Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Geography
H081/02: Geographical debates
Advanced Subsidiary GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leadi
...
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Geography
H081/02: Geographical debates
Advanced Subsidiary GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 2020H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
2
Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Highlight
Off page comment
Omission
Indicates questionable points / comments
Rubric error (place at start of Question not being counted)
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 4
Development of point
Irrelevant; a significant amount of material that does not answer the question
Point has been seen and noted
No Examples
Must be used on all blank pages where there is no candidate response
Evaluation
Highlighting an issue e.g. irrelevant paragraph. Use in conjunction with another stamp e.g IRRLH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
3
Subject Specific Marking Instructions
INTRODUCTION
Your first task as an Examiner is to become thoroughly familiar with the material on which the examination depends. This material includes:
• the specification, especially the assessment objectives
• the question paper and its rubrics
• the mark scheme.
You should ensure that you have copies of these materials.
You should ensure also that you are familiar with the administrative procedures related to the marking process. These are set out in the OCR booklet
Instructions for Examiners. If you are examining for the first time, please read carefully Appendix 5 Introduction to Script Marking: Notes for New
Examiners.
Please ask for help or guidance whenever you need it. Your first point of contact is your Team Leader.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
4
USING THE MARK SCHEME
Please study this Mark Scheme carefully. The Mark Scheme is an integral part of the process that begins with the setting of the question paper and ends
with the awarding of grades. Question papers and Mark Schemes are developed in association with each other so that issues of differentiation and positive
achievement can be addressed from the very start.
This Mark Scheme is a working document; it is not exhaustive; it does not provide ‘correct’ answers. The Mark Scheme can only provide ‘best guesses’
about how the question will work out, and it is subject to revision after we have looked at a wide range of scripts.
The Examiners’ Standardisation Meeting will ensure that the Mark Scheme covers the range of candidates’ responses to the questions, and that all
Examiners understand and apply the Mark Scheme in the same way. The Mark Scheme will be discussed and amended at the meeting, and administrative
procedures will be confirmed. Co-ordination scripts will be issued at the meeting to exemplify aspects of candidates’ responses and achievements; the coordination scripts then become part of this Mark Scheme.
Before the Standardisation Meeting, you should read and mark in pencil a number of scripts, in order to gain an impression of the range of responses and
achievement that may be expected.
In your marking, you will encounter valid responses which are not covered by the Mark Scheme: these responses must be credited. You will encounter
answers which fall outside the ‘target range’ of Bands for the paper which you are marking. Please mark these answers according to the marking criteria.
Please read carefully all the scripts in your allocation and make every effort to look positively for achievement throughout the ability range. Always be
prepared to use the full range of marks.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
5
AO1 AO2 AO3 Quality of extended
response
Comprehensive A wide range of detailed and
accurate knowledge that
demonstrates fully developed
understanding that shows full
relevance to the demands of
the question.
Precision in the use of
question terminology.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is consistently applied to
the context of the question, in
order to form a:
clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate.
clear, developed and convincing
interpretation that is fully
accurate.
detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure
judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence
based.
Quantitative, qualitative and/or
fieldwork skills are used in a
consistently appropriate and
effective way and with a high
degree of competence and
precision.
There is a welldeveloped line of
reasoning which is clear
and logically structured.
The information
presented is relevant
and substantiated.
Thorough A range of detailed and
accurate knowledge that
demonstrates well developed
understanding that is relevant
to the demands of the
question.
Generally precise in the use
of question terminology.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is mainly applied to the
context of the question, in order
to form a :
clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy.
clear and developed
interpretation that shows
accuracy.
detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements,
with some link between rational
conclusions and evidence.
Quantitative, qualitative and/or
fieldwork skills are used in a
suitable way and with a good
level of competence and
precision.
There is a line of
reasoning presented with
some structure. The
information presented is
in the most-part relevant
and supported by some
evidence.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
6
Reasonable Some sound knowledge that
demonstrates partially
developed understanding that
is relevant to the demands of
the question.
Awareness of the meaning of
the terms in the question.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is partially applied to the
context of the question, in order
to form a:
sound analysis that shows some
accuracy.
sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy.
sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and
conclusions, with limited use of
evidence.
Quantitative, qualitative and/or
fieldwork skills are used in a
mostly suitable way with a
sound level of competence but
may lack precision.
The information has
some relevance and is
presented with limited
structure. The
information is supported
by limited evidence.
Basic Limited knowledge that is
relevant to the topic or
question with little or no
development.
Confusion and inability to
deconstruct terminology as
used in the question.
Knowledge and understanding
shows limited application to the
context of the question in order
to form a:
simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy.
simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy.
Un-supported evaluation that
offers simple conclusions.
Quantitative, qualitative and/or
fieldwork skills are used
inappropriately with limited
competence and precision.
The information is basic
and communicated in an
unstructured way. The
information is supported
by limited evidence and
the relationship to the
evidence may not be
clear.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
7
Question Answer Mark Guidance
1 (a) Explain two ways in which continental
drift has influenced past climates.
• 100 million years ago (cretaceous period)
the continents were in different positions
(). The distribution and configuration of
the continents affect ocean
circulation/currents which can influence
the climate through heat transfer/the
Earth’s energy budget ()
• Distribution: More land mass at higher
latitudes increases ice cover which
increases albedo () and lowers the
Earth’s average temperature ().
• Movement of Antarctica south where it
was isolated from South America and
Australia. The Antarctic Circumpolar
Current formed around it, limiting heat
transfer from the north/insulating it from
warmer water further north () and
contributing to ice-house conditions/fall in
temperatures ().
4
AO1 x4
AO1 – 4 marks
2 x 1 (✓) for each way in which continental drift has influenced
past climates
2 x 1 (✓) for each explanation point
Only two ways can be credited.
Focus should be on how continental drift has influenced past
climates.
1 (b) Examine the role of international
organisations in response to climate
change.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and
understanding of the role of international
organisations in response to climate change
(AO1).
6
AO1 x3
AO2 x3
The EU and the UN are possible organisations which may be
used. Other international organisations also acceptable. The
choice will determine the content of the answer.
AO1 - 3 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the role of international
organisations in response to climate change could potentially
include:
The UNH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
8
Place-specific details should be accurate
with the amount helping determine where
within the level the response lies.
Demonstrates thorough application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a
clear and developed analysis that shows
accuracy as to the role of international
organisations in response to climate change
(AO2).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the role of international
organisations in response to climate change
(AO1).
Place specific material is present which is
partially accurate with the amount helping
determine where within the level the
response lies.
Demonstrates reasonable application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a
sound analysis that shows some accuracy
as to the role of international organisations in
response to climate change (AO2).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and
understanding of the role of international
organisations in response to climate change
(AO1).
Little or no place specific material is present
and/or is inaccurate.
In 1992, 41 countries joined the UNFCCC (United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change) which led to the
Kyoto Protocol in 1997 - this was the first time that legally binding
targets were placed on GHG emissions. Various agreements
have since taken place such as the Kyoto Protocol and the Paris
Agreement. The UN also created the IPCC (Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change) which creates reports to inform policymaking for climate change.
The EU
The ECCP (European Climate Change Programme) is the EU’s
own mitigation package to reduce GHG emissions which was
launched in 2000. Each EU state has its own policies which build
upon this. The ETS (Emissions Trading System) is a vital part
which includes Cap-and-Trade.
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
examine the role of international organisations in response to
climate change could potentially include:
• Recognition that as a global problem, climate change
requires international cooperation to successfully address.
• Creating global forums to research the global climate,
discuss findings and plan actions for the future. Examples
are likely to be given, such as the Kyoto Protocol or the
Paris Agreement.
• A recognition that ACs take the lead due to their high level
of responsibility.
• Setting ambitious and legally binding targets to mitigate
climate change.
• A consideration of success and failures, e.g.
o Successes: global cooperation - all countries
working towards the same goal of reducing
emissions; clear targets – climate change
addressed quickly through top-down schemes; EU
ETS incentivises through monetarising emissionsH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
9
Demonstrates basic application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a
simple analysis that shows limited accuracy
as to the role of international organisations in
response to climate change (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
whilst reducing the number of credits year-on-year
therefore addressed quickly;
o Failures: environmental groups – belief that
initiatives do not go far enough to mitigate climate
change; the Paris Agreement INDCs (Intended
Nationally Determined Contributions) means
countries can set themselves easy challenges, it
has a “non-punitive compliance mechanism” so a
lack of punishment if targets are not me and does
not take into account international transport - a
significant proportion of GHG emissions.
1 (c) (i) Study Fig. 1, which shows the Columbia
Glacier in Alaska in 2009 and 2015.
Using evidence from Fig. 1, identify
evidence that indicates climate change
between 2009 and 2015.
• Top left of both photos - the ice surface is
higher in 2009 than in 2015 ()
• Main part of photos – in 2009 it is largely
glacier; 2015 it is largely a lake with
floating ice ()
• Bottom left of both photos – 2009 there is
a rocky outcrop then the edge of the
glacier, 2015 the rocky outcrop extends
down a muddy looking slope to the lake
()
• Top right of both photos – what appears
to be ice in 2009 is dark with little sign of
fresh ice in 2015 ()
• Peaks of both photos – in 2009 even
though there is some cloud it looks as
though the snow on the mountain tops is
less extensive than on the mountain tops
4
AO3 x4
AO3 – 4 marks
4 x 1 mark () for correct identification of climate change
evidence.
Specific parts of the photographs should be mentioned within the
answer.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
10
in 2015 which might suggest recent falls
of snow before the 2015 photo was taken
1 (c) (ii) Using evidence from Fig. 1, analyse
reasons for differences between the two
photographs.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of
knowledge and understanding to provide
clear and developed analysis that shows
accuracy as to reasons for differences
between the two photographs (AO2).
Demonstrates thorough investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully
evidence differences between the two
photographs. There must be strong ideas
linking resource evidence to the possible
reasons for differences between the two
photographs (AO3).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of
knowledge and understanding to provide
clear and developed analysis that shows
accuracy as to reasons for differences
between the two photographs (AO2).
Demonstrates reasonable investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully
evidence differences between the two
photographs. There must be good ideas
linking resource evidence to the possible
reasons for differences between the two
photographs (AO3).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
6
AO2 x3
AO3 x3
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse the
reasons for differences between the two photographs could
potentially include:
• An increase in GHG emissions leading to the enhanced
greenhouse effect and raised temperatures
• Warmer average global temperatures over time have
caused glaciers and ice sheets globally to melt.
• Changes in albedo (from high to low) creates a positive
feedback loop where the ice melt accelerates over time -
as the ice melts, darker surfaces are revealed below and
less reflection of insolation takes place, warming the area
further.
• It is possible that differences could be due to variation in
the local climate, e.g. seasonal variations in snow and ice
melt.
AO3 - 3 marks
Evidence from the photographs of reasons for differences
between them could potentially include:
• Evidence of melting:
o The Columbia glacier previously extended beyond
the frame of the photograph in 2009 but now
terminates at the base of the mountains in the
distance, leaving a lake in its place.
o Small glaciers surrounding the main glacier in
2009 have disappeared and bare ground remains
in its place e.g. the right of the photograph.
• Some surfaces look darker in the bottom photo suggesting
lower albedo.
• The lake height is much lower than the height of the
original glacier as seen by their positions relative to the
surrounding landscape – suggests a reduction in ice/water
storage in this area.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
11
Demonstrates basic application of
knowledge and understanding to provide
clear and developed analysis that shows
accuracy as to reasons for differences
between the two photographs (AO2).
Demonstrates basic investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully
evidence differences between the two
photographs There must be some ideas
linking resource evidence to the possible
reasons for differences between the two
photographs (AO3).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
1 (d) ‘The influence of positive feedback makes
predicting climate change difficult’. To
what extent do you agree?
Level 4 (10–12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive and accurate
knowledge and understanding of the
influence of positive feedback and climate
change (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application
of knowledge and understanding to provide a
detailed and convincing evaluation offering
secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to
the extent to which the influence of positive
feedback makes predicting climate change
difficult (AO2).
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
AO1 - 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the influence of positive
feedback and climate change could potentially include:
Positive feedback amplifies change and increases disequilibrium.
There is a range of positive feedback relating to climate change
including:
• Albedo - as ice melts, it reveals a darker surface below
which is less reflective. As more radiation is absorbed, the
temperature of the land or sea increases and melts more
ice.
• Clouds: Higher temperatures increase levels of
evaporation which increases the amount of water vapour
in the atmosphere, which has a very high warming
potential. Clouds also limit the release of radiation to
space (greenhouse effect) which can raise local
temperatures.
• Vegetation: Higher temperatures cause heat stress in
tropical areas reducing the amount of photosynthesis.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
12
Demonstrates thorough and mainly
accurate knowledge and understanding of
the influence of positive feedback and
climate change (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a
detailed evaluation offering generally secure
judgements with some link between rational
conclusions and evidence as to the extent to
which the influence of positive feedback
makes predicting climate change difficult
(AO2).
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable and some
accurate knowledge and understanding of
the influence of positive feedback and
climate change (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a
sound evaluation offering generalised
judgements and conclusions with limited
links to evidence as to the extent to which
the influence of positive feedback makes
predicting climate change difficult (AO2).
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic and/or inaccurate
knowledge and understanding of the
influence of positive feedback and climate
change (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of
knowledge and understanding offering either
unsupported or minimal if any evaluation.
Carbon dioxide concentrations increase [less
sequestration (absorption through photosynthesis) and
more decomposition of decaying plant life] which further
raises temperatures.
Climate change:
• Rising temperatures (global warming), most recently
caused by increases in greenhouse gases. Leads to more
extreme weather; long term changes to climate with
implications for life (plant, animal, humans).
