Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Geography
H481/03: Geographical debates
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awardin
...
Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
GCE
Geography
H481/03: Geographical debates
Advanced GCE
Mark Scheme for Autumn 2021Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations
OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA) is a leading UK awarding body, providing a wide range of
qualifications to meet the needs of candidates of all ages and abilities. OCR qualifications
include AS/A Levels, Diplomas, GCSEs, Cambridge Nationals, Cambridge Technicals,
Functional Skills, Key Skills, Entry Level qualifications, NVQs and vocational qualifications in
areas such as IT, business, languages, teaching/training, administration and secretarial skills.
It is also responsible for developing new specifications to meet national requirements and the
needs of students and teachers. OCR is a not-for-profit organisation; any surplus made is
invested back into the establishment to help towards the development of qualifications and
support, which keep pace with the changing needs of today’s society.
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and students, to indicate the requirements
of the examination. It shows the basis on which marks were awarded by examiners. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions which took place at an examiners’ meeting before marking
commenced.
All examiners are instructed that alternative correct answers and unexpected approaches in
candidates’ scripts must be given marks that fairly reflect the relevant knowledge and skills
demonstrated.
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the published question papers and the report
on the examination.
© OCR 20212
1. Annotations
Annotation Meaning
Highlight
Off page comment
Omission mark
Unclear or Indicates material for which there is no credit
Rubric error placed at start of response not being counted
Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Level 4
Synoptic link
Development of a point
Significant amount of material which doesn’t answer the question
Used to denote that points had been seen and noted but mostly where credit was given
No place specific detail
Highlighting an issue e.g. irrelevant paragraph. Use in conjunction with another stamp e.g. or
Blank page
Evaluation3
2. Subject Specific Marking Instructions
INTRODUCTION
Your first task as an Examiner is to become thoroughly familiar with the material on which the examination depends. This material includes:
• the specification, especially the assessment objectives
• the question paper and its rubrics
• the mark scheme.
You should ensure that you have copies of these materials.
You should ensure also that you are familiar with the administrative procedures related to the marking process. These are set out in the OCR booklet
Instructions for Examiners. If you are examining for the first time, please read carefully Appendix 5 Introduction to Script Marking: Notes for New
Examiners.
Please ask for help or guidance whenever you need it. Your first point of contact is your Team Leader.
USING THE MARK SCHEME
Please study this Mark Scheme carefully. The Mark Scheme is an integral part of the process that begins with the setting of the question paper and ends
with the awarding of grades. Question papers and Mark Schemes are developed in association with each other so that issues of differentiation and positive
achievement can be addressed from the very start.
This Mark Scheme is a working document; it is not exhaustive; it does not provide ‘correct’ answers. The Mark Scheme can only provide ‘best guesses’
about how the question will work out, and it is subject to revision after we have looked at a wide range of scripts.
Please read carefully all the scripts in your allocation and make every effort to look positively for achievement throughout the ability range. Always be
prepared to use the full range of marks.
LEVELS OF RESPONSE QUESTIONS:
The indicative content indicates the expected parameters for candidates’ answers, but be prepared to recognise and credit unexpected approaches where
they show relevance.
Using ‘best-fit’, decide first which set of level descriptors best describes the overall quality of the answer. Once the level is located, adjust the mark
concentrating on features of the answer which make it stronger or weaker following the guidelines for refinement.
Highest mark: If clear evidence of all the qualities in the level descriptors is shown, the HIGHEST Mark should be awarded.4
Lowest mark: If the answer shows the candidate to be borderline (i.e. they have achieved all the qualities of the levels below and show limited evidence of
meeting the criteria of the level in question) the LOWEST mark should be awarded.
Middle mark: This mark should be used for candidates who are secure in the level. They are not ‘borderline’ but they have only achieved some of the
qualities in the level descriptors.
Be prepared to use the full range of marks. Do not reserve (e.g.) highest level marks ‘in case’ something turns up of a quality you have not yet seen. If an
answer gives clear evidence of the qualities described in the level descriptors, reward appropriately.
Quality of extended response will be assessed in questions marked with an (*). Quality of extended response is not attributed to any single assessment
objective but instead is assessed against the entire response for the question.5
AO1 AO2 AO3 Quality of extended
response
Comprehensive A wide range of detailed and
accurate knowledge that
demonstrates fully
developed understanding
that shows full relevance to
the demands of the
question.
Precision in the use of
question terminology.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is consistently applied to
the context of the question, in
order to form a:
Clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate.
Clear, developed and convincing
interpretation that is fully
accurate.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills are
used in a consistently
appropriate and effective
way and with a high
degree of competence
and precision.
There is a well-developed
line of reasoning which is
clear and logically
structured. The
information presented is
relevant and
substantiated.
Detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure
judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence
based.
Thorough A range of detailed and
accurate knowledge that
demonstrates well
developed understanding
that is relevant to the
demands of the question.
Generally precise in the use
of question terminology.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is mainly applied to the
context of the question, in order
to form a:
Clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills are
used in a suitable way
and with a good level of
competence and
precision.
There is a line of
reasoning presented with
some structure. The
information presented is in
the most-part relevant and
supported by some
evidence.
Clear and developed
interpretation that shows
accuracy.
Detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements,
with some link between rational
conclusions and evidence.6
AO1 AO2 AO3 Quality of extended
response
Reasonable Some sound knowledge that
demonstrates partially
developed understanding
that is relevant to the
demands to the question.
Awareness of the meaning
of the terms in the question.
Knowledge and understanding
shown is partially applied to the
context of the question, in order
to form a:
Sound analysis that shows some
accuracy.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills are
used in a mostly suitable
way with a sound level of
competence but may lack
precision.
There information has
some relevance and is
presented with limited
structure. The information
is supported by limited
evidence.
Sound interpretation that shows
some accuracy.
Sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgments and
conclusions, with limited use of
evidence.
Basic Limited knowledge that is
relevant to the topic or
question with little or no
development.
Confusion and inability to
deconstruct terminology as
used in the question.
Knowledge and understanding
shows limited application to the
context of the question in order
to form a:
Simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy.
Quantitative, qualitative
and/or fieldwork skills are
used inappropriately with
limited competence and
precision.
The information is basic
and communicated in an
unstructured way. The
information is supported
by limited evidence and
the relationship to the
evidence may not be
clear.
Simple interpretation that shows
limited accuracy.
Un-supported evaluation that
offers simple conclusions.7
Question Answer Mark Guidance
1 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 1 as a source of
information about the greenhouse effect.
Possible limitations include:
• GHGs present throughout the atmosphere
not just in an upper level layer
• No indication of different types and efficacy
of GFGs
• Nothing to indicate where the GHGs
originate from - natural or anthropogenic
• No scale to show the relevance of the width
of arrows – i.e. absence of quantification
• Lack of information about the source e.g.
date
• No labelling of incoming radiation flows as
short-wave
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for limitations of the data identified through
critical questioning of the resource.
