GCE
Psychology
H167/01: Research methods
Advanced Subsidiary GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Psychology
H167/01: Research methods
Advanced Subsidiary GCE
Mark Schem
...
GCE
Psychology
H167/01: Research methods
Advanced Subsidiary GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Psychology
H167/01: Research methods
Advanced Subsidiary GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 2020H167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Unclear
Attempts evaluation
Benefit of doubt
Context
Cross
Evaluation
Extendable horizontal line
Extendable horizontal wavy line
Significant amount of material that doesn’t answer the question
Not answered question
Good use of resources
Tick
Development of point
Omission markH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Section A: Multiple Choice
Quest Answer
1 B
2 C
3 A
4 A
5 B
6 C
7 A
8 B
9 D
10 D
11 D
12 C
13 B
14 A
15 CH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Section B: Research Design and Response
Question Answer Marks Guidance
Write a two-tailed alternative hypothesis for this study. [3]
16 For example ... (accept variations in operational
decisions of IV and DV)
There will be a significant difference in the ability to
concentrate (solving anagrams) when doodling
(scribbling whatever liked) compared to not
doodling.
3 mark answer:
Correctly cited alternative hypothesis with both IV and
DV operationalised
2 mark answer:
Correctly cited alternative hypothesis with reference to
both variables but neither or only one operationalised
1 mark answer:
Simply stating ‘there will be a difference’ OR
An alternative hypothesis with reference to just one
variable
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 3 Context – doodling, drawing, scribbling, concentration
etc
- Can be written in future or present tense
- Use of the word significant is not necessary for full
marks
- Award zero for citing a null alternative hypothesis
- Award zero if reference to ‘relationship’ or
‘correlation’
- For full marks both the IV and DV must be
operationalisedH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Explain how you would conduct a study using the experimental method to investigate if people are able to concentrate
better when doodling compared to when not doodling. Justify your decisions as part of your explanation.
You must refer to: [12]
- use of repeated measures design
- how you would operationalise the dependent variable (DV) in a way that would produce quantitative data
- the control of one extraneous variable
You should use your own experience of practical activities to inform your response.
Question Answer Marks Guidance
17 Max 12 Context = doodling, drawing, scribbling,
concentration etcH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Level of Response Details of required features
(RFs) included
Justification of decisions made Reference to own practical work
Good
10-12 marks
- All 3 required features addressed
- Accurate and detailed knowledge
and understanding of each feature in
context
- Good evidence of application of
required features in context
-Appropriatejustificationof all decisions
and some is contextualised
- Well developedline of reasoningthat is
clear and logicallystructured
- Explicit reference to own practical work
and clear links between own work and the
planned research for each required
feature e.g. specific mention of aim or
procedural features
- For top level, 10 marks if one RF linker,
11 marks if two and 12 marks if all three
- If there is no explicit link between own
practical work and any of the three
required features – max 9 marks
Reasonable
7-9 marks
- All 3 required features addressed
- Reasonably accurate and detailed
knowledge and understanding of
each feature
- At least two applications of required
features in context
- Some appropriate justification of
decisions related to all three required
features
- Bottom of the band if only two required
features justified
- There was some line of reasoning
evident with some structure
It two required features are addressed in detail and justified in context and explicit
links made to own practical work – award 8 marks
Limited
4–6 marks
- Two of the required features
addressed
- Limited application of required
features
- OR all three required features
referred to but in a limited way
- Attempt to justify decision(s) but weak
- Evidence of some structure, but weak
If one required feature is addressed in detail and justified in context and explicit
links made to own practical work – award 4 marks
Basic
1-3 marks
- One of the required features
addressed
- Weak application of required
features
OR more than one of the required
features referred to but in a very brief
and/or basic way
- None, or if present very weakH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Outline how you would use random sampling to obtain a sample of 20 participants for this study from a group of 120 students in a lecture
theatre at a university. [3]
Question Answer Marks Guidance
18 (a) For example:
Random sampling could be used by writing the name
of all the 120 students in a lecture theatre at a
university on slips of paper, put the slips of paper in a
box, shake it up and pull out 20 slips of paper. The
names of the students on these slips of paper would
then be asked to participate in the study on doodling
and concentration.
