GCE
Religious Studies
H573/03: Developments in Christian thought
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Religious Studies
H573/03: Developments in Christian thoug
...
GCE
Religious Studies
H573/03: Developments in Christian thought
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Religious Studies
H573/03: Developments in Christian thought
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 20202
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
1. ‘The God of love would not elect a limited number of
people to salvation.' Discuss.
AO1 Candidates may demonstrate knowledge and understanding
through the use of some of the following ideas:
• election means ‘choice’ and refers to the biblical notion of God
calling each person to salvation
• salvation has a wide range of meanings but in traditional
Christianity means to come fully into God’s presence in the
Kingdom of God in heaven
• it means to experience perfection in the beatific vision or not
(as hell or in a state of estrangement from God)
• election when coupled with the doctrine of predestination
explains why many people might be called to salvation but not
everyone is chosen
• the idea is contained in Matthew 25:31-46 (the Parable of the
Sheep and the Goats) – God’s last judgement – where only
the righteous are chosen to enter the heavenly kingdom and
those who thought they were righteous but have not acted
justly are excluded
• predestination suggests that the divine decree or God’s
judgement occurs either at the beginning of creation or
immediately after the Fall
• Christian theologians have developed various versions of
election and predestination: unlimited election in which God
calls all because Christ died for the sins of the whole world;
limited election in which God calls a few people because only
a few are worthy of heaven and Christ’s death atones only for
them.
AO2 Candidates may demonstrate evaluation and analysis through
the use of some of the following arguments.
• Some candidates might argue that the God of love would not elect
a limited number of people to salvation because:
o God loves all his creation and it would be unjust and
contrary to His nature to condemn some to eternal
punishment therefore as no one is excluded from God’s
love and therefore all people will, at some stage, be saved
(universalism)
o limited election undermines human free will and moral
responsibility, especially when coupled with strong version
of predestination where God appears to have elected the
righteous even before or immediately after the Fall; this
Matthew 25 is a set
text; candidates may
use other texts or ideas
not directly from the
specification but there
is no requirement to do
so.3
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
contradicts the central Christian notion that Christ died for
the sins of the world
o it makes more sense to say that although God elects the
righteous, the unrighteous elect themselves to hell through
wilfully turning away from God.
• Some candidates might argue that the God of love would elect a
limited number of people to salvation because:
o a God of love means that he is a God of justice. Justice
does not mean that everyone is entitled to salvation,
especially after the Fall. It is fair and just that only a few
should be saved and rewarded with eternal bliss
o if everyone is saved there is no point in Christ’s
redemption of the world and from Adam’s sin
o humans cannot know God’s will which is hidden from
them; they cannot know what God has or has not got in
store for them. Therefore, free will is not limited as
everyone must act as morally as they can because no-one
can know who is chosen and who is not.
• Some candidates may combine these views and argue that:
o election when it is combined with predestination is often
over simplified. The idea of election is the way the God of
love relates to all humans. Therefore, saying he only elects
a few people imposes a human limitation on God.
o God may elect a few but humans cannot know this.4
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
2. Evaluate the view that God cannot be known from
creation.
AO1 Candidates may demonstrate knowledge and understanding
through the use of some of the following ideas:
• knowing God means he can be understood in various ways. It can
mean to know of God’s existence and/or it can mean knowing as
in being in relationship with God
• natural theology suggests that as humans have reason and
discernment, then they are capable of knowing God through their
experience of the world
• experience might include seeing order and purpose in creation
and concluding that this points to God (the argument from design)
or from religious experience and a sense of the numinous and
wonder of God through music, art or the natural world or from the
experience of conscience and natural law
• revealed theology suggests that since the Fall humans cannot
know God in a true or proper sense, God can only be known when
he reveals himself to them directly/specifically
• true knowledge of God is faith in God’s grace as revealed in Jesus
Christ and sustained by the Holy Spirit
• true knowledge is when God recreates, restores and renews the
relationship between himself and the individual.
AO2 Candidates may demonstrate evaluation and analysis through
the use of some of the following arguments.