AO2 - 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to evaluate the
extent to which the influence of positive feedback makes
predicting climate change difficult could potentially include:
Ways in which it is not difficult:
• Advancements in technology allow in-depth analysis and
therefore patterns and correlations to be identified. The
role of positive feedback can, to a certain extent, be
identified from the data.
• Data from a variety of scales allows the role of positive
feedback loops at regional and global scales to be better
understood.
• Extrapolation of data allows us to take current and past
findings to discover what the future climate may be like.
Ways in which it is difficult:
• Many feedback loops may act positively or negatively,
which makes future predictions difficult: e.g. when clouds
reflect insolation they can provide negative feedback thus
regulating global temperatures; vegetation may form
negative feedback loops where the photosynthetic rate ofH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
13
Judgements and conclusions, if any, are
simplistic regarding the extent to which the
influence of positive feedback makes
predicting climate change difficult (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
vegetation in higher latitudes increases (more CO2
absorbed) - regulates global temperatures.
• There are so many inter-related variables involved in the
global climate that accurately predicting the climate
change is very difficult. Predictions are only as good as
the data they are based on.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
14
Question Answer Mark Guidance
2 (a) Explain two ways in which relief of land can affect
the spread of diseases.
• Fall in temperature with altitude means that some
diseases decrease in prevalence with height above
sea level (). For example, areas in the Ethiopian
Highlands above 2,000m in altitude only experience
malaria outbreaks for short periods when the
temperature has been unusually high ().
• Water is frozen () reducing spread of diseases
(). Converse equally acceptable
• Higher population densities are often lower at higher
altitudes which reduces the likelihood of
contamination of drinking water by sewage () and
communicable, water-borne diseases such as
typhoid are less likely to spread between mountain
ranges (via relocation diffusion) (). Converse
equally acceptable.
• Low relief land could increase the amount of
stagnant water (). This will increase the breeding
habitats for mosquitoes and any other waterborne,
disease carrying vectors affecting the spread of the
disease().
• Relief being a barrier to movement of people ()
and as a result the spread of diseases is lower due
to less people interacting in high relief areas().
NB do not allow mirror answers.
4
AO1 x4
AO1 – 4 marks
2 x 1 (✓) for each way in which relief of land can affect the
spread of diseases
2 x 1 (✓) for each explanation point
Only two ways can be credited.
Focus should be how relief can affect the spread of diseases.
2 (b) Examine the role of global organisations in
providing international strategies to combat
disease.
6
AO1 x3
AO2 x3
AO1 - 3 marksH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
15
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of global organisations in providing international
strategies to combat disease (AO1).
Place-specific details should be thorough with the
amount helping determine where within the level the
response lies.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to the role of global
organisations in providing international strategies to
combat disease (AO2).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of global organisations in providing
international strategies to combat disease (AO1).
Place specific material is present which is partially
accurate with the amount helping determine where
within the level the response lies.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows some accuracy as to the role of global
organisations in providing international strategies to
combat disease (AO2).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the role of global organisations in providing international
strategies to combat disease (AO1).
Little or no place specific material is present and/or is
inaccurate.
Knowledge and understanding of global organisations in
providing international strategies to combat disease could
potentially include:
WHO - likely to be the main organisation referred to; World
Bank or international NGOs may also be referenced. The
choice of global organisations will determine the content of the
answer.
WHO
Established in 1948, HQ - Geneva, the directing and
coordinating authority on international health within the UN.
Works closely with other international organisations (World
Bank and NGOs such as the Red Cross and Red Crescent).
WHO gathers health data (World Health Statistics from 194
countries), prioritises areas requiring assistance, researches
health problems, monitors the international health situation,
supports UN member states’ health strategies and provides
technical support in health crises.
Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement
The Red Cross is a private humanitarian institution to protect
human life, founded in 1863 in Geneva. Has approximately 17
million volunteers, members and staff worldwide across 187
countries. Provides education about health e.g. HIV/AIDS, First
Aid training, natural hazard drills and has been involved in
vaccination programmes (e.g. measles in Africa and India
preventing 2 million child deaths annually).
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
examine the role of global organisations in providing
international strategies to combat disease:
• Recognition that as a global problem, many diseases
such as HIV/AIDS or influenzas require international
cooperation to successfully address them.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
16
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy as to the role of global organisations in
providing international strategies to combat disease
(AO2).
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Creating global forums to research the diseases,
discuss findings and plan actions for the future.
Examples are likely to be given, such as TB or
HIV/AIDS.
• A recognition that many diseases can be prevented e.g.
measles which can now be vaccinated against and
therefore aim to eradicate diseases such as this
globally.
• Recognition that a correlation exists between
development status and disease outbreaks, particularly
water-borne and vector-borne diseases. Working
alongside disaster relief organisations to avoid
outbreaks such as cholera after a tropical storm or
earthquake when access to clean water may decrease.
• A consideration of successes and failures:
o Successes: eradication of diseases globally by
the WHO e.g. smallpox in 1977; more
sustainable through addressing environmental
and social issues also e.g. community-based
solutions, water quality, poor housing.
o Failures: the WHO have made incorrect
predictions about eradications despite cures e.g.
Cholera and Tuberculosis; often only large,
newsworthy diseases are tackled – they are less
involved with small, isolated incidents.
The Red Cross and Red Crescent helps people in disaster and
war zones in a non-discriminatory way so that all people can
access health care. It has saved thousands of lives over the
years as a result.
There have been oversights over the years which have harmed
people’s heath, e.g. the Canadian Red Cross and Red
Crescent were found to be using infected blood which infected
people with HIV and Hepatitis C.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
17
2 (c) (i) Study Fig. 2, which shows two photographs of
healthcare challenges in LIDCs.
Using evidence from Fig.2, identify evidence of
healthcare challenges faced by government
hospitals in LIDCs.
The first photo of a government hospital demonstrates
multiple challenges:
• Overcrowding () – at least 12 patients are in the
photograph within one room, which creates a
greater risk of infectious diseases spreading ()
• There are a lack of beds () just mattresses,
which highlights a lack of equipment ()
• The drip stands () create a trip hazard for the
patients and staff, evidence of a lack of health
and safety organisation within the facility ()
• Lack of waste disposal () as seen by the
number of boxes pushed against the wall ()
• Disorganised nature of the facilities () makes it
difficult for medical staff to access the patients
()
• There are limited number of water bottles around
the room (), unlikely to be enough for the
number of patients present ()
• The floor cannot be wiped clean ()on account of
the number of patients lying directly on top of it
()
• Lack of medical staff () stretched to capacity ()
4
AO3 x4
AO3 – 4 marks
2 x 1 mark () for evidence of healthcare challenges from
Figure 2.
2 x 1 mark () for challenges faced by the government
hospitals in LIDC’s.
Evidence from the photographs should be mentioned within the
answer.
2 (c) (ii) Using evidence from Fig. 2, analyse reasons why
grassroots strategies play a vital role in combating
disease risk.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
6
AO2 x3
AO3 x3
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to suggest why
grassroots strategies play a vital role in combating disease risk
could potentially include:H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
18
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to reasons why grassroots
strategies play a vital role in combating disease risk
(AO2).
Demonstrates thorough investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence
grassroots strategies that play a vital role in combating
disease risk. There must be strong ideas linking
resource evidence to the possible reasons why
grassroots strategies play a vital role in combating
disease risk (AO3).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to reasons why
grassroots strategies play a vital role in combating
disease risk (AO2).
Demonstrates reasonable investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence
grassroots strategies that play a vital role in combating
disease risk. There must be good ideas linking resource
evidence to the possible reasons why grassroots
strategies play a vital role in combating disease risk
(AO3).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to reasons why grassroots
strategies play a vital role in combating disease risk
(AO2).
Demonstrates basic investigation and interpretation of
the resource to fully evidence grassroots strategies that
play a vital role in combating disease risk There must
• Grassroots strategies empower local communities –
their healthcare is put in their hands which is more
sustainable than involving external agencies
• Women are included in grass roots scale strategies
which is not always the case with top-down schemes,
even though they are key players in providing food and
water to local communities
• Volunteers can be used which removes a cost
• Outbreaks can be dealt with rapidly because local
medical services are trained and ready; top-down often
requires transport to cities which can be both lengthy
and costly
• The local population are focused on the needs of their
community – their issues and solutions e.g.
contamination of local water and the need to prevent it
with latrines and/ or water treatment
• The Cholera epidemic (12 patients pictured) could have
been avoided if local people had been educated about
safe water and the local water supplies, sewage
disposal etc were safer, through grass roots strategies.
AO3 - 3 marks
Evidence from Fig.2 to analyse reasons why grassroots
strategies play a vital role in combating disease risk could
potentially include:
• Volunteers could increase the workforce available from
5 to treat the patients
• Lots of people waiting for a medical exam in the
grassroots photo - evidently a need for these strategies
• Access to medical exams for those who may not be
able to afford to travel to a hub for a proper hospital
• Grassroots helps the most vulnerable (young and
elderly) by giving greater access.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
19
be some ideas linking resource evidence to the
possible reasons why grassroots strategies play a vital
role in combating disease risk (AO3).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
2 (d) ‘Disease epidemics pose the greatest health
problem in developing countries’. To what extent do
you agree?
Level 4 (10–12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive and accurate
knowledge and understanding of epidemics and other
health problems in developing countries (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a detailed and
convincing evaluation offering secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which disease epidemics pose the
greatest health problems in developing countries (AO2).
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough and mainly accurate
knowledge and understanding of epidemics and other
health problems in developing countries (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation offering
generally secure judgements with some link between
rational conclusions and evidence as to the extent to
which disease epidemics pose the greatest health
problems in developing countries (AO2).
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
AO1 - 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of disease epidemics and other
health problems in developing countries could potentially
include:
• The speed at which diseases spread in developing
countries can be very rapid.
• Epidemics create a significant strain on health centres
within a country.
• Other health problems as counterarguments including lack
of Doctors, education programmes, engagement of the
population.
• Involvement of the WHO in many epidemics in developing
countries means that epidemics should not pose the
greatest health problem.
• Expect case study detail to be included e.g. Ebola, Covid-
19, Malaria, HIV/ AIDs, influenza, cholera; accept
pandemics as an example of an epidemic.
AO2 - 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to evaluate the
extent to which disease epidemics pose the greatest health
problems in developing countries could potentially include:
• Reasons may be given for rapid disease diffusion in
developing countries such as poor sanitation, lack of
education, lack of engagement, which means that health
agencies cannot easily limit their effect.
• Epidemics stretch the resources of health centres within
developing countries. This limits the extent to which they
can be preventative in their approach.
• Evidence for and against the statement.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
20
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable and some accurate
knowledge and understanding of epidemics and other
health problems in developing countries (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation
offering generalised judgements and conclusions with
limited links to evidence as to the extent to which
disease epidemics pose the greatest health problems in
developing countries (AO2).
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic and/or inaccurate knowledge and
understanding of epidemics and other health problems
in developing countries (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding offering either unsupported or minimal if
any evaluation. Judgements and conclusions, if any,
are simplistic regarding the extent to which disease
epidemics pose the greatest health problems in
developing countries (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
• Expect case study detail to be used.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
21
Question Answer Mark Guidance
3 (a) Explain two ways in which ocean basins can
change in size over time.
• Mid-oceanic ridges exist in areas where the tectonic
plates move apart (divergent/ constructive plate
boundaries) (). An example includes the MidAtlantic Ridge where the plates are moving apart at
a rate of approximately 2.5cm per year. This causes
sea-floor spreading and widening of the ocean over
time ().
• Tectonic plates may move towards one another
(convergent/ destructive plate boundaries) which
can cause the ocean to narrow (). The gradient of
the continental shelf and slope can influence the
basin size, a higher angle resulting in a greater
overall basin size ().
• Sediment entering the ocean from surrounding land
masses can reduce the capacity of the oceans ()
by accumulating on the seabed or around guyots
(former volcanoes) ().
4
AO1 x4
AO1 – 4 marks
2 x 1 (✓) for each way in which ocean basins can
change in size over time
2 x 1 (✓) for each explanation point
Only two ways can be credited.
Focus should be ocean basins and how they can
change in size (area and/or volume).
3 (b) Examine the use of international frameworks in the
management of ocean resources.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the use of international frameworks in the
management of ocean resources (AO1).
Place-specific details should be accurate with the
amount helping determine where within the level the
response lies.
6
AO1 x3
AO2 x3
AO1 - 3 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the use of
international frameworks in the management of ocean
resources could potentially include:
The UNCLOS is likely to be the main framework
which is referred to, although the IWC (International
Whaling Commission) may be referenced. The choice
of international framework will determine the content
of the answer.
The UNCLOSH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
22
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to the use of
international frameworks in the management of ocean
resources (AO2).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the use of international frameworks in
the management of ocean resources (AO1).
Place specific material is present which is partially
accurate with the amount helping determine where
within the level the response lies.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows some accuracy as to the use of international
frameworks in the management of ocean resources
(AO2).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the use of international frameworks in the management
of ocean resources (AO1).
Little or no place specific material is present and/or is
inaccurate.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy as to the use of international
frameworks in the management of ocean resources
(AO2).
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
The UNCLOS is the international agreement which
came into effect in 1994 and defines the rights and
responsibilities of nations with respect to their use of
the world's oceans, establishing guidelines for
businesses, the environment, and the management of
marine natural resources.
The IWC
The IWC was founded in 1946 and, with its now 89
member governments, is the organization responsible
for the management of whale species. In 1986, a
moratorium banned commercial whaling with limited
catches allowed for communities for whom it is
culturally and economically important.
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and examine the use of international
frameworks in the management ocean resources
could potentially include:
• Recognition that as a global common, ocean
use requires international cooperation to be
successfully managed.