3 mark answer:
Clear description of how random sampling could be
used, in context
2 mark answer:
Clear description of how random sampling could be
used but not in context
OR
Attempt in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or unclear description of random sampling
(whether in context or not)
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 3 - Context – doodling, drawing, scribbling, concentration etcH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Outline one strength of using random sampling to obtain participants for this study [3]
(b) Answers could include:
More representative of the effect of doodling on
concentration of students as all students have had an
equal chance of being selected, can generalise
findings about the effects of doodling on
concentration better etc
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of strength in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline strength (whether
in context or not)
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 3 - Context – doodling, drawing, scribbling, concentration etcH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Name the sampling technique you used in any one of your own practical activities and outline one strength of obtaining participants in this
way for your study [3]
19 Answer here relates to one of the candidates own
practical activities
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of strength in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline strength (whether
in context or not)
0 marks:
If a sampling technique is simply named
No credit worthy information
3 Context – the theme of the candidates own chosen
practical activityH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Outline one strength and one weakness of not having any qualitative data in this study [6]
20 Strengths could include: easy to analyse data; easy
to compare across individuals and conditions
Weaknesses could include: don’t know reasons why
doodling may/may not affect concentration; lack of
detail in general
Up to 3 marks for each strength / weakness
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength/weakness in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength/weakness but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of strength/weakness in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline strength
/weakness (whether in context or not)
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 6 - Context – doodling, drawing, scribbling, concentration etc
Note: Accept interchanging strengths/weaknesses of
qualitative data. For example if a candidate has given a
weakness of qualitative data as a strength of now having
qualitative data in the study.H167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Outline how you could obtain some nominal data in this study [2]
21 (a) For example:
Participants could be asked a closed question asking
them to choose one of the following:
❑ Doodling helped me focus
❑ Doodling distracted me
❑ Doodling neither helped me focus or distracted me
2 mark answer:
Categories in context
1 mark answer:
An attempt at categories
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 2 - Context – doodling, drawing, scribbling, concentration etc
Note: Candidate must outline categories that relate to
collection of data regarding the IV. Do not accept
categories relating to the IV such as ‘doodling’ and ‘not
doodling’.H167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
(b) Answers could include: provides more insight about
the reason why doodling did / did not help
concentration; can create fixed choice response
options that allow ideas why doodling may help
concentration or not to be explored more etc
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of strength in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline strength (whether
in context or not)
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 3 - Context – doodling, drawing, scribbling, concentration etcH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Section C: Data analysis and interpretation
Question Answer Mark Guidance
What level of data has been collected in this study? Give reasons for your answer [2]
22 Nominal as the data is just frequent count of the
number of males and females who did or did not use
their phone whilst walking
2 mark answer:
Correct data identified and clear justification in
context
1 mark answer:
Correct data identified and justified but not in context
OR
Correct data identified and a brief attempt to justify
why in context
OR
Correct data identified
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 2 Context = mobile, phone, walk(ing), texting etcH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Outline two conclusions that can be made from the data collected in this study
23 For example: Overall, most people walk whilst using
their mobile, which suggests that they may think they
are too busy to stop whilst doing what they are on their
phone; more males than females walk whilst using
their phone, which suggests that females may be more
self-conscious of using their phone whilst walking than
males and prefer to stop whilst doing so.
Up to 2 marks for each conclusion
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of conclusion in context
1 mark answer:
Clear outline of conclusion but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of conclusion in context
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 4 Context = mobile, phone, walk(ing), texting etc
Must be conclusions (interpretation of data), and not simply
stating findings (if so cap at 1 mark max, whether one or
two findings stated)H167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Draw a fully labelled pie chart displaying the data from this study [4]
24
Pie chart showing percentage of males and females
walking or not whilst using their mobile phones
1 mark for correctly calculating what proportion of the
circle should represent each of the four behavioural
categories.