• Some candidates might argue that it is the case that God cannot
be known from creation because:
o the God who redeems the world is very different from the
God of the philosophers and natural theology. The God of
the philosophers is merely a logical principle of the
creation, a first cause or an unmoved mover, but this is
utterly different from the biblical revelation of the God of
Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Jesus Christ
o critics of the design argument point out that the design
perceived in creation and attributed to God is no more than5
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
a projection of the human mind’s tendency to order and
organise the world
o God is far greater than any mind can conceive, so humans
are only capable of seeing God’s order in creation once it
has been revealed to them in the person of Jesus Christ
o God becomes human in the person of Jesus Christ so that
human minds can now know him – he is the true ‘mirror’ or
reflection of God
o given the corruption of human nature, any form of natural
theology does not provide any knowledge or point of
contact with God.
• Some candidates might argue that God can be known from
creation because:
o if God is the creator of the world, as set out in Genesis 1,
then creation reflects his will and so he can be known
o all humans have an innate faculty to know God (which is
why there are so many religions in the world and why so
many people have a sense of the divine which they
express in music, poetry, art and architecture)
o human reason and imagination are capable of drawing
analogies between the natural world and the divine – the
Bible is a source of experiences expressed in many
different ways
o knowledge of God does not have to lead to a ‘God of the
philosophers’ abstract view of God but a God who is active
in all the processes of the natural world.
• Some candidates may combine these views and argue that:
o that natural theology is not contrary to revealed theology
and vice versa. Both require each other: without reason
revealed theology is less likely to deteriorate into irrational
faith (fideism)
o natural theology provides a point of contact with creation
from which faith in God, who reveals himself in Jesus
Christ, can be known.6
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
3. To what extent are the methods and aims of the scriptural
reasoning movement realistic?
AO1 Candidates may demonstrate knowledge and understanding
through the use of some of the following ideas:
• the scriptural reasoning movement grew out of a university setting
where academics applied scholarly analysis of texts to the
scriptures
• it was seen as a good way in which practising members of the
three main monotheistic religions Christianity, Islam and Judaism
could engage in discussion each with their own distinctive
interpretation of their scriptures.
• as the movement has grown it has provided a focused way in
which interfaith dialogue can take place. The fundamental
theological and practical value is hospitality – being open and
welcoming to the ideas of others
• although scriptural reasoning is mostly aimed at the Abrahamic
religions it is now developing to other faith traditions
• another aim is collegiality by working in a small group of no more
than twelve people. Over a period of time, as groups get to know
each other, they develop trust and openness. Having a meal
together is integral to hospitality and symbolises sharing ideas
• another aim is wisdom. The aim is not to convert or proselytise but
to explore an idea or theme through texts from the different
religions. Each person presents their set passage, interprets it and
then allows members of the group to reflect and learn on it from
their faith position.
AO2 Candidates may demonstrate evaluation and analysis through
the use of some of the following arguments.
• Some candidates might argue that the methods and aims of the
scriptural reasoning movement are realistic because:
o no-one in a group is assuming to be an authority or
claiming to be a typical representative of their religious
tradition, this enables more open-ended discussion of texts
and fuller understanding of different religious beliefs
o collegiality is essential for productive inter-faith dialogue
which aims to be cooperative and not competitive; this
works particularly well in a plural social and theological
context where the aim is to broaden one’s understanding
of religious traditions – especially in the monotheistic
Abrahamic traditions
o scriptural reasoning is also effective and reasonable for
theological exclusivists as each person is committed to the7
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
truth of their tradition and is not seeking to compromise the
doctrinal basis of their religion.
• Some candidates might argue that the methods and aims of the
scriptural reasoning movement are not realistic because:
o those who hold their scripture to be authoritative as God’s
revelation might not accept the validity of someone’s
opinion outside their own religious tradition, this could
negate the meaningfulness of exchange of ideas
o if there are no right or wrong interpretations, then who
decides on the validity of an interpretation? This might lead
to theological relativism and lack of meaningful and
insightful dialogue
o the movement so far may have worked because it has
assumed shared foundational Abrahamic beliefs, but to be
a more effective interfaith tool it needs to extend to nonAbrahamic religions. However, these faiths don’t share
these foundational beliefs and so the scriptural reasoning
model is not reasonable and is unlikely to work with nonmonotheistic faiths.
• Some candidates may combine these views and argue that:
o the scriptural reasoning model works where members are
academically well-informed and understand different
traditions and scriptural interpretations within their religion
o the problem of relativism must be taken into account by
allowing members to be critical of each other’s beliefs and
express disagreement
o scriptural reasoning is successful only when members
have intellectual humility.8
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
4. 'Freud was right that society would be happier without
Christianity.' Discuss.