• The UNCLOS has expanded since it was first
established to include the International
Seabed Authority to oversee the exploitation of
sea-bed resources.
• A consideration of success and failures, e.g.
o Successes: provided clarity about use
of the oceans; IWC has enabled the
population of whales to increase;
creates a culture of cooperation on a
global scale.
o Failures: exact boundaries often
disputed e.g. Russia and Arctic
seabed; piecemeal when multiple
separate treaties; more managementH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
23
issues have emerged since
establishment e.g. acidification and
bio-prospecting – stretched to capacity;
pressure from Norway and Japan to
whale; whales can be harmed by nonwhaling activities so limits IWC impact.
3 (c) (i) Study Fig. 3, which shows part of the Great Barrier
Reef, Australia, in 2009 and 2010.
Using evidence from Fig.3, identify evidence of
change in this coral reef between 2009 and 2010
• More fish in 2009 than 2010 ()
• Many of the corals are significantly smaller, if
present at all, in 2010 compared to 2009 ()
• The water appears more turbid in 2010 than 2009
()
• Fish are no longer present but there is a shark –
change in species ()
• One coral in the background to the left of the
image remains in the 2010 photographs which
was present in the 2009 image ()
4
AO3 x4
4 x 1 mark () for correct identification of change
between the photographs.
Evidence from the photographs should be mentioned
within the answer.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
24
3 (c) (ii) Using evidence from Fig. 3, analyse the reasons for
differences identified in (c)(i).
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO2).
Demonstrates thorough investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence identified
in (c)(i). There must be strong ideas linking resource
evidence to the possible reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO3).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to reasons for
differences identified in (c)(i) (AO2).
Demonstrates reasonable investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence
differences identified in (c)(i). There must be good ideas
linking resource evidence to the possible reasons for
differences identified in (c)(i) (AO3).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO2).
Demonstrates basic investigation and interpretation of
the resource to fully evidence differences identified in
(c)(i). There must be some ideas linking resource
evidence to the possible reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO3).
6
AO2 x3
AO3 x3
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse the reasons for differences identified in (c)(i)
could potentially include:
• Increased temperatures causing bleaching
• Sea level rise: increasing the depth of water
over corals thereby reducing light levels.
• Damaged to cause the reef from tourism
related activities.
• Ocean acidification: carbon dioxide emissions
diffuse into the ocean creating a weak
carbonic acid which bleaches coral (the pH of
the oceans has decreased by 0.1 since
records began).
• Increase wave energy from more intense
storms.
• Bottom trawling fishing: large nets scrape the
sea floor which can smash up coral.
AO3 - 3 marks
Evidence from the photographs of reasons for
differences identified in (c)(i) could potentially include:
• Thermal expansion of water due to global
warming.
• The lack of fish could be evidence of
destructive fishing.
• The high level of damage in the one year
between 2009 and 2010 could suggest a
sudden catastrophic event such as waves
generated by a severe storm or tsunami.
• If the coral was previously near its limits
(depth, temperature, salinity and clarity of
water) relatively small changes in these could
cause damage, but not as quickly as the
differences between 2009 and 2010 indicate.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
25
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
3 (d) ‘Piracy poses the greatest political challenge to the
use of oceans in the 21st century’. To what extent
do you agree?
Level 4 (10–12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive and accurate
knowledge and understanding of piracy and other
political challenges to the use of oceans in the 21st
century (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a detailed and
convincing evaluation offering secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which piracy poses the greatest
political challenge to the use of oceans in the 21st
century (AO2).
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough and mainly accurate
knowledge and understanding of piracy and other
political challenges to the use of oceans in the 21st
century (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation offering
generally secure judgements with some link between
rational conclusions and evidence as to the extent to
which piracy poses the greatest political challenge to
the use of oceans in the 21st century (AO2).
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable and some accurate
knowledge and understanding of piracy and other
political challenges to the use of oceans in the 21st
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
AO1 - 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of piracy and other
political challenges to the use of oceans in the 21st
century could potentially include:
• Greater transcontinental shipping brings about a
rise in piracy; the two go hand in hand
• Case study detail e.g. the choke points of the
Malacca Straight or the Gulf of Aden.
• Crew being held at ransom involves government
negotiations which can create tensions between
countries.
• Incidents have gone down in recent years due to
the involvement of maritime coalitions.
• Alternative political challenges may include:
o Shipping, including China’s growing naval
power
o Fishing disputes between nations
o Use of the oceans by different nations,
territories and the implementation of the
UNCLOS.
o The production of pollution
o Migration e.g. across the Mediterranean
Sea
AO2 - 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
evaluate the extent to which piracy poses the greatest
political challenge to the use of oceans in the 21st
century could potentially include:
• Piracy is often affected by weather conditions and
incidents therefore decrease in monsoon seasons;
this makes it less of a challenge than non-weather
related challenges such as pollution production.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
26
century (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation
offering generalised judgements and conclusions with
limited links to evidence as to the extent to which piracy
poses the greatest political challenge to the use of
oceans in the 21st century (AO2).
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic and/or inaccurate knowledge and
understanding of piracy and other political challenges to
the use of oceans in the 21st century (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding offering either unsupported or minimal if
any evaluation. Judgements and conclusions, if any,
are simplistic regarding the extent to which the
influence of positive feedback makes predicting climate
change difficult (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
• Influence of maritime coalitions (EU, NATO etc).
Patrolling the most vulnerable areas has reduced
attacks i.e. reducing the challenge.
• Petro-piracy (theft from tankers) is becoming a
greater problem e.g. in the Gulf of Guinea
therefore challenges relating to piracy have
evolved.
• Piracy is difficult to eradicate due to links to
organised crime networks which are extensive
and well-disguised e.g. through money laundering.
• Piracy v other political challenges. a) Depends on
the location e.g. dangerous migration across the
Mediterranean or fishing ‘wars’ in the North Sea
cannot be compared with piracy in the Gulf of
Aden, b) economic cost e.g. additional costs to
shipping c) political issues e.g. attacks on foreign
nationals leading to negotiations, loss of life.
• Geographical location can influence the extent
that piracy can be the greatest challenge.
Expect case study detail to be used to offer evidence
for and against the statement.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
27
Question Answer Mark Guidance
4 (a) Explain two ways in which soil characteristics can
affect food security.
• Soils are the mixture of mineral and organic matter
in which crops grow (); they supply water,
nutrients and material in which root systems can
develop ().
• Soils are the mixture of mineral and organic matter
in which crops grow (). Without soil plants cannot
grow (unless an artificial replacement is found as in
high-tech glasshouse systems) ().
• Soil depth, drainage, texture, structure, pH and
mineral content influence food production (), and
many essential nutrients – mainly nitrogen,
phosphorus, potassium and calcium () – are
absorbed from soil by plant roots ()
4
AO1 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
2 x 1 (✓) for each way in which soil characteristics
can affect food security
2 x 1 (✓) for each explanation point
Only two ways can be credited.
4 (b) Examine the role of food retailers in influencing the
global food system.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the role of food retailers in influencing the global food
system (AO1).
Place-specific details should be accurate with the
amount helping determine where within the level the
response lies.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to the role of food
retailers in influencing the global food system (AO2).
6
AO1 x3
AO2 x3
AO1 - 3 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the role of food
retailers in influencing the global food system could
potentially include:
• Fast-food retailers such as McDonalds has led
to dietary change e.g. in China where there is
an emerging middle class; meat consumption
here has increased six-fold in 30 years.
• Advertising provided by such retailer’s
changes food consumption patterns quickly
creating more demand for meat and dairy
products in particular.
• Retailers also influence agriculture through
consumer demands e.g. rise in cattle ranching
in South America.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
28
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the role of food retailers in influencing
the global food system (AO1).
Place specific material is present which is partially
accurate with the amount helping determine where
within the level the response lies.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows some accuracy as to the role of food retailers in
influencing the global food system (AO2).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the role of food retailers in influencing the global food
system (AO1).
Little or no place specific material is present and/or is
inaccurate.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy as to the role of food retailers in
influencing the global food system (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Retailers influencing the availability of
seasonal produce.
• Recent changes by food retailers influencing
healthy eating options.
• TNCs such as Tesco and Wal-Mart
o Major role in food supply chains e.g.
chosen suppliers/farmers who follow
production rules;
o Aim for maximum profit gain;
distribution globally.
• TNCs often target investment opportunities
e.g. EDCs with an emerging middle class and
large populations.
• The rise of Fair Trade and sustainable food
production in ACs with the recent rise in
environmental concern e.g. Iceland + palm oil
advert.
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse the role of food retailers in influencing the
global food system could potentially include:
• Recognition of positive feedback whereupon
dietary changes also serve to attract further
fast-food retailers which accelerates changes
in the food system globally.
• Reasons for influences of retailers on the
global food system e.g. maximise profit, quality
control, meet consumer demands.
4 (c) (i) Study Fig. 4, which shows a fenced area of the
Karoo Desert in South Africa.
Using evidence from Fig.4, identify differences in
the vegetation either side of the fence.
4
AO3 x4
4 x 1 mark () for correct identification of differences
in the landscape either side of the fence.
Specific use of the evidence from Figure 4 should be
mentioned within the answer.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
29
• Grass/ vegetation: abundant on left side of the
photograph and not on right (); grass (fairly
long) on left, no grass on right ()
• Height of shrubs: taller on left than right()
• Number of shrubs: at least 10 shrubs in the
foreground on the left, none on the right. ()
• Bare ground: the right side - approximately 70%
bare, dry ground (), 0% on left side()
• Trees: the background of the right part of the
photograph has trees, which are not as evident in
the left part ()
4 (c) (ii) Using evidence from Fig. 4, analyse reasons for the
differences identified in (c)(i).
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO2).
Demonstrates thorough investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence identified
in (c)(i). There must be strong ideas linking resource
evidence to the possible reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO3).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to reasons for
differences identified in (c)(i) (AO2).
Demonstrates reasonable investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence
differences identified in (c)(i). There must be good ideas
linking resource evidence to the possible reasons for
6
AO2 x3
AO3 x3
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse the reasons for the differences identified in
(c)(i). could potentially include:
• Causes of desertification e.g.:
o Overgrazing: livestock such as goats or
sheep exceed the carrying capacity of
the land so vegetation is unable to
grow.
o Exhaustion of land from overuse: soil
nutrients are depleted and harvesting
leaves the soil bare and susceptible to
wind and water erosion.
o Fires: large areas are cleared to create
new farmland which leads to
degradation.
AO3 - 3 marks
Evidence from the photographs of reasons for
differences identified in (c)(i) could potentially include:
• The fence suggests livestock control; possibly
on the right overgrazing is taking place.
• Land degradation is evident from bare earth
and the lack of vegetationH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
30
differences identified in (c)(i) (AO3).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO2).
Demonstrates basic investigation and interpretation of
the resource to fully evidence differences identified in
(c)(i). There must be some ideas linking resource
evidence to the possible reasons for differences
identified in (c)(i) (AO3).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
• Abundant vegetation on the left side evidences
alternative farming practices which are more
sustainable and have not exhausted the land.
4 (d) ‘Food aid is the least effective method for tackling
food insecurity’. To what extent do you agree?
Level 4 (10–12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive and accurate
knowledge and understanding of food aid and other
methods for tackling food insecurity (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a detailed and
convincing evaluation offering secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the effectiveness of food aid as a method for
tackling food insecurity (AO2).
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough and mainly accurate
knowledge and understanding of food aid and other
methods for tackling food insecurity (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation offering
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
AO1 - 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of food aid and other
methods for tackling food insecurity could potentially
include:
• Mention of examples such as bilateral
agreements between governments, the work
of international agencies such as the WFP,
and the storing and distribution of major food
staples such as rice; types include project food
aid or emergency or relief food aid.
• In 2011 there was a major review of food aid
through the FAC (Food Aid Convention) –
many questioned the effectiveness of food aid.
• The main benefit is that it saves lives in
emergency situations.
• Problems include creating dependency,
putting farmers in recipient countries out of
business, and creating power imbalances
between donor and recipient nations.
• Other strategies for tackling food insecurity are
likely to be mentioned e.g. top-down initiativesH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
31
generally secure judgements with some link between
rational conclusions and evidence as to the
effectiveness of food aid as a method for tackling food
insecurity (AO2).
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable and some accurate
knowledge and understanding of food aid and other
methods for tackling food insecurity (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation
offering generalised judgements and conclusions with
limited links to evidence as to the effectiveness of food
aid as a method for tackling food insecurity (AO2).
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic and/or inaccurate knowledge and
understanding of food aid and other methods for
tackling food insecurity (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding offering either unsupported or minimal if
any evaluation. Judgements and conclusions, if any,
are simplistic regarding the effectiveness of food aid as
a method for tackling food insecurity (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
such as economic development and
agricultural restructuring; education,
technological strategies e.g. GM crops;
appropriate methods e.g. rainwater harvesting
etc.
AO2 - 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
evaluate the effectiveness of food aid as a method for
tackling food insecurity could potentially include:
Benefits
• Food aid has saved lives in emergency
situations e.g. following the Nepal Earthquake
in 2015.
• Proper use can save lives, protect livelihoods
and promote recovery following disasters.
Problems
• Often food aid reflects the interests of the
donor countries as opposed to the recipients’
needs e.g. donor-driven uses food aid as a
vehicle to dispose of surpluses from ACs e.g.
the USA, Canada, the EU etc., creating
geopolitical ties which may not be favourable
to the LIDC.
• Creates a culture of food aid dependency for
recipient countries.
• A flooding of markets in LIDCs can put
indigenous farmers out of business.
Expect case study detail to be used to offer evidence
for and against the statement e.g. emergency food aid
in Nepal.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
32
Question Answer Mark Guidance
5 (a) Explain two causes of volcanic activity at hot spots.
