Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Design and Technology
H404/01: Principles of Design Engineering
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA)
...
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Design and Technology
H404/01: Principles of Design Engineering
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 20211. Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Blank Page – this annotation must be used on all blank pages within an
answer booklet (structured or unstructured) and on each page of an
additional object where there is no candidate response.
Tick
Cross
Confused (replaces the question mark)
Benefit of doubt
AO1 – Knowledge and understanding
AO2 – Apply knowledge and understanding
AO3 - Analyse
AO4 - Evaluation
Omission
Not answered question
Noted but no credit given
Too vague
Own figure rule
RepetitionH404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
2.Subject Specific Marking Instructions
INTRODUCTION
Your first task as an Examiner is to become thoroughly familiar with the material on which the examination depends. This material includes:
• the specification, especially the assessment objectives
• the question paper
• the mark scheme.
You should ensure that you have copies of these materials.
You should ensure also that you are familiar with the administrative procedures related to the marking process. These are set out in the OCR
booklet Instructions for Examiners. If you are examining for the first time, please read carefully Appendix 5 Introduction to Script Marking:
Notes for New Examiners.
Please ask for help or guidance whenever you need it. Your first point of contact is your Team Leader.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
Question Answer Mark Guidance
1 (a) (i) Possible ways my include:
• The product can be used in the left or right hand (1).
• The product has the bare minimum controls, just on/off and screw direction (1).
• No labelling of controls is visible on the case, so there should be no language
barriers (1).
• Using it is intuitive – no instructions are required (1).
• The product has been ergonomically designed to fit comfortably in one hand (1).
• The illumination will help for users with non-perfect eyesight (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
2 In each case:
One mark for identifying a way
in which the electric screwdriver
has been designed to be an
inclusive and easy-to-use
product.
Specific reference to the
context in the question is
needed for marks to be
awarded.
(ii) Number of seconds in one year:
One year = 60 x 60 x 24 x 365 = 31536000 s (1)
Time to manufacture one unit:
Time per unit = seconds in year / number of units
Time per unit = 31536000* / 1000000 = 31.54 s (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for calculating the
number of seconds in one year.
One mark for calculating the
average time in seconds to
manufacture one screwdriver.
If correct answer is given
without working out shown
award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is
given working out should be
used to credit appropriate
marks.
*Allow error carried forward
(ECF) where correct working
out is shown.
(b) (i) Possible reasons may include: 4 In each case:H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
• A gearbox is needed to increase the torque output (1) because the torque direct
from the motor is very small (1).
• An epicyclic gearbox has a co-linear (in-line) input and output shaft (1) which
enables the design of the electric screwdriver to be slim/compact (1).
• Epicyclic gears can handle higher torque (1) because of their design, which is
required in a screwdriver (1).
• Epicyclic gearbox is compact (1) which leads to a smaller screwdriver design
(1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
Up to two reasons for
explaining why the designer
chose to use an epicyclic
gearbox in this application.
Specific reference to the
context in the question is
needed for marks to be
awarded.
(ii) Combined gear ratio:
GR = 7 x 7 = 49 (1)
GR = input speed / output speed (non-maths mark)
Therefore input (motor) speed:
Rotational speed of motor = GR x output speed (1)
= 49* x 215 = 10 535 rpm (1)
3 Award three marks as follows:
One mark for calculating the
combined gear ratio.
One mark for
recalling/manipulating the gear
ratio formula (non-maths).
One mark for calculating the
rotational speed of the motor in
the electric screwdriver.
If correct answer is given
without working out shown
award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is
given working out should be
used to credit appropriate
marks.
*Allow error carried forward
(ECF) where correct working
out is shown.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(c) (i) Motor current = 1.25A (1) 1
(ii) V = IR (1) (non-maths mark)
V = 2.5 x 0.1
Voltage = 0.25V (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for recalling the
correct formula to calculate
voltage.