AO1 Candidates may demonstrate knowledge and understanding
through the use of some of the following ideas:
• Freud believed that religions tend to create and foster
neuroses because they repress natural human
experiences and try to control them and make them
conform to social norms
• the result of religious neurosis is unhappiness, guilt and
dysfunctional societies
• he argued that the source of religious experience is wish
fulfilment, usually brought on by an unresolved Oedipus
Complex moment - a traumatic moment in childhood when
a child feels guilt after rebelling against his father. The
infantile desire to return to the pre-Oedipal moment
elevates his father to god-like proportions
• religion in general, and Christianity in particular, are the
source of obsessional behaviour which manifests itself in
rituals (such as baptism, confession and Holy Communion)
and perpetuates guilty, infantile behaviour
• Freud was optimistic that the abolition of religion and its
replacement with a secular society based on rational and
scientific principles would lead to people being much
happier; he thought this would happen in the near future.
AO2 Candidates may demonstrate evaluation and analysis through
the use of some of the following arguments.
• Some candidates might argue that Freud was right that society
would be happier without Christianity because:
o society’s welfare should be based on scientific/rational
principles and not illusory ideas which cause guilt and fear
o Freud’s analysis is supported by secularists such as
Richard Dawkins and other influential humanists who go
further even than Freud and argue that Christianity is a
source of indoctrination and a cause of fear
o even though Christianity might teach that God is love, in
reality its leaders sometimes teach about the fires of hell,
the God of judgement, the sin of being gay and other
oppressive and abusive ideas
o Christianity should not be controlling schools and other
public places of education because whether it intends to
do so or not, it is indoctrinating people and limiting their
Candidates may focus
on the idea of
secularisation and the
impact on society that it
would have (rather than
a discussion about
Freud) and this is a
valid response to the
question.9
Indicative content – Responses might include: Guidance
autonomy. Lack of autonomy reduces happiness and
prevents the development of diverse, flourishing societies.
• Some candidates might argue that Freud was not right that
society would be happier without Christianity because:
o not everything humans experience is totally rational and
scientific Christianity offers a view of the world which
celebrates the mystery and beauty of the world which in
turn enhances human social welfare
o Freud accepted that there are some mystical experiences
which science cannot explain and which are not obviously
the result of guilt and infantile wish fulfilment
o some Christians might dwell on God as judge and on the
fires of hell, but this doesn’t mean the whole religion is an
illusion – Christianity has been a source of enormous
human creativity in art, music, poetry, architecture in
response to God as revealed in the person of Jesus Christ;
not to mention its contributions in charitable works
o it does not follow that Christianity necessarily leads to
abuse and loss of autonomy as for many Christians faith is
a source of freedom and happiness.
• Some candidates may combine these views and argue that:
o Freud is right to point out that elements of religion and
Christianity can be dangerous and that left unchecked they
would do society damage
o a secular society does not mean abolishing Christianity, as
Freud suggested, but allowing it to contribute positively
alongside other religious and non-religious institutions to
enhance overall happiness.1
Level
(Mark)
Levels of Response for A Level Religious Studies: Assessment Objective 1 (AO1)
Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of religion and belief, including:
• Religious, philosophical and/or ethical thought and teaching
• Approaches to the study of religion and belief
Note: The descriptors below must be considered in the context of all
listed strands of Assessment Objectives 1 (AO1) and the indicative
content in the mark scheme.
6
(14–16)
An excellent demonstration of knowledge and understanding in response to the question:
• fully comprehends the demands of, and focusses on, the question throughout
• excellent selection of relevant material which is skillfully used
• accurate and highly detailed knowledge which demonstrates deep understanding through a complex and nuanced approach to the material used
• thorough, accurate and precise use of technical terms and vocabulary in context
• extensive range of scholarly views, academic approaches, and/or sources of wisdom and authority are used to demonstrate knowledge and understanding
5
(11–13)
A very good demonstration of knowledge and understanding in response to the question :
• focuses on the precise question throughout
• very good selection of relevant material which is used appropriately
• accurate, and detailed knowledge which demonstrates very good understanding through either the breadth or depth of material used
• accurate and appropriate use of technical terms and subject vocabulary.
• a very good range of scholarly views, academic approaches, and/or sources of wisdom and authority are used to demonstrate knowledge and understanding
4
(8–10)
A good demonstration of knowledge and understanding in response to the question:
• addresses the question well
• good selection of relevant material, used appropriately on the whole
• mostly accurate knowledge which demonstrates good understanding of the material used, which should have reasonable amounts of depth or breadth
• mostly accurate and appropriate use of technical terms and subject vocabulary.