A hot spot is a fixed area of intense volcanic activity
where magma from a rising mantle plume reaches the
Earth’s surface ().As the plate moves over the plume,
volcanoes that were once active become dormant and
then extinct () with the area directly above the plume
being the most active.
Continental drift and the movement of a plate over a
plume creates a chain of volcanic islands (), for
example the movement of the Pacific plate northwest at
an average rate of 10cm per year has created the
basaltic Hawaiian Islands ().
4
AO1 x4
2 x 1 (✓) for each cause of volcanic activity at hot
spots.
2 x 1 (✓) for each explanation point
Only two causes can be credited.
Credit the use of diagrams in showing the relationship
between plate movement and vulcanicity.
Credit the use of examples.
5 (b) Examine how and why the frequency of tectonic
hazards globally has changed over time.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the frequency of tectonic hazards and change over
time (AO1).
Place-specific details should be accurate with the
amount helping determine where within the level the
response lies.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to how and why the
frequency of tectonic hazards globally has changed
over time (AO2).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
6
AO1 x3
AO2 x3
AO1 - 3 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the frequency of
tectonic hazards and change over time could
potentially include:
• The number of tectonic hazards has increased
over the past 50 years and now averages
around 30 per year globally.
• There are seemingly more tsunamis in the
past two decades than previously, including
the Sumatra-Andaman tsunami of 2004, the
Tōhoku tsunami of 2011 and the Sulawesi
tsunami of 2018.
• In terms of fatalities, numbers affected and
economic cost, a few years stand out as being
particularly disastrous, including 2012.
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse how and why the frequency of tectonic
hazards globally has changed over time could
potentially include:H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
33
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the frequency of tectonic hazards and
change over time (AO1).
Place specific material is present which is partially
accurate with the amount helping determine where
within the level the response lies.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows some accuracy as to how and why the frequency
of tectonic hazards globally has changed over time
(AO2).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the frequency of tectonic hazards and change over time
(AO1).
Little or no place specific material is present and/or is
inaccurate.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy as to how and why the frequency of
tectonic hazards globally has changed over time (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Changing definitions or differing definitions
between sources of what constitutes as a
disaster means that the events which are
included in global statistics gives the illusion
that the number of hazards has increased.
• Events are more reported than previously; we
have instant access to 24 hour news which
also gives the illusion that the number of
events has increased. Such events are often
reported by the media due to public interest,
and as such there is also an element of overselection of these types of events.
• Equipment for recording tectonic events has
improved which means that seismometers
identify much smaller tremors than previously
which may add to the global statistics.
• Humans, and reporting equipment, are present
in many more parts of the globe than
previously which means that few events
escape identification and recording.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
34
5 (c) (i) Study Fig 5, which shows the town of Amatrice in
central Italy before and after the 2016 earthquake.
Using evidence from Fig.5, identify evidence of the
impact of the 2016 earthquake.
• Access made difficult (): centre of right hand
photograph: the road has changed: course, the
road markings have gone and the top layer of
tarmac is no longer visible ()
• Property (both businesses and homes) severely
damaged (): left of photograph: the houses
which were structurally sound in photograph A
are a pile of broken and scattered debris in
photograph B ().
• Unemployment () created as a result of
damage to local businesses ()e.g. restaurants
• Increase in the number of people made
homeless ()due to damage of residential
property().
• Infrastructure damage (): cable dangling on
the left which probably provided electricity to the
buildings ().
• Demand for volunteers (): bottom of
photograph: there are more people in
photograph B, possibly to volunteer to help in
the clear up which requires their time and
availability ().
4
AO3 x4
2 x 1 mark () for correct identification of evidence of
the impact of the 2016 earthquake.
2 x 1 mark () for each explanation point.
Use of the resource should be mentioned within the
answer.
5 (c) (ii) Using evidence from Fig.5, analyse strategies that
could be used to manage hazards from earthquakes
in Advanced Countries.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
6
AO2 x3
AO3 x3
AO2 - 3 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding of
strategies that could be used to manage hazards from
earthquakes in ACs could potentially include:H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
35
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to strategies that could be used
to manage hazards from earthquakes in ACs (AO2).
Demonstrates thorough investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence
strategies that could be used to manage hazards from
earthquakes in ACs. There should be strong ideas
linking resource evidence to strategies that could be
used to manage hazards from earthquakes in ACs
(AO3).
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide clear and developed
analysis that shows accuracy as to strategies that could
be used to manage hazards from earthquakes in ACs
(AO2).
Demonstrates reasonable investigation and
interpretation of the resource to fully evidence
strategies that could be used to manage hazards from
earthquakes in ACs. There must be good ideas linking
resource evidence to strategies that could be used to
manage hazards from earthquakes in ACs (AO3).
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy as to strategies that could be used
to manage hazards from earthquakes in ACs (AO2).
Demonstrates basic investigation and interpretation of
the resource to fully evidence strategies that could be
used to manage hazards from earthquakes in ACs.
There must be some ideas linking resource evidence to
• Building design and strength: earthquakeproof buildings with cross-bracing or pivots
minimise the damage due to being able to
move flexibly during a seismic event. Rigid
structures are more likely to experience
damage and therefore collapse during an
earthquake.
• Education: practicing earthquake drills and
preparing earthquake emergency kits
minimises the number of fatalities due to
people understanding what to do during a
seismic event.
• Preparation for secondary hazards:
o Avalanche clearance or barriers:
reduces further casualties from
avalanches or landslides during or after
a seismic event and improves access
to remote areas.
o Emergency gas shut offs: prevents
fires after an earthquake has occurred.
• Emergency procedure: fast and effective
emergency services can reduce further
casualties.
Do not credit prediction.
AO3 - 3 marks
Evidence from interpretation of the resource could
potentially include:
• The buildings to the left of the photographs
clearly lacked earthquake-proof design; they
appear to be relatively old in the before
photograph and as such it is unlikely that they
were made using earthquake-proof
technology.
• Photograph to the right: the road has been
cleared by emergency services and/orH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
36
strategies that could be used to manage hazards from
earthquakes in ACs. (AO3).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
volunteers to allow access to damaged parts
of the town.
• There are four people in the foreground of the
after picture, more in the background, who are
likely helping with the clear up operation to
minimise deaths from people trapped during
the event.
5 (d) “Tsunamis are the most damaging hazard
generated by earthquakes”. To what extent do you
agree?
Level 4 (10–12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive and accurate
knowledge and understanding of hazards generated by
earthquakes (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a detailed and
convincing evaluation offering secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
of the extent to which tsunamis are the most damaging
of the hazards generated by earthquakes. (AO2).
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough and mainly accurate
knowledge and understanding of hazards generated by
earthquakes (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation offering
generally secure judgements with some link between
rational conclusions and evidence of the extent to which
tsunamis are the most damaging of the hazards
generated by earthquakes (AO2).
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable and some accurate
knowledge and understanding of hazards generated by
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
AO1 - 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the hazards
generated by earthquakes could potentially include:
• Ground shaking and displacement: horizontal
movements tend to create the most damage to
buildings and infrastructure.
• Liquefaction: fine-grain sediments behave like
liquids and so lose their strength.
• Landslides and avalanches: ground shaking
and liquefaction can cause slope failure in high
relief regions e.g. the Himalayas.
• Tsunamis: underwater earthquakes cause the
sea bed to rise vertically, displacing the water
above it. High velocities and wave shoaling at
the coast cause waves arrive unexpectedly
and to be as high as 30 metres, both of which
add to the damage created.
Credit use of relevant case study detail.
Not all hazards need to be considered to achieve full
marks.
AO2 - 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
evaluate the extent to which tsunamis are the most
damaging of all the hazards generated by
earthquakes could potentially include:
Evaluation of damage caused by each hazardH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
37
earthquakes (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation
offering generalised judgements and conclusions with
limited links to evidence of the extent to which tsunamis
are the most damaging of the hazards generated by
earthquakes (AO2).
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic and/or inaccurate knowledge and
understanding of hazards generated by earthquakes
(AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding offering either unsupported or minimal if
any evaluation. Judgements and conclusions, if any,
are simplistic regarding the extent to which tsunamis
are the most damaging of the hazards generated by
earthquakes (AO2).
0 marks
No response or no material worthy of credit.
In agreement with the statement:
Areas obliterated by amount of water; difficulties
detecting due to high velocities and long wavelengths/
low heights; radial spread means large areas of
coastline are affected; too strong and/or high for
tsunami walls to contain; rebuild creates temporary
increase in vulnerability; contamination can cause
disease e.g. cholera.
Disagreement with the statement:
Seismometers and buoys help in prediction and
therefore preparation; sea walls offer some protection;
ground shaking and displacement occur more
frequently so cause more global damage; landslides
and avalanches restrict access to further areas but
tsunamis are more localised; less immediate
preparation time with ground shaking and
displacement; recognition that the hazards are not
mutually exclusive; significant role of preparation
makes it difficult to provide a generalised answer.
Geographical location of places and proximity to plate
tectonics can influence the damage caused.
Candidates need to weigh up tsunami damage
against that of other hazards to acknowledge “the
extent of agreement”.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
38
Question Answer Mark Guidance
6 (a) With reference to Fig.6, suggest how rising sea level
might influence placemaking.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
rising sea level and placemaking (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
interpretation that shows accuracy of how rising sea level
might influence placemaking (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
linking resource evidence of rising sea level to
placemaking.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of rising sea level and placemaking (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy of how rising sea level might influence
placemaking (AO2).
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of sea level rise and
placemaking could potentially include:
• Ways in which sea level rise may affect urban areas
such as:
o Built environment e.g. inundation of low-lying
land, flooding roads, offices, houses; damage
from debris and mud on roads and walls after
the water has subsided, then reduces ease of
transport
o Socio-economic: deterring investment and
immigration; deterring tourists and reducing
income from tourism; emigration to less
vulnerable areas e.g. cities at higher altitudes.
• Placemaking involves:
o Built environment: housing developments;
transport improvements; change in street
landscape e.g. widening streets,
pedestrianizing areas, planting trees, installing
more street furniture; art e.g. graffiti; flagship
projects.
o Socio-economic: investing in businesses;
marketing the area with a new image and
identity; providing more education housing
opportunities.
• Allow additional reference to case studies.
AO2 - 4 marksH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
39
This will be shown by including developed ideas linking
resource evidence of rising sea level to placemaking.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of sea
level rise and placemaking (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy of how rising sea level might influence
placemaking (AO2).
There will be simple ideas linking resource evidence of
rising sea level to placemaking.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
Application of knowledge and understanding to interpret
how rising sea level might influence placemaking could
potentially include:
• Flood defences: inundation of the land creates the
need for defences e.g. the Thames Barrier in London
which affects the aesthetics of the city. This then may
go on to deter tourists if it is an area famed for an
attractive coastline or reassure investors that the area
is safe, preventing a decline in investment.
• Infrastructure: transport which is less affected by
frequent inundation from the sea, e.g.
encouragement for people to ride bikes, or train
tracks or roads being raised higher on bridges than
the predicted sea level rise; drains and sewers
reconfigured to prevent overground contamination
during floods.
• Reimaging/ rebranding: representing the city to
prevent a decline in investment or tourism, e.g.
publicising other areas of the city which are likely to
be of interest other than the seafront.
• Emergency services: relocated away from the
coastline to areas which are both at higher altitude
whilst being close to the population.
• Property development: town planners may need to
encourage property developers to focus new-builds
on areas which are low risk from flooding.
• Green spaces: integrated into the city design to allow
water to infiltrate and be stored during flood events.
• Reference to the figure could include the mention of
the water rising around high-rise buildings which
contributes significantly to New York’s identity;
increased inundation along roads; increased need for
bridges and green spaces.
6 (b) Examine how increases in global mean temperatures
can influence weathering processes within ONE
landscape system that you have studied.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of increases in global
mean temperatures and weathering processes within one
landscape system could potentially include:H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
40
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
increases in global mean temperatures and weathering
processes within one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how increases in global mean
temperatures can influence weathering processes in ONE
landscape system (AO2).
There must be well-developed ideas of how increases in
global mean temperatures can influence weathering
processes.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of increases in global mean temperatures and weathering
processes within one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows
some accuracy of how increases in global mean
temperatures can influence weathering processes in ONE
landscape system (AO2).
There must be developed ideas of how increases in global
mean temperatures can influence weathering processes.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
• Detail about the expected change in temperature e.g.
the globally averaged combined land and ocean
surface temperature has shown a warming between
0.65 and 1.06°C from 1880 to 2012; the polar regions
are warming faster than the global mean etc (taken
from the IPCC 5th assessment report).
• Weathering processes include physical/mechanical
eg freeze-thaw, thermal expansion, chemical eg
oxidation, solution, biological eg chelation, growth of
plant roots
Candidates demonstrate that they have knowledge and
understanding of some of these in the context of their
chosen landscape system.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how increases in global mean temperatures can
influence weathering processes in ONE landscape
system.
• Temperature is an important factor in rate of
weathering
• As temperature rises weathering often increases;
particularly true of chemical weathering (Van’t-Hoff’s
Law) but carbonation can be more effective at lower
temperatures.
• Weathering contributes to landform development.
Examples from chosen landscape system.
• Increased temperatures can contribute to extreme
weather events which in turn have an impact on e.g.
weathering may increase/ decrease in response to
extreme weather becoming more intense and
frequent; ablation exceeds accumulation causing
glacial retreat; decreases hydration, oxidation and
solutions leads to desertification in drylands.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
41
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
increases in global mean temperatures and weathering
processes within one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how increases in global mean
temperatures can influence weathering processes in ONE
landscape system (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas of how
increases in global mean temperatures can influence
weathering processes.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
7 (a) With reference to Fig. 7, suggest how opportunities for
disease mitigation can be influenced by the rebranding
of a place.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
disease mitigation and rebranding (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
interpretation that shows accuracy of how for disease
mitigation can be influenced by the rebranding of a place
(AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
linking resource evidence of opportunities for disease
mitigation to rebranding
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of disease mitigation and
rebranding could potentially include:
o Visible evidence – coloured paint, quality of
structures.
