Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Design and Technology
H404/01: Principles of Design Engineering
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RS
...
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Design and Technology
H404/01: Principles of Design Engineering
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 2020H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
2
Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Blank Page – this annotation must be used on all blank pages within an
answer booklet (structured or unstructured) and on each page of an
additional object where there is no candidate response.
Tick
Cross
Confused (replaces the question mark)
Benefit of doubt
AO1 – Knowledge and understanding
AO2 – Apply knowledge and understanding
AO3 - Analyse
AO4 - Evaluation
Omission
Not answered question
Noted but no credit given
Too vague
Own figure ruleH404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
3
RepetitionH404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
4
Question Answer Mark Guidance
1 a i Smart object – a physical object with embedded electronic
sensors/microcontrollers/actuators which is equipped for two-way
communication (1).
Network – a series of devices (e.g. smart objects) connected together in such
a way that they can communicate with each other and exchange data (1).
Communication protocol – an agreed method of communication between
the devices in a network which allows for successful data exchange and
routing (1).
3 In each case:
One mark for definition of term.
Answers should convey that twoway communication is happening
between devices.
No marks for points that only
consider the control of devices.
As long as understanding is shown
award marks.
ii Possible responses may include:
• The microcontroller can add enhanced functionality to a kettle, e.g. a smart
kettle (1) which will increase the attraction to potential buyers (1).
• The microcontroller control circuit may be a commonly available standard
subsystem (1) which makes it simple for a designer to integrate rather than
designing a bespoke control system (1).
• Kettle can be networked (1), so can be controlled remotely or exchange
information e.g. about energy usage (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Other possible responses may include:
• Increased reliability, which prolongs the kettle’s life.
• Can accurately sense water temperature which means reliable boiling and
potential energy saving.
• Firmware can be upgraded, so development features can be added later.
4 In each case:
If candidates mention enhanced
functionality to the kettle but do not
justify with a benefit to the
manufacturer award one mark.
Up to two marks for describing two
benefits to a designer or
manufacturer of embedding a
microcontroller into a kettle.
Mix and match approach to be
taken.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
5
Question Answer Mark Guidance
It must be clear how the points
benefit the designer or
manufacturer.
No marks for points that appear to
only benefit the user.
1 b i Possible responses may include:
• The input worm scan drive the output gear but not vice-versa (1) which
means that the blind cannot fall under its own weight when the motor is not
running (1).
• The input worm screw can drive the output wheel but not vice-versa (1)
which means that the blind cannot fall under its own weight when the motor
is not running (1).
• A large gear ratio provides slow rotation and steady controlled movement
of the blind (1), enabling the user to stop the blind at a desired position (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Other possible responses may include:
• A large gear ratio can be achieved in one stage, which allows for a
compact gearbox size.
• A large gear ratio means that smaller, lower torque motors can be used.
• The mechanism is quiet in operation, which is beneficial in a home
environment.
2 Up to two marks for explaining one
functional feature of a worm drive
system that makes it useful in the
roller-blind mechanical drive
system.
Mix and match approach.
Specific reference to the context in
the question is needed for marks to
be awarded.
Do not accept ‘the drive is
transferred through 90 degrees’
unless it is clearly justified why this
is useful in a roller blind system.
ii Circumference = πd (or 2πr) (1)
Circumference = π x 35
= 110 mm (to nearest mm) (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for recalling formula.
One mark for applying formula to
calculate the circumference of the
roller to the nearest mm.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
6
Question Answer Mark Guidance
If the correct answer is given award
full marks.
iii Revolutions of roller to raise blind 165 mm = distance/circumference
= 165/110*
= 1.5 revs (1)
Rotational speed of roller = 1.5*/2
= 0.75 revs s-1 (1)
The gear ratio of the worm drive system is 40
Motor rotational speed = 0.75* x 40
= 30 rev s-1 (1)
Convert to rpm:
Motor rotational speed = 30* x 60
= 1800 rpm (1)
4 Award four marks as follows:
One mark for calculating the
number of revolutions of the roller
needed to raise the bind.
One mark for calculating the
rotational speed of the roller.
One mark for calculating the motor
rotational speed.in revolutions per
second.
One mark for converting revolutions
per second to revolutions per
minute.
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
7
Question Answer Mark Guidance
*Allow error carried forward (ECF)
where correct working out is shown.