1 (b) Explain how geoengineering can cut global
emissions of greenhouse gases.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of how geoengineering can cut global emissions of
greenhouse gases (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about how geoengineering can cut global emissions
of greenhouse gases.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of how geoengineering can cut
global emissions of greenhouse gases (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
how geoengineering can cut global emissions of
greenhouse gases.
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of how
geoengineering can cut global emissions of
greenhouse gases could potentially include:
• geoengineering = use of technology to
modify environment on a large-scale
• two types of strategy - ↓ amount of
insolation entering atmosphere; ↓ level of
CO2 in atmosphere – NB it is only
geoengineering that reduces emissions of
GHGs that is relevant
• carbon removal: fertilising oceans with iron to
absorb carbon dioxide through increased
phytoplankton growth
• carbon capture: developing plastic trees which
absorb and store carbon dioxide
• enhanced weathering – crushing huge
quantities of some types of rock to ↑ surface8
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
how geoengineering can cut global emissions of
greenhouse gases (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about how
geoengineering can cut global emissions of
greenhouse gases.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of
area → accelerated weathering absorbing CO2
to form carbonates - sequestration9
Question Answer Mark Guidance
2 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 2 as a source of
information about the global distribution of
people living with dementia in 2015.
Possible limitations include:
• Is there a standard definition of
‘dementia’ used across the world?
Different locations may have different
definitions.
• Unequal access to health care so
diagnosis rates likely to vary.
• Possible bias – lack of information
about purpose and author
• Regions large and not comparable in
geographical size - regions have
different sized populations so number
per 1000 people would be more helpful
• Intra-continental differences masked
• Map projection distorts in favour of
northern hemisphere
• Unclear if Asia includes Australia, NZ
and Pacific nations
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for limitations of the data identified through
critical questioning of the resource.
Do not accept a limitation that the resource is out
of date.
2 (b) Explain the environmental causes of one
communicable disease.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the environmental causes of one communicable
disease (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the environmental causes of one
communicable disease.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the environmental
causes of one communicable disease could
potentially include:
• environmental factors, can include; climate
rainfall, temperatures, relief, natural hazards
• communicable disease = transmitted from one
person to another directly or indirectly or by
means of vectors
• malaria – warm humid conditions required as well
as stagnant surface water which is required for10
understanding of the environmental causes
of one communicable disease (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
the environmental causes of one communicable
disease.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the environmental causes of one communicable
disease (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about the environmental
causes of one communicable disease.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
breeding mosquitoes.
• diarrhoea/cholera/typhoid/ guinea worm – water
contaminated with bacteria / water fleas, often
occurring after or during flood events
• candidates could refer to the role of an
appropriate natural hazard and link to a
communicable disease e.g. flooding, drought or
monsoon rains
Candidates should not be penalized for discussing more
than one communicable disease.11
Question Answer Mark Guidance
3 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 3 as a source of
information about the pattern of circulation in
the North Atlantic.
Possible limitations include:
• Scale not added
• Diagram doesn’t show if currents are shallow
or deep
• Diagram doesn’t show if currents are warm or
cold
• No key provided for width of current or
meaning of a dashed current.
• Speed of flow not shown
• No inflow to the Atlantic from the
Mediterranean shown
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for limitations of the data identified through
critical questioning of the resource.
3 (b) Explain the distinctive features of guyots.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and
understanding of the distinctive features of
guyots (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the distinctive features of guyots.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the distinctive features of
guyots (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
the distinctive features of guyots.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the distinctive
features of guyots could potentially include:
• Once rose above the surface of the ocean
• Erosion reduced height to below sea level
• Due to erosion, peak has a flat top
• Over time the weight of the guyots on the
oceanic crust may cause it to subside into the
upper mantle
• Accumulation of sediment can bury these
peaks over time e.g. within the Atlantic ocean
• Many are of volcanic origin, often part of midocean ridge → igneous geology12
the distinctive features of guyots (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about the distinctive
features of guyots.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.13
Question Answer Mark Guidance
4 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 4 as a source of
information about the global distribution of
organic agriculture in 2015.
Possible limitations include:
• original size of each country/continent is distorted
so very difficult to accurately appreciate
significance of organic area
• no scale
• no indication if organic agriculture produced is
subsistence farming or bound for the domestic or
international market.
• difficulty in obtaining accurate and reliable data in
some areas of the world
• no historical data available for comparison of
change over time
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for limitations of the data identified through
critical questioning of the resource.
Do not accept resource is out of date as a
limitation.
4 (b) Explain how food production methods can vary
within a country or region.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of how food production methods can vary within a
country or region (AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about how food production methods can vary within a
country or region.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of how food production methods can
vary within a country or region (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of how food production
methods can vary within a country or region could
potentially include:
• Wide range of farming methods within just one
country
• Any one farming system can include several
different features e.g. market gardening in the
Vale of Evesham
• Arable and pastoral systems work alongside
each other at all scales
• Subsistence and commercial systems can exist
within a local distance e.g. wet-rice farming in
India close to commercial rice farming, or
subsistence crofting farming in Scotland close to14
how food production methods can vary within a country
or region.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
how food production methods can vary within a country
or region (AO1).
There may be simple ideas about how food
production methods can vary within a country or
region.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
commercial dairy farming
• Shifting cultivation in the Brazilian rainforest,
close to sedentary cattle ranching
• Extensive and intensive farming systems within
close distance to each other e.g. large scale
commercial (Fens, Prairies) and market
gardening nearer cities (Cambridge, Winnipeg)
Credit should be given for any relevant answers.15
Question Answer Mark Guidance
5 (a) Identify three limitations of Fig. 5 as a source of
information about rift valleys.
Possible limitations include:
• lack of information about the source leading to
potential bias based on who took the photo and
for what purpose
• lack of information about geology
• no scale e.g. height of rock faces, width of flat
floor (ranging pole / person)
• only a very short section visible – unclear as to
the overall scale / impact of the landscape
• how representative is this example
3
AO3 x3
AO3 – 3 marks
3x1 () for limitations of the data identified through
critical questioning of the resource.
5 (b) Explain the role of convection currents in the
asthenosphere.
Level 3 (5-6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the role of convection currents in the asthenosphere
(AO1).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the role of convection currents in the
asthenosphere.
Level 2 (3-4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the formation and role of convection
6
AO1 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the role of
convection currents in the asthenosphere could
potentially include:
• asthenosphere = layer in upper mantle c. 100
down to c. 300km. Solid but flows under
pressure thus behaving like a very viscous
material over very long time scales
• Shallow and deep convection currents in the
asthenosphere caused by heat generated in the
Earth’s interior – left over from Earth’s formation +
unstable radioactive isotopes
• Viscous asthenosphere moves carrying the16
currents in the asthenosphere (AO1).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
the role of convection currents in the asthenosphere.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the role of convection currents in the asthenosphere
(AO1).
There may be simple ideas about the formation and
role of convection currents in the asthenosphere
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
overlying solid lithosphere and crust with it
• Upwelling plumes of hot material at mid-oceanic
ridges are warm → higher elevation than colder
more dense plate material further away → gravity
causes higher ridge to ‘push’ away the lithosphere
lying further away from the ridge. Diverging
convection currents may operate in these
locations.