One mark for calculating the
voltage across the 0.1Ω
resistor when the motor current
is 2.5A.
(iii) Possible reasons may include:
• It blocks direct current (1) while allowing alternating current to pass (1).
• It stores electrical charges (1) and releases it as it is required by the circuit (1).
• They can stabilise a power supply line (1) to prevent damage to components
such as microprocessors (1).
• They can be used to remove undesirable frequencies (1) by filtering interference
such as radio frequencies. (1)
• It can be sued to decouple one part of a circuit from another (1) to prevent noise
in one part of the circuit affecting the rest of it (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
2 Up to two marks for explaining
why a capacitor is used in
electronic systems.
Answers do not need to relate
directly to the screwdriver
application.
(iv) For two marks:
• 1st mark for stating that the amplifier will increase the voltage signal (1).
• 2nd mark for stating that the signal is increased by a factor of 4 (1).
2 Up to two marks for describing
the effect the amplifier will have
on the voltage signal.
Specific reference to the
context in the question is
needed for marks to be
awarded.
Only really one route available
to access the two marks for this
question.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(d)
Indicative content:
The candidate is expected to demonstrate their understanding of the
process involved through a series of annotated sketches and/or notes.
There may be variations to the process as indicated but to get into L3
candidates must demonstrate a clear understanding of the end to end
process.
Equipment: hand tools (saw, file, rasp, glasspaper, knife etc), hot wire cutter, CAD
software and computer (3D design software, CAE software, 2D profile software
combined with layering software), machines (drill, sander, router, CNC miller, 3D
printer, laser-cutter), etc.
Materials: polystyrene foam, polymorph, clay, casting resin, ABS/PLA filament for
3D printing, MDF, foam board, surface filler, paints etc.
Processes: sculpting, filing, cutting, drilling, sanding, surface finishing and painting,
3D printing (with post processing of part), laser cutting (and explanation of how 3D
model is created), description of how 3D CAD is used to create a part from a series
of features, limitations of CNC machines, etc.
Example of a Level 3 response:
6
All
processes
demonstrated must
relate to the product
in the question.
Level 3 [5-6 marks]
The candidate demonstrates a
good level of detail of the
process needed to make a nonfunctional model of an electric
screwdriver using technical
terms and considering any
relevant equipment and
materials. Sketches, if used will
be clear and supported with
relevant notes. The process
includes all relevant stages.
Level 2 [3-4 marks]
The candidate will demonstrate
a sound level of detail of the
process needed to make a nonfunctional model of an electric
screwdriver using some
technical terms and there will
be some consideration of any
relevant equipment and/or
materials. Sketches, if used, will
for the most part be clear and
supported with notes most of
which are relevant. The
process includes some relevant
stages.
Level 1 [1-2 marks]
The candidate will demonstrate
a limited level of detail of the
process needed to make a nonfunctional model of an electric
screwdriver with a limited use of
technical terms and there will
be a basic consideration of any
relevant equipment and/or
materials. Sketches, if used, willH404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
be unclear with only basic notes
to accompany them. Few
relevant stages are included.
0 marks
No response or no response
worthy of credit.
2 (a) (i) Converting ¼ inch to mm:
¼ inch = 0.25 x 25.4 = 6.35 mm (1)
The most suitable drill bit is 6 mm (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for converting the ¼
inch to mm.
One mark for identifying the
size of the most suitable drill bit
to drill the hole.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(ii) The lower tolerance limit of the hole will be 95% of the specified value (1)
The lower tolerance limit:
Lower limit = 0.95 x 6.35 = 6.0325 mm (1)
The 6 mm drill would not be within tolerance (1)
Lower tolerance limit can also be calculated by:
6.35 – ((6.35/100) x 5)
If part (i) is inaccurate but candidate states no (with no workings) award max 1
mark.
3 Award three marks as follows:
One mark for determining that
the lower tolerance limit of the
hole will be 95% of the
specified value.
One mark for calculating the
lower tolerance limit.
One mark for determining that
the 6 mm drill bit would not be
within the tolerance.
(b) (i) Probability of faulty gear = 80 / 5 000
Therefore probability (P) = 0.016 (1)
1 One mark for calculating the
probability of a gear being faulty
in the batch.
Do not award a mark for an
answer given as a fraction or as
a percentage.
(ii) No. of gears needed to find one faulty = 1/probability = 1 / 0.016*
= 62.5 (1)
Number of gears = 63 (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for dividing the
calculated probability by 1.
One mark for calculating the
minimum number of gears
which should be inspected if the
probability of a faulty gear
remains the same
If correct answer is given
without working out shown
award full marks.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
Where an incorrect answer is
given working out should be
used to credit appropriate
marks.
*Allow error carried forward
(ECF) where correct working
out is shown.
(c) (i)
Tan function to find the drop in height from start to end:
Tan (2.5) = y / 30 (1)
y = 30 x tan (2.5) = 1.31 m (rounded) (1)
H = 2.8 – 1.31* = 1.5 m (1)
3 Award three marks as follows:
One mark for recalling correct
trigonometry formula (there
could be more than one).
One mark for calculating the
distance y.
One mark for calculating the
height h in mm to 1 decimal
place.
If correct answer is given
without working out shown
award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is
given working out should be
used to credit appropriate
marks.
*Allow error carried forward
(ECF) where correct working
out is shown.
2.8m
H
2.5°
y
30mH404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(ii)
Calculating the third angle in the triangle (A):
Angle A = 180 – 66 – 69 = 45° (1)
Using sine rule expression:
3/sin (A) = d/sin (66)
Therefore:
3 / sin (45*) = d / sin (66) (1)
Rearrange formula to find d:
d = 3 x sin (66) / sin (45*) (1)
Candidates may also write this as:
d = (3/sin (45*)) x sin (66)
Therefore:
d = 3.88 m (1)
4 Award four marks as follows:
One mark for calculating the
third angle in the triangle.
One mark for applying the
correct trigonometry formula.
One mark for rearranging the
formula to find D.
One mark for calculating the
distance D in mm to 2 decimal
places.
If correct answer is given
without working out shown
award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is
given working out should be
used to credit appropriate
marks.
*Allow error carried forward
(ECF) where correct working
out is shown.
A 69°
3m
66°
dH404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(iii) Probability of zero failure = 1 – (1/25 000) = 0.99996 (1)
No of days in use over 25 years = 300 x 25 = 7500 (1)
Probability of zero failures = 0.99996*7500* = 0.74 (2 dec places) (1)
Probability of failure over a 25 year period = 1-0.74* = 0.26 = 26% (1)
4 Award four marks as follows:
One mark for calculating the
probability of failure.
One mark for calculating the
number of days in use over a
25 year period.
One mark for calculating the
probability of zero failures.
One mark for calculating the
probability of failure as a
percentage over a 25 year
period.
If correct answer is given
without working out shown
award full marks.
Where an incorrect answer is
given working out should be
used to credit appropriate
marks.
*Allow error carried forward
(ECF) where correct working
out is shown.
3 (a) (i) Possible design features may include:
• The LED bulb has the same screw fitting as the incandescent bulb (1).
• The light output of the LED bulb has been made to almost match that of the
incandescent bulb (1).
• The dimensions/shape are/is the same (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
2 In each case:
One mark for identifying a
design feature of the LED bulb
that has been influenced by the
style and function of the
incandescent bulb.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
Specific reference to the
context in the question is
needed for marks to be
awarded.
(ii)* Indicative content:
Impact on industry
• Investment in new equipment and machinery
• Investment in retraining workers in new manufacturing processes
• New testing procedures
• Searching for new suppliers of materials and components
• New technology to learn
• Health and safety implications/risk assessments
• Review of profits, sales targets
• New marketing strategy
• New ventures, new opportunities for capitalists
Impact on the lifestyle of users
• New, unfamiliar technology
• Costs of replacing bulbs
• Concerns over the quality of the light from an LED bulb
• Lower running costs, lower electricity bills
• Lower costs mean than users can have more lights on at once, changing the
ambience in the house
• Less replacing of bulbs as LEDs last longer
• Better security/safety because outside lights can be left on all night (including
streetlamps)
• Ability to integrate into smart house systems
Impact on the environment
• Lower power consumption means less fuel used, so lower carbon footprint,
lower emissions
• Bulbs last longer so less use of raw materials and less waste produced
• Questions about recyclability of LED bulbs as they are more complex and
contain multiple components
• Questions about RoHS in LED bulbs
• More lights left on at night causes light pollution
8
If candidate does
not provide an
analytical/evaluative
response then only
L1 can be awarded.
Level 3 [6-8 marks]
The candidate has a clear
understanding of impact of
changing from the stated
product to another. They
produce a thorough discussion
in relation to the question by
explaining the impact of
changing from incandescent
light bulbs to LED light bulbs.
The explanation of impacts is
clear and well developed and
all three contexts provided
within the question are covered.
There is a well-developed line
of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The
information presented is
relevant and substantiated with
the use of examples.
Level 2 [3-5 marks]
The candidate has a
reasonable understanding of
the impact of changing from the
stated product to another. They
produce a sound discussion in
relation to the question by
explaining the impact of
changing from incandescent
light bulbs to LED light bulbs.
The explanation of impacts is
sufficient although one or twoH404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
Any other valid response.
Example Level 3 response:
opportunities are missed in
providing different perspectives.
At least two contexts provided
within the question are covered.
There is a line of reasoning
presented with some structure.
The information presented is for
the most part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 1 [1-2 marks]
The candidate has a basic
knowledge of the impact of
product change. Any reference
to the impact of changing from
incandescent light bulbs to LED
light bulbs is largely descriptive
in nature. The response
contains no analysis or
evaluation. Only one context
provided within the question is
likely to be covered.
The information has some
relevance and is presented with
limited structure or detail. The
information is supported by
limited evidence.
0 marks
No response or no response
worthy of credit.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(b) Possible methods may include:
• Use celebrity endorsement (1) as part of an advertising campaign (1).
• Incremental innovation (1) over the life of the product, increasing demand as
popular new features are added (1).
• A change of branding, image and logo (1) can attract a new target market and
increase demand (1)
• Release of product upgrades and add-ons (1) can extend the life of a product
and maintain demand (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
4 In each case:
Up to two marks for describing
a method that could be used to
create more demand and
maintain a longer product
popularity.
This question is in no particular
context so generic responses
are fine.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
4 (a) Possible properties may include:
• They have a high impact resistance to withstand knocks and bangs on the cool
box (1).
• They have a low thermal conductivity which helps to insulate the contents inside
(1).
• They soften and become plastic when heated which means they can be
moulded and formed into complex shapes (1).
• Durability so the cool box can withstand scrapes and wear (1).
• Resistant to corrosion so surface will stay clean and hygienic (1).
• Good strength to weight ratio so the box will not be too heavy (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
2 In each case:
One mark for identifying a
property of thermo polymer
softeners which make them
suitable for the manufacture of
parts in an electrically powered
cool box.
Specific reference to the
context in the question is
needed for marks to be
awarded.
The property must be qualified
to gain the mark. i.e. low
thermal conductivity on its own
isn’t enough.
(b) (i) Possible responses may include:
• Electrical wires (1)
• Screws (1)
• Heatsink (1)
• Magnets in motor (1)
• Printed circuit board (1)
• Any other valid suggestion.
1 One mark for identifying a part
in an electrically powered cool
box that would be made from
metal.
(ii) Possible responses may include:
• If wires – copper (1) good electrical conductivity (1)
• If screws – steel (1) hard/strong/machinable (1)
• If heatsink – aluminium (1) good thermal conductivity (1)
• If magnets in motor – neodymium (1) very strong magnetic properties (in alloy
form) (1)
• If PCB – copper (1) good electrical conductivity (1)
• Any other valid suggestion.
2 One mark for stating a metal
that would be used to
manufacture the part of the
electrically powered cool box
identified.
One mark for identifying a
property of the metal that
makes it suitable for use.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(c) Possible ways may include:
• Use product labels (1) which will provide a clear indication to the consumer what
action should be taken with product at end of its life (1).
• Look at ways of incentivising consumer to take action (1) for example providing
a product trade-in exchange for a new product (1).
• Design for disassembly, incorporating modular design and semi-permanent
joints (1) to increase the ease with which disassembly can be undertaken (1).
• Label individual parts (1) to aid with dismantling and recycling (1).
• Product take-back schemes (1) enable consumers to exchange old products for
new products (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
4 In each case:
Up to two marks for explaining
what action a manufacturer can
take to ensure that products,
such as the electrically powered
cool box, can be successfully
recovered and effectively
processed when they reach the
end of their life.
Answer can be given in or out
of context here.
(d) (i) Possible responses may include:
• The cross ribs reduce the volume of polymer needed to manufacture the handle
(1) whilst maintaining structural rigidity (1). This makes the handle cheaper to
manufacture (1) and lighter weight (1).
• The handle is flared out in the middle (1), and the cross ribs at this point provide
a hand grip feature (1). The triangulation within the handle provides a texture
that can be gripped firmly (1) to aid with carrying (1).
• The cross ribs reduce the volume of polymer needed to manufacture the handle
(1) whilst maintaining structural rigidity (1). Using less material for the handle
reduces environmental impact (1) from excessive use of polymers (1).
• The cross ribs stiffen the handle (1) so that it is less likely to bend when a heavy
box is carried (1). The visible cross rib structure (1) enhances the aesthetics of
the design (1).
• Any other valid suggestion.
4 Up to four marks for describing
how the performance of the
handle is enhanced by its
design.
Specific reference to the
context in the question is
needed for marks to be
awarded.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(ii) Example responses: 2 One mark for a sketch showing
a valid mode of failure of the
handle.
One mark for marking the
forces acting on the handle.
There is only one way of
accessing the two marks here
although other modes of failure
may be shown.
(e) (i) One mark for formula recall:
I = P/V (1) (non-maths mark)
I = 42 / 12
I = 3.5A (1)
2 Award two marks as follows:
One mark for recalling the
correct formula to calculate the
current (non-maths).
One mark for calculating the
current in amps when the cool
box is plugged into a 12V
supply.
Weight Weight
Handle
breaks here
Lift forceH404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
(ii) Example full-mark response: 6
For full marks it will
be clear that both
internal and
external
temperatures will
need measuring,
and there will be
some indication that
time will be needed
for the system
temperature to
stabilise. There may
be an
understanding that
the test should be
carried out over a
range of external
temperatures.
Level 3 [5-6 marks]:
A valid and rigorous test is
described to evaluate whether
the cool box can maintain a
temperature 18° below external
temperature. Valid equipment is
identified (including a
thermometer (temperature
probe)), the method is clear and
logically structured, and it is
clear how the results would be
used to reach a conclusion.
Level 2 [3-4 marks]:
A valid test is described to
evaluate whether the cool box
can maintain a temperature 18°
below external temperature.
Equipment is identified
(including a thermometer
(temperature probe)), the
method is reasonable clear,
and there is an attempt to
explain how the results would
be used to reach a conclusion.
Level 1 [1-2 marks]
A test is described to measure
the temperature inside the cool
box. Some equipment is
identified, and there is some
attempt to describe a method.
There may be no indication of
how the results would lead to a
conclusion.
0 marks
No response or no response
worthy of credit.H404/01 Mark Scheme October 2021
Example Level 3 responses:OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]