Do not award a mark for stating that
the gear ratio is 40. The mark for
this comes from using this figure to
calculate the motor rotational
speed.
iv Possible responses may include:
• As the blind rises the roller diameter increases (1) due to the thickness of
the blind fabric (1).
• As the blind rises there is less weight hanging off the roller (1) meaning
there is less load on the motor (1).
• As the blind rises the roller diameter increases (1), which increases the
circumference of the roller (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Other possible responses may include:
• The motor must overcome the initial inertia of the system (1), meaning the
speed will significantly increase over the first couple of seconds of
operation (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
4 In each case:
Up two marks for explaining why the
speed of the blind increases
throughout the raising cycle.
Mix and match approach.
Specific reference to the context in
the question is needed for marks to
be awarded.
v Sensor:
• Slotted opto-sensor and a slotted disk on the blind roller (1).
• Reed switch and a magnet on the blind roller (1).
• Microswitch and a cam on the blind roller (1).
• Rotary encoder on the blind roller (1).
4 Award four marks as follows:
One mark for identifying a suitable
sensor for detecting the roller
speed.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
8
Question Answer Mark Guidance
• Continuous potentiometer on the blind roller (1).
• Hall effect sensor on the blind roller (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
System diagram (or similar) (1):
Explanation:
• The speed signal from the sensor is compared to the desired speed by the
processor (1).
• The motor speed is adjusted until it matches the desired speed (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
One mark for a system diagram
showing the sensor, a process
subsystem, the motor as the
system output and closed loop
feedback.
Award one mark for a circuit
diagram showing the sensor, a
microprocessor, and the motor.
Up to two marks for explaining the
principle of operation of the closed
loop system.
Candidates are likely to use a
combination of sketches and/or
notes although the candidate may
outline the closed loop system in
place of drawing a system diagram.
The interaction between the sensor
and the mechanical system must be
clear for the sensor mark.
Credit should be given wherever the
candidate has supplied the required
information in their response.
vi Indicative Content: 6 Level 3 [5-6 marks]
Speed
sensor
Processor Motor
Desired speed
signalH404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
9
Question Answer Mark Guidance
• Problem of a power source. Batteries could be used, but a means of
recharging or replacing them needs to be found. Rechargeable battery
pack could be made removable. Possible inclusion of low battery warning.
• Problem of recharging batteries. Possible use of renewable energy source,
e.g. solar panels, which could work as the blind is next to a window.
• Problem of communication with the device, e.g. to make blind raise or
lower. Investigate wireless protocols such as WiFi, Bluetooth etc.
• Wireless communication is prone to interference, and limited range. Twoway communication allows for information feedback or ‘handshaking’.
System could send alerts to central hub, e.g. low battery, blind jammed.
• Problem of integrating the battery into the housing of the blind. Use of
existing battery form factors may be necessary. A balance of battery
energy capacity against size of enclosure will need to be struck by the
designer.
• Any other valid suggestion.
For MB3 to
be awarded
there will be
both
challenges
and
solutions
listed.
If candidate
does not
provide an
analytical/ev
aluative
response,
then only L1
can be
awarded.
The candidate has a clear
understanding of challenges when
designing wireless devices. They
produce a thorough discussion in
relation to the question by
explaining a number of challenges
that designers could face as well as
identifying potential solutions that
could be investigated further. The
explanation is clear and welldeveloped and there is a clear
appreciation of both challenge and
solution in the iterative designing
process.
Level 2 [3-4 marks]
The candidate has a reasonable
understanding of challenges when
designing wireless devices. They
produce a sound discussion in
relation to the question by
explaining a number of challenges
that designers could face as well as
identifying potential solutions that
could be investigated further. The
explanation is sufficient although
one or two opportunities are missed
in drawing out solutions from the
challenges presented.
Level 1 [1-2 marks]
The candidate has a basic
knowledge of wireless devices. Any
reference to aH404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
10
Question Answer Mark Guidance
technical challenge when
developing wireless devices is
largely descriptive in nature. There
is little appreciation of solutions and
the response contains no analysis
or evaluation.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy
of credit.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
11
2 a Converting 4m to 4000 mm (1)
Similar triangles methodology:
100 / 4000 = 5 / L (1)
Finding L:
L = (4000 x 5) / 100
= 200 mm (1)
3 Award three marks as follows:
One mark for converting 4 m to mm.
One mark for applying similar triangles
methodology.
One mark for re-arranging formula to
find L.