• Older colder plates sink at subduction zones
because as they cool → become denser than
underlying asthenosphere → ‘pull’ the rest of the
warmer plate along behind it. Converging currents
may operate in these locations.
• Credit point that research into how plates move
ongoing and questions over exactly how
convection operates remain17
SECTION B – SYNOPTIC QUESTIONS
Question Answer Mark Guidance
6 Examine how climate change may be
impacting the water cycle in tropical
rainforests.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of climate change and the water
cycle in tropical rainforests (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how climate change may be impacting the water
cycle in tropical rainforests (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about how climate change may be impacting the
water cycle in tropical rainforests.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make
appropriate synoptic links between content from
different parts of the course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of climate change and the water cycle in tropical
rainforests (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how climate change may be
impacting the water cycle in tropical rainforests (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about either climate change or the water cycle in
tropical rainforests and developed ideas for the other
focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of climate change
and the water cycle in tropical rainforests could
potentially include:
• Climate change
o increase in surface, atmospheric and
oceanic temperatures
o rising sea level
o increasing atmospheric water vapour
o climate modelling to show influence of
positive and negative feedback
• Water cycle in the tropical rainforest
o water cycles specific to tropical
rainforests
o physical factors affecting the flows and
stores in the water cycle, including
temperature
o explore changes to the flows and
stores within the water cycle caused by
natural factors
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how climate change may be impacting the water cycle in
tropical rainforests could potentially include:
• tropical rainforests have high average annual
temperatures and high average annual rainfall,
with little or no ‘dry’ season.
• Some areas are predicted to be much drier as
a result of climate change with a pronounced
dry season.
• Precipitation may be less frequent and more
intense leading to increased run-off and
reduced stores of water. This could cause
increased stress on plants and reduced ability
to grow as water supplies limited
• precipitation feedback loops likely to change as
precipitation events are less frequent, but high18
between the content from different parts of the course
of study but these are not always appropriate.
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of climate change and the water
cycle in tropical rainforests (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide sound analysis that
shows some accuracy of how climate change may
be impacting the water cycle in tropical rainforests
(AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
either climate change or the water cycle in tropical
rainforests and simple ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study but these are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
climate change and the water cycle in tropical
rainforests (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how climate change may be
impacting the water cycle in tropical rainforests (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about
climate change and the water cycle in tropical
rainforests.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
temperatures cause continued high rates of
evaporation from interception storage on leaf
surfaces and transpiration from the soil
• continued high temperatures will continue to
allow high capacity for water storage in the
atmosphere, however vegetation storage likely
to decrease19
Question Answer Mark Guidance
7 Examine how the prevalence of noncommunicable disease is influenced by issues
of EITHER human rights OR territorial integrity.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of prevalence of non-communicable
disease and issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how the prevalence of non-communicable disease is
influenced by issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the relationship between prevalence of noncommunicable disease and issues of either human
rights or territorial integrity.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make
appropriate synoptic links between content from
different parts of the course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of prevalence of non-communicable disease and issues
of either human rights or territorial integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how the prevalence of noncommunicable disease is influenced by issues of either
human rights or territorial integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about either prevalence of non-communicable disease
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of prevalence of noncommunicable disease and issues of either human
rights or territorial integrity could potentially include:
• Non-communicable disease – a disease
that cannot be spread between people
• Prevalence of non-communicable disease such as
diabetes, CVD, types of cancer. As countries
develop economically the frequency of
communicable diseases decreases, while the
prevalence of non-communicable diseases rises
• Issues of human rights:
o Basic rights and freedoms to which all people
are entitled including access to medical care,
food, education, shelter, gender equality
• Current spatial patterns of human rights issues
can influence prevalence of non-communicable
disease
• Global governance of human rights has
consequences for citizens and places
• Issues of territorial integrity:
o The concept of territorial integrity is that the
defined territory of a state, over which it has
exclusive and legitimate control, is inviolable
o Challenges to territorial integrity include contested
territory, claims for separatism, ethnic partitioning,
ethnic conflict, economic power of TNCs20
or either human rights or territorial integrity and
developed ideas for the other focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links
between the content from different parts of the course
of study but these are not always appropriate.
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of prevalence of non-communicable
disease and issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide sound analysis that
shows some accuracy of how the prevalence of noncommunicable disease is influenced by issues of
either human rights or territorial integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
either prevalence of non-communicable disease or
either human rights or territorial integrity and simple
ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study but these are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
prevalence of non-communicable disease and issues
of either human rights or territorial integrity (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how the prevalence of noncommunicable disease is influenced by issues of
either human rights or territorial integrity (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about the
prevalence of non-communicable disease and issues of
either human rights or territorial integrity.
o Global governance of sovereignty and territorial
integrity has consequences for citizens and people
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how the prevalence of non-communicable disease is
influenced by issues of either human rights or territorial
integrity could potentially include:
Human rights:
• Prevalence of non-communicable disease can be
reduced or increased by human rights issues
• Where human rights are upheld such as in many
parts of ACs and EDCs, reduction in the
prevalence of non-communicable diseases may
be influenced by:
o access to education / awareness of
potential medical conditions
o access to medical / health care
o food security and nutritional advice
o gender equality in access to education and
health care
o lower levels of poverty
o better access to effects of government
strategies
• Even in countries where human rights are upheld
there may be spatial and temporal variations in
prevalence of non-communicable disease related
to:21
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
o Distribution of elderly populations
o Poor diet / overnutrition
o Level of alcohol / tobacco consumption
o Air pollution
• In the developing world in some LIDCs and EDCs
where human rights are not upheld, overnutrition
is a significant health problem and there is
increasing prevalence of non-communicable
diseases such as CVD, type-2 diabetes, cancer
Territorial integrity:
• Prevalence of non-communicable diseases can
be reduced or enhanced by territorial integrity
issues
• Where territorial integrity is secure and there is
political stability, prevalence of noncommunicable diseases may be affected by the
effectiveness of state apparatus such as the
health care system, education provision, gender
equality and wealth / ability of government to put
in place effective strategies
• Where territorial integrity is insecure, especially in
the conflict zones, prevalence of noncommunicable diseases may be affected by
military action restricting access to national
government and international organisations that
might otherwise mitigate against noncommunicable diseases
• In conflict zones prevalence may be increased or
decreased depending on access to food, clean22
water, living conditions, threats to food security
and medical facilities
• NGOs and other organisations, WHO / UNICEF,
involved in intervention may help to reduce
prevalence of non-communicable disease by
supporting populations, e.g. IDPs, especially if
threat to territorial integrity is long-term.23
Question Answer Mark Guidance
8 Examine how oceans influence patterns of
EITHER global trade OR global migration.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of oceans and patterns of either global
trade or global migration. (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how oceans influence patterns of either global trade
or global migration (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the relationship between oceans and patterns
of either global trade or global migration.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make
appropriate synoptic links between content from
different parts of the course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of oceans and patterns of either global trade or global
migration (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how oceans influence patterns of
either global trade or global migration (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about either oceans or patterns of either global trade
or global migration and developed ideas for the other
focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links
between the content from different parts of the course
of study but these are not always appropriate.
