GCE
Psychology
H567/01: Research methods
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Psychology
H567/01: Research methods
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021Oxford
...
GCE
Psychology
H567/01: Research methods
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Psychology
H567/01: Research methods
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 2021H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
ANNOTATIONSH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Section A: Multiple choice
Ques Answer
1 B
2 D
3(a) A
3(b) B
4 B
5 D
6 C
7 A
8 A
9 C
10 A
11 B
12 D
13 A
14 C
15 D
16 D
17 B
18 B
19 BH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Section B: Research design and response
Question Answer Marks Guidance
20 The self-report method involves obtaining data from participants
through responses to questions.
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of one feature of self-report method
Possible answers:
• Uses questions to obtain responses from participants
• Likert and semantic rating scales can be used to get
opinions from participants
1 mark answer:
Identification of one feature
Possible answers:
• Uses questions
• Involves scales
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
2 Three ways to outline feature of selfreport (award 2 marks):
1 general comment on question and
response, e.g. uses questions to
obtain responses from participants
2 outline of two features of
questionnaires or interviews e.g.
open/ closed questions, types of
scales: semantic/ Likert,
structure/unstructured interviews,
3 two methods of data collection
outlined e.g. questionnaires and
interviews
21 (a) Detailed response of sample clearly contextualised
Possible answers:
Age, Gender, Number, Target Population.
2 mark answer:
Clear details provided in context
Possible answer:
20 participants aged 16-19 with a range of happiness levels
1 mark answer:
Clear details provided but not in context
2 -Context = happy, happiness,
comedy, emotion etc
Wide range of ages, gender,
ethnicity, etc. award 1 mark.H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
OR
attempt to provide details in context
Possible answer:
The participants in this study on happiness should be varied in
age and ethnicity.
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
21 (b) Clear outline of how sample would be recruited using the selfselected sampling technique. i.e. what researcher would do to
recruit the participants, how the researcher would select
participants from those who have volunteered, in context
3 mark answer:
Clear outline in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline but not in context
OR
Attempted outline in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline how self-selected sampling
could be used (whether in context or not)
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
3 Context = happy, happiness,
comedy, emotion etc
Self-selected sampling can use
posters, adverts, social media,
mailshot, etc.
21 (c) Weakness identified, elaborated/explained, contextualised
Answers could include: bias (e.g. only happy people respond);
problems obtaining a representative sample as researcher
limited in choice by type of people who respond, etc.
3 mark answer:
Clear outline in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline but not in context
Max 3 Context = happy, happiness,
comedy, emotion etc
Not generalisable/representative
without any link to self-selected
sampling technique award 1 mark
whether in context or not.
Demand characteristics is not
creditworthy.H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
OR
Attempted outline in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline of weakness of the use of
self-selected sampling (whether in context or not)
0 marks:
No creditworthy responseH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
22 Max = 15 -Context = happy, happiness, comedy, emotion
etc
Level of
response
Details of required features (RFs) included Justification
of decisions made Reference to own practical work
Good
12-15 marks
-All 4 required features (RFs) addressed in context
-Accurate and detailed knowledge and understanding of
each feature in context
-Good evidence of application of required features in
context
-Appropriate justification of all decisions and
some is contextualised
-Well developed line of reasoning that is clear
and logically structured
-Explicit reference to own practical work and clear
links between own work and the planned research,
e.g. specific mention of question/scales used or
extraneous variables controlled
-If there is no explicit clear link between own
practical work and any of the 4 required features
caps the mark at 11 maximum.
RF1- Good – two closed questions with response
categories. Reasonable – not identifying the RF as a
closed question. Limited – one closed question with
response categories. Basic – one or two questions
that could be answered as closed questions.
RF2 Good – two open questions and identified as
open questions. Reasonable – not identifying the
open question. Limited – one open question. Basic
– unclear open question(s).
RF3 Good – the questions correctly identified as
Likert and semantic differential. One Likert scale
statement (with fully labelled scale showing strength
of agreement/disagreement) and one semantic
differential scale question (clearly labelled/how to
complete). Reasonable – one of the questions is
unclear/labelling is unclear. Limited – Both of the
questions are unclear/labelling is unclear.