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.
This problem can also be solved using
trigonometry.
b i Subtracting 2x radii off the length:
W = 180 – 30 – 30 (1)
Calculating answer:
W = 120 mm (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for understanding that you
need to take 2 x radii of the length.
One mark for calculating the Width W.
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
12
ii The radius of the outer curved surface:
30 + (3 x 5) = 45 mm (1)
The total arc length of the curved sections:
Total arc length = πd/2 = 141.371669412 (1)
The height of the vertical sides:
Height = 90 – 45* = 45 mm (1)
4Total outside length PQ:
(2 x 45*) + 120* + 141.371669412*
= 351.4 mm (1)
Accept rounded answer e.g. 350mm to 2sf, 351mm to 3sf.
4 Award four marks as follows:
One mark for calculating the radius of
the outer curved surface.
One mark for calculating the total arc
length of the curved sections.
One mark for calculating the height of
the vertical sides.
One mark for calculating the outside
length PQ.
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.
*Allow error carried forward (ECF)
where correct working out is shown.
Height of vertical sides can also be
calculated (75 – 30) = 45mm from Fig.
2.2.
iii Possible responses may include:
• The former needs to separate from the part after forming (1).
• This requires the former to have tapered sides with a draft angle (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
2 Up to two marks for explaining why
well-designed formers are not usually
manufactured with vertical sides.
One mark can be awarded for stating
that the part cannot easily separate
from the former if the sides are vertical.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
13
One mark can be awarded for stating
that the former has tapered sides or
draft angle.
Specific reference to the context in the
question is needed for marks to be
awarded.
iv Possible materials may include:
• Polystyrene modelling foam (1).
• Any timber (e.g. pine) (1).
• Plywood (1).
• Plaster of Paris (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Functional performance:
• The polystyrene foam has a small cell structure (1) which allows it to be
sanded to the shape shown without crumbling (1).
• The wide grain in the pine allows for it to be easily sanded to shape (1)
whilst being resilient enough to resist splitting (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Environmental considerations:
• Polystyrene foam is unlikely to be recycled after use (1) but the former
could be used to manufacture several parts, so the negative
environmental impact is reduced (1).
• Pine can be sourced from sustainable forests (1) or the pine for the
former could be reused from an obsolete or unwanted product (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
5 One mark for naming a material
suitable for manufacturing the former.
Up to two marks for explaining the
selection of materials in terms of
functional performance.
Up to two marks for explaining the
selection of materials in terms of
environmental considerations.
Specific reference to the context in the
question is needed for marks to be
awarded.
A specific named material must be
given, e.g. no credit for ‘wood’.
An obscure material can be awarded
one mark if justification is given in the
explanation that follows.
Justification for an obscure material
may be given in the explanation which
follows.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
14
The functional explanation must go
beyond ‘it is strong’ or ‘it can be
sanded’ for the award of marks.
The environmental considerations may
be positive or negative in nature. The
strongest answers will realise that there
is a negative environmental impact
when using most materials.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
15
3 a Possible responses may include:
• Incremental innovation can be used to gradually improve versions of
an already successful product (1) which requires very little
investment from a manufacturer as each change can be quite small
(1).
• The small changes can be released as part of a planned product
lifetime strategy (1) which can help sustain sales of an already
established product within the market (1).
• As new technology emerges, its use can enhance the function of a
product (1), which can increase its attraction to buyers (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Other responses may include:
• Incremental innovation also applies to manufacturing systems, so
manufacturing techniques can evolve to reduce costs and improve
manufacturing speed.
• Small changes may be demanded by customers, to fit fashions or to
ensure product compatibility with other technology systems.
4 In each case:
Up to two marks for explaining two ways in
which an incremental strategy can be
beneficial to a product manufacturer.
b* Indicative Content:
Registered designs
• Gives the designer ownership rights for the appearance of a product.
• Protects distinctive product shape, pattern or decoration.
• Protects distinctive visual features e.g. lines, contours, colours,
materials.
• The design must be new and original.
• Must have a unique character, not resemble an existing design.
• Must be registered with the Intellectual Property Office (IPO).
• Must be renewed every 5 years.
Registered trademarks
• Used by a company or individual to identify their brand.
• Used to distinguish their product from others’ brands.
8
For MB3 to
be awarded
a number of
ways will be
given.