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of oceans and patterns
of either global trade or global migration could
potentially include:
• oceans;
o the global distribution of the world’s
oceans, their areas and volumes
o the global distribution of warm and
cold surface currents
• patterns of global trade
o Current spatial patterns in the
direction and components of
international trade, including
examples of intra-regional – must be
linked to oceans as question
specifies
• patterns of global migration
o Current spatial patterns in the
numbers, composition and direction
of international migration flows,
including examples of intra-regional
– must be linked to oceans as
question specifies
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how oceans influence patterns of either global trade or
global migration could potentially include:
• Oceans provide opportunities for flows of
trade and migration directly for countries with
a coastline and indirectly for land-locked
countries
• the size of the ocean can influence patterns
e.g. shorter distances are more manageable
and cheaper so likely to have increased
traffic e.g. migration flows from South-East
Asia to Australia
• The distribution of currents can influence
routes making them more treacherous or
faster and cheaper depending on the24
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of oceans and patterns of either global
trade or global migration (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide sound analysis that
shows some accuracy of how oceans influence
patterns of either global trade or global migration
(AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
either oceans or patterns of either global trade or
global migration and simple ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study but these are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
oceans and patterns of either global trade or global
migration (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how oceans influence patterns of
either global trade or global migration (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about the
relationship between oceans and patterns of either
global trade or global migration.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
direction of travel
• These patterns are affected by many other factors
which may have a greater influence e.g. political
or socio-economic factors, the distribution of 21st
century piracy and its management
• Globalisation resulting in time space compression
as technological developments have reduced time
taken for ships to cross.
• New routes developing such as the use of ice
breakers in the Arctic.
• New ocean routes for migrant crossings25
Question Answer Mark Guidance
9 Examine how physical factors affect food security in
any ONE landscape system you have studied.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of the physical factors that affect
food security in one landscape system. (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how physical factors affect food security in one
landscape system (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about the physical factors that affect food security and
one landscape system.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make
appropriate synoptic links between content from
different parts of the course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of the physical factors that affect food security in one
landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how physical factors affect
food security in one landscape system (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about either the physical factors that affect food
security or one landscape system and developed
ideas for the other focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links
between the content from different parts of the course
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of the physical factors
that affect food security in any one landscape system
could potentially include:
• Producing sufficient food is heavily influenced by
the physical environment
• Physical factors that affect food security include
geology, soil, length of growing season,
temperature, precipitation, water supply,
altitude, aspect, slope angle
• The physical factors vary spatially within coastal,
glaciated and dryland landscape systems
• Physical factors can also change over time in
both the short- and long-term; they may be
affected by natural hazards, climate change and
the impact of human activity
• ‘Food security exists when all people, at all times,
have physical and economic access to sufficient
safe and nutritious food that meets their dietary
needs and food preferences for an active an
healthy life’ (UN FAO definition)
• Whilst one particular physical factor can influence
food security it is often a range of physical factors
in combination - also with human factors - that
affect food security
• Physical factors may have a positive or negative
effect on food security
AO2 – 6 marks26
of study but these are not always appropriate.
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of the physical factors that affect
food security in one landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide sound analysis that
shows some accuracy of how the physical factors
that affect food security in one landscape system
(AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
either the physical factors that affect food security or
one landscape system and simple ideas for the other
focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study but these are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
the physical factors that affect food security in one
landscape system (AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how the physical factors affect
food security in one landscape system (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about the
physical factors that affect food security in one
landscape system.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Application of knowledge and understanding to
examine how physical factors affect food security in
any one landscape system could potentially include:
Factors that could be applied to each specific
landscape system depending on the particular
examples cited:
• Soil characteristics: texture, structure, mineral
content
• Temperature, minimum threshold for crop
growth and length of growing season
• Precipitation and water supply: amount,
effectiveness, seasonal distribution
• Altitude: affects relationship between climate,
soil and growing season
• Aspect and slope angle: affect microclimate and
soil characteristics such as depth and drainage
Additional factors specific to each landscape
system, depending on examples cited:
• Coastal landscapes
o Change, gain or loss in area / quality of land
available for farming may be affected by:
- Submergence e.g. loss of lower valley
deeper more fertile soils in ria formation
- Emergence e.g. raised beaches
- Marine / subaerial erosion e.g. coasts of
weaker rocks such as East Anglia27
- Deposition e.g. Dungeness, Orford Ness
o Proximity to the sea / warm ocean currents
where temperatures milder in winter in midlatitudes is of benefit to crop / livestock
production e.g. British west coasts
o Climate change; warming may lead to
increased incidence / energy of storms,
coastal flooding affecting food productivity,
e.g. small island communities
o Relief; low lying coasts, e.g. deltas, may
be affected by salt water incursion as sea
level rises
• Glaciated landscapes
o Glacial erosion in upland areas has
removed soil, leaving barren areas of low
agricultural productivity / extensive
livestock rearing e.g. Snowdonia
o Deposition by ice has created relatively
fertile deep soils in till plains which are
highly productive e.g. East Anglia
o Deposition by glacio-fluvial processes has
produced extensive outwash plains of only
poor to moderate soil fertility
o The combination of factors such as high
altitude, low temperatures, high
precipitation, steep slopes in uplands has
led to low productivity affecting food
security, whereas the converse may be
true of lowland glaciated landscapes28
o Length of growing season (thermal and
hydrological) is influenced by latitude and
altitude in glaciated landscapes
o Post-glacial submergence of glacial
troughs / fjords limits area of flat land /
fertile soil available for farming
• Dryland landscapes
o Fragility of dryland environments; threats to
food security may be caused by cascading
effects of change in a single factor such as
precipitation
o Drought where populations depend on
farming can initiate, intensify or contribute to:
- Desertification
- Soil erosion
- Effects of blown sand on crops / dune
encroachment in oases
especially in semi-arid drylands
o The combination of low mean annual rainfall
and very high summer day time
temperatures affect farming type and
productivity / food security
o Water supply – patterns of rainfall vary
spatially and may change over time
affecting crop yields positively or negatively
o Food security is vulnerable in polar
drylands; ‘hunting and gathering’ by
indigenous people is a product of low29
temperatures, permafrost, lack of moisture,
low precipitation, and low biodiversity.30
Question Answer Mark Guidance
10 Examine how strategies to manage tectonic
hazards shape place identity.
Level 4 (10-12 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and
understanding of strategies to manage tectonic
hazards and place identity (AO1).
Demonstrates comprehensive application of
knowledge and understanding to provide clear,
developed and convincing analysis that is fully accurate
of how strategies to manage tectonic hazards shape
place identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about strategies to manage tectonic hazards and
place identity.
There are clear and explicit attempts to make
appropriate synoptic links between content from
different parts of the course of study.
Level 3 (7-9 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding
of strategies to manage tectonic hazards and place
identity (AO1).
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide clear and developed analysis
that shows accuracy of how strategies to manage
tectonic hazards shape place identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including well-developed ideas
about either strategies to manage tectonic hazards
or place identity and developed ideas for the other
focus.