• Disease mitigation strategies include:
o Education programmes
o Sanitation of water
o Appropriate waste disposal (both refuse and
sewage)
o Increase in doctors per thousand and health
care clinics
o Vaccination and screening programmes
• Expect reference to case studies.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to interpret
how opportunities for disease mitigation can beH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
42
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of disease mitigation and rebranding (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy of how for disease mitigation can be
influenced by the rebranding of a place (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas linking
resource evidence of opportunities for disease mitigation to
rebranding.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
disease mitigation and rebranding (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy of how for disease mitigation can be
influenced by the rebranding of a place (AO2).
There will be simple ideas linking resource evidence of
opportunities for disease mitigation to rebranding.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
influenced by the rebranding of a place could potentially
include:
• Improve quality of life for the inhabitants by setting up
local scale healthcare programmes such as
healthcare centre which educate the population about
disease prevention and response.
• Reduce the likelihood of disease diffusion by
reducing sanitation problems (e.g. waste collection or
by appropriate sewage disposal e.g. through sewers)
and by improving water quality (e.g. having potable
water standpipes and water treatment plants).
• The attraction of tourists would also provide an
incentive to improve disease mitigation as they
provide further investment opportunities through a
multiplier effect.
• A community focus brings the two themes of disease
mitigation and rebranding together - grassroots
rebranding is likely to place the community in the
centre as the focus which also places their wellbeing
as a priority, therefore making education and
vaccination programmes more prevalent.
• The risk of injury and therefore diseases such as
tetanus or sepsis are less due to the walkways being
reinforced and safer.
• Mention may be made to mental health due to the
quality of life and built environment improving.
• Reference to the figure could include the following:
the waterway in the foreground of the ‘before’ picture
is likely to have been cleaned up, both physically by
removing litter and in terms of water quality through a
treatment programme; the roofing and stairs of the
houses have been improved making them safer e.g.
damp, ventilation, possibly water quality; some
buildings may have changed function to bring about a
community focus e.g. drop-in healthcare clinics.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
43
7 (b) Examine how relocation diffusion of diseases could be
influenced by human activities in ONE landscape
system that you have studied.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
relocation diffusion of diseases and human activities in one
landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how relocation diffusion of diseases
could be influenced by human activities in ONE landscape
system (AO2).
There must be well-developed ideas of how relocation
diffusion of diseases could be influenced by human
activities.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of relocation diffusion of diseases and human activities in
one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows
some accuracy of how relocation diffusion of diseases
could be influenced by human activities in ONE landscape
system (AO2).
There must be developed ideas of how relocation diffusion
of diseases could be influenced by human activities.
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of relocation diffusion of
diseases and human activities in one landscape system
could potentially include:
Disease diffusion:
• Socioeconomic and political barriers to diffusion e.g.
political borders, curfews, quarantines.
• Possible mention of Hägerstrand’s diffusion model
including the neighbourhood effect, the number of
infected people and physical barriers.
• Human activities in one landscape system include
management strategies e.g. groynes, managed
retreat, dams, climate change mitigation; tourism and
recreation; conservation.
Candidates demonstrate that they have knowledge and
understanding of some of these in the context of their
chosen landscape system.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how relocation diffusion of diseases could be influenced
by human activities in ONE landscape system could
potentially include:
• Tourism management: managing numbers to prevent
damage to fragile ecosystems such as sand dunes
and glaciers – reduces probability of relocation
diseases.
• Climate change mitigation: to reduce sea level rise,
glacial retreat, increased aridity may involve a
reduction of international travel – reduces probability
of relocation diseases.
• Restricting human activity: e.g. extraction of
resources or road building in wilderness, areas such
as the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge or Utah, USAH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
44
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
relocation diffusion of diseases and human activities in one
landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how relocation diffusion of diseases
could be influenced by human activities in ONE landscape
system (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas of how
relocation diffusion of diseases could be influenced by
human activities.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
restricts relocation diseases spreading through
workers relocating there.
8 (a) With reference to Fig.8, suggest how high levels of
biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems can influence
socio-economic place characteristics.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
inter-tidal ecosystems and socio-economic place
characteristics (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
interpretation that shows accuracy of how high levels of
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of inter-tidal ecosystems
and socio-economic place characteristics could
potentially include:
• Organisms within this zone have evolved to cope with
sometimes rapid and frequent changes in
environmental conditions; zonation leads to high
biodiversity’s.
• Mention may be made regarding salt-marshes as an
example, e.g. high biodiversity’s due to rapid
accumulation of sediment from rivers; high
productivity from the nutrients provided by rivers;
succession across the zones.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
45
biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems can influence socioeconomic place characteristics (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
linking resource evidence of biodiversity in inter-tidal
ecosystems to socio-economic place characteristics.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of inter-tidal ecosystems and socio-economic place
characteristics (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy of how high levels of biodiversity in intertidal ecosystems can influence socio-economic place
characteristics (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas linking
resource evidence of biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems
to socio-economic place characteristics.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of intertidal ecosystems and socio-economic place characteristics
(AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy of how high levels of biodiversity in inter-
• Socio-economic place characteristics include
employment, income, family status and education.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to interpret
how high levels of biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems
can influence socio-economic place characteristics could
potentially include:
• Fishing practices: fishing within the low-tide zone and
the collection of shellfish in the high-tide zone can
directly provide employment opportunities and
therefore increase the income in some areas.
• Fishing and foraging of a high diversity of fish and
shellfish can lead to the creation of fish markets and
seafood restaurants, which may attract tourists due to
a place identity and therefore boost employment and
income.
• Recreational opportunities e.g. boat trips, glassbottom boats, paddle boarding etc can bring tourism
to the area.
• Educational and job opportunities arise from the
creation of conservation areas, aquariums or sea-life
centres which showcase the biodiversity of the intertidal zone.
• Use of the figure is likely to involve selecting species
at particular tide zones to highlight biodiversity and
ecosystem goods.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
46
tidal ecosystems can influence socio-economic place
characteristics (AO2).
There will be simple ideas linking resource evidence of
biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems to socio-economic
place characteristics.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
8 (b) Examine how far the impacts of climate change are the
same for an island community and ONE landscape
system that you have studied.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
the impacts of climate change on an island community and
one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how far the impacts of climate
change are the same for an island community and ONE
landscape system (AO2).
There must be well-developed ideas of how far the
impacts of climate change are the same for an island
community and ONE landscape system.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the impacts of climate
change on an island community and one landscape
system could potentially include:
• Climate change impacts include acidification, higher
temperatures, rising sea levels, salt contamination,
increased frequency of storms/severe weather etc
• Impacts of these on an island community include
specifically acidification leading to declining fish
stocks; sea-level rise creating climate change
refugees; salt contamination of fresh water aquifers;
inundation and storm surges reducing tourist
numbers.
Impacts of these on ONE landscape systems include:
Coastal landscapes:
• Rising sea-level leading to greater coastal erosion
and flooding (potentially leading to the formation of
rias and fjords).
• Potential reduction in tourism due to sea-level rise
directly or anaesthetic sea defences being erected.
• Salt contamination of fresh water aquifers by rising
sea-levels.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
47
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of the impacts of climate change on an island community
and one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows
some accuracy of how far the impacts of climate change
are the same for an island community and ONE landscape
system (AO2).
There must be developed ideas of how far the impacts of
climate change are the same for an island community and
ONE landscape system.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
impacts of climate change on an island community and one
landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how far the impacts of climate change
are the same for an island community and ONE landscape
system (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas of how far the
impacts of climate change are the same for an island
community and ONE landscape system.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Acidification and warming will affect ecosystems
leading to an overall reduction in fish stocks.
Glaciated landscapes:
• Potential reduction in tourism due to a loss of snow
and ice over in high altitude areas e.g. the European
Alps, which will negatively impact upon ski resorts.
• Decrease of water supply from melting glaciers may
result in increased dam-building e.g. Grande Dixence
Scheme, Switzerland.
• Freeze-thaw weathering is likely to increase in high
latitude and altitude areas where temperatures rarely
exceeded 0°C, and decrease in areas lower latitude
and altitude areas where the temperature will rarely
dip below 0°C.
• Release of methane and carbon dioxide from
permafrost melt e.g. in Siberia leading to positive
feedback in temperature increase.
Dryland landscapes:
• Deserts could expand if the average temperature
increases due to less frequent and reliable
convection rainfall and more drought; this is likely to
decrease hydration, oxidation and solution due to a
lack of water.
• Decrease of water supply due to a reduction in
convection rainfall.
• Wadis and ephemeral streams may lack water which
will affect organisms dependent upon rainfall in semiarid areas e.g. buffalo and the Lesser Flamingos in
Tanzania.
• Semi-arid areas are likely to experience an increase
in wildfires; they are susceptible already and a
decrease in precipitation will dry the vegetation and
make the area more susceptible.
• Rates of weathering, mass movement and fluvial
erosion will slow.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
48
• The effectiveness of aeolian erosion and transport
will increase causing the advancement of dunes.
Candidates demonstrate that they have knowledge and
understanding of some impacts of climate change in the
context of their chosen landscape system.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to examine
how far the impacts of climate change are the same for
an island community and ONE landscape system could
potentially include:
Coastal landscapes - possible examples
• Increased inundation of coastal areas by storm
surges and an increase in coastal erosion.
• Loss of tourism due to inundation or a change in
aesthetics due to sea defences.
• Acidification leading to fewer fish stocks.
• Mention may be made to the higher level of
vulnerability of island communities to climate change
than many other coastal landscapes due to a reliance
on fishing and tourism for income.
Glaciated landscapes - possible examples
• Decrease in reliable fresh water supplies.
• Reduction in tourism.
• Changing geomorphological processes e.g. levels of
erosion.
Dryland landscapes - possible examples
• Decrease in reliable fresh water supplies.
• Decrease in food supply (soil degradation in drylands
and a decrease in fish stocks in island communities).
• Changing geomorphological processes e.g. levels of
erosion.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
49
9 (a) With reference to Fig. 9, suggest how TWO strategies
to improve food security could affect socio-economic
place characteristics in developing countries.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
strategies to improve food security and socio-economic
place characteristics in developing countries (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
interpretation that shows accuracy of how two strategies to
improve food security may influence socio-economic place
characteristics in developing countries (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
linking resource evidence of strategies to improve food
security to socio-economic place characteristics in
developing countries.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of strategies to improve food security and socio-economic
place characteristics in developing countries (AO1).
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of strategies to improve
food security and socio-economic place characteristics in
developing countries could potentially include:
• The figure acts as a prompt but expect further
detail regarding two of the approaches to be
provided, this may be through the use of a case
study e.g. Cuba
• Socio-economic place characteristics include
employment, income, family status and
education.
• Strategies to improve food security:
o Small-scale bottom-up and appropriate
approaches e.g. self-help schemes such
as the use of simple tools manufactured
locally, rainwater harvesting and sack
gardening.
o Large-scale technological techniques
e.g. GM crops creating higher yields and
pest resistance; water conservation and
irrigation schemes to reduce the effects of
climate change.
o Long-term system redesign e.g.
capacity building where a resilient food
system is constructed.
o Short-term relief e.g. food aid donations
for those requiring immediate suppliesH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
50
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy of how two strategies to improve food
security may influence socio-economic place
characteristics in developing countries (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas linking
resource evidence of strategies to improve food security to
socio-economic place characteristics in developing
countries.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
strategies to improve food security and socio-economic
place characteristics in developing countries (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy of how two strategies to improve food
security may influence socio-economic place
characteristics in developing countries (AO2).
There will be simple ideas linking resource evidence of
strategies to improve food security to socio-economic place
characteristics in developing countries.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
following political unrest or a natural
disaster.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to interpret
how two strategies to improve food security may
influence socio-economic place characteristics in
developing countries could potentially include:
• Long-term system redesign
o Local farmers may be better educated
about how to produce high yields of
necessary and desirable crops, which also
increases income.
o Employment for local people becomes
available in other parts of the supply chain
e.g. transport, infrastructure, research and
trade.
• Small-scale bottom-up and appropriate
approaches
o Increase in yields and therefore income
for farmers without requiring spending on
costly inputs.
o Farmers learn new skills and methods
which increases their knowledge and
understanding of agricultural techniques.
• Large-scale technological techniques
o Local farmers are potentially put out of
business and become unemployed due to
expertise being used from ACs.
o Opportunities for local farmers to learn new
skills and to continue their livelihoods due
to knowledge and/ or infrastructure being
provided by ACs.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
51
• Short term relief
o Local farmers can be put out of business
due to supply exceeding demand.
o Reduction in unemployment and faster
recovery from a disaster as recipients do
not need to find food.
9 (b) Examine how the globalisation of the food industry
impacts on human activities in ONE landscape system
that you have studied.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
the globalisation of the food industry and human activities
in one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how the globalisation of the food
industry impacts on human activities in ONE landscape
system (AO2).
There must be well-developed ideas of how the
globalisation of the food industry impacts on human
activities in ONE landscape system.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of the globalisation of the food industry and human
activities in one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows
some accuracy of how the globalisation of the food industry
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the globalisation of the
food industry and human activities in one landscape
system could potentially include:
• Detail about the globalisation of the food industry,
including production for a growing global population,
supply chain, marketing, consumption, waste
management and retailers.
• Human activities in landscape systems include
management strategies e.g. groynes, managed
retreat, dams, climate change mitigation; tourism and
recreation; conservation.