If candidate
does not
provide an
analytical/e
valuative
response,
then only
Level 3 [6-8 marks]
The candidate has a clear understanding of
IP legislation. They produce a thorough
discussion in relation to the question by
explaining some of the ways in which the
IP of designers can be protected.
The explanation is clear and welldeveloped and specific areas of legislation
are used to exemplify the points being
made.
There is a well-developed line of reasoning
which is clear and logically structured. The
information presented is relevant and
substantiated with the use of examples.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
16
• Trademarks can be in the form of a word, name, song, or symbol.
• Trademarks can be registered as a logo, slogan, domain name,
shape or sound.
• To register a trademark it must be unique and distinctive.
• Trademarks must be fair and accurate.
• Trademarks must be morally acceptable.
• Must be registered with the Intellectual Property Office (IPO).
• Must be renewed every 10 years.
Copyright
• A set of exclusive rights given to creators of original ideas,
information or other intellectual works.
• Copyright material can only be copied, used or recreated with the
owner’s permission.
• Copyright protection is automatic and no registration is needed.
• The work is often marked with the © symbol, used alongside the
creator’s name and the date.
• Work is still protected even without the © symbol.
• Copyright does not protect the ideas for a piece of work.
• Copyright lasts for 70 years for most types of written work.
• Photographs are copyrighted for 25 years.
Design rights
• Protect the creator of a design (unless a 3rd party commissions the
work).
• Design rights protect the configuration or shape of a product.
• They can be used to prevent copying of an original design without
permission.
• Design rights do not protect the 2D aspects of the design, e.g.
patterns.
• Design rights can be bought, sold or licensed.
• They stay in force for 10 years after first marketing of the product (or
15 years after creating the design).
• For the first 5 years, others are prevented from copying the design.
• For the remaining time the design is subject to a licence of right.
L1 can be
awarded.
Level 2 [3-5 marks]
The candidate has a reasonable
understanding of IP legislation. They
produce a sound discussion in relation to
the question by explaining some of the
ways in which the IP of designers can be
protected. The explanation of ways is
sufficient although one or two opportunities
are missed in referring to different areas of
legislation.
There is a line of reasoning presented with
some structure. The information presented
for the most part relevant and supported by
some evidence.
Level 1 [1-2 marks]
The candidate has a basic knowledge of IP
legislation. Any reference to this issue is
descriptive in nature and has little
appreciation of the ways in which the IP of
designers can be protected. The response
contains no analysis or evaluation.
The information has some relevance and is
presented with limited structure or detail.
The information is supported by limited
evidence.
0 marks
No answer or answer not worthy of credit.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
17
• Design rights only apply in the UK.
Patents
• Granted by the government, they offer strong protection.
• Difficult to obtain, involving long, expensive, technical processes.
• Inventors must publicise all details of the invention.
• Patent lawyers are often employed to write a strong patent.
• Protect against copying the technical and functional aspects of a
design.
• Can cover how a device works and what materials are used.
• Protect designs and inventions for 20 years.
• The invention must be new.
• It must have an inventive step that is not obvious to someone with
technical knowledge.
• The invention must be capable of being made.
Any other valid suggestion.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
18
4 a i Reading on-time (or off-time) from graph:
On time = 0.1 ms
Off time = 0.3 ms (1)
Adding on + off times to determine the period:
0.1 + 0.3
= 0.4 ms (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for reading on-time (or offtime) from graph.
One mark for adding on and off times
to determine the period.
Award 1 mark for the answer 0.1ms or
0.3ms.
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.
ii Recall of formula:
Frequency = 1/period (1)
Calculating frequency in kHz:
Frequency = 1 / 0.4*
= 2.5 kHz (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for recalling formula.
One mark calculating frequency in kHz.
*Allow error carried forward (ECF)
where correct working out is shown.
b i R = 1.25 x 0.003
0.005 × 50×10−6 (1) (1)
= 15000 Ω (1)
Conversion to kΩ:
R = 15 kΩ (1)
4 Award four marks as follows:
One mark for two conversions of mm
measurements to m and inserting in
formula.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
19
One mark for conversion of of µm
measurement to m and inserting in
formula.
One mark for calculating the resistance
result in Ω.
One mark for conversion to kΩ.
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.
ii Calculating voltage (pd) across probes:
V = 3 – 2 = 1V (1)
Ratio of voltages to the ratio of the resistances:
Vprobes / VR = 1 / 2
1 / 2 = Rprobes* / R (1)
Calculating R:
R = (2 x Rprobes*) / 1
= 30 kΩ (1)
3 Award three marks as follows:
One mark for calculating voltage (pd)
across probes.
