falls.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Yachi Marrero Email this Author 7/30/2016 8:32:02 PM
When I was in the military working in Supply you saw and still see so much of that. Especially at the end of the physical year when there is money that has to be spent so it will not be lost. That was the craziest time because you get the craziest request.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/29/2016 9:29:59 PM
Budgeting in government is for sure political as it depends not he lecture officials priorities and very same applies to any organization. If a CEO has a priority to make
sure increase the market share by promoting more ads then that is where money will be spent.
Thanks Sawrab
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/30/2016 12:51:11 AM
Hi Sawrab, what has been your experience with organizational budgeting? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/30/2016 9:17:12 PM
Hello Professor,
I work as a Business Architect and have very minimal involvement in the capital budgeting. Normally, I would attend the meetings where they share the budget and forecast on resources. I been talking at work that I would like to get more involved in finances and I was told to start working on EVM.
Thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Desiree Bell Email this Author 7/27/2016 11:51:56 PM
Modified:7/28/2016 11:15 PM
The procedures that should be used are involving the employees in the loop of events. I think by notifying employees ahead of time of the change or need for the capital budgeting will make it easier for them to understand why there is a need for it and then also decrease all the political suspicion most of them have. To eliminate this perception and provide a consistent evaluation of capital projects healthcare organizations can explain the purchase decision and identify how it will be useful for patients and staff.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Aurora Velez Email this Author 7/28/2016 12:26:25 PM
Hello Desiree,
I found some of the procedures for Capital Budgeting and its understanding. In addition of the importance of the Capital Budgeting of marketing and its role in Capital Budgeting.
The fist step is to differentiate the type of investments evaluating the economic investment proposal outcomes of a team brainstorming. The financial team also must considered the advantage and disadvantage of the payback method and the techniques on measuring the project advancement. and finally the raw calculation of the values if internal and external rate returns on the outcomes of the project.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. (06/2011). Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, Retrieved from https://online.vitalsource.com/#/books/978-1-56793-412-0/ on July 08, 2016
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/30/2016 12:49:49 AM
Class, from your learning this week what do you think are the common mistakes with capital budgeting and as a finance manager what might you do to correct this? Thanks, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Christina McLaughlin Email this Author 7/30/2016 8:42:01 PM
I would think one of the big mistakes is misjudging the cash flow coming in to pay for the projects. If it is a change in payment models or an error in math it could throw off the cash flow. To correct that it would need to be taken into consideration the least amount of money that could be flowing in and the project still be financed.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Neil McCann Email this Author 7/30/2016 8:51:26 PM
http://www.bkd.com/articles/2014/most-common-mistakes-made-in-financial- budgeting-forecasting-part-3.htm
Mistakes occur when a budget splits off from the goals set up by the strategic plan.
It also is a mistake when the results of the capital use is not communicated in time to make changes and also mistakes occur when they do not hold the people accountable or use the right people.
This happens often when unit managers do not adjust their budgets to the match. Many times they allow physicians who are not hired under their unit but directly by HR. Physicians often get bonuses by how many patients they see, so piling on higher patient ratios to nurses is often done to compensate and instead it makes nurses leave or burn out and the doctors keep on billing and making money. Nurses are often seen as cash cows and if they can see more patients with no financial incentive but to keep their jobs there doesn't seem to be sound reasoning there.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Veronica Paz Email this Author 7/30/2016 11:39:30 PM
When it comes preparing the budgets for an organization, as a finance manager it is extremely important that the numbers are correct. Ensuring every detail has been included in the budget and the correct amounts for each allocation has been checked and double checked should be at the top of the list when submitting the final budget. If the amounts are done incorrectly or do not match to what has initially been stated could cause some major problems for the organization. They have set monies aside, but a simple mistake can turn into a huge issue. If the cash flow that has been noted in the budget is incorrect and the organization is depending on it there could be some serious consequences for everyone involved.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/31/2016 9:03:00 PM
Good point budgets are still estimates but actuals are the most important numbers to report. However making sure numbers are accurate in any reporting of finance is equals important.
Thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Cuong Manh Luong Email this Author 7/31/2016 1:57:15 AM
Professor!
One common mistake in capital budgeting is to overestimate your cost of capital. Business managers are often conservative, so they want to screen out all but the most promising projects. The consequence of this very conservative strategy is that profitable investment projects aren’t undertaken.
Another common error is for firms to assume profit levels won’t change even if capital investment isn’t undertaken. Because rival firms are investing, the lack of
investment ultimately leads to profits eroding. Estimated cash flows should reflect this incremental difference. If they don’t, new project profitability is underestimated. Source: http://financetrain.com/common-pitfalls-in-capital-budgeting/
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Kildia Martinez Email this Author 7/31/2016 10:43:32 AM
Forgetting to Write Down Expenses It's impossible to stick to your budget if you don't know where your money is going. Ideally, you need to keep track of every single purchase, whether it's something small like a parking garage fee or something bigger like a new television. Buying things on impulse before considering the budget, intentionally not writing down purchases, and over spending. these mistake can cause your business to fail.