Basic – Rating scales are given (which are neither
Likert nor semantic differential).
RF4 – Good – the self-report can be reliably
administered e.g. 1. whether it is an
interview/questionnaire 2. if the participant does the
questionnaire at home or in front of the researcher 3.
how the participant submits the questionnaire/how
the interview is recorded.
Reasonable
8-11 marks
-At least 3 required features in context
-Reasonably accurate and detailed knowledge and
understanding of each feature
-Some appropriate justification of decision
related to required features (if no justification in
context award 8 marks)
-There was a line of reasoning evident with
some structure
Limited
4-7 marks
-At least two of the required features addressed in context
-Limited application of required features
-Attempt to justify decision(s) but weak
-Evidence of some structure, but weak
OR three or all four required features referred to but in a
limited way
If one required feature addressed in detail and justified in context and explicit links made to own practical work
award 4 marks
Basic
1-3 marks
-At least one of the required features addressed
-Weak application of required features
-None, or if present very weak
OR more than one of the required features referred to but in
a very brief and/or basic wayH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
23 Likely answers could include: dishonesty (lowering validity);
demand characteristics (lowering validity); comprehension of
questions asked (affecting reliability and / or validity) etc
For each weakness:
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of weakness in context
1 mark answer:
Clear outline of weakness but not in context
OR
attempted outline of weakness in context
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
Max 2+2 -Context = happy, happiness,
comedy, emotion etc
Identification of weakness in context
award 1 mark
Identification of weakness not in
context award 0 marks
A weakness that is specific to a type
of question (e.g. rating scale) that is
not a weakness for all self-reports is
not creditworthy.
24 (a) Clear focus on technique, i.e. identification of sampling
technique, description of how this technique is used to select the
participants, contextualised. Description of the features of the
sample is not creditworthy on its own.
3 mark answer:
Clear outline in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline but not in context
OR
Attempted outline in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempted outline (whether in context or not)
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
3 -Context = theme for candidates
own selected practical activity OR
specific location/target population of
participants.H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
24 (b) Identification and elaboration of strength plus context
Clear focus on technique not on features of sample
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of strength but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of strength in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak attempt to outline strength (whether in context
or not)
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
3 -Context = theme for candidates
own selected practical activity or
specific location/target population of
participants.H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Section C: Data analysis and interpretation
Question Answer Marks Guidance
25 (a) Total 14,21,32,28,20,8,26,12,22,18,20,21 =242 /12
Mean = 20.16666
So to 3 SFs = 20.2
1 mark for correct working
1 mark for correct mean
1 mark for correctly stating to 3 significant figures
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
3
25 (b) Order: 10, 10, 12, 12, 16, 18, 19, 21, 23, 24, 24, 24
Median = 18.5
Range = 24-10 = 14 OR 24-10 = 14+1 = 15
1 mark for ordering data correctly
1 mark for identifying median correctly
1 mark for calculating range correctly
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
3H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
26 Answer = 25% less food consumed when eyes on fridge
compared to when no eyes on fridge
Workings ...
8 items less when eyes on fridge (32-24)
8 as a percentage of 32 = 8/32 x 100 = 25%
3 mark answer:
Percentage correctly stated with full workings shown
2 mark answer:
Percentage correctly stated with some workings shown OR
Percentage only shown (no workings)
1 mark answer:
Partial workings shown e.g. 8/32 or 32-24
0 mark answer:
No credit worthy response
3H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
27 (a) There was more variation in the consumption of snacks when
eyes were not on the fridge compared to when they were. This
informs us that having eyes on the fridge has a fairly consistent
effect on the amount of food consumed across the different
participants. Without eyes on the fridge there is more variation,
which informs us that some people may be better than others at
restricting taking food from the fridge.
3 mark answer:
Clear explanation in context
2 mark answer:
Clear explanation, but not in context
OR
Attempted explanation in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak explanation (whether in context or not)
0 mark answer:
No credit worthy response
3 Context = food, snacks, eat(ing),
fridge etcH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
27 (b) The standard deviation is the square root of the variance. The
advantage of this is that the answer is a figure that is much more
typical of the actual difference (actual data collected) in the
amount of snacking taking place with or without eyes on the
fridge. The variance is a much bigger (untypical) figure as it is
the sum of the differences in each individual’s snacking
compared to the mean which is then squared (squaring makes
the answer a much bigger figure).