• a good range of scholarly views, academic approaches, and/or sources of wisdom and authority are used to demonstrate knowledge and understanding
3
(5–7)
A satisfactory demonstration of knowledge and understanding in response to the question:
• generally addresses the question
• mostly sound selection of mostly relevant material
• some accurate knowledge which demonstrates sound understanding through the material used, which might however be lacking in depth or breadth
• generally appropriate use of technical terms and subject vocabulary.
• A satisfactory range of scholarly views, academic approaches, and/or sources of wisdom and authority are used to demonstrate knowledge and understanding with only partial success
2
(3–4)
A basic demonstration of knowledge and understanding in response to the question:
• might address the general topic rather than the question directly
• limited selection of partially relevant material
• some accurate, but limited, knowledge which demonstrates partial understanding
• some accurate, but limited, use of technical terms and appropriate subject vocabulary.
• a limited range of scholarly views, academic approaches, and/or sources of wisdom and authority are used to demonstrate knowledge and understanding with little success
1
(1–2)
A weak demonstration of knowledge and understanding in response to the question:
• almost completely ignores the question
• very little relevant material selected
• knowledge very limited, demonstrating little understanding
• very little use of technical terms or subject vocabulary.
• very little or no use of scholarly views, academic approaches and/or sources of wisdom and authority to demonstrate knowledge and understanding
0 (0) No creditworthy response2
Level
(Mark)
Levels of Response for A Level Religious Studies: Assessment Objective 2 (AO2)
Analyse and evaluate aspects of, and approaches to, religion and belief, including their significance, influence and
study
Note: The descriptors below must be considered in the context of
all elements of Assessment Objective 2 (AO2) and the indicative
content in the mark scheme.
6
(21–24)
An excellent demonstration of analysis and evaluation in response to the question:
• excellent, clear and successful argument
• confident and insightful critical analysis and detailed evaluation of the issue
• views skillfully and clearly stated, coherently developed and justified
• answers the question set precisely throughout
• thorough, accurate and precise use of technical terms and vocabulary in context
• extensive range of scholarly views, academic approaches and sources of wisdom and authority used to support analysis and evaluation
Assessment of Extended Response: There is an excellent line of reasoning, well-developed and sustained, which is coherent, relevant and logically structured.
5
(17–20)
A very good demonstration of analysis and evaluation in response to the question:
• clear argument which is mostly successful
• successful and clear analysis and evaluation
• views very well stated, coherently developed and justified
• answers the question set competently
• accurate and appropriate use of technical terms and subject vocabulary.
• a very good range of scholarly views, academic approaches and sources of wisdom and authority used to support analysis and evaluation
Assessment of Extended Response: There is a well–developed and sustained line of reasoning which is coherent, relevant and logically structured.
4
(13–16)
A good demonstration of analysis and evaluation in response to the question:
• argument is generally successful and clear
• generally successful analysis and evaluation
• views well stated, with some development and justification
• answers the question set well
• mostly accurate and appropriate use of technical terms and subject vocabulary.
• a good range of scholarly views, academic approaches and sources of wisdom and authority are used to support analysis and evaluation
Assessment of Extended Response: There is a well–developed line of reasoning which is clear, relevant and logically structured
3
(9–12)
A satisfactory demonstration of analysis and/evaluation in response to the question:
• some successful argument
• partially successful analysis and evaluation
• views asserted but often not fully justified
• mostly answers the set question
• generally appropriate use of technical terms and subject vocabulary.
• a satisfactory range of scholarly views, academic approaches and sources of wisdom and authority are used to support analysis and evaluation with only partial success
Assessment of Extended Response: There is a line of reasoning presented which is mostly relevant and which has some structure.
2
(5–8)
A basic demonstration of analysis and evaluation in response to the question:
• some argument attempted, not always successful
• little successful analysis and evaluation
• views asserted but with little justification
• only partially answers the question
• some accurate, but limited, use of technical terms and appropriate subject vocabulary.
• a limited range of scholarly views, academic approaches and sources of wisdom and authority to support analysis and evaluation with little success
Assessment of Extended Response: There is a line of reasoning which has some relevance and which is presented with limited structure.
1
(1–4)
A weak demonstration of analysis and evaluation in response to the question:
• very little argument attempted
• very little successful analysis and evaluation
• views asserted with very little justification
• unsuccessful in answering the question3
• very little use of technical terms or subject vocabulary.