Read more: Budgeting Basics - Mistakes To Avoid | Investopedia http://www.investopedia.com/university/budgeting/basics6.asp#ixzz4G0O6ZAdD Follow us: Investopedia on Facebook
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budgeting Sanyu Kasalirwe Email this Author 7/31/2016 9:15:28 PM
One of the common mistakes with capital budgeting is misunderstanding sunk costs and opportunity costs. A company may incorrectly include sunk costs into its capital budgeting analysis, but exclude opportunity costs. As a finance manager i would make sure i understand fully the difference between the sunk costs and opportunity costs and how they each affect the capital budgeting process.
In capital budgeting analysis, sunk costs have already been incurred but cannot be recovered and they are included in the incremental cash flows. On the other hand, opportunity costs are not necessarily cash outflows but need to be considered since they reflect the foregone profit that could have been elsewhere in a particular financial period.
http://financetrain.com/common-pitfalls-in-capital-budgeting/
Collapse Mark as Unread Capital budget apprehension Crystal Allen Email this Author 7/28/2016 11:58:13 AM
It is important that staff understand that capital budgeting is performed to determine the long-term value of an investment. Managers can let them know how the investment directly relates to them and can make their job processes more
efficient or how the investment helps achieve organizational goals. There will always be a budget to follow when undergoing an investment. To some staff, one investment may seem more important than another so it is important to educate stake holders so that they're informed. Large scale projects often have a team.
Where there's a team, voting takes place. The result should be for the greater good of the organization and proper procedures should be followed to ensure an adequate decision is made. Everyone will never be satisfied with these decisions, so managers should not strive to do so. There are many methods to determine the value of capital projects; debt to capitalization ratio, capital expense ratio, and average age of plant. These help to determine how much debt an organization can incur which helps in the decision making process.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budget apprehension Denise Bailey Email this Author 7/28/2016 12:11:55 PM
Crystal,
I agree that staff should be informed what is taken place, as far as short-term and long-term investments. But like you said you can satisfy some but not all. An example: Before our merger was took place upper management came in a month before and told staff that they sign a contact to a company and what was going to happen within the next 5 years. We 2 town hall meeting before we go introduce to the partner. It was broken down what the plan was and why they felt as an organization this needed to happen, looking at the future and revenue. At the end result half of the people was okay with it the other half was not. Some people felt that the company sold out and what was being said was untrue.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budget apprehension Aurora Velez Email this Author 7/28/2016 12:34:32 PM
Hello Krystal and Denise,
Thank you for your post, I enjoyed reading them. I found this website from the Congressional Budget Office a financial analysis for the U. S congress I thought to share it with the class since addresses the 2016 Long Term budget Outlook, Federal Subsidies for Health Insurance Coverage for People Under Age 65: 2016 to 2026, the Private Health Insurance Premiums and Federal Policy, and Private Health Insurance Premiums and Federal Policy, among other interesting and related topics.
https://www.cbo.gov/topics/health-care
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budget apprehension Desiree Bell Email this Author 7/28/2016 11:17:47 PM
I agree that you cant win or please them all but informing staff is important. Having staff feel involved or cared about should be critical in healthcare organizations because when staff starts to feel out the loop is when they also tend to begin losing interest in their job because they no longer feel part of a team. They feel just like a screw in a big machine, playing their role.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budget apprehension Nicole Clancey Email this Author 7/29/2016 10:15:20 AM
Desiree,
I could not agree with you more. While this discussion is about the financial choices that a healthcare organization must make, the ultimate goal must always come back to providing safe and effective health care. When employees communication breaks down, due to factors like not feeling involved in the processes, then patient care takes the biggest toll of all. This article, posted in the NIH journal, discusses this and mentions that this is the "human factor," which can not be ignored or the patients are the ones that suffer the most, and in the end, ends up costing more money than if it had been prevented with clear communication.
Reference: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15465961
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budget apprehension Jennifer Boren Email this Author 7/29/2016 9:54:04 PM
I agree, the human factor of healthcare has slowly faded to the point it's non- existent. Recently, I was on the receiving end of the un-human business dealings in regards to a business' accounts receivable. The facility refused to take a partial payment for services which were to be rendered due to a high deductible I have.
Prior to submitting the claim to my insurance, I was required to pay the estimated patient portion which was more than I had on one credit card. The non-human part I believe was their unwillingness to work with me due to their new status as a facility. I have encountered this more and more as a consumer and I believe it's a trend due
to the low reimbursements providers are getting and inability to collect patient portions.