Candidates demonstrate that they have knowledge and
understanding of some impacts of globalisation in the
context of their chosen landscape system.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how the globalisation of the food industry impacts on
human activities in ONE landscape system could
potentially include:
• Demand for food and pressure on land: e.g. deltas,
semi-arid land, cattle farming for increased meat and
dairy diets – excessive human use for a growing
population is likely to degrade soil long term.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
52
impacts on human activities in ONE landscape system
(AO2).
There must be developed ideas of how the globalisation of
the food industry impacts on human activities in ONE
landscape system.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
globalisation of the food industry and human activities in
one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how the globalisation of the food
industry impacts on human activities in ONE landscape
system (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas of how the
globalisation of the food industry impacts on human
activities in ONE landscape system.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Increased hazards e.g. storm surges and avalanches,
and weathering and erosion, ablation of glaciers,
desertification due to increased food miles and their
contribution to climate change.
• Management e.g. sea walls protecting inundation
affects transportation of sediment and deposition.
• Pollution – plastic wrappers often used by TNCs,
particularly those operating in EDCs and LIDCs which
have laxer environmental regulations.
• Roads and infrastructure to transport food can
increase melting in high altitude areas and aeolian
erosion in drylands where ATV use increases.
• Water supply solutions for irrigation – dams increase
deposition behind the construction.
10 (a) With reference to Fig. 10, suggest how earthquake
damage and social inequality are linked.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
earthquake damage and social inequality (AO1).
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of earthquake damage
and social inequality could potentially include:
• Includes differences in wealth, housing, health
etc.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
53
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
interpretation that shows accuracy of how earthquake
damage and social inequality are linked (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
linking resource evidence of earthquake damage to social
inequality.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of earthquake damage and social inequality (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy of how earthquake damage and social
inequality are linked (AO2).
This will be shown by including reasonable ideas linking
resource evidence of earthquake damage to social
inequality.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
earthquake damage and social inequality (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy of how earthquake damage and social
inequality are linked (AO2).
• Earthquake damage will include landslides,
ground shaking, tsunamis, etc
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how earthquake damage and social inequality are linked
could potentially include:
• Earthquake damage and housing:
High MMI earthquakes destroy almost all housing
regardless of location or proofing.
• Slums are often located on marginal land e.g.
high relief areas which are prone to mass
movement damage during earthquakes. More
expensive housing tends to be in safer areas and
more earthquake-proof.
• Spiral of decline/ negative multiplier effect where
rebuilding costs and time reinforces low-income
statuses.
Earthquake damage and education:
• High MMI earthquakes destroy almost all schools
and universities regardless of building quality
which limits education across the population
• Schools in low-income areas can be located on
marginal land e.g. high relief areas which are
prone to mass movement damage during
earthquakes.
• Inequality in the earthquake education e.g. drills
and procedures. This is very thorough in ACs
such as New Zealand and Japan but occasionally
less-so in LIDCs such as Afghanistan.
• Earthquake damage and health:
o High MMI earthquakes destroy almost all
healthcare centres regardless of buildingH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
54
There will be simple ideas linking resource evidence of
earthquake damage to social inequality.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
quality which limits healthcare provision
following an earthquake across the
population e.g. Sulawesi, Indonesia in
2018 where disinfectant had to be sprayed
over the deceased.
o Healthcare centres in low-income areas
can be located on marginal land e.g. high
relief areas which are prone to mass
movement damage during earthquakes.
o Inequality in the healthcare provided such
that those with less access to healthcare
are more vulnerable e.g. potentially less
mobile or less resilient to surviving injuries.
• Earthquake damage and gender:
o Women and children affected more due to
poorer health generally – more susceptible
to disease (maternal health and infant
health).
o Linked to landscape of gender inequality
generally.
• Use of the figure to link earthquake damage and
social inequality e.g. class leveller – if magnitude
is high enough then does not discriminate; terrain
affected – mass movement greater in high relief
areas; building quality meant that poor were
affected more; women and children more affected
than men; widening gap.
Do not double credit the same explanation for multiple
factors.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
55
10 (b) Examine how far people’s choice of where to live is
influenced by the same factors for volcanically active
regions and ONE landscape system that you have
studied.
Level 3 (6-8 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
people’s choice for living in volcanically active regions and
one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how far people’s choice of where to
live is influenced by the same factors for volcanically active
regions and one landscape system (AO2).
There must be well-developed ideas of how far people’s
choice of where to live is influenced by the same factors for
volcanically active regions and one landscape system.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
Level 2 (3-5 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
people’s choice for living in volcanically active regions and
one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of how far people’s choice of where to live is
influenced by the same factors for volcanically active
regions and one landscape system (AO2).
There must be developed ideas of how far people’s choice
of where to live is influenced by the same factors for
volcanically active regions and one landscape system.
8
AO1 x4
AO2 x4
AO1 - 4 marks
Knowledge and understanding of people’s choice for
living in volcanically active regions and one landscape
system could potentially include:
• Reasons for living in volcanically active regions
include intensive farming can be practiced due to the
fertile soil from weathered lava, particularly in wet
tropical regions; lack of choice; tourism; geothermal
energy; mineral mining; research.
• Reasons for living in coastal/ glaciated/ dryland
regions include trading; energy provision (tidal, wave,
HEP, solar); tourism and recreation; constructing
transport routes; fishing and farming; extraction of
minerals and oil; research; desirable climate; lack of
choice.
• Credit relevant case study detail if included.
AO2 - 4 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how far people’s choice of where to live is influenced by
the same factors for volcanically active regions and one
landscape system could potentially include:
• Agriculture e.g. deltas, livestock herding in
drylands.
• Income opportunities from tourism and recreation
(beach holidays, skiing, hiking, desert excursions
etc).
• Improved water supply due to relief rainfall in
glaciated regions.
• Energy provision from tidal, wave, HEP, solar,
geothermal.
• Lack of choice.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
56
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study but these
are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
people’s choice for living in volcanically active regions and
one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how far people’s choice of where to live
is influenced by the same factors for volcanically active
regions and one landscape system (AO2).
This will be shown by including basic ideas of how far
people’s choice of where to live is influenced by the same
factors for volcanically active regions and one landscape
system.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
57
Question Answer Mark Guidance
11* To what extent has the global balance of
anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases
changed in recent history?
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of the global balance of anthropogenic
emissions of greenhouse gases and changes in recent
history.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the global balance of anthropogenic emissions of
greenhouse gases and changes in recent history.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the global balance of anthropogenic
emissions of greenhouse gases and changes in recent
history.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the global balance of anthropogenic emissions of
greenhouse gases and changes in recent history.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how the global balance of anthropogenic emissions
of greenhouse gases has changed in recent history.
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the global balance of
anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases and changes
in recent history could potentially include:
• Anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases globally:
o Carbon dioxide
o CFCs
o Methane
• Global balance now: CO2 - USA and Australia both emit
an average of 17 tonnes/ year per person of carbon
dioxide, compared with 5.4 tonnes by China and 1.4
tonnes by India.
o Global GHG emissions. EDCs produce a
substantial proportion, for example, China
produces an estimated 28.6% of the global GHG
emissions which is the highest when not provided
as a per capita measurement.
o LIDCs produce few greenhouse gas emissions but
stand to suffer the most from their impacts.
• Changes of emissions over the last 200 years
o Carbon dioxide was the main greenhouse gas
emission - 280ppm before 1800 . Today it
accounts for more than 75% of all anthropogenic
greenhouse gas emissions; 400ppm in 2015 and
nearly half the increase has occurred since 1960.
o Methane is 25x more potent than carbon dioxide
and is being produced in higher quantities today
(1735ppb in 1984; 1890ppm in 2009).
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate the extent to which the global balance of
anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases has changed
in recent history could potentially include:
• Changes in emissions related to development status:
o ACs have produced the most emissions
cumulatively in the last 200 years; AC contributionH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
58
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which the global balance of
anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases has
changed in recent history.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows how the global balance of
anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases has
changed in recent history.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to the
extent to which the global balance of anthropogenic
emissions of greenhouse gases has changed in recent
history.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows how the global balance of anthropogenic
emissions of greenhouse gases has changed in recent
history.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to the extent to which the
global balance of anthropogenic emissions of
greenhouse gases has changed in recent history.
has been the result of developing their economies;
they were the first to begin this process at the time
of the Industrial Revolution which led to a
significant increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide.
AC emissions are plateauing or decreasing at
present and coal which produces the most carbon
dioxide of the three fossil fuels no longer leads.
o EDCs emissions have changed significantly
particularly in the last 50 years - surge in demand
for energy (powered largely by coal in China and
India): an emerging middle class now with higher
disposable incomes; growth of secondary
industries/ manufacturing and services; decline of
rural employment (using biofuels with limited GHG
emissions).
o LIDCs produce few GHG emissions due to a lack
of growth of energy consuming industries so
limited change over 200 years.
• Reasons for changes in emissions
o The combustion of fossil fuels during the Industrial
Revolution - main GHG at this time. Today,
demand for energy globally and technological
advances in transport and manufacturing
(particularly in EDCs) explain GHG increase; fossil
fuels still supply 87% of the world’s energy.
o Deforestation which reduces the carbon sink and,
with other land use changes accounts for 30% of
GHG emissions.
o Methane production is higher today on account of
rice paddies in Asia (a quarter of the world’s
population) + ruminant farming (increased
demand for animal products in EDCs)
o The current reduction in AC emissions is largely
due to a growing concern over climate change and
greater global interest in mitigation, (school
climate strikes March 2019) e.g. in 2017 the UK
government planned to: invest £900 million intoH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
59
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
how human the global balance of anthropogenic
emissions of greenhouse gases has changed in recent
history.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to the extent to which
the global balance of anthropogenic emissions of
greenhouse gases has changed in recent history.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
renewable and nuclear to meet a 2050 emissions
reduction target;
• Outcomes:
o global balance of anthropogenic GHG emissions
has changed particularly since 1960 where
dominance by Europe and N America has been
replaced by Asia.
o increased anthropogenic GHG emissions linked
to positive feedback mechanisms which release
further greenhouse gases naturally (the melting
permafrost in Siberia which releases methane).
Conclusion expected to show how the global balance of
anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases changed in
recent history.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
60
Question Answer Mark Guidance
12* Examine the extent to which different stages of
economic development affect current socioeconomic and environmental impacts of climate
change.
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of different stages of economic
development and current socio-economic and
environmental impacts of climate change.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of different stages of economic development and
current socio-economic and environmental impacts of
climate change.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of different stages of economic
development and current socio-economic and
environmental impacts of climate change.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
different stages of economic development and current
socio-economic and environmental impacts of climate
change.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of different stages of economic
development and current socio-economic and environmental
impacts of climate change could potentially include:
Different stages of economic development:
• LIDCs: lower income e.g. Bangladesh, Niger, Sierra
Leone; predominantly primary and secondary industries;
fewer healthcare and educational provisions.
• EDCs: middle income e.g. Brazil, China, India;
predominantly secondary industries; average incomes
increasing but widening gap between emerging middle
class and poor.
• ACs: high income e.g. UK, the USA, Germany;
predominantly tertiary industries but some quaternary;
generally accessible healthcare and education for all.
Socio-economic and environmental impacts of climate change:
Socio-economic:
• Deaths from increasing hazard frequency e.g. tropical
cyclones and drought
• Spread of disease
• Homelessness and climate change refugees
• Cost from hazard response and adaptation
• Tourism negatively affected
• Agriculture – lower yields and possible need to change
crops
Environmental:
• Increase in the frequency and magnitude of climatic
hazards e.g. tropical storms, wild fires, flooding.
• Sea-level rise
• Contamination of land from salt-water intrusion
• Loss of coastal ecosystems e.g. mangrove forests and
wetlandsH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
61
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how human activities influence the balance between
incoming and outgoing energy through the atmosphere.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which human activities influence the
balance between incoming and outgoing energy
through the atmosphere.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows how different stages of economic
development affect current socio-economic and
environmental impacts of climate change.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to the
extent to which different stages of economic
development affect current socio-economic and
environmental impacts of climate change.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows how different stages of economic development
affect current socio-economic and environmental
impacts of climate change.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
Give credit where the content of the answer is two contrasting
case studies e.g. Bangladesh and Australia.
Many socioeconomic and environmental impacts overlap -
expect some crossover in categorisation.
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate the extent to which different stages of economic
development affect current socio-economic and
environmental impacts of climate change could potentially
include:
Examples of common impacts regardless of different stages
of development:
• Increase in the frequency and magnitude of coastal
flooding from storm surges in the future.
• Significant cost, either through adaptation or damage
response.
• Decline in agricultural productivity.
• Loss of coastal ecosystems.
Examples of contrasting impacts linked to different stages of
development:
• The cost of is likely to slow development in LIDCs
compared to ACs as they have less money to put towards
adaptation and repairs.
• LIDCs are more dependent upon primary industries such
as fishing and agriculture than ACs and EDCs and so
they will be disproportionately more affected by climate
change.
• A lack of options and often official welfare systems means
that the level of homelessness is likely to be higher in
LIDCs and EDCs than ACs.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
62
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to the extent to which
different stages of economic development affect current
socio-economic and environmental impacts of climate
change.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
how different stages of economic development affect
current socio-economic and environmental impacts of
climate change.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to the extent to which
different stages of economic development affect current
socio-economic and environmental impacts of climate
change.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
• Generally higher life expectancies in ACs means that
healthcare could be stretched more in ACs than EDCs and
LIDCs e.g. by heat stress.