One mark for equating the ratio of
voltages to the ratio of the resistances.
One mark for calculating the minimum
value of Resistor R.
Other valid methods may be used,
including the use of the potential divider
formula Vout = Vin x R2/(R1+R2) or V=IR
If correct answer is given without
working out shown award full marks.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
20
Where an incorrect answer is given
working out should be used to credit
appropriate marks.
Correct answer with no working gains
full marks.
*Allow error carried forward (ECF)
where correct working out is shown.
iii 0 V (1) 1 Award mark as indicated.
c Problem 1: After executing the ‘A.0>2V?’ command the program becomes
stuck in a loop if the result is ‘No’ (1).
Solution 1: The ‘No’ output from ‘A.0>2V?’ should loop back to ‘Read ADC
A.0’ (1).
Problem 2: After switching on the LED (High B.0), there is no later command
to turn it off again (1).
Solution 2: Insert a ‘Low B.0’ command in the ‘Yes’ loop after Y=1600? (1).
Problem 3: The loop containing the Y counter does not last for 1.5s, so the
sound will not last for 1.5s (1).
Solution 3: The loop duration is 0.4ms, so the loop must be executed
1.5/0.0004 = 3750 times, so change the decision command to ‘Y=3750?’ (1).
6 When evaluating the flowchart against
the functional specification candidate
should be able to identify three
problems and suggest solutions in each
case.
The solutions must be specific and
detailed to gain the marks. They be
presented as per the mark scheme or
more likely in narrative prose.
Candidates may draw their answers
from Fig. 4.4.
Specific reference to the context in the
question is needed for marks to be
awarded.
d i Possible materials may include:
• Thermochromic pigment (1).
• Photochromic pigment (1).
• Electroluminescent material (1).
1 The answer requires a smart material
NOT a modern material.
A smart material has a property which
reacts in response to a stimulus.H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
21
• Piezoelectric material (1).
• Shape memory alloy (1).
• Shape memory polymer (1).
• Motion control grease (1).
• Electro translucent glass (privacy glass) (1).
• Electrochromic material (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Other possible responses may include:
Nitinol
As there is a blurred boundary for some
materials, it may be necessary to look
at the candidate’s response to part
4)d)ii) to see if they have correctly
identified the property and the stimulus.
Do NOT allow ‘conductive ink’ or ‘smart
ink’.
Specific reference to the context in the
question is needed for marks to be
awarded.
d ii Possible responses may include:
• Thermochromic pigment is used in battery testers (1). Thermochromic
pigment is coloured at low temperature but loses its colour above a
transition temperature (1). In the battery tester, a thin conductive strip
heats up when current is passed through it and this heats the
thermochromic material (1). The conductive strip is tapered, so for low
currents it only heats the thermochromic piment at one end, revealing
Red ink behind, whilst at higher currents it heats the entire length of strip
(1), revealing red, yellow and green ink.
• Thermochromic pigment is used in baby feeding products, such as bowls,
cups and spoons (1). These products are made of polymers mixed with
thermochromic pigments that change colour with heat (1), allowing the
user to check the temperature (1), without contaminating the food by
touching it (1).
• Electrochromic windows are used in airliners (1). Suspended particle
device (SPD) glass films provide active shading (1). The films are applied
between the double glazing (1). When off (no voltage) the particles are
scattered creating opacity, as voltage is increased by the user pressing a
button, the particles align and light can pass through the window (1).
• Electrochromic glass, known as privacy glass is used in shower and
bathrooms (1). They switch from transparent to opaque when a voltage is
4
Up to four marks for describing how the
properties of the smart materials
identified in part (d)(i) (in relation to a
specific product) provide functionality.
Award one mark for identification of a
specific product.
A specific product must be identified or
described for full marks.
The functional description must be
sufficiently detailed and accurate to
award full marks.
Award a maximum of two marks if the
description does not correspond to the
material identified in part d)i).H404/01 Mark Scheme November 2020
22
applied to them (1). When the voltage is applied, the liquid crystals inside
the glass align and allow light to pass through (1). When the voltage is
nor present the liquid crystal molecules are positioned randomly and
block out any light, becoming opaque (private) (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Specific reference to the context in the
question is needed for marks to be
awarded.OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]