Nowicki, Michael, EdD, FACHE, FHFMA. Introduction to the Financial Management of Healthcare Organizations, Fifth Edition, 5th Edition. Health Administration Press, 06/2011. VitalBook file.
(an instructor response)
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital budget apprehension Professor Nathanson Email this Author 7/31/2016 5:39:07 PM
Thanks for your example Jen. We will cover more of this in the weeks ahead! Regards, Craig.
Collapse Mark as Unread Capital Budgeting Khanh Nguyen Email this Author7/29/2016 2:26:36 PM
Capital budgeting causes a lot of disagreement because it is the allocation of funds based on the perspective of those in charge. Everyone else's concerns mayor may not be addressed. The political nature of this is becasue people often believe that priority is given to areas that they deem unimportant. To remedy this a clear goal needs to be established. It is far more easy to accept something if you all agree it is important to achieve the goal. In addition, make sure that the other parties understand why you are allocation the funds. And thirdly, have some discussion with other parties. Even if you disagree with them, it is better for them to speak. This may raise problems as well as solutions you have not thought of.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Crystal Allen Email this Author 7/30/2016 7:27:12 PM
I think that apprehension is inevitable when people are kept out of the loop. With all decision making, all stakeholders should be educated and considered during the process. All staff aren't skilled to make such decisions, so it isn't expected to include them in that part. For instance, when deciding on a new scheduling system it is a good idea to list the faults of the current system and the benefits of the new system. Getting input from admissions and schedulers should be the first thing to do towards even selecting a system to present to the staff. When asked questions, managers should not shy away from answering them.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Monica Ilnicki Email this Author 7/31/2016 10:01:52 AM
Hi Crystal
I currently work in a small private practice where we have an office manager, and a billing girl who believes herself to be "office manager". She often makes decisions based on her own ideas and what she believes to be right or wrong. She besides a high school diploma and a couple of certificates she really has no schooling or training to go behind her decision making. There have been a couple of times now where she has made the wrong decision and tried to blame us for it that "we should know better". It often brings a lot of problems to our office, and she usually gets put "in her place" by the true office manager.
I just recently accepted a new position in a hospital and I am very interested to see how different things are. I have never worked anywhere other than private practices so this will be an eye opener for me. I am excited to learn all about the budgeting and the politic of larger hospital settings.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Ebenezer Olusanya Email this Author 7/30/2016 9:03:43 PM
Hello Khanh and Class,
Capital budgeting of an organization, is usually steered towards restructuring of financial resources to the most needed units in a scenario where the organization is an hospital. The management meeting where such decisions are made, are guided with known facts and projections for the coming year and objectives the hospital intend to accomplish. The accomplishment to be set could be increase in the number of staffs to reduce the hours spent by patients, buying of new technological equipment for department that lack the most current equipment in medicine, or building an extension (building), to the main building in other to increase the number of bed in their facility.
Hence, capital budgeting should not be politicalized because, the final consumer of healthcare services (patience), will be ones at the receiving end of irrational and unproductive decisions. As you have rightly mentioned Khanh, management should always carry all the board members, management and mid-level manager along when capital budgeting is being decided upon.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Terry Smothers Email this Author 7/31/2016 12:45:03 PM
I agree with you all the way, they only thing I would like to add is that is important to have and use a very clear prioritization plan that can truly be explained to all
involved so that everyone can see the decisions were based on a plan and not on personal likes or dislikes.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Capital Budgeting Sawrab Nayak Email this Author 7/31/2016 9:04:58 PM
Very true, budget allocation is entirely based on people in power and their priorities. However I believe there is always a third party vendor to recommend proper allocations specially for public company.
Thanks Sawrab
Collapse Mark as Unread Politics L. Alexander Email this Author 7/29/2016 7:54:53 PM
The political stability of a country directly affects borrowing costs, taxes and regulation for businesses. For example, Turkey has experienced a number of economic and political setbacks that raised the cost of borrowing for the national government. Corruption allegations, tight lending conditions and financial volatility within the country made it more challenging for corporate entities to operate there effectively.
Collapse Mark as Unread RE: Politics Nicole Clancey Email this Author 7/30/2016 6:17:53 PM
Similar situations are occurring in African regions including Nigeria, Kenya and South Africa, where their inflation rates are as high as 61%. They have seen such a decrease in the inflow of capital funds that there has been a halt on such funds that the U.S. and other countries pledged in previous years to fight the war on AIDS and HIV. Financial instability is as alarming in situations such as these, as political turmoil. Imagine the nightmare of financial distress on businesses in those countries, when funds aren't even being allotted to the country for prevention of aids, let alone business purposes!
Reference: http://blogs.worldbank.org/africacan/financial-market-turmoil-and- africa
* Times are displayed in (GMT-07:00) Mountain Time (US & Canada)
[Show More]