Expect conclusions that consider the extent to which stages
of economic development affect impacts.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
63
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
Question Answer Mark Guidance
13* ‘At a national scale the socio-economic impacts of
a communicable disease are more significant than
they are for a non-communicable disease.’ Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of the socio-economic impacts of a
communicable and a non-communicable disease at a
country scale.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the socio-economic impacts of a communicable and
a non-communicable disease at a country scale.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the socio-economic impacts of a
communicable and a non-communicable disease at a
country scale.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the socio-economic impacts
of a communicable and a non-communicable disease at a
country scale could potentially include (content depends upon
the diseases referenced):
Socio-economic impacts of communicable diseases e.g.
HIV/AIDS, Covid-19, cholera, Ebola or influenza:
• Significant cost due to early deaths, time off work,
treatment from the government/ NHS, the cost of unpaid
care and also funding efforts to minimise the spread.
• Social isolation often due to the need to quarantine.
• Psychological effects such as anxiety and trauma.
• Deters tourism, particularly during epidemics when
government advice is to not travel.
• Prevents mobility e.g. restrictions in international travel.
• Reduces inwards investment
• Punctuated in effects due to quickly leading to
epidemics if not contained.
• Often involves a spiral of decline where a lack of control
leads to further disease spread which makes control more
challenging.
• In LIDCs, often requires international aid to bring to
manageable levels.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
64
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the socio-economic impacts of a communicable and a
non-communicable disease at a country scale.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how human activities influence the balance between
incoming and outgoing energy through the atmosphere.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to whether the socio-economic impacts of
communicable diseases are more significant than those
of non-communicable diseases.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows whether the socio-economic
impacts of communicable diseases are more significant
than those of non-communicable diseases.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to
whether the socio-economic impacts of communicable
diseases are more significant than those of noncommunicable diseases.
Socio-economic impacts of non-communicable diseases e.g.
cancer, malaria, heart disease:
• Significant cost due to early deaths, time off work,
treatment from the government/ NHS and the cost of
unpaid care.
• Delayed diagnosis and treatments due to the focus on
disease prevention such as Covid-19.
• Social isolation, particularly if the disease is stigmatised.
• Psychological effects such as anxiety and trauma.
• Survival rates often correlate with deprivation.
• Occasionally related to lifestyle which is difficult to
change at a country scale.
• Deters tourism.
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate whether the socio-economic impacts of
communicable diseases are more significant than those of
non-communicable diseases could potentially include:
Examples of how the socio-economic impacts of
communicable diseases are more significant than those of
non-communicable diseases:
• The timescale on which communicable diseases spread
means that the socio-economic impacts are often greater
in intensity than non-communicable diseases.
• Communicable diseases are often more isolating on a
country scale e.g. travel restrictions, loss of tourism, loss
of inward investment – this means that they can have a
greater impact on a country’s overall development status.
• Communicable diseases can have a more direct impact
on food security due to a sudden loss in workforce,
particularly in LIDCs.
Examples of how the socio-economic impacts of
communicable diseases are not more significant than those
of non-communicable diseases:H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
65
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows whether the socio-economic impacts of
communicable diseases are more significant than those
of non-communicable diseases.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to whether the socioeconomic impacts of communicable diseases are more
significant than those of non-communicable diseases.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
whether the socio-economic impacts of communicable
diseases are more significant than those of noncommunicable diseases.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to whether the socioeconomic impacts of communicable diseases are more
significant than those of non-communicable diseases.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
• Although communicable diseases often occur quickly and
at high intensity, non-communicable diseases are more
chronic which creates longer-term socioeconomic impacts
for countries.
• Both create spirals of decline, although these are
arguably faster for communicable diseases.
• Non-communicable diseases are more closely linked to
lifestyle and therefore levels of deprivation and so the
impacts are not spread evenly through a country’s
population.
Conclusions are expected which consider whether the socioeconomic impacts of communicable diseases are more
significant than those of non-communicable diseases.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
66
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
Question Answer Mark Guidance
14* ‘Use of medicines from nature continues to be an
essential part of disease mitigation’. How far do you
agree with this statement?
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of use of medicines from nature and
disease mitigation.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of use of medicines from nature and disease mitigation.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of use of medicines from nature and
disease mitigation.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of use of medicines from
nature and disease mitigation could potentially include:
• Use of medicines from nature – healing properties known
for thousands of years. E.g. Hippocrates recorded more
than 300 medicinal plants and herbs. The Society of
Apothecaries founded the Chelsea Physic Garden in
London in 1673. 19th century – first naturally derived
medicine extracted from a plant, morphine from poppies;
others included quinine and aspirin.
• Disease mitigation in addition to medicines from plants:
o chemically manufactured medicinal drugs
o campaigns and educational programmes on a
variety of scales such as those created by the
WHO;
o lifestyle changes e.g. prevention of heart attacks
brought on by lack of exercise and poor diets;
o scientific research to identify diseases e.g. HIV/
AIDSH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
67
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
use of medicines from nature and disease mitigation.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of whether use of medicines from nature continues to
be an essential part of disease mitigation.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to whether use of medicines from nature continues
to be an essential part of disease mitigation.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows whether use of medicines from
nature continues to be an essential part of disease
mitigation.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to
whether use of medicines from nature continues to be
an essential part of disease mitigation.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate whether use of medicines from nature continues to
be an essential part of disease mitigation could potentially
include:
• Many modern medicines originate from natural
compounds found in wild plants. Today, the active
ingredients of many herbal medicines have been
extracted in laboratories and synthesised as compounds,
including
o Nicotine from tobacco plants to treat wounds,
Alzheimer’s, depression
o Rosy periwinkle from Madagascar (contains 70
alkaloids shown to treat some cancers such as
leukaemia)
Agreement with the statement:
• Plants were clearly the main source of medicine in the
past but they continue to have an essential role through
providing the compounds for the relief of various
symptoms and diseases as highlighted above.
• The essential nature of medicinal plants is apparent even
in city centres today where shops and clinics are
dedicated to using them e.g. Holland and Barratt.
• There is a movement at present away from synthetic
products to more holistic and wellbeing type medicines
which plants provide e.g. St John’s Wort.
Disagreement with the statement:
• Many compounds that were discovered in plants can now
be synthesised in laboratories, - plants may only be
required at the beginning of the process.
• Much disease mitigation is about education and
awareness (preventative methods) as opposed to fighting
diseases.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
68
shows whether use of medicines from nature continues
to be an essential part of disease mitigation.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to whether use of medicines
from nature continues to be an essential part of disease
mitigation.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
whether use of medicines from nature continues to be
an essential part of disease mitigation.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to whether use of
medicines from nature continues to be an essential part
of disease mitigation.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
• The compounds from plants are often used to relieve
symptoms as opposed to tackling the disease itself e.g.
aspirin and quinine; the effects are temporary.
• Awareness of environmental implications as well as
biopiracy so when alternatives to plants are economically
available they are/should be used.
Conclusions are expected which consider whether the use of
medicines continue to be an essential part of disease
mitigation.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
69
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
Question Answer Mark Guidance
15* ‘The opportunities arising from the use of ocean
resources greatly outweigh the threats’. How far do
you agree with this statement?
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of the opportunities and threats arising
from the use of ocean resources.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the opportunities and threats arising from the use of
ocean resources.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the opportunities and threats arising
from the use of ocean resources.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the opportunities and threats arising from the use of
ocean resources.
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the opportunities and
threats arising from the use of ocean resources could
potentially include:
• Ocean resources include:
o Biological resources/ natural capital e.g.
phytoplankton, krill, fish
o Non-renewable resources e.g. oil and gas
o Renewable ocean resources e.g. waves and tides
o Sea-floor mining e.g. ferrous and non-ferrous
deposits
o Bio-prospecting
• Expect use of case studies e.g. commercial harvesting of
krill or the Gulf of Mexico
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate whether the opportunities arising from the use of
ocean resources greatly outweigh the threats, could
potentially include:
Opportunities outweigh the threats:
Economic including
Versatility a) harvesting krill e.g. for paste, oil or animal
feed, b) Oil can be used in the production of many otherH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
70
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of whether the opportunities arising from the use of
ocean resources greatly outweigh the threats.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to whether the opportunities arising from the use of
ocean resources greatly outweigh the threats.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows whether the opportunities arising
from the use of ocean resources greatly outweigh the
threats.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to
whether the opportunities arising from the use of ocean
resources greatly outweigh the threats.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows whether the opportunities arising from the use of
ocean resources greatly outweigh the threats.
materials e.g. plastic, fertiliser; Oil and gas provision e.g.
from the Gulf of Mexico, the Persian Gulf and the North
Sea. Drilling rigs are operating in deeper water due to
advancing technology so more areas are accessible;
Minerals mined e.g. diamonds off the coast of southern
Africa which are a valuable resource to sell; often they are
in greater concentrations than on land
Provision of jobs + Contribution towards GDP + Increased
standard of living
Environmental including
The ocean provides both non-renewable and renewable
energy resources which allows a gradual and managed
transition from non-renewable to renewable; Renewable
energies reduce emissions which helps in mitigating
climate change
Collecting ocean resources forces improvements in ocean
mapping and navigation
Threats outweigh opportunities
• Lack of sustainability/damage to ecosystem
Concerns that the harvesting of krill is showing signs of
“boom and bust” patterns. (need for controls);
communities become over dependent on one industry
(e.g. fishing or oil drilling) for jobs; Ecosystem disturbance
means that the population of species may decrease
unsustainably; Oil spills are costly to clean up and harm
organisms and their habitats.; Sea-floor mining is
controversial given the potential damage it may be doing
to relatively unknown ocean ecosystems, particularly from
tailings
• Cost may be prohibitive until economic climate
changes/demand increases e.g. offshore wind farms,
wave energy – expensive, equipment damage - parts
becomes debris (harming ecosystems).
• Geopolitics include monitoring of commercial operations
e.g. CCAMLR – krill harvest in Antarctic, mining of RareH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
71
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to whether the opportunities
arising from the use of ocean resources greatly
outweigh the threats.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
whether the opportunities arising from the use of ocean
resources greatly outweigh the threats.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to whether the
opportunities arising from the use of ocean resources
greatly outweigh the threats.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Earth Elements (REEs) has strategic importance with
possible restrictions to permissions granted in EEZs.
Conclusions are expected about the opportunities arising
from the use of ocean resources outweighing the threats.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
72
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
Question Answer Mark Guidance
16* ‘Plastic is the most problematic ocean pollutant of
the 21st century’. Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of ocean pollutants of the 21st century.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of ocean pollutants of the 21st century.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of human activities and the balance
between incoming and outgoing energy through the
atmosphere.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
human activities and the balance between incoming
and outgoing energy through the atmosphere.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of ocean pollutants of the 21st
century could potentially include:
Pollutants and their harmful effects
• Plastic from rivers, beaches and ships:
o Larger marine organisms such as turtles and seals
can become entangled in discarded fishing nets or
plastic packaging
o Most plastics are long lasting and do not biodegrade
for hundreds of years. Photodegradation breaks
them down to form microplastics which accumulate
in ocean gyres, e.g. the Great Pacific Garbage
Patch.
• Agricultural runoff including leached phosphate fertilisers
and pesticides such as DDT
• Heavy metals e.g. mercury off the coast of Minamata,
Japan
• Products of combustion of fossil fuels for shipping e.g.
SO2, nitrogen oxides; the volume of shipping means that
levels are significant on a global scale (approximately
100,000 cargo vessels for 24 hours each day, 280 days of
the year on average plus cruise ships).
• Lack of environmental regulation in LIDCs means that
many toxic substances are released into oceans annually
e.g. organic waste, hormones and heavy metals
• Oil spills e.g. the Deepwater Horizon disaster of 2010
which affected 180,000km2 of the Gulf of MexicoH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
73
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of whether plastic is the most problematic ocean
pollutant of the 21st century.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to whether plastic is the most problematic ocean
pollutant of the 21st century.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows whether plastic is the most
problematic ocean pollutant of the 21st century.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to
whether plastic is the most problematic ocean pollutant
of the 21st century.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows whether plastic is the most problematic ocean
pollutant of the 21st century.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to whether plastic is the most
problematic ocean pollutant of the 21st century.
• Carbon dioxide from terrestrial activities which leads to
ocean acidification; pH of the oceans has lowered by 0.1
(8.2 to 8.1 representing a 30% increase in acidity) since
records began which causes a softening and reduced
production of calcite exoskeletons.
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate whether plastic is the most problematic ocean
pollutant of the 21st century could potentially include:
Plastics are the most problematic ocean pollutant
• Plastic is found in every ocean and along the majority of
coastlines either in the form of whole plastic or as
microplastic
• Microplastic can enter food chains, particularly those that
filter sea water. This bio-accumulates through food chains
• Other pollutants have been present in the oceans for
decades but plastic has become a particular problem
within the 21st century
• A combination of EDCs using more plastic and lack of
environmental regulation - the amount of plastic has
rapidly increased in the last 20 years
• Plastics are a chronic problem - the estimated 5 trillion
pieces of plastic in the ocean, particularly microplastic,
will now be near impossible to remove
Plastics are not the most problematic ocean pollutant
• The amount of media attention on plastics may make it
appear to be the worst ocean pollutant of the 21st
century.
• Other pollutants which have a less visible impact are no
less deadly or harmful to ecosystems e.g. mercury off the
coast of Japan which has resided there for decades still
contaminates fishing grounds.
• Pollutants which are more punctuated in their impacts e.g.
low frequency/ high magnitude oil spills could be argued
to be more damaging at the time that they occurH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
74
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
whether plastic is the most problematic ocean pollutant
of the 21st century.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to whether plastic is
the most problematic ocean pollutant of the 21st
century.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
• Larger pieces of plastic can be removed through
environmental legislation, beach cleans and the Ocean
Cleanup Project whereas agricultural pollution or carbon
dioxide cannot be addressed so easily.