3 mark answer:
Clear outline in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline, but not in context
OR
Attempted outline in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak outline (whether in context or not)
0 mark answer:
No credit worthy response
3 Context = food, snacks, eat(ing),
fridge etc
Responses that refer to the
standard deviation as more
valid/accurate than the variance are
not creditworthy.H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
28 Answer T = 5
Workings
p
Number of times snacks taken from fridge during one week
(a)
Without eyes
on fridge door
(b)
With eyes
on fridge
door
Diff
(a – b)
Ranks
of diffs
Sum of
ranks of
neg’ diffs
Sum of
ranks of
pos’ diffs
a 14 10 4 7 7
b 21 18 3 5 5
c 32 24 8 10 10
d 28 24 4 7 7
e 20 16 4 7 7
f 8 10 -2 3.5 3.5
g 26 24 2 3.5 3.5
h 12 12 0 -
i 22 23 -1 1.5 1.5
j 18 12 6 9 9
k 20 19 1 1.5 1.5
l 21 21 0 −
Σr= 5 Σr= 50
1 mark for finding difference a-b
1 mark for ranking differences
1 mark for sum of negative ranks
1 mark for sum of positive ranks
1 mark for correct identification of T
5 Allow Diff to be b-a
Question Answer Marks GuidanceH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
29 (a) Table critical value = 8
2 mark answer:
Critical value correctly stated
1 mark answer:
Correct sample size used (10) but wrong critical value quoted
0 mark answer:
No creditworthy response
2
29 (b) T = 5 , n = 10, p<0.05
OR In words ...
e.g. the null hypothesis (i.e. that there is no difference in amount
of food consumed with eyes on fridge compared to without) is
rejected as the calculated value is less than the critical value.
There is a significant finding/the hypothesis is accepted (eyes on
fridge does make a difference to amount of food consumed).
2 mark answer:
Correctly written significance statement (calculated value,
sample size and probability level)
OR
written in words rather than a formal statement
1 mark answer:
just stating p<0.05
OR
weak and/or brief written response
0 mark answer:
No creditworthy response
Max 2 Context = food, snacks, eat(ing),
fridge etc OR the correct numerical
data (e.g. T=5).
1 mark for correctly saying null
rejected, hypothesis accepted.H567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
29 (c) Answers could include:
• Population/scores normally distributed ( 68% of our data
should be less than ±1 standard deviation around the
mean)
• At least interval/ratio (continuous) data
• No extreme scores
1 mark per criteria:
Appropriate criteria identified
0 marks:
No creditworthy response
2
30 Answer could include: low generalisability as participants could
be all quite well known to each other (contacts of contacts), so
all similar (e.g. all big or small snackers etc); high
generalisability as sample could have been diverse as snowball
sampling potentially allows access to individuals not known to
the researcher, so may have a variety of different snacking
habits etc
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of way sampling technique could have affected
generalisability of the data in context.
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of way sampling technique could have affected
generalisability of the data, but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of way sampling technique could have
affected generalisability of the data in context
1 mark answer:
3 Context = food, snacks, eat(ing),
fridge etcH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Brief and/or weak to outline way sampling technique could have
affected generalisability of the data (whether in context or not)
0 mark answer:
No credit worthy responseH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
Question Answer Marks Guidance
31 (a) Answer could include: ability to analyse data about snacking
more easily; can compare across conditions and individual
participants easily etc
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of advantage in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of advantage, but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of advantage in context
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak to outline advantage (whether in context or
not)
0 mark answer:
No credit worthy response
3 Context = food, snacks, eat(ing),
fridge etc
31 (b) Answer could include: no reasons for why snacks consumed
obtained
3 mark answer:
Clear outline of disadvantage in context
2 mark answer:
Clear outline of disadvantage, but not in context
OR
Attempted outline of disadvantage in context
3 Context = food, snacks, eat(ing),
fridge etcH567-01 Mark Scheme Oct 21
1 mark answer:
Brief and/or weak to outline disadvantage (whether in context or
not)
0 mark answer:
No credit worthy responseOCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]