• very little or no use of scholarly views, academic approaches and sources of wisdom and authority to support analysis and evaluation
Assessment of Extended Response: The information is communicated in a basic/unstructured way.
0 (0) No creditworthy response1
Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Level one – to be used at the end of each part of the response in the margin.
Level two – to be used at the end of each part of the response in the margin.
Level three – to be used at the end of each part of the response in the margin.
Level four – to be used at the end of each part of the response in the margin.
Level five – to be used at the end of each part of the response in the margin.
(H573 only) Level six - to be used at the end of each part of the response in the
margin.
Highlighting a section of the response that is irrelevant to the awarding of the mark.
Point has been seen and noted, e.g. where part of an answer is at the end of the script.
SUBJECT–SPECIFIC MARKING INSTRUCTIONS
H173, H573 AS and A Level Religious Studies
Introduction
Your first task as an Examiner is to become thoroughly familiar with the material on which the examination
depends. You should ensure that you have copies of these materials:
• the specification, especially the assessment objectives
• the question paper and its rubrics
• the mark scheme.
Please ask for help or guidance whenever you need it. Your first point of contact is your Team Leader.
Information and instructions for examiners
The practice scripts provide you with examples of the standard of each band. The marks awarded for these
scripts will have been agreed by the Lead Marker and Team Leaders.2
The specific task-related indicative content for each question will help you to understand how the band
descriptors may be applied. However, this indicative content does not constitute the mark scheme: it is
material that candidates might use, grouped according to each assessment objective tested by the
question. It is hoped that candidates will respond to questions in a variety of ways. Rigid demands for ‘what
must be a good answer’ would lead to a distorted assessment. Candidates’ answers must be relevant to
the question. Beware of prepared answers that do not show the candidate’s thought and which have not
been adapted to the thrust of the question. Beware also of answers where candidates attempt to reproduce
interpretations and concepts that they have been taught but have only partially understood.
Using the Mark Scheme
Please study the Mark Scheme carefully. The Mark Scheme is an integral part of the process that begins
with the setting of the question paper and ends with the awarding of grades. Question papers and Mark
Schemes are developed in association with each other so that issues of differentiation and positive
achievement can be addressed from the very start.
This Mark Scheme is a working document; it is not exhaustive; it does not provide ‘correct’ answers. The
Mark Scheme can only provide ‘best guesses’ about how the question will work out, and it is subject to
revision after we have looked at a wide range of scripts.
Please read carefully all the scripts in your allocation and make every effort to look positively for
achievement throughout the ability range. Always be prepared to use the full range of marks.
The Mark Scheme contains a description of possible/content only; all legitimate answers and approaches
must be credited appropriately. Learners are expected to make use of scholarly views, academic
approaches and sources of wisdom and authority to support their argument.
The Levels of Response must be used in conjunction with the outlined indicative content.
Assessment Objectives
Two Assessment Objectives are being assessed in all questions:
AO1 (Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of religion and belief) and
AO2 (Analyse and evaluate aspects of, and approaches to, religion and belief, including their significance,
influence and study).
Responses are credited for AO1 for selection, detail and accuracy of the knowledge and understanding of
religion and belief deployed.
Responses are credited for AO2 for how well the response addresses the question, for candidates using their
knowledge and understanding to draw, express and support conclusions in relation to the question posed.
Candidates will be assessed on the quality of the conclusions and points they argue and the clarity and
success of their argument.
Levels of Response
Questions in this paper are marked using a levels of response grid. When using this grid examiners must use
a best fit approach. Where there are both strengths and weaknesses in a particular response or particularly
imbalanced responses in terms of the assessment objectives, examiners must carefully consider which level
is the best fit for the performance.
Note that candidates can achieve different levels in each assessment objective, for example a Level 3 for
AO1, and a Level 2 for AO2.3
Please note that the Assessment Objectives being assessed are listed at the top of the mark scheme.
Where a candidate does not address all of the Assessment Objective strands listed, the candidate cannot
achieve the top level of response.
Assessment of Extended Response
The GCE General Conditions of Recognition state that:
GCE 5.1 In designing and setting the assessments for a GCE qualification which it makes available,
or proposes to make available, and awarding organization must ensure that, taken together, those
assessments include questions or tasks which allow Learners to -
a) provide extended responses
As such, the quality of extended responses are assessed in all questions. While marks are not specifically
given for this, descriptors for extended responses can be found in the AO2 Levels of Response in italics.OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]