Conclusions are expected which consider whether plastic is
the most problematic ocean pollutant of the 21st century.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
75
Question Answer Mark Guidance
17* Examine the view that extreme weather events
caused by climate change have the greatest impact
on food security.
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of factors which affect food security.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of factors which affect food security.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of factors which affect food security.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
factors which affect food security.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of whether extreme weather events caused by climate
change, amongst other factors, have the greatest
impact on food security.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of factors which affect food
security could potentially include:
• Knowledge of the three pillars of availability, access and
utilisation.
• Climate change may be outlined through various means
e.g. 0.87°C of average surface temperature warming
since 1880 or efforts to cap global average temperature
increase to 2°C in accordance with the Paris Agreement.
• Extreme weather caused by climate change include
drought, tropical cyclones, wildfire and heatwaves.
• Other factors which may be mentioned as contenders to
climate change may include:
o Distribution whereupon ACs often experience food
waste whilst LIDCs often lack the infrastructure,
trade agreements and income to import food.
o Pests e.g. locust plagues can cause famine and
therefore reduce availability, e.g. Africa in 2004.
o Disease e.g. wheat blight in Africa and Asia in 2007.
o Lifestyle e.g. obesity in ACs where meat and dairy
foods are often very affordable, promoting unhealthy
diets.
o Land grabbing where farmland is bought in
developing countries by other countries wishing to
make their food supplies more secure e.g. China
buying up land in Africa.
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate whether extreme weather events caused by climate
change, amongst other factors, have the greatest impact on
food security could potentially include:
Extreme weather caused by climate change does have the
greatest impact on food security:
• Drought and higher temperatures: can lead to
desertification and land degradation, lowering foodH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
76
as to whether extreme weather events caused by
climate change, amongst other factors, have the
greatest impact on food security.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows whether extreme weather events
caused by climate change, amongst other factors, have
the greatest impact on food security.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to
whether extreme weather events caused by climate
change, amongst other factors, have the greatest
impact on food security.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows whether extreme weather events caused by
climate change, amongst other factors, have the
greatest impact on food security.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to whether extreme weather
events caused by climate change, amongst other
factors, have the greatest impact on food security.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
whether extreme weather events caused by climate
availability particularly in areas which already have low
Food Security Indices E.g. Sub-Saharan Africa.
• Heatwaves may increase availability in some areas such
as the UK due to longer growing seasons and higher
temperatures. Reference may be made to new varieties
being introduced such as vineyards in Cornwall.
• Increasing frequency of floods, wildfires and drought
will significantly reduce food production in affected areas.
• Mention may also be made to the fact that climate change
will have indirect effects upon some of the factors
mentioned above, e.g. locust swarms and spread of
diseases e.g. the Bluetongue virus travelling westwards
from Asia.
Extreme weather caused by climate change does not have
the greatest impact on food security:
• Socioeconomic and political factors have a greater impact
e.g.:
o Land ownership, land grabbing and competition
which may be linked to greater global issues such as
population increase and uneven power relations
(particularly in EDCs such as China and India).
o Trade agreements which restrict some countries
importing food at an affordable price, therefore
affecting all three of the food security pillars. Some
candidates may refer to Brexit and the potential
implications that this may have on the UK’s food
security.
o “Globesity” where more affordable meat and dairy
products in ACs coupled with a reduction in exercise
has reduced utilisation.
A conclusion should be present which considers the view that
extreme weather events caused by climate change have the
greatest impact on food security.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
77
change, amongst other factors, have the greatest
impact on food security.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to whether extreme
weather events caused by climate change, amongst
other factors, have the greatest impact on food security.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
78
Question Answer Mark Guidance
18* ‘The role and responsibilities of agribusinesses
have had a positive influence on the global food
system’. How far do you agree with this statement?
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of agribusinesses and the global food
system.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of agribusinesses and the global food system.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of agribusinesses and the global food
system.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
agribusinesses and the global food system.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how the role and responsibilities of agribusinesses
have had a positive influence on the global food
system.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of agribusinesses and the
global food system could potentially include:
• Agribusiness - likely to include reference to the following:
o Commercial agriculture where farming for profit is
conducted on a large scale with often high capital
inputs e.g. cattle ranching in South America. This
improves access for consumers.
o Intensive agriculture which is small-scale with high
labour and/or capital inputs and high yields per
hectare e.g. horticulture in the Netherlands. This
improves both availability and access for consumers.
o Globally, agriculture is largely controlled by TNCs
such as Tyson and Walmart which favour large,
capital intensive growers. In Brazil, for example,
large agribusinesses account for 62% of the value of
agricultural production.
o Biotechnology such as GMOs (genetically modified
organisms) can increase yields and the distribution
of crops
• Global food system could include pre-production, farming,
market supply chain, distribution, consumption, waste
management.
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate the extent to which the role and responsibilities of
agribusinesses have had a positive influence on the global
food system could potentially include:
Ways in which agribusinesses have had a positive influence
on the global food system:
• Cheaper food - improved access and utilisation: due
to commercial and intensive agriculture, particularly those
with lower income.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
79
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which the role and responsibilities of
agribusinesses have had a positive influence on the
global food system.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows how the role and responsibilities of
agribusinesses have had a positive influence on the
global food system.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to the
extent to which the role and responsibilities of
agribusinesses have had a positive influence on the
global food system.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows how the role and responsibilities of
agribusinesses have had a positive influence on the
global food system.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to the extent to which the
role and responsibilities of agribusinesses have had a
positive influence on the global food system.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
• Higher yields - improved availability and utilisation:
biotechnology has produced HYVs (higher yielding
varieties) and GMOs – these improve availability and
reduce the long term costs of using fertilizers and
pesticides, therefore improving access. The example of
the Green Revolution may be mentioned.
• Distribution is improved by TNCs who transport food
globally using container ships, air freight and lorries – this
improves availability, access and utilisation.
Ways in which agribusinesses have not had a positive
influence on the global food system:
• “Globesity”: commercial agriculture has arguably
reduced utilisation due to making meat and dairy products
more affordable.
• Unequal food security: biotechnology has improved
food security for largely ACs who are more able to take
advantage of technological innovation than LIDCs due to
greater capital reserves and expertise. The example of
the Green Revolution may be mentioned.
• Appropriate technology: is a more effective way to
ensure food security for LIDCs who often lose out from
agribusiness models.
• Agribusinesses are often very present in competition with
food markets and land grabbing, which promotes food
security for the countries that they supply to but reduces
security for those that they are located within.
A conclusion should be present which acknowledges the role
and responsibilities agribusinesses have had on the global
food system.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
80
how the role and responsibilities of agribusinesses have
had a positive influence on the global food system.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
that offers simple conclusions as to the extent to which
the role and responsibilities of agribusinesses have had
a positive influence on the global food system.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
81
Question Answer Mark Guidance
19* Examine the view that information collected from
the sea floor provides compelling evidence for
continental drift.
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of evidence for continental drift.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of evidence for continental drift.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of evidence for continental drift.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
evidence for continental drift.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how information collected from the sea floor provides
compelling evidence for continental drift.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which information collected from the
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of evidence for continental
drift could potentially include:
From the sea floor:
• Palaeomagnetism: the oceanic crust at mid-oceanic
ridges is made up of igneous rocks which form
symmetrical bands parallel to the ridge. This led to
conclusions about sea floor spreading. The orientation
of the iron particles indicates the polarity of the Earth
at the time that the lava cooled and is seen to change
every 400,000 to 500,000 years.
Not limited to the sea floor:
• Biological evidence: similar fossils are found in
continents that are now separated, e.g. brachiopods in
Australia and Indian limestone and Mesosaurus
fossils in South America and Africa.
• Continental fit: the continents look like pieces of a
jigsaw - North America fits with Europe and South
America fits with Africa to form a supercontinent,
Pangaea, approximately 250 million years ago.
• Geological evidence: rock samples in different areas
are similar in composition and age, e.g. northeast
Canada and northern Scotland.
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate the view that information collected from the sea floor
provides compelling evidence for continental drift could
potentially include:
• Palaeomagnetism and sea floor spreading: the
symmetry in rock type, magnetic orientation and
coverage either side of the plate boundary suggests
that the rocks have originated from the boundary andH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
82
sea floor provides compelling evidence for continental
drift.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows how information collected from the
sea floor provides compelling evidence for continental
drift.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to the
extent to which information collected from the sea floor
provides compelling evidence for continental drift.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows how information collected from the sea floor
provides compelling evidence for continental drift.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to the extent to which
information collected from the sea floor provides
compelling evidence for continental drift.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
how information collected from the sea floor provides
compelling evidence for continental drift.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
moved outwards. The increasing age of the rocks
either side suggests that the sea floor is moving over
time on account of the divergent plates.
• Biological evidence: the Mesosaurus was a
freshwater reptile and as such, to be found in now
separated continents, the continents must have drifted
apart.
• Continental fit and geological samples suggest that
the continents once joined as the rocks would have
been formed in once location and then separated by
continental drift.
The sea floor provides compelling evidence:
• The symmetry of the igneous rocks, both in rock type
and polarity, provides compelling evidence for
continental drift. The symmetry suggests that the
ocean floor acts as a conveyor belt where new rock
surfaces at the ocean ridges whilst old rock is
subducted into the asthenosphere at ocean trenches.
• Sea floor spreading and palaeomagnetism provide
comprehensive evidence in terms of age, symmetry,
existence globally, along with a mechanism for the
creation and destruction of crust, which the other
pieces of evidence do not.
• Continental fit could be coincidental; it is not
quantitative enough to provide strong evidence by
itself.
• With regards to geological evidence, there are
anomalies where certain areas which would be
expected to match do not; some areas have been
eroded such that they no longer provide compelling
evidence.
Compelling evidence is not limited to the sea floor:
• Biological evidence is very compelling due to identical
evolutionary pathways being near impossible inH081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
83
that offers simple conclusions as to the extent to which
information collected from the sea floor provides
compelling evidence for continental drift.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.
separated areas, e.g. the Mesosaurus existing in
multiple continents.
• It is the “convergence of evidence” where the
agreement of all of the evidence towards one
mechanism, the theory of continental drift, makes it
compelling.
Conclusions expected which examine the view that
information collected from the sea floor provides compelling
evidence for continental drift.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
84
Question Answer Mark Guidance
20* ‘Effective management of volcanic eruptions
prevents disasters.’ To what extent do you agree
with this statement?
AO1
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of management of volcanic eruptions
and disasters.
Level 3 (5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of management of volcanic eruptions and disasters.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of management of volcanic eruptions
and disasters.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
management of volcanic eruptions and disasters.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (8-10 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide a clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how effective management of volcanic eruptions
prevents disasters.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide detailed and
substantiated evaluation that offers secure judgements
20
AO1 x10
AO2 x10
AO1 - 10 marks
Knowledge and understanding of management of volcanic
eruptions and disasters could potentially include:
• Mention of the disaster risk equation
o (R = (H x V) / C where R is risk, H is the frequency
or magnitude of a hazard, V is the level of
vulnerability and C is the capacity to cope.
• Mention of the disaster-response curve (Park, 1991)
focusing on modifying the cause and event.
• Presence of case study detail to be expected.
Volcanic Eruptions
• Volcanic disasters can be related to the following volcanic
hazards:
o Pyroclastic flows (e.g. Montserrat)
o Lava bombs
o Gas release (e.g. Lake Nyos, Cameroon, 1986)
o Tephra and asphyxiation
o Lahars (e.g. Nevado del Ruiz, 1984)
o Floods, often from jökulhlaups
o Tsunamis
• Effective volcanic eruption management includes:
o Geological monitoring e.g. use of seismometers
and tiltmeters on volcano flanks to detect changes
in activity.
o Educating the population in terms of what to do in
the event of a volcanic eruption.
o Detecting gases – greater release can indicate
and impending eruption.
o Houses which can be moved in the event of
effusive eruptions e.g. Hawaii
o Evacuation and closing roads and airports during
an event.
o Well trained and accessible health clinics to treat
injuries relating to a volcanic eruption e.g.
asphyxiation.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
85
leading to rational conclusions that are evidence based
as to the extent to which effective management of
volcanic eruptions prevents disasters.
Level 3 ( 5-7 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed
analysis that shows how effective management of
volcanic eruptions prevents disasters.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that
offers generally secure judgements, with some link
between rational conclusions and evidence as to the
extent to which effective management of volcanic
eruptions prevents disasters.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound analysis that
shows how effective management of volcanic eruptions
prevents disasters.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide a sound evaluation that
offers generalised judgements and conclusions, with
limited use of evidence as to the extent to which
effective management of volcanic eruptions prevents
disasters.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows
how effective management of volcanic eruptions
prevents disasters.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation
AO2 - 10 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse and
evaluate the extent to which effective management of
volcanic eruptions prevents disasters could potentially
include:
• Application of the disaster risk equation, to demonstrate
the R value is lowered through a high C value and low H
and V values.
• A recognition that other factors influence disaster severity
e.g. magnitude of the event, human factors (e.g. level of
development)
• Many of the AO2 marks will be gained through relevant
exemplification, using case studies to demonstrate that
effective management of volcanic eruptions does or does
not always prevent disasters (eg Eyjafjallajökull in 2010
where the airports were closed internationally and the
volcanic eruption Nevado del Ruiz in 1984 respectively).
A conclusion should be present which acknowledges the
extent to which effective management of volcanic eruptions
prevents disasters.H081/02 Mark Scheme November 2020
86
that offers simple conclusions as to the extent to which
effective management of volcanic eruptions prevents
disasters.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is
clear and logically structured. The information
presented is relevant and substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some
structure. The information presented is in the most-part
relevant and supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented
with limited structure. The information is supported by
limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by
limited evidence and the relationship to the evidence
may not be clear.OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]