Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Geography
H481/03: Geographical debates
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK award
...
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Geography
H481/03: Geographical debates
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for November 2020Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 2020H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
2
Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Highlight
Off page comment
Omission mark
Unclear or Indicates material for which there is no credit
Rubric error placed at start of response not being counted
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 4
Synoptic link
Development of a point
Significant amount of material which doesn’t answer the question
Used to denote that points had been seen and noted but mostly where credit was given
No place specific detail
Highlighting an issue e.g. irrelevant paragraph. Use in conjunction with another stamp e.g. or
Blank page
EvaluationH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
3
Subject Specific Marking Instructions
INTRODUCTION
Your first task as an Examiner is to become thoroughly familiar with the material on which the examination depends. This material includes:
• the specification, especially the assessment objectives
• the question paper and its rubrics
• the mark scheme.
You should ensure that you have copies of these materials.
You should ensure also that you are familiar with the administrative procedures related to the marking process. These are set out in the OCR booklet
Instructions for Examiners. If you are examining for the first time, please read carefully Appendix 5 Introduction to Script Marking: Notes for New
Examiners.
Please ask for help or guidance whenever you need it. Your first point of contact is your Team Leader.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
USING THE MARK SCHEME
Please study this Mark Scheme carefully. The Mark Scheme is an integral part of the process that begins with the setting of the question paper and ends
with the awarding of grades. Question papers and Mark Schemes are developed in association with each other so that issues of differentiation and positive
achievement can be addressed from the very start.
This Mark Scheme is a working document; it is not exhaustive; it does not provide ‘correct’ answers. The Mark Scheme can only provide ‘best guesses’
about how the question will work out, and it is subject to revision after we have looked at a wide range of scripts.
The Examiners’ Standardisation Meeting will ensure that the Mark Scheme covers the range of candidates’ responses to the questions, and that all
Examiners understand and apply the Mark Scheme in the same way. The Mark Scheme will be discussed and amended at the meeting, and administrative
procedures will be confirmed. Co-ordination scripts will be issued at the meeting to exemplify aspects of candidates’ responses and achievements; the coordination scripts then become part of this Mark Scheme.
Before the Standardisation Meeting, you should read and mark in pencil a number of scripts, in order to gain an impression of the range of responses and
achievement that may be expected.
In your marking, you will encounter valid responses which are not covered by the Mark Scheme: these responses must be credited. You will encounter
answers which fall outside the ‘target range’ of Bands for the paper which you are marking. Please mark these answers according to the marking criteria.
Please read carefully all the scripts in your allocation and make every effort to look positively for achievement throughout the ability range. Always be
prepared to use the full range of marks.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
LEVELS OF RESPONSE QUESTIONS:
The indicative content indicates the expected parameters for candidates’ answers, but be prepared to recognise and credit unexpected approaches where
they show relevance.
Using ‘best-fit’, decide first which set of level descriptors best describes the overall quality of the answer. Once the level is located, adjust the mark
concentrating on features of the answer which make it stronger or weaker following the guidelines for refinement.
Highest mark: If clear evidence of all the qualities in the level descriptors is shown, the HIGHEST Mark should be awarded.
Lowest mark: If the answer shows the candidate to be borderline (i.e. they have achieved all the qualities of the levels below and show limited evidence of
meeting the criteria of the level in question) the LOWEST mark should be awarded.
Middle mark: This mark should be used for candidates who are secure in the level. They are not ‘borderline’ but they have only achieved some of the
qualities in the level descriptors.
Be prepared to use the full range of marks. Do not reserve (e.g.) highest level marks ‘in case’ something turns up of a quality you have not yet seen. If an
answer gives clear evidence of the qualities described in the level descriptors, reward appropriately.
Quality of extended response will be assessed in questions marked with an (*). Quality of extended response is not attributed to any single assessment
objective but instead is assessed against the entire response for the question.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
AO1 AO2 AO3 Quality of extended
response
Comprehensive A wide range of detailed and
accurate knowledge that
demonstrates fully
developed understanding
that shows full relevance to
the demands of the
question.
Precision in the use of
question terminology.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is consistently applied to
the context of the question, in
order to form a:
Clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate.
Clear, developed and convincing
interpretation that is fully accurate.
Detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure
judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence
based.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills
are used in a
consistently appropriate
and effective way and
with a high degree of
competence and
precision.
There is a well-developed
line of reasoning which is
clear and logically
structured. The
information presented is
relevant and
substantiated.
Thorough A range of detailed and
accurate knowledge that
demonstrates well
developed understanding
that is relevant to the
demands of the question.
Generally precise in the use
of question terminology.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is mainly applied to the
context of the question, in order to
form a:
Clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy.
Clear and developed
interpretation that shows
accuracy.
Detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with
some link between rational
conclusions and evidence.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills
are used in a suitable
way and with a good
level of competence and
precision.
There is a line of
reasoning presented with
some structure. The
information presented is in
the most-part relevant and
supported by some
evidence.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
7
AO1 AO2 AO3 Quality of extended
response
Reasonable Some sound knowledge that
demonstrates partially
developed understanding
that is relevant to the
demands to the question.
Awareness of the meaning
of the terms in the question.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is partially applied to the
context of the question, in order to
form a:
Sound analysis that shows some
accuracy.
Sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy.
Sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgments and
conclusions, with limited use of
evidence.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills
are used in a mostly
suitable way with a
sound level of
competence but may
lack precision.
The information has some
relevance and is
presented with limited
structure. The information
is supported by limited
evidence.
Basic Limited knowledge that is
relevant to the topic or
question with little or no
development.
Confusion and inability to
deconstruct terminology as
used in the question.
Knowledge and understanding
shows limited application to the
context of the question in order to
form a/an:
Simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy.
Simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy.
Un-supported evaluation that
offers simple conclusions.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills
are used inappropriately
with limited competence
and precision.
The information is basic
and communicated in an
unstructured way. The
information is supported
by limited evidence and
the relationship to the
evidence may not be
clear.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
8
Question Answer Mark Guidance
1 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 1 as a source of
information about shrinking ice as a result of climate
change.
The photograph shows the meltwaters and a distant
glimpse of the Franz Josef glacier, New Zealand.
Possible limitations include:
• No evidence on rate of change i.e. no early photo to
compare
• Reasons for melting of ice/shrinking of glacier not
clear e.g. temperature data
• No clear evidence of scale e.g. scale of glacier and
valley which can inform comments regarding rate of
change
• Franz Josef is just one glacier and not necessarily
representative of all
• Who produced the source – bias / purpose of photo
• Time of year photo taken – seasonal change to
extent of ice
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for three limitations of the photograph as a
source of information identified through critical study of
the resource.
1 (b) Explain the role and possible bias of the media in
shaping the public image of climate change.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
the role and possible bias of the media in shaping the
public image of climate change (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the role and possible bias of the media in shaping
the public image of climate change.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the role and possible
bias of the media in shaping the public image of climate
change could potentially include:
Role
• Crucial role in forming public opinion as many
do not read scientific papers, reports, blogs +
specialist websites
• Social media growing in popularity as source of
information / opinion
BiasH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
9
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding
of the role and possible bias of the media in shaping the
public image of climate change (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
either the role or possible bias of the media in shaping the
public image of climate change.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
either the role or possible bias of the media in shaping the
public image of climate change (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about either the role or
possible bias of the media in shaping the public image of
climate change.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Simplistic and sensational reporting in some
media
• Social media in particular unregulated allowing
unsubstantiated claims to be made
• Not necessarily representative of scientific
research – overwhelming majority of scientific
research supports idea of anthropogenic climate
change - false balance by giving equal
weighting to dissenting views - increasing
appearance of controversy
• Political leanings of the media organisation will
slant the content e.g. right leaning publications
are more sceptical than left and their differences
make the issue appear more contentious than it
is
• Some of the strongest opinions are from large
wealthy companies (with media influence)
seeking to protect profits from extraction and
use of fossil fuels by opposing climate change
evidence
• Role and bias to be considered for bottom of
L2+.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
10
Question Answer Mark Guidance
2 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 2 as a source of
information about survival rates for common cancers in
the UK.
The table shows different types of cancer and the
percentage of those who survived.
Possible limitations include:
• Definition of survival - 3/5/10 years after diagnosis?
• No data on length of survival
• No data on the frequency of each cancer in the
population
• No data on how rates compare with previous years /
decades
• No information on geographical distribution/post
code that might affect survival rates e.g. access to
health care; socio-economic factors (age structure /
deprivation / over-crowding)
• Gender bias in Breast cancer – males also contract
• No comparison with other places how does the UK
compare with the rest of the World / Europe, USA
etc?
• Who produced the source – bias
• Source is out of date
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for three limitations of the chart as a source of
information identified through critical questioning of the
resource.
2 (b) Explain cultural causes of non-communicable diseases.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
cultural causes of non-communicable diseases (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
at least two cultural causes of non-communicable diseases.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of cultural causes of a
non-communicable disease could potentially include:
• Non-communicable = not spread from person to
person. Non-infectious + non-contagious
e.g.CVDs, diabetes, asthma
• Response based on communicable = 0
• Cultural factors include traditions, values, beliefs
and behaviours held by a defined group of
peopleH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
11
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
cultural causes of non-communicable diseases (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
cultural causes of non-communicable diseases.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
cultural causes of non-communicable diseases (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about cultural causes of noncommunicable diseases.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Behavioural / lifestyle risk factors e.g.
consumption of unhealthy substances e.g.
alcohol, tobacco. Russia – high levels of oral,
oesophageal + liver cancers associated with
drinking culture
• Behavioural / lifestyle risk factors e.g. sedentary
→ ↑ incidence of CVDs, type-2 diabetes; dietary
choices → ↑ incidence of CVDs + some
cancers. Some groups in ACs and increasingly
some EDCs as ↑ wealth allows change in diets.
• Lower economic status among some groups in
ACs → poor diets
• Economic changes allow changes in behaviour /
lifestyle e.g. ↓ real cost of alcohol, cheap
processed food e.g. fast food
• Unavoidable hazardous life-style e.g. cooking +
lighting + heating with biomass / paraffin in
EDCs + LIDCs ↑ incidence of lung cancers
• Behavioural / lifestyle risk factors e.g. use of
tanning lotions and sunbeds, in some societies
that value a suntanned skin, increasing risk of
skin cancers
• L3 possible if only one disease referenced.
• 1 cause = bottom of L2 max.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
12
Question Answer Mark Guidance
3 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 3 as a source of
information about the world’s oceans.
The extract focuses on the world’s oceans.
Possible limitations include:
• List of size order – it isn’t clear if this is by volume or
area
• Lack of data on Indian and Atlantic Oceans
• Data given for Southern Pacific and Arctic Oceans
not comparable
• No overall information on location/ distribution
• No information about who produced this information
– possible bias
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for three limitations of the extract as a source of
information about the world’s oceans, identified through
critical questioning of the resource.
3 (b) Explain factors that influence the biodiversity in intertidal ecosystems.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
factors influencing biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems
(AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
factors influencing biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
factors influencing biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems
(AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
factors influencing biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of factors influencing
biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems could potentially
include:
• Tidal range – dynamic zone between low and
high tide
• Biodiversity has adapted to cope with such
extreme conditions (e.g., flooded/exposed)
• Alluvial as well as marine sediment feeds the
system, (i.e. dissolved and solid nutrients mixed
by tidal movements).
• Supports a very productive ecosystem
encouraging a complex and wide ranging
biodiversity, often zoned according to conditions
each with different and distinctive flora and
associated fauna.
• Formation of zones and evidence of succession.
• Linked examples and reference to salt marshesH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
13
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
factors influencing biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems
(AO1).
There may be simple ideas about factors influencing
biodiversity in inter-tidal ecosystems.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
14
Question Answer Mark Guidance
4 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 4 as a source of
information about the predicted impact of climate
change on world food prices since 2010.
The bar graph focuses on a range of food products prices
which are affected by climate change. Possible limitations
include:
• Background assumptions/calculations about impact
of climate change e.g. regional temperature +
precipitation patterns; sunshine levels not given
• No information on how ‘2030 baseline prediction
calculated for each food category e.g. is this the
mean global price?
• No reference to actual cost of foods related to local
purchasing power
• Lack of data relating to a variety of climate change
scenarios and/or margins of error in prediction
• Some categories very vague e.g. ‘other processed
meat’, ‘other crops’ while others are not clear e.g.
‘livestock’ which could be anything from poultry to
beef cattle
• Who produced the source - bias
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for three limitations of the graph as a source of
information identified through critical questioning of the
resource.
4 (b) Explain how globalisation creates the issue of food
miles.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
how globalisation creates the issue of food miles (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
how globalisation creates the issue of food miles.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of how globalisation
creates the issue of food miles could potentially include:
• Increasing proportion of food items are
transported over longer distances as a greater
awareness of different foods and diets are
created by globalisation.
• Implications for GHG emissions and the
environment (19 million tonnes of carbon dioxide
is released by transportation of UK food)H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
15
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
how globalisation creates the issue of food miles. (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about how
globalisation creates the issue of food miles.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of how
globalisation creates the issue of food miles. (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about how globalisation creates
the issue of food miles.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Food produced in heated glasshouses e.g.
tomatoes in UK glasshouses, may have higher
carbon footprint than the same food grown
further away in hotter climates e.g. Spain
• UK produces only c. 60% of its food
domestically.
• Transportation is only a small part of food miles,
often the production process produces 4 times
as much GHG emissions e.g. machinery;
fertilisers + pesticides + fungicides; irrigation –
pumping water; methane output from livestock.
Also food processing + storage uses energy +
produces GHGs.
• Source of energy used in production +
processing important e.g. electricity produced by
HEP / solar / wind c.f. energy used in transport
which is usually oil. NZ lamb has lower carbon
footprint than most UK lamb.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
16
Question Answer Mark Guidance
5 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 5 as a source of
information about mitigation against vulnerability to
hazards from earthquakes.
The sketch shows a range of earthquake proofing
techniques for a building.
Possible limitations include:
• Lack of information on engineering
techniques/materials used
• Cost of mitigation (engineering)
• Lack of data on effectiveness of earthquake proofing
techniques for buildings
• Lack of detail on the type of earthquake waves that
each building technique is mitigating against
• No information on type of rock on which the building
stands in relation to nature of engineering e.g. depth
of piling
• No other types of mitigation mentioned such as
preparation
• Lack of information about who has produced this -
bias
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for three limitations of the sketch as a source of
information about mitigation against vulnerability to
hazards from earthquakes identified through critical
questioning of the resource.
5 (b) Explain the features of shallow-focus earthquakes.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
the features of shallow-focus earthquakes (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
the features of shallow-focus earthquakes.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
the features of shallow-focus earthquakes (AO1).
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the features of
shallow-focus earthquakes could potentially include:
• Shallow-focus earthquakes extend from surface
to a depth of c.70km
Features:
• Release of energy → either or both crustal / fault
movements in brittle, cold rocks or magma
movement. Also mine collapse. Therefore
common – c. 75% of ‘quakes.
• Although generally low magnitude, can cause
relatively high levels of damage as energyH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
17
This will be shown by including developed ideas about the
features of shallow-focus earthquakes.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
features of shallow-focus earthquakes (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about the features of shallowfocus earthquakes.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
released over a smaller area c.f. deep focus
‘quakes
• Difference in time between primary + secondary
waves relatively short as focus and epicentre
close to each other.
NB Watch for mirror responses
‘…shallow focus are…. Whereas deep focus are …’
Max bottom of L2 for such an answer.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
6 Assess how responses to climate change are affected by
issues of either human rights or territorial integrity.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding of
responses to climate change and issues of either human rights
or territorial integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how responses to climate
change are affected by issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about how
responses to climate change are affected by issues of either
human rights or territorial integrity.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make appropriate
synoptic links between content from different parts of the course
of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
responses to climate change and issues of either human rights
or territorial integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how responses to climate change are
affected by issues of either human rights or territorial integrity
(AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
either responses to climate change or issues of either human
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of responses to climate
change and issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity could potentially include:
Responses to climate change could include:
• Work of the IPCC, international directives (e.g.
Kyoto protocol), EU climate directives all depend
on co-operation at all scales for success
• Carbon trading and carbon credits
• National and sub-national policies
• There are a range of methods at a range of
scales
Issues of human rights
• How human rights are promoted and protected
by global governance e.g. treaties, laws,
institutions, norms
• Contributions and interactions of global
governance of different organisations
(UN/national government/NGO) at a range of
scales
• How global governance of human rights has
consequences for citizens and places both
positive and negative
OR - Issues of territorial integrity
• How access to resources can cause territorial
conflict
• Role of institutions, treaties, laws and norms in
regulating conflict
• Interventions and interactions of organisations at
a range of scalesH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
19
rights or territorial integrity and developed ideas for the other
focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between the
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always appropriate.
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
responses to climate change and issues of either human rights
or territorial integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of how responses to climate change are affected by
issues of either human rights or territorial integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about either
responses to climate change or issues of either human rights or
territorial integrity and simple ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of responses
to climate change and issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of how responses to climate change are affected by
issues of either human rights or territorial integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about responses to
climate change or issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity.
• Consequences for local communities (both
positive and negative)
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how responses to climate change are affected by
issues of either human rights or territorial integrity could
potentially include:
• where human rights or territorial integrity are
stable, the international responses to climate
change are likely to be stable, experience
greater success and uniformity e.g. ACs and
some EDCs
• a wide range of examples could be used, at a
variety of different scales. Although question
specifies international responses, these could
be exemplified at a national or sub-national
scale (e.g. Scottish v. UK emission targets)
• International responses could have varying rates
of success e.g. less unified response, if any, to
climate change where human rights (China/India
exemption from Kyoto), or territorial integrity
under dispute (eg Azawad, Tuareg Mali, where
instability has led to UN involvement, but not
related to responses to climate change),
• Role of other organisations such as World bank
and Oxfam.
• A country’s right to development – some don’t
sign up to initiatives as they believe it is their
right to economic prosperity.
• Response to climate change can be about the
rights of citizens to be free from issues
associated with it
• Countries experiencing human rights abuses
can be more prone to suffering the
consequences of climate change.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
20
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Many are of the belief that ACs should pay
LIDCs to protect the environment and mitigate
against climate change.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
7 Assess how the global distribution of communicable
disease is affected by either global trade or global
migration.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of the global distribution of communicable disease and either
global trade or global migration (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the global distribution of
communicable disease and how it is affected by either global
trade or global migration (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about the
global distribution of communicable disease and either global
trade or global migration.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make appropriate
synoptic links between content from different parts of the
course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of the
global distribution of communicable disease and either global
trade or global migration (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the global distribution of communicable
disease and how it is affected by either global trade or global
migration (AO2).
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the global distribution
of communicable disease and either global trade or
global migration could potentially include:
Global distribution of communicable diseases
• Communicable disease (an infectious disease
which spreads from host to host) e.g. malaria,
HIV, tuberculosis,
• Current distributions are influenced by:
o physical factors, (e.g. patterns of
temperature, precipitation, relief and
water sources)
o economic factors, (e.g. wealth/poverty,
health care)
o social factors, (e.g. population density,
housing quality, health, education)
o political factors (e.g. government
priorities such as investment in
sanitation/food supplies
Global trade
• Spatial patterns of international trade in
merchandise, services + capital
• Global = inter-regional e.g. Europe ↔ Asia
• Dominated by ACs + faster growing EDCs
(China, Indonesia). LIDCs have limited access.
• Can promote stability or create inequalities
through flows of people, money, ideas and
technology
OR - Global migration
• Spatial patterns of international migrationH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
22
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
either global distribution of communicable disease or global
trade or global migration and developed ideas for the other
focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between the
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always appropriate.
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of the
global distribution of communicable disease and either global
trade or global migration (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the global distribution of communicable disease
and how it is affected by either global trade or global migration
(AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about either
global distribution of communicable disease or global trade or
global migration and simple ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
global distribution of communicable disease and either global
trade or global migration (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the global distribution of communicable disease
and either global trade or global migration (AO2).
• Can promote stability or create inequalities
through flows of people, money, ideas and
technology
• Globalisation leading to emergence of new
source areas and host destinations both of
economic migrants + refugees + asylum seekers
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how the global distribution of communicable disease is
affected by either global trade or global migration could
potentially include:
Increasing incidence of communicable disease;
• Diseases able to spread over wider area
through global trade or migration links
• Movement of people can lead to different strains
of disease spreading e.g. cholera → Haiti due to
relief personnel following 2010 earthquake
• Importance of scale e.g. from diffusion of
disease within an LIDC to global pandemic due
to infected migrants e.g. Covid 19; MERS-CoV;
SARS-CoV
Decreasing incidence of communicable disease;
• Global trade → ↑ wealth which can be spent on
raising HDI → ↓ in incidence of disease e.g. ACs
• Migrant remittances raise living standards of
families in receipt → ↓ in susceptibility to
disease
• Technology can limit spread of disease despite
global trade and migratory routes e.g. vaccines
• Border controls can limit spread of potential
disease e.g. prevent contaminated goods
entering; health checks of arrivalsH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
23
This will be shown by including simple ideas about the global
distribution of communicable disease and either global trade or
global migration.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
• Physical factors still limit spread of disease
despite global trade and migratory routes e.g.
oceans + mountain barriersH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
8 Assess how pollution in oceans is influenced by players
driving economic change.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of pollution in oceans and players driving economic change.
(AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how pollution in oceans is
influenced by players driving economic change. (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
pollution in oceans and players driving economic change.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make appropriate
synoptic links between content from different parts of the
course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
pollution in oceans and players driving economic change
(AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how pollution in oceans is influenced by
players driving economic change (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
either pollution in oceans or players driving economic change
and developed ideas for the other focus.
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of pollution in oceans is
influenced by players driving economic change could
potentially include:
Pollution in oceans
• variety of pollutants that affect the ocean
• Off-shore oil spill causing pollution
• Causes of the accumulation of plastic in one
ocean gyre
players driving economic change
• role of players in driving economic change
(expect range of players; MNC)
• Environmental impacts on people and place
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
examine how pollution in oceans can be influenced by
players driving economic change could potentially
include:
• The Deepwater Horizon disaster driven by BP,
an MNC driving economic change through the
production of oil. An estimated 4.9 million
barrels of oil was released and was claimed the
largest oil spill in history. Economic change was
halted during the recovery period as the fishing
industry stopped, tourism ceased causing a
downward spiral into local communities
• Some plastic is accidental discard from fishing
boats which are serving global trade routes e.g.
1992 accidental discard of plastic bath toys;
however without the MNCs driving economic
change in EDCs or LIDCs this wouldn’t occurH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
25
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between the
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always appropriate.
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
pollution in oceans and players driving economic change
(AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of pollution in oceans is influenced by players driving
economic change (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about either
pollution in oceans or players driving economic change and
simple ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding pollution in
oceans and players driving economic change (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of how pollution in oceans is influenced by players
driving economic change (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about pollution in
oceans and players driving economic change.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
• The demand for greater catches of fish in
society has driven change in the technology for
fishing nets and they no longer biodegrade. Now
made of stronger plastic, they breakdown
through photodegradation creating significant
pollution through nurdles.
• National government e.g. Japan driving changes
in nuclear power leading to leakage of
radioactive material impacting the marine food
chain
• Accept disagreements evidenced by examples
of players minimising oceanic pollutionH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
9 Assess how attempts to increase food production can
affect water cycles.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of food production and water cycles (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how attempts to increase food
production can affect water cycles (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
food production and water cycles
There are clear and explicit attempts to make appropriate
synoptic links between content from different parts of the
course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of food
production and water cycles (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how attempts to increase food production
can affect water cycles (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about
either food production or water cycles and developed ideas for
the other focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between the
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always appropriate.
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of food production and
water cycles could potentially include:
Attempts to increase food production
• Irrigation and salinization
• Deforestation and the impacts on biodiversity
• Changing landscapes for food production – e.g.
terracing
• Water quality from agrochemicals
• Use of machinery in food production
• GM and hydroponics.
Water cycles
• Distribution and size of stores
• Characteristics of main inputs and outputs
• Processes within the water cycle
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how attempts to increase food production can affect
water cycles could potentially include:
• Impacts at different scales.
• Over irrigation soaks upper layers increasing
evaporation and reducing infiltration, capillary
action and ground water storage.
• Deforestation and reduction of hedgerows
reduces precipitation as transpiration and
interception decrease, runoff increases while
infiltration, percolation, throughflow and
groundwater flow reduce
• Use of machinery and compaction of the land
reducing infiltration.
• Certain types of farming demand more water.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
27
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
food production and water and carbon cycles (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of attempts to increase food production can affect
water cycles (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about either
food production or water cycles and simple ideas for the other
focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of food
production and water cycles (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of attempts to increase food production can affect
water cycles (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about food
production and water cycles
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
• Increase of built environment with polytunnels,
glass houses, livestock sheds and silos (a)
vegetation is removed and impacts on water
cycle; (b) increase of impermeable surfaces –
decreased infiltration/through flow/soil water and
groundwater storage - increased runoff/overland flow/channel flow (increased
flooding)
• Water volumes and quality changing
E.g. Small scale/local: food production increases
– farming changes that impact on land surfaces;
other factors affecting water – include
agrochemicals/slurry
• Large scale/national or international:
Dams/reservoirs impact large areas including
drowned tributary valleys, downstream water
supply to rivers reducedH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
10 Assess how impacts of volcanic eruptions can affect place
identity.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of the impacts of volcanic eruptions and place identity (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how impacts of volcanic
eruptions can affect place identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas about the
impacts of volcanic eruptions and place identity.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make appropriate
synoptic links between content from different parts of the
course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of the
impacts of volcanic eruptions and place identity (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how impacts of volcanic eruptions can affect
place identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about the
impacts of volcanic eruptions and place identity.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always appropriate.
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the impacts of
volcanic eruptions and place identity could potentially
include:
Impacts of volcanic eruptions:
• Impacts can include lava + pyroclastic flows,
tephra (fine ash → volcanic bombs) lahars, toxic
gases, floods, tsunami
• Damage + disruption to built environment
including infrastructure
• Damage + disruption to natural environment
• Death + injury to humans
Characteristics making up place identity include:
• Physical geography
• Demographic
• Socio-economic
• Cultural
• Political
• Built environment
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how the impacts of volcanic eruptions can affect place
identity could potentially include:
• Impacts on place identity may depend on the
nature and scale of the eruption such as
explosive, effusive
• Impacts can be short, medium or long term
• Impacts on place identity may be negative e.g.
disruption or destruction of place e.g. Montserrat
/ Armero / ChaitenH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
29
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of the
impacts of volcanic eruptions and place identity (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of how impacts of volcanic eruptions can affect place
identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including sound ideas about the impacts
of volcanic eruptions and place identity.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study, but these are
not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
impacts of volcanic eruptions and place identity (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of how impacts of volcanic eruptions can affect place
identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about the impacts
of volcanic eruptions and place identity.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links between
content from different parts of the course of study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
• Impacts on place identity may be positive e.g.
development of agriculture on fertile soil, mineral
extraction or the tourism e.g. Indonesia, Japan
• The impact on place identity may depend on the
frequency of eruptions and time available for
recovery e.g. Indonesia
• The ability of authorities to mitigate against risk,
perhaps enabling communities to live with risk
may be a factor in influencing place identity e.g.
Hawaii
• Place identity may be influenced by how a place
is branded or rebranded following eruption e.g.
Iceland
• Place identity may evolve over time and be
influenced by a combination of past and present
day characteristics in response to eruption,
including multiple volcanic eruptions e.g. EtnaH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
11* ‘Changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions
since the pre-industrial era reflect economic development
at a national scale.’ Discuss
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since
the pre-industrial era and economic development at a national
scale.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since the
pre-industrial era and economic development at a national
scale.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since the
pre-industrial era and economic development since 1850 at a
national scale.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of changes
in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since the preindustrial era and economic development at a national scale.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions
since the pre-industrial era and economic
development at a national scale could potentially
include:
• Definition/examples of ‘anthropogenic’ gas
emissions
• the balance of anthropogenic emissions
around the world and how this has changed in
recent history
• how anthropogenic emissions influence the
global mean energy budget
• example(s) of economic development at
national scale
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which changes in
anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since the
pre-industrial era reflect economic development at a
national scale could potentially include:
• Evaluation of different greenhouse gases and
their variations in contributions and their
contributions to global warming e.g. carbon
dioxide increased significantly since 1960,
related to changes in ACs in particular,
although mix changing. Note China and India
despite large contribution to global emissions
have relatively low emissions per capita
• Depending on case studies used comments
relating to population growth, land-use
changes and energy demand and mix as wellH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
31
analysis that is fully accurate of how changes in anthropogenic
greenhouse gas emissions since the pre-industrial era reflect
economic development at a national scale.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since the
pre-industrial era reflect economic development at a national
scale.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how changes in anthropogenic greenhouse
gas emissions since the pre-industrial era reflect economic
development at a national scale.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which changes in anthropogenic
greenhouse gas emissions since the pre-industrial era reflect
economic development at a national scale.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of how changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas
emissions since the pre-industrial era reflect economic
development at a national scale.
as other principal activities responsible for
greenhouse gas emissions
• Contribution of factors responsible for changes
in emissions over time and space other than
economic development e.g. response to
international protocols, new technologies,
political pressure etc
• Prediction of future trends also applicable and
may indicate higher level answer
• Reasons GHGs cab increase as a result of
industrialisation (demand for energy,
technological advances, transport and
manufacturing, population growth, land use
change).
• Reference to current situation and countries
currently reducing GHG emissions
• Higher level answer likely to include
discussion about international protocol and
political pressureH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
32
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which changes in anthropogenic
greenhouse gas emissions since the pre-industrial era reflect
economic development at a national scale.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of how changes in anthropogenic greenhouse gas
emissions since the pre-industrial era reflect economic
development at a national scale.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which changes in
anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions since the preindustrial era reflect economic development at a national scale.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
33
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
12* Assess the success of adaptation strategies to reduce the
vulnerability of human populations at risk from climate
change.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of human
populations at risk from climate change.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of human
populations at risk from climate change.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of human
populations at risk from climate change.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of human
populations at risk from climate change.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of adaptation strategies to reduce
the vulnerability of human populations at risk from climate
change
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
adaptation strategies reducing the vulnerability of
human populations at risk from climate change could
potentially include:
• Definition/examples of adaption
• Framework of adaption and its implementation
in a range of communities e.g. retreat,
accommodation and protection strategies
• What future homes, offices, cities, transport
and economies will look like following
adaptation throughout the 21st century
• Vulnerability – why people continue to live in
areas prone to risk/ability to cope with risk.
Two contrasting case studies to illustrate
adaptation strategies and associated
technological, socio-economic and political
challenges associated with them
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the success of adaptation
strategies to reduce the vulnerability of human
populations at risk from climate change could
potentially include:
• Success may be judged in a number of
different ways e.g. sustainability, cost benefit
analysis, appropriate technology etc.
• A wide range of case studies can be used to
exemplify
• Economic development can affect success of
strategies e.g. managed retreat in UK,
including land use zoning through shoreline
management plans, has worked; however, inH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
35
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based of the success of
adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of human
populations at risk from climate change.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of adaptation strategies to reduce the
vulnerability of human populations at risk from climate change.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions of the success of adaptation strategies to reduce
the vulnerability of human populations at risk from climate
change.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of
human populations at risk from climate change.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence of the success of adaptation strategies to reduce the
vulnerability of human populations at risk from climate change.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Bangladesh 140 million live on the GangesBrahmaputra delta unable to afford to move
• Reducing deforestation in EDCs and LIDCs is
a more sustainable soft option for reducing
vulnerability to climate change (minimise
floods, reduce soil erosion e.g. UN’s REDD
scheme educating and paying local tribes to
protect the rainforest); significantly cheaper
than hard engineering structures such as steel
and concrete structures on slopes or storm
surge barriers in the Netherlands. Many
challenges in the physical management of
large areas as well as training/education
needs for local communities to make the
schemes successful
• Some technological adaptations use simple
technology and are environmentally friendly.
Training/education needed. Examples
rainwater harvesting, use of grey water,
sunshades for windows, white walls and
ceilings, green roofs etc
• In Bangladesh protection of coastal
mangroves forests, a priority. However, local
communities motivated by economic gain,
clearing the forest for agriculture and lucrative
fish farming, limiting success of coastal
protection measures
• In Australia there is much more hard
engineering protecting economic centres as
well as land use planning to prevent building in
flood prone areas, relocation of high value
residential and business areas as well as dam
projects to mitigate increasing drought.
• The success of adaptation projects will be
debated and the impacts on vulnerable
populations explored to allow credit for
evaluationH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
36
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of adaptation strategies to reduce the vulnerability of
human populations at risk from climate change.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions of the success of adaptation strategies to
reduce the vulnerability of human populations at risk from
climate change.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
• Evaluation of other methods of mitigating
against climate changeH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
37
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
38
Question Answer Mark Guidance
13* Evaluate the extent to which mitigation strategies can
successfully reduce the outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of mitigation strategies, outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
mitigation strategies, outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
mitigation strategies, outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
mitigation strategies, outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the success of mitigation
strategies to reduce the outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
mitigation strategies, outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease could potentially include:
• Non-communicable = not spread from person
to person. Non-infectious + non-contagious
e.g.CVDs, diabetes, asthma
• Mitigation strategies provide a framework to
reduce the severity of a disease
• Direct strategies (aimed specifically at a
particular disease e.g. screeening) + indirect
(more generic strategies aimed at overall
health improvements including noncommunicable diseases e.g. tax)
• Mitigation strategies will be informed by
o Social, economic and cultural causes
o Outbreak rates
o Socio-economic impacts
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which mitigation
strategies can successfully reduce the outbreak and
impacts of non-communicable disease, could
potentially include:
• Incidence of disease e.g. regional differences
within the UK of cancer. For example, south
west has the highest incidence for breast
cancer, whereas 15% more of those living the
north east will suffer from cancer than those in
London, the north/south divide in cancer
incidence is seen more in women than men.
Thus, mitigation needs to concentrate on
regions more exposed to riskH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
39
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based of the extent to which
mitigation strategies successfully reduce the outbreak and
impacts of non-communicable disease.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the success of mitigation strategies to
reduce the outbreak and impacts of non-communicable
disease.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions of the extent to which mitigation strategies
successfully reduce the outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the success of mitigation strategies to reduce the
outbreak and impacts of non-communicable disease.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence of the extent to which mitigation strategies
• Success at reducing outbreak by tackling
cultural causes is a longer process with limited
success e.g. education of dangers of smoking
cigarettes in reducing incidence of lung cancer
in the UK. Varied approach with advertising
limited, stark warnings required by law on
each packet and products hidden in retail
areas, however varying rates of success with
incidence rates significantly reducing in males,
but increasing in females. Popularity of
smoking has fallen, but still nearly 20% of
diagnosed cancer cases are smoking related
• UK governments’ attempts to
o reduce social causative factors e.g.
sedentary/unhealthy lifestyles
o improve healthier diets
have been widespread with campaigns e.g.
Change4Life, sugar swap, especially focused
on the next generation however these
schemes seem to be unsuccessful as child
obesity is continuing to rise, in 2018 overtaking
America’s statistics for the first time
• Cancer is costing the UK £15 billion a year
due to early death, sick or compassionate
leave and the cost of care and treatment. Very
few strategies have been successful with the
exception of early diagnosis and intervention
which has led to prolonging of life; however
treatment costs have increased.
• Cancer rates linked to socio-economic divides
e.g. areas with higher deprivation suffer higher
cancer incidence e.g. north east and south
west England compared to London. Research
suggests links with education, and early
diagnosis requiring specific mitigation
strategies in these areas. Research also
suggests in areas of higher deprivation higherH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
40
successfully reduce the outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the success of mitigation strategies to reduce the
outbreak and impacts of non-communicable disease.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions of the extent to which mitigation strategies
successfully reduce the outbreak and impacts of noncommunicable disease.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
incidence of smoking and alcohol consumption
contributing to higher incidence of cancer.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
41
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
14* ‘Disease eradication depends on the sustainable use of
medicines from nature.’ To what extent do you agree?
AO1
Level 4 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of the sustainable use of medicines from nature to eradicate
disease.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of the
sustainable use of medicines from nature to eradicate disease.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of the
sustainable use of medicines from nature to eradicate disease.
Level 1 (1-2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
sustainable use of medicines from nature to eradicate disease.
0 marks No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19-24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the sustainable use of
medicines from nature to eradicate disease.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the sustainable use
of medicines from nature to eradicate disease.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
different medicines from nature, the diseases they are
used to eradicate and the sustainability of their use
could potentially include:
• Examples of specific plants, such as rosy
periwinkle, include opium poppy, species of
willow and yew, cinchonas evergreen tree,
autumn crocus, magnolia, African cherry
• Habitats and ecosystems, including conditions
for growth especially soil type and climate
• Their medical usage/importance in treating
specific diseases
• Demand for medicinal plants especially in the
developing world is very great and the
locations of their particular habitats means
they are often delivered to market by
international trade
• Understanding of the sustainability of
medicinal plants as resources environmentally;
this includes the survival of endangered
species, the survival of natural ecosystems,
and the erosion of genetic diversity
• Understanding of how their use and
exploitation by some pharmaceutical TNCs,
known as biopiracy, can influence
sustainability economically; in some supply
areas, such as LIDCs and indigenous
communities, economic growth, and
addressing issues of poverty and inequality
are hindered
• Understanding of the complex nature of
disease eradication e.g. only smallpox
successfully eradicated and without medicines
from natureH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
43
Level 3 (13-18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the sustainable use of medicines from
nature to eradicate disease.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the sustainable use of medicines from nature
to eradicate disease.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7-12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the sustainable use of medicines from nature to
eradicate disease.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the sustainable use of medicines from nature to
eradicate disease.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1-6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the sustainable use of medicines from nature to
eradicate disease.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
secure judgements leading to rational conclusions that offers
simple conclusions as to the sustainable use of medicines from
nature to eradicate disease.
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which disease
eradication depends on the sustainable use of
medicines from nature could potentially include:
• The impact of overharvesting of wild plants on
the survival of wild species – a large number
of medicinal plants are sourced from wild
populations
• Loss of specific habitats/natural ecosystems in
which wild plants used for medicines grow as
a result of deforestation of tropical rainforest
for example
• Other conservation issues such as the impact
of exploitation on soils, potential flood hazards,
biodiversity
• Threats to socio-economic sustainability of
indigenous populations in some LIDCs as a
result of biopiracy
• Growing demand for medicines from medicinal
plants especially from the large and rapidly
growing populations of the developing world
(only a few medical species are cultivated)
threatens supply
• On the other hand, some medical species in
use are cultivated (rather than wild) by TNCs
which have increasingly responsible/ethical
policies towards the environment and
indigenous populations in the developing world
– plants such as foxglove (dropsy/heart failure)
and rosy periwinkle (various cancers)
• A number of organisations such as the
National Cancer Institute in the USA and the
Swedish International Development Authority
provide funds for economic development and
forest protection (Samoa) ensuring aH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
44
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.
sustainable supply of medicinal plants and
forest conservation treaties such as the
Convention on International Trade of
Endangered Species of Wild Flora and Fauna
also address conservation issues
• Currently few diseases are near eradication;
polio, measles, guinea worm, yaws and none
requiring use of medicines from nature.
Eradication hopeful through widespread
vaccination. For polio this requires peace and
stability in order for health programmes to be
completed – only Nigeria, Afghanistan and
Pakistan currently hosting polio
• Attempts to eradicate disease may depend on
strategies at global and national scales e.g.
lifestyle campaigns, top-down or bottom-up
programmesH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
15* To what extent are oceans hazardous obstacles to human
activities?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of oceans as hazardous obstacles to human activities.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
oceans as hazardous obstacles to human activities.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
oceans as hazardous obstacles to human activities.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of oceans
as hazardous obstacles to human activities.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of oceans as hazardous obstacles
to human activities.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based of the extent to which
oceans are hazardous obstacles to human activities.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
oceans as hazardous obstacles to human activities in
a variety of contexts could potentially include:
• Oceans present hazardous obstacles to
human activities – a physically dangerous
environment.
• Distribution of 21st century piracy and its
management
• The use of oceans as escape routes for
migrants
• Wide ranging use of oceans globally
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which oceans are
hazardous obstacles to human activities, could
potentially include:
• Wide range of examples used. Expect analysis
over time (within last 20 years) and space
• Hazards/obstacles caused by and alleviated
by human activity:
o Some areas of the oceans will be
hazardous during periods of conflict
e.g. South China Sea armed clashes
between 2012-2015
o Piracy a historic and current threat but
spatially limited e.g. along trading
routes, most recently western Indian
Ocean and Malacca and Singapore
Straits – spatial limitation reduces
extent to which oceans are hazardous,
however these routes are particularly
hazardous, although this can change
e.g. seasonally - lower incidenceH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
46
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of oceans as hazardous obstacles to human
activities
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions of the extent to which oceans are hazardous
obstacles to human activities.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of oceans as hazardous obstacles to human activities
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence of the extent to which oceans are hazardous
obstacles to human activities.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of oceans as hazardous obstacles to human activities
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions of the extent to which oceans are
hazardous obstacles to human activities.
during monsoons; e.g. human activity,
international action - maritime coalition
between EU, NATO, USA, Russia,
China, India, Japan and South Korea
to patrol and monitor most dangerous
areas, piracy incidence rates reduce
dramatically
o For refugees and migrants crossing
oceans, the oceans can be the
gateway to safety from countries with
very poor human rights records.
o Exploitation of vulnerable people
[human traffickers] at significant ocean
crossing points e.g. from north Africa to
Europe across the Mediterranean,
southwards from Bangladesh and
Myanmar to Thailand, Indonesia and
Malaysia or from Vietnam and Sri
Lanka to Australia. An international
issue: Short term relief eg
coastguard/naval rescue missions,
provision of refugee camps. Long term
- attempts to improve quality of life and
freedom in source nations and
catching and punishing traffickers.
o Issues or dangers with mineral
extraction (gas, oil, and renewable
such as wave or tidal
o Is there a future in mining – ferrous and
non- ferrous deposit and associated
issues.
o Hazardous obstacles – physical
conditions: Perils of sea crossings
(distance, storms, waves, exposure);
poor physical condition of boats; high
risk of capsize and drowning
• There are many situations where oceans are
not hazardous obstacles to human activities:H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
47
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.
o Relatively secure routes for trade,
cruises, sports etc
o Biological resources including fish
o Source of renewable energy – wind,
tidal and wave powerH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
16* Examine the extent to which the use of ocean energy and
mineral resources is sustainable.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of use of ocean energy, mineral resources and
sustainability.Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of use
of ocean energy, mineral resources and sustainability.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
use of ocean energy, mineral resources and sustainability.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of use of
ocean energy, mineral resources and sustainability.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of use of ocean energy and
mineral resources and sustainability.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
the use of ocean energy and mineral resources is sustainable.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of use
of ocean energy, mineral resources and sustainability
could potentially include:
• Use and management of oil and gas
• Use and management of wave and tidal
energy
• Use of sea-bed minerals
• Sustainable use – renewable and nonrenewable resources
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which the use of
ocean energy and mineral resources is sustainable,
could potentially include:
• Both energy and mineral use needs to be
addressed. A candidate that presents an
answer worthy of Level 4 in AO2 but only
discusses either ocean energy or mineral
resources should be penalised within AO1
rather than AO2
• Expect range of examples to evidence
arguments
• Discussion of relevant social, economic and
environmental sustainability
• Use of tidal energy reduces dependence on
fossil fuels and can also improve water quality
e.g. South Korea Shiwa Lake scheme
However, schemes are expensive and
dependent on physical landscape to create a
suitable location
• Oil and gas exploitation create significant
economic growth however, the extraction ofH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
49
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of use of ocean energy and mineral resources
and sustainability
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which the use of ocean energy
and mineral resources is sustainable.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of use of ocean energy and mineral resources and
sustainability
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which the use of ocean energy and
mineral resources is sustainable.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of use of ocean energy and mineral resources and
sustainability
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
both resources and their use in production and
for energy are not environmentally sustainable
• Sustainable use of wave energy is limited as
technology unable to harness energy
effectively – although Finnish waveroller works
in shallow water, but technology expensive
and limited in areas where it can be used
• Seafloor mining environmentally unsustainable
especially as many areas unknown so impact
is unmeasurable. However oceanic minerals
exist in higher concentrations so less required,
which minimises mining and disturbance
making it more sustainable, however disposal
of tailings can harm sea-bed ecosystems
• Accidental damage – e.g. Deep Water Horizon
example or deep water mining, where you
can’t see the consequencesH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
50
simple conclusions as to the extent to which the use of ocean
energy and mineral resources is sustainable.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
17* Examine the extent to which food is a geopolitical
commodity.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of food as a geopolitical commodity.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of food
as a geopolitical commodity.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
food as a geopolitical commodity.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of food as a
geopolitical commodity.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of food as a geopolitical
commodity.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
food is a geopolitical commodity.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of food
as a geopolitical commodity could potentially include:
• How food can be considered a geopolitical
commodity – candidates may define this
• Creating opportunities between countries to
ensure food security e.g. agricultural trading
policies, WTO and appropriate aid
• Role and responsibility of key players such as
international/trans-national commercial
organisations including agribusiness, TNCs,
food retailers and fair trade organisations in
influencing the global food system
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which food is a
geopolitical commodity could potentially include:
• Wide range of examples given, at a range of
spatial and temporal scales (accept last 20
years)
• Role of food supply shocks, civil unrest, food
riots or other events can be used to justify food
as a geopolitical commodity
• Trade contributing to global peace and
security as food trade has increased five-fold
in last 50 years. Spatial geography of the trade
is unbalanced and dominated by Europe, USA
and Asia. Flows ever changing as diets
change and populations increase in affluence
demanding more imports and a more varied
diet
• Trading blocs allow promotion of free trade as
well as tariffs on imports – these deals can
significantly affect farmers in LIDCs and suchH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
52
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of food as a geopolitical commodity.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which food is a geopolitical
commodity.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of food as a geopolitical commodity.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which food is a geopolitical
commodity.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of food as a geopolitical commodity.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which food is a
geopolitical commodity.
deals can be used to exert control over other
nations
• WTO is to help promote geopolitical stability
however some criticise it for not doing enough,
thus limiting geopolitical relationships globally
• Food aid can be used to dump surpluses from
ACs as well as create a cycle of food aid
dependency in LIDCs which reduces incomes
for farmers, however it can be lifesaving
especially in disaster relief situations.
Emergency aid is less likely to have
geopolitical ramifications when compared with
longer term food aid
• Increase in fair trade organisations around the
world.
• Profit making organisations and food as a
geopolitical commodity
o Large scale agribusinesses can improve
international relations as trade improves,
however with demands for sustainable
environmental practices these may cause
challenges as the environment is often
sacrificed for profit.
o TNCs can improve geo-political relations;
however are footloose and move freely
when conditions in the host nation change
leading to increased stress on geopolitical
relations. TNCs increase geopolitical
nature of food as crosses international
boundaries and often take over business
from local retailers who would function at
a significantly smaller scale
• Conclusion will vary according to arguments
made by candidates. However, expect
comments about variation in food as a
geopolitical resource spatially, across time orH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
53
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.
economic development or to be judged in
terms of sustainability.
• Though trade, WTO and profit making
organisations food has increasingly become a
geopolitical resource and is increasingly linked
with economic and political stabilityH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
18* To what extent are the views of Malthus and Boserup
relevant to food security in the 21st century?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of the views of Malthus and Boserup and food security in the
21st century.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of the
views of Malthus and Boserup and food security in the 21st
century.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of the
views of Malthus and Boserup and food security in the 21st
century.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the views
of Malthus and Boserup and food security in the 21st century.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the relevance of the views of
Malthus and Boserup to food security in the 21st century.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of the
views of Malthus and Boserup and food security in the
21st century could potentially include:
• Definition of food security
• Theoretical positions on food security, Malthus
and Boserup
• 21st century food security including changes in
food production technology e.g. developments
in irrigation, Asian Green Revolution,
biotechnology, GM crops, deep displacement
fertiliser programmes etc
• Knowledge of factors affecting food security
o Physical – soil, temperature and
growing season, water, altitude,
aspect, slope, desertification
o Human – land ownership, capital
competition, land grabbing, technology,
globalisation.
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which the views of
Malthus and Boserup are relevant to food security in
the 21st century, could potentially include:
• A wide range of case studies could be used to
illustrate candidate’s opinion. Expect variations
in levels of economic development
• Beneficial changes to 21st century food
production (leading to food security) can be
interpreted socially, economically,
environmentally, politically or sustainably.