1 mark for drawing the sectors in proportional size to the
data displayed
1 mark for clear labelling of each sector of the pie chart
1 mark is awarded for a clear and appropriate title
Max 4 Context = mobile, phone, walk(ing), texting etc
Sectors of the pie chart need only be approximate sizes
(examiners do not need to check with protractor or
overlay in RM assessor)
Calculations can be percentages and/or degrees
(decimal places or whole figures) of circle (within labelling
of the pie chart, or separately at the side)
Females walking
58/200 x 100 = 29%
58/200 x 360 = 104.4 degrees
Females not walking
26/200 x 100 = 13%
58/200 x 360 = 46.8 degrees
Males walking
84/200 x 100 = 42%
84/200 x 360 = 151.2 degrees
Males not walking
32/200 x 100 = 16%
32/200 x 360 = 57.6 degreesH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Calculate the overall percentage of people using their phones whilst walking. Show your workings [3]
25 71%
84 males + 58 females = 142 in total
142/200 * 100 = 71%
3 mark answer:
Correct answer with full workings shown
2 mark answer:
Correct answer with some workings shown
1 mark answer:
Correct answer with no workings shown
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 3H167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Explain why the chi-square would be the appropriate non-parametric inferential statistical test to use to analyse the data from this study
[3]
26 (a) Reasons:
- test of difference (the study investigated the
difference between males/females walking or not whilst
using mobile phone)
- nominal data collected (frequency count of people
using phone or not whilst walking)
- independent measures design (males vs females
using phone or not whilst walking)
3 mark answer:
Two appropriate reasons provided, both in context
2 mark answer:
Two appropriate reasons provided, but only one, or
neither in context
1 mark answer:
One appropriate reason provided but, not in context
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 3 -Context = mobile, phone, walk(ing), texting etcH167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Using the extract of the tables of critical values for the chi-square test presented below, what is the critical value at the 5% probability level
for data collected in this study? [2]
(b) The critical value is 3.841
2 mark answer:
Critical value stated
1 mark answer:
Degrees of freedom correctly identified as 1 but without
stating the critical value from the table (or incorrectly
stating the critical value)
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 2 If a candidate just circles the correct critical value in the table
award 2 marks (as to be able to do this requires knowledge of
what df to use)
Award 1 mark if df = 1 is just circled on the table (so
remember to check table)
The calculated value of chi-square is 0.2681. Write the significance statement at the 5% level of probability for this study [3]
(c) X2 = 0.2681, df=1, p>0.05
OR in words
e.g. this is not a significant result (at the 5% probability
level) because the calculated value of X2 had to be
equal to or exceed the table critical value (3.841) to be
significant, therefore we reject the alternative
hypothesis and accept the null hypothesis
2 mark answer:
Correctly written significance statement (calculated
value, degrees of freedom and probability level)
OR written in words rather than a formal statement
1 mark answer:
Just stating p>0.05
OR weak and/or brief written response
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 2H167/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
Name the appropriate inferential statistical test to analyse the data from any one of your own practical activities. Give reasons for your
answer [4]
27 Depends on candidates own practical activity
4 mark answer:
Appropriate test named and justified with two or more
clear reasons in context
3 mark answer:
Appropriate test named and justified with one clear
reason in context
2 mark answer:
Appropriate test named and justified, but not in context
1 mark answer:
Appropriate test named and weak attempt to justify why
(whether in context or not)
OR correct test named only
0 marks:
No credit worthy information
Max 4 Context here = the theme of the candidates own
chosen practical activity
If incorrect test named = zero, regardless of whether any
justification is provided or not (and regardless of whether
the justification relates to the correct test)
Cap at 2 marks if correct test named and reasons given, but
one is incorrectOCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]