There are clear attempts to make synoptic links
between the content from different parts of the course
of study but these are not always appropriate.
12
AO1 x6
AO2 x6
Indicative content
AO1 – 6 marks
Knowledge and understanding of strategies to
manage tectonic hazards and place identity could
potentially include:
• strategies to manage tectonic hazards –
mitigation against the event, vulnerability or
losses
• place identity – demographic, socio-economic,
cultural, political, built and physical
characteristics
AO2 – 6 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
how strategies to manage tectonic hazards shape place
identity could potentially include:
• mitigating against lava flows e.g. building lava
diversion channels in Italy change the built
environment potentially balancing the
demographics of the population as emigration
slows because confidence grows (so all age
groups stay rather than just the elderly who
cannot move)
• mitigating against vulnerability improving
community preparedness e.g. locally run radio
warning system near Mount Merapi, Indonesia
changes culture as the community understands
the signs that can indicate a potential eruption
rather than relying on local folklore about the
movement of woodworms
• mitigation against vulnerability changing building
design e.g. in Kobe, Japan the railway station is
covered in cross bracing which changes the built
nature of Kobe’s place identity
• mitigation against the event e.g. land-use zoning
may change both the built and natural
environment of the place identity as land-use
zones are changed by decision makers
• distinction between long and short term
mitigation.
• Impact of aid agencies31
Level 2 (4-6 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and
understanding of strategies to manage tectonic
hazards and place identity (AO1).
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge
and understanding to provide sound analysis that
shows some accuracy of how strategies to manage
tectonic hazards shape place identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including developed ideas about
either strategies to manage tectonic hazards or place
identity and simple ideas for the other focus.
There are some attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study but these are not always relevant.
Level 1 (1-3 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
strategies to manage tectonic hazards and place identity
(AO1).
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide simple analysis that shows
limited accuracy of how strategies to manage tectonic
hazards shape place identity (AO2).
This will be shown by including simple ideas about
strategies to manage tectonic hazards and place
identity.
There are limited attempts to make synoptic links
between content from different parts of the course of
study.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit
• All mitigation creates a perception of safety to
both the residents of an area as well as those
looking in e.g. tourists
SECTION C32
Question Answer Mark Guidance
11* ‘Vulnerability to climate change depends on location rather
than the level of economic development.’ Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of vulnerability to climate change and locational (spatial)
factors and level of economic development.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
vulnerability to climate change and locational factors and level
of economic development.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
vulnerability to climate change and locational factors and level
of economic development.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of
vulnerability to climate change and locational factors and level
of economic development.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how the vulnerability to
climate change depends on location and level of economic
development.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
the vulnerability to climate change depends on location rather
than the level of economic development.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
vulnerability to climate change and locational factors
and level of economic development could potentially
include:
• What is climate change, including discussion of
rates
• Implications of climate change for people and
the environment, such as changes to
ecosystems, economies, health and extreme
weather in different locations, and how these
are projected to change in the future
• The vulnerability of people and the
environment to the impacts of climate change
• Case studies of contrasting countries at
different stages of economic development
including current socio-economic and
environmental impacts and the opportunities
and threats they present, technological socioeconomic and political challenges associated
with effective mitigation and adaptation
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which
vulnerability to climate change depends on location
rather than the level of economic development, could
potentially include:
• Level of economic development can
determine mitigation and level of adaptation
and therefore affect vulnerability for both
people and environment
• Vulnerability determined by effects, some of
which are localised geographically e.g. only
specific latitudes affected by vulnerability to
tropical storms, or coastal flooding with
rising sea level affects coastal zones
• It could be argued that level of economic
development is critical factor e.g. Southern33
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how the vulnerability to climate change
depends on location and level of economic development.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which the vulnerability to
climate change depends on location rather than the level of
economic development.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of how the vulnerability to climate change
depends on location and level of economic development.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which the vulnerability to climate
change depends on location rather than the level of economic
development.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of how the vulnerability to climate change depends
on location and level of economic development.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
Bangladesh and South East USA are both
affected by tropical storms, but Bangladesh
is often more adversely affected e.g. in
1991 138,000 killed compared with 2005 in
USA where 1400 died
• However, vulnerability for some people is
greater e.g. farmers in marginal
environments – combination of
geographical vulnerability and employment
that is dependent on the changing
environment
• Population density could be argued to affect
vulnerability as in higher density areas,
greater proportions of the population is at
risk increasing vulnerability
• Global warming is most rapid at the poles,
increasing vulnerability to polar
environments and population e.g. Inuits in
the Arctic
• Impact of heat waves on humans
• Low lying coastal areas and the impact of
powerful storms
• Impact to the global distribution of
ecosystems
• Coastal flooding34
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that
offers simple conclusions as to the extent to which the
vulnerability to climate change depends on location rather than
the level of economic development.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.35
Question Answer Mark Guidance
12* ‘Evidence from the past contributes to accurate
predictions of future climate change.’
Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of past evidence and predictions of future climate change.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
past evidence and predictions of future climate change.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
past evidence and predictions of future climate change.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
past evidence and predictions of future climate change.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of how evidence from the past
contributes to accurate predictions of future climate change.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated evaluation
that offers secure judgements leading to rational conclusions
that are evidence based as to whether evidence from the past
contributes to accurate predictions of future climate change.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
past evidence and predictions of future climate
change could potentially include:
• Past
o Methods used to reconstruct past
climate
o Past climate to reveal periods of
greenhouse and icehouse Earth
o How natural forcing has driven
climate change in the geological past
o Humans have influenced the climate
system, leading to a new epoch, the
Anthropocene
• Future
o An effective human response relies on
knowing what the future will hold e.g.
importance of the carbon cycle,
influence of positive and negative
feedback, future emission scenarios
o The global cooperation of nations is
also vital to managing climate change
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate whether evidence from the past
contributes to accurate predictions of future climate
change could potentially include:
• Without understanding the past we cannot
understand the present or begin to adjust the
future.
• Using a variety of methods helpful for
ensuring a realistic picture e.g. sea-floor
sediments, ice cores, lake sediments, tree
rings and fossils
• We need to understand natural forcing in
order to interpret results appropriately e.g.
external and internal forcing mechanisms
• Using past data we need to use evidence of36
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of how evidence from the past contributes to
accurate predictions of future climate change.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to whether evidence from the past contributes
to accurate predictions of future climate change.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of how evidence from the past contributes to
accurate predictions of future climate change.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to whether evidence from the past contributes to
accurate predictions of future climate change.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of how evidence from the past contributes to
accurate predictions of future climate change.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to whether evidence from the past
contributes to accurate predictions of future climate change.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
human influences especially since the
industrial revolution to appreciate the speed of
change and it’s relative significance
• Consideration of the reliability of past data
• Using a range of methods enables a more
accurate reading e.g. glacial retreat, sea level
rise, global temperatures as well as
atmospheric water vapour and anthropogenic
greenhouse gas emissions
• The rate of change globally is different now
as:
o technologies develop faster,
o increased globalisation leading to
quicker communications
o much increased population growth
This limits the effectiveness of past climate
change data for predicting the future.