• Arguments may be presented that Malthusian
theories are most relevant in specific areas of
the world where technological advance isH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
55
the views of Malthus and Boserup are relevant to food security
in the 21st century.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the relevance of the views of Malthus and
Boserup to food security in the 21st century.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which the views of Malthus and
Boserup are relevant to food security in the 21st century.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the relevance of the views of Malthus and Boserup
to food security in the 21st century.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which the views of Malthus and
Boserup are relevant to food security in the 21st century.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
limited due to low levels of economic
development, where society is largely
dependent on traditional agriculture, and is
experiencing significant population growth e.g.
parts of Sub-Saharan Africa
• Malthusian theory has not been confirmed as
increases in food production have been at a
geometric, even logarithmic rate at times, far
beyond what Malthus predicted
• Boserupian theory could be argued to be
partially confirmed as ‘necessity is the mother
of invention’ and perceived need for food
security has driven changes. But advances in
technology often occur in ACs whereas the
demand for food is more often in LIDCs e.g.
drip irrigation is unaffordable by many LIDC
famers, but widely used in ACs.
• Advances in food production and food
technology to improve food security in LIDCs
can be simple, appropriate technologies e.g.
‘magic stones’ in Burkina Faso, which do not
match the perception of advanced invention
suggested by Boserup
• Food security in the 21st century food may
have a wider cost to society eg negative
impacts on the environment, impacts on wider
human societies e.g. use of DDT affecting
water supplies and ecosystems as well as
human health which potentially partially
support Malthusian theoriesH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
56
accuracy of the relevance of the views of Malthus and Boserup
to food security in the 21st century.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which the views of
Malthus and Boserup are relevant to food security in the 21st
century.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
19* ‘The impacts of earthquake activity vary with levels of
economic development.’ How far do you agree with this
statement?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of economic development and impacts of earthquakes.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
economic development and impacts of earthquakes.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
economic development and impacts of earthquakes.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
economic development and impacts of earthquakes.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the impacts of earthquake
activity and level of economic development.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to whether the impacts
of earthquake activity vary with level of economic development.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
economic development and the impacts of
earthquakes could potentially include:
Impacts of earthquakes include social, economic +
political + environmental most of which are interlinked:
• Economic – damage + destruction to built
environment including infrastructure e.g.
transport, utilities; disruption to economic
activities → loss of employment
• Social – death + injury; families separated;
loss of employment; disruption to education +
health care
• Political - ↑ demands placed on government
for relief, rehabilitation + reconstruction;
changes in political priorities; undermines
effective government at different scales e.g.
national / regional / local
• Environmental – damage + destruction e.g.
landslides + avalanches; rivers dammed and
then flood; pollution e.g. from damaged
sewage, radio-active leaks
• Earthquakes vary greatly in their magnitude
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate whether the impacts of
earthquake activity vary with level of economic
development could potentially include:
• Distinguishing between long – short term
impacts may indicate Level 3+
• Economic impacts – ACs have resources to
put into relief, rehabilitation + reconstruction;H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
58
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the impacts of earthquake activity and level
of economic development.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to whether the impacts of earthquake activity
vary with level of economic development.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the impacts of earthquake activity and level of
economic development.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to whether the impacts of earthquake activity vary
with level of economic development.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the impacts of earthquake activity and level of
economic development.
EDCs and LIDCs less so. However mitigation
can be successful across economic continuum
e.g. vernacular architecture in ‘quake prone
regions – Iran, Turkey, Nepal.
However, economic ‘hit’ can still be significant
e.g. Tōhoku ‘quake estimated cost = $US 210
million to Japan + costs for other ACs e.g.
California + Oregon coasts.
EDCs + LIDCs appear to be less impacted but
this is in absolute terms – considered
proportionally the costs can be very significant
e.g. Gorkha ‘quake, Nepal 2015 disrupted
planting season → threatened food security.
• Social impacts – death = the same awful
impact no matter what level of econ.
development. Injury can be more significant in
EDCs + LIDCs as health care and capacity to
cope more challenging e.g. loss of a limb.
Separation of families and displacement of
families – generally more significant in EDCs +
LIDCs as fewer resources to manage this
issue.
Most ‘quake prone countries irrespective of
level of econ development have improved their
preparation.
In general, no matter the level of econ
development of the country, the poorer and
more marginalised people tend to suffer most
from impacts.
• Political – most ACs have generally robust and
secure governmental organisations that cope.
However, extreme magnitude events can pose
significant challenges for all levels of econ
development. An already insecure political
situation can be exacerbated by an
earthquake e.g. Nepal 2015.
Tōhoku ‘quake had political ramificationsH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
59
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to whether the impacts of earthquake
activity vary with level of economic development.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.
regarding nuclear power – energised lobby
against nuclear, mostly in ACs.
• Environmental – possibly depends on
magnitude more than econ development.
• Other factors influence impact such as urban v
rural, coastal or inland, nature of relief, time of
event, seasonH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
Question Answer Mark Guidance
20* ‘Over time the ability to manage hazards from volcanic
activity increases.’ Examine the extent to which this
statement is true.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of risk and ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity over
time.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of risk
and ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity over time.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
risk and ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity over
time.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of risk and
ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity over time.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how time affects risk and ability
to manage hazards from volcanic activity.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to whether risk
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of risk
and ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity
over time could potentially include:
• How and why risks from volcanic hazards
change over time
• Changes in frequency and impacts of volcanic
hazards over time
• Degree of risk posed by a hazard and the
probability of the hazard event occurring
• Possible current and future strategies to cope
with risks from volcanic hazards (may include
illustration from the Park model)
• Hazard risk equation
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which risk
decreases and ability to manage hazards from
volcanic activity increases over time could potentially
include:
• Expect a range of examples [volcanoes and
different levels of economic development].
• Over last 150 years risk has increased in
many tectonic hazards as frequency has
increased. However, consideration needs to
be taken of;
o Population size as well as density and
therefore proximity to risk
o Monitoring and recording of events
which will affect reliability of data
o Human activity e.g. deforestation and
landslides
• Increased levels of development, technology
and education so ability to cope increases,H481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
61
decreases and ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity
increases over time.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of factors which affect how time affects risk
and ability to manage hazards from volcanic activity.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to whether risk decreases and ability to manage
hazards from volcanic activity increases over time.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of factors which affect how time affects risk and ability
to manage hazards from volcanic activity.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to whether risk decreases and ability to manage
hazards from volcanic activity increases over time.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
although this maybe limited as magnitude and
predictability can override these factors e.g. Mt
St Helen’s erupting with a lateral blast was not
predictable and could have caused significant
damage, however evacuation orders
minimised the human impact. Human decision
in cost benefit analysis and risk assessment is
a significant factor.
• Ability to cope can grow with time learning
from experience of strategies applied to
previous volcanic events to minimise impacts
in the future e.g. land use zoning, some
maybe developed during relief and
rehabilitation period e.g. lava diversion
channels in Italy
• Historical examples such as Krakatoa would
be used to exemplify change over time
• There is no way to predict exact date and time
of any eruption and this cannot be altered by
level of development
• Type of eruption can make the event harder to
manage – e.g. Icelandic eruption – no control
of ash cloudH481/03 Mark Scheme November 2020
62
accuracy of factors which affect how time affects risk and ability
to manage hazards from volcanic activity.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to whether risk decreases and ability to
manage hazards from volcanic activity increases over time.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]