• Society is seeing evidence of significant
climate change in the recent past in contrast
to evidence of slower changes over previous
centuries/millennia.
• It should be noted that atmospheric
fluctuations are a natural phenomena.37
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.38
Question Answer Mark Guidance
13* To what extent can one NGO effectively mitigate against
disease at a national scale?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of one NGO mitigating against disease at a national scale.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of a
NGO mitigating against disease at a national scale.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of a
NGO mitigating against disease at a national scale.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of a
NGO mitigating against disease at a national scale.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the effectiveness of one NGO
mitigating against disease at a national scale.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
one NGO can effectively mitigate against disease at a national
scale.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of one
NGO mitigating against disease at a national scale
could potentially include:
• Case study of the role that one NGO has
played in dealing with a disease outbreak within
one country at national level
• E.g. British Red Cross mitigating cholera in
Haiti or Cancer UK improving prevention,
diagnosis and treatment across UK (other
relevant examples are creditable)
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which one NGO
can effectively mitigate against disease at a
national scale, could potentially include:
• The effectiveness of the NGO in the case
study studied – measured by ability to
mitigate disease e.g. BRC in Haiti was
ineffective in managing the scale of outbreak
of cholera in Haiti.
• Importance of co-operation of the NGO with
various other bodies – without this, effect of
NGO severely limited
• Impact of grass roots strategies as more
effective use of resources
• Perhaps more effective at dealing with
infectious diseases rather than noncommunicable e.g. Cancer UK is having an
impact, but role of education in prevention of
cancer is changing culture, society and habits
which is much more difficult to measure and
achieve compared with supplying clean
drinking water to an area to mitigate cholera
• Effectiveness of alternative national
strategies in comparison e.g.39
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the effectiveness of one NGO mitigating
against disease at a national scale.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the effectiveness of one NGO mitigating
against disease at a national scale.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the effectiveness of one NGO mitigating against
disease at a national scale.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the effectiveness of one NGO mitigating
against disease at a national scale.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the effectiveness of one NGO mitigating against
disease at a national scale.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the effectiveness of one NGO
mitigating against disease at a national scale.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
o Education e.g. UK government running
campaigns and adverts to improve
awareness of causes of obesity
o Government action e.g. Indian
government decreasing subsidies on
petrol to increase cost of fuel, to reduce
use of cars and decrease incidence of
lung cancer
o Multi agency strategies e.g. Ethiopian
government working with UNICEF,
World Bank, WHO to reduce incidence
of malaria through spraying, destruction
of breeding sites as well as mass
publicity campaigns, early diagnosis and
treatment and provision of treated bed
nets
o Role of pharmaceutical transnationals
o Discussion of a range of NGOs working
in an area/with a particular disease.
o Consideration of the fact that any NGO
will work with the government of an
area, thus meaning they cannot solve a
situation alone.
o Various agencies work at different
scales. WHO has a very different role to
say UNICEF or the red cross.40
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.41
Question Answer Mark Guidance
14* ‘Increasing mobility is the main influence on diffusion of
disease at a variety of scales.’
To what extent do you agree?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding of
mobility and diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
mobility and diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
mobility and diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of mobility
and diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of mobility and other different factors
that influence the diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated evaluation
that offers secure judgements leading to rational conclusions that
are evidence based as to whether increasing mobility is the main
influence on diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of mobility
and diffusion of disease at a variety of scales could
potentially include:
• mobility – movement of people within and
between countries
• Disease diffusion – spread of disease outwards
from its origin to new areas
• Hagerstrand model
• Types of diffusion – expansion, relocation,
contagious and hierarchical
• Consideration of scale – local /national
/international
• Other factors impacting diffusion such as;
o International organisations e.g. WHO
o Physical conditions and barriers
o Level of development, socio-economic
barriers
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to analyse
and evaluate the influence of increasing mobility, and
other different factors, on diffusion of disease, could
potentially include:
• A range of scales should be discussed from
local, national to international
• Physical barriers reduce the spread of disease
and remote locations are becoming less isolated
with increasing globalisation
• Examples of the impact of increasing mobility
include:
o Ebola outbreak in West Africa 2014 spread
locally between villages and regionally within
and between nations
o Recent influenza and other viruses,
outbreaks spreading rapidly across
continents following trade or migration42
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of mobility and other different factors that
influence the diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to whether increasing mobility is the main
influence on diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of mobility and other different factors that influence the
diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to whether increasing mobility is the main influence
on diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and understanding
to provide a simple analysis that shows limited accuracy of
mobility and other different factors that influence the diffusion of
disease at a variety of scales.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and understanding
to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers simple
conclusions as to whether increasing mobility is the main
influence on diffusion of disease at a variety of scales.
patterns as well as international and national
sporting or business events
o The outbreak of Cholera in Haiti following the
2010 earthquake was brought in via global
mobility [with UN worker from Nepal] Poor
local living conditions caused rapid national
spread of disease. South - lower mortality
rates e.g. Sud, Sud-Est and Nippes, with
greater access to safe drinking water and
sanitation in IDP camps; higher mortality -
remote areas where access to healthcare
was limited.
• Other factors that impact diffusion of disease,
evaluated against increasing mobility, may
include
o Significance of physical conditions where
diseases thrive e.g. flu in low
temperatures, dengue fever in high
temperatures and humidity,
o Effectiveness of work of the WHO in
researching, predicting and controlling
disease diffusion,
o level of economic development e.g.
effectiveness of local education and
healthcare programmes.
o Government barriers e.g. national
lockdown or closing borders.
o Physical barriers
o Mitigation already in place.43
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and supported
by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with limited
structure. The information is supported by limited evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.44
Question Answer Mark Guidance
15* Discuss the extent to which climate change has
irreversibly damaged the oceans.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of climate change and damage to the oceans.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
climate change and damage to the oceans.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
climate change and damage to the oceans.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of climate
change and damage to the oceans.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of climate change and damage
to the oceans.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
climate change has irreversibly damaged the oceans.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
climate change and damage to the oceans could
potentially include:
• Impact of climate change
o Acidification of oceans
o Rising temperature and threat to coral
ecosystems
o Sea level change
o Threats, impact and adaptations of island
communities
o Impact on sea ice
o Impacts on Arctic region
o Trends or inclusion of data.
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which climate
change has irreversibly damaged the oceans, could
potentially include:
• Acidity has increased by 30% since the
industrial revolution limiting the ability of coral
reefs, molluscs to accumulate calcium
carbonate
• Mussels cannot cling to rocks as acidification
increases, severely affecting the ecosystem
• Coral bleaching is prevalent across the tropics
and has been increasing since 1980s. Events
have grown in intensity, frequency and scale.
Some of this coral is unable to recover, proving
the ocean has passed the threshold for
sensitive communities
• Arctic sea ice has decreased 2.9% since 1978,
reducing from 15 million km2 to 4 million km2.
Depth of Arctic sea ice has also decreased
from 4m to 1.25m on average.
• Concept of threshold (critical tipping point in
ocean causing massive and irreversible45
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of climate change and damage to the
oceans
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which climate change has
irreversibly damaged the oceans.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of climate change and damage to the oceans.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which climate change has
irreversibly damaged the oceans.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of climate change and damage to the oceans.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which climate change
has irreversibly damaged the oceans.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
damage) may be used in evaluation46
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear47
Question Answer Mark Guidance
16* ‘Plastic is the most serious threat to marine ecosystems.’
Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of threats to marine ecosystems.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
threats to marine ecosystems.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
threats to marine ecosystems.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of threats
to marine ecosystems.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the threats to marine
ecosystems.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated evaluation
that offers secure judgements leading to rational conclusions
that are evidence based as to the extent to which plastic is the
most serious threat to marine ecosystems.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
threats to marine ecosystems could potentially
include:
• Plastic
o Major sources of plastic pollutants
o How plastic can spread around the globe via
oceanic circulation
o Causes of the accumulation of plastic in one
ocean gyre
o Plastic is moved around the world from
source via waves. This movement is
controlled by winds and Coriolis effect,
contributing to the creation of gyres e.g.
Western and Eastern Pacific Garbage Patch
• Other threats
o Oils spills – impacts and management on
the marine ecosystem
o Climate change – impact of acidification on
fish, rising temperatures on coral
ecosystems
o Any other relevant sources of pollution
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which plastic is
the most serious threat to marine ecosystems, could
potentially include:
• Plastic has been mass produced since 1907, it
has risen in production exponentially since e.g.
1950 1.5 million tons of plastic produced, in 2016
more than 320 million tons. This is expected to
double by 2034, littering the ocean further.
Production is likely to continue to increase
because plastic is light, durable and cheap to
produce
• Plastic expected to outweigh fish by 2050. Much
is micro-plastic which is impossible to remove
• Plastic ends up in the ocean from rivers,48
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the threats to marine ecosystems.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which plastic is the most
serious threat to marine ecosystems
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the threats to marine ecosystems.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which plastic is the most serious
threat to marine ecosystems.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the threats to marine ecosystems.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which plastic is the most
serious threat to marine ecosystems.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
beaches, industrial shipping accidents
• It is estimated that every day 8 million pieces of
plastic end up in the ocean, making up 80% of
marine debris – waste policies in many countries
are not effective enough to reduce plastic waste.
Other issues taking precedence
• Variety of plastic waste increasing year by year,
it’s going to get worse and incidence of plastic
increase
• Nurdles light, easily transported and small so
easily spilled and dispersed around the ocean.
Found in every ocean and along most coastlines
globally affecting a much larger area than oil
spills
• Entire marine ecosystem affected by Deepwater
Horizon disaster in 2010. High mortality rates
among birds, fish and turtles in numbers not
reported on in relation to plastic
• Gulf of Mexico home to 5 endangered species of
turtle, all of which were affected. Due to the
contained area of the oil spill and the importance
of the Gulf of Mexico as a nursery ground, and
the vulnerability of these species indicate that
this is a greater threat than plastic
• Ocean acidification is affecting every trophic
level in the marine ecosystem from sea
butterflies to whales and mackerel making it a
more serious threat as so many species are
affected
• Coral bleaching caused by rising sea
temperatures is very serious for coral reefs, but
these only make up 25% of marine species,
although arguably they have the highest
biodiversity of all marine ecosystems, but they
cover a very small portion of the ocean floor
(less than 1%), making this a very localised
problem and therefore a relatively small threat
• Loss of biodiversity globally
• Coastal flooding and the impact on Island
communities and low lying areas such as the
Maldives
• Economic issues arising from the impact of
plastic such as on the fishing industry49
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an
unstructured way. The information is supported by limited
evidence and the relationship to the evidence may not be
clear.50
Question Answer Mark Guidance
17* ‘Advanced Countries will always experience food
security.’
To what extent do you agree with this statement?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of ACs and food security.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
ACs and food security.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
ACs and food security.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of ACs
and food security.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of Advanced Countries and
food security.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to
which Advanced Countries will always experience food
security.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
Advanced Countries and food security could
potentially include:
• Issues surrounding food security –
availability, access, utilization, stability and
security
• Advanced countries – development
characteristics e.g. well-developed financial
markets, effective supply and demand of
capital, goods, services and information,
diversified economic structures enabling
economic resilience
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which Advanced
Countries will always experience food security, could
potentially include:
• ACs suffer from less than 5% of global
prevalence of undernourishment, however this
doesn’t mean that food is secure
• Recent geographical pinch points were within
ACs e.g. issues of distribution during the UK
fuel crisis in 2012, or during the volcanic
eruption in Iceland in 2010
• ACs with semiarid land can easily suffer from
increased desertification e.g. USA, Spain or
Australia
• Climate change increasing extreme weather
events e.g. heatwaves in Europe 2003 or
flooding (58% of UK most productive farmland
is within floodplains and increasingly at risk
from increasingly unpredictable precipitation
patterns)
• Water scarcity in Australia caused by periodic
drought linked to El Niño events51
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of Advanced Countries and food security.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which Advanced Countries will
always experience food security.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of Advanced Countries and food security.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which Advanced Countries will
always experience food security.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of Advanced Countries and food security.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which Advanced
Countries will always experience food security.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
• Tectonic hazards significantly affect agriculture
in ACs e.g. Mount Etna 2002 eruption in Italy
caused 50% of orange crop to be destroyed
and 80% of vegetable crops lost
• Candidates may analyse and evaluate by
comparing ACs to EDCs or LIDCs, this can be
credited, but the focus must be on ability of the
AC to consistently benefit from food security.
An answer that is dependent upon the
contrasting food insecurity of EDCs / LIDCs is
unlikely to satisfy Level 4 AO2.52
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.53
Question Answer Mark Guidance
18* ‘Food production and food security issues have a
greater impact on the physical environment than they
do on people.’
Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of food production and security issues.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
food production and security issues.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
food production and security issues.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of food
production and security issues.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of the impact of food production
and security issues on the physical environment and on
people.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to which
food production and security issues have a greater impact on
the physical environment than they do on people.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
food production and food security issues could
potentially include:
• Food production issues e.g. irrigation,
deforestation, changing landscapes, use of
agrochemicals
• Food security issues e.g. food
shortages, food surpluses and poor diet
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which food
production and security issues have a greater
impact on the physical environment than they do
on people, could potentially include:
• Analysis of issues of food production and
security e.g. deforestation – an area equal
to Costa Rica is deforested globally every
year predominately for food production
reducing biodiversity and carbon store
• Security issues are more influential
because both issues of shortage and
surplus can lead to death, an effect we
cannot change
• Social issues associated with surplus
causing globesity is an international
phenomenon and likely to continue to
spread into more LIDCs as wealth of
citizens increases. There are more
global initiatives to mitigate against
issues associated with food shortages
e.g. MDGs, but far fewer international
efforts to control, stem the rise of
globesity
• Many of the environmental impacts are
short term as effective management or54
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of the impact of food production and
security issues on the physical environment and on people.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which food production and
security issues have a greater impact on the physical
environment than they do on people.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of the impact of food production and security
issues on the physical environment and on people.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which food production and
security issues have a greater impact on the physical
environment than they do on people.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of the impact of food production and security issues
on the physical environment and on people.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
agricultural practice adaptations can
lead to a relatively quick recovery of the
soil, land or ecosystem e.g. managing
herd sizes reduces compaction, weed
infestations and salinisation
• Expect wide variety of case studies to
evidence arguments55
simple conclusions as to the extent to which food production and
security issues have a greater impact on the physical
environment than they do on people.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.56
Question Answer Mark Guidance
19* ‘The impacts of tectonic hazards are mainly economic
rather than political or environmental.’ Discuss.
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of the impacts caused by tectonic hazards.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
the impacts caused by tectonic hazards.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
the impacts caused by tectonic hazards.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
impacts caused by tectonic hazards.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of whether impacts of tectonic
hazards are mainly economic rather than political or
environmental.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to
which impacts of tectonic hazards are mainly economic
rather than political or environmental.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of the
impacts caused by tectonic hazards could potentially
include:
• Political:
o Government declaring state of
emergency
o Ordering military to assist with recovery
o Accepting or requesting international aid
o Investment in recovery and mitigation
o Undermine stability of governments,
regional and national
• Economic
o Cost including reconstruction
o Disruption to power supplies
o Damage to infrastructure
o Widespread debris requiring mechanical
removal
o Disruption to economic activities e.g.
agriculture, manufacturing and services
e.g. loss of production
o Fall in stock market
o Fall in value of currency
o Increased insurance costs post-event
• Environmental
o New relief e.g. new land created from
lava flows, relief changed as steep
sided valleys infilled, or crevices created
from seismic shift, change in slope due
to lahar or mass movement, land moves
with seismic activity
o Change in weather patterns due to ash
in the atmosphere
o Increase in acid rain from emission of
Sulphur dioxide
o Earth shifts of axis due to large seismic
movement e.g. Tōhoku 2011
o Tsunamis triggered – coastal and inland57
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of whether impacts of tectonic hazards are
mainly economic rather than political or environmental.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which impacts of tectonic
hazards are mainly economic rather than political or
environmental.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of whether impacts of tectonic hazards are mainly
economic rather than political or environmental.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which impacts of tectonic
hazards are mainly economic rather than political or
environmental.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of whether impacts of tectonic hazards are mainly
economic rather than political or environmental.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which impacts of tectonic
hazards are mainly economic rather than political or
environmental.
flooding; shoreline erosion; sediment
flows
o Change in altitude of shoreline e.g.
northern Honshu ↓ 0.6m
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate whether impacts of
tectonic hazards are mainly economic rather
than political or environmental could potentially
include:
• Economic impacts are easily measured by
looking at cost of repair or recovery e.g.
Japanese earthquake cost $235 billion, Kobe
earthquake cost $100 billion, Northridge USA
cost $42 billion. Significance of cost indicates
extent of impact.
• Some economic impacts are also political or
environmental e.g. ash fall from Mount Merapi
destroyed the rice harvest
• Environmental impacts could outlast other
impacts because land has been created or
shifted which is more than we can do e.g. island
of Honshu moved 2.4m east during the Great
East Japan earthquake 2011 – this is something
that only another earthquake can affect and
would potentially out last any economic impact
• Political impacts could be linked to development
e.g. Haiti is still recovering from the earthquake
in 2010 and this is still affecting rates of tourism
which have significant economic implications. In
comparison, Japan has widely recovered
however Fukashima is an exclusion zone until
2023.
• Expect wide range of justification and case
studies.
• Candidates may evaluate by ability to recover,
duration of impact, size of population affected by
impact, scale of impact etc
• Responses do not have to include both seismic58
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.
and volcanic examples.59
Question Answer Mark Guidance
20* All types of plate boundaries generate tectonic hazards
for people.
To what extent are those at convergent boundaries the
most damaging?
AO1
Level 4 (7–9 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive knowledge and understanding
of tectonic hazards created at plate boundaries.
Level 3 (5–6 marks)
Demonstrates thorough knowledge and understanding of
the tectonic hazards created at plate boundaries.
Level 2 (3–4 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable knowledge and understanding of
the tectonic hazards created at plate boundaries.
Level 1 (1–2 marks)
Demonstrates basic knowledge and understanding of the
tectonic hazards created at plate boundaries.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
AO2
Level 4 (19–24 marks)
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear, developed and convincing
analysis that is fully accurate of whether tectonic hazards
created at convergent plate boundaries are the most
damaging to people compared with hazards created at other
plate boundaries.
Demonstrates comprehensive application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed and substantiated
evaluation that offers secure judgements leading to rational
conclusions that are evidence based as to the extent to
which tectonic hazards created at convergent plate
33
AO1 x9
AO2 x24
Indicative content
AO1 – 9 marks
Demonstrating knowledge and understanding of
tectonic hazards generated at plate boundaries
could potentially include:
• Divergent plate boundaries
o Seismic activity along transform faults
o Uprising of magma creating shield
volcanoes
• Conservative plate boundaries
o Friction causing seismic activity
• Convergent plate boundaries;
o Faulting and fracturing in the Benioff
zone causing seismic activity
o Subduction causing basaltic magma to
melt and rise to form strato-volcanoes
releasing explosive eruptions
AO2 – 24 marks
Application of knowledge and understanding to
analyse and evaluate the extent to which tectonic
hazards generated at convergent plate boundaries
are the most damaging to people compared with
tectonic hazards created at other plate boundaries
could potentially include:
• Use of exemplar seismic or volcanic
activity and the associated impact on
people. E.g. VEI 4 eruption of Merapi,
Indonesia in 2010 at the convergent
boundary between Indo-Australian and
Eurasian plate. Pyroclastic flows reached
15km at their furthest extent (southerly),
lava bombs thrown 4km from summit,
lahars caused widespread disruption. 367
killed, 277 injured and 410,000 made
homeless. Communications disrupted as
ash and pyroclastic flows destroyed
infrastructure.
• Ridges of diverging boundaries on average60
boundaries are the most damaging to people compared with
hazards created at other plate boundaries.
Relevant concepts are authoritatively discussed.
Level 3 (13–18 marks)
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a clear and developed analysis that
shows accuracy of whether tectonic hazards created at
convergent plate boundaries are the most damaging to
people t compared with hazards created at other plate
boundaries.
Demonstrates thorough application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a detailed evaluation that offers
generally secure judgements, with some link between rational
conclusions as to the extent to which tectonic hazards
created at convergent plate boundaries are the most
damaging to people compared with hazards created at other
plate boundaries.
Relevant concepts are discussed but this may lack some
authority.
Level 2 (7–12 marks)
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound analysis that shows some
accuracy of whether tectonic hazards created at convergent
plate boundaries are the most damaging to people
compared with hazards created at other plate boundaries.
Demonstrates reasonable application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a sound evaluation that offers
generalised judgements and conclusions, with limited use of
evidence as to the extent to which tectonic hazards created
at convergent plate boundaries are the most damaging to
people compared with hazards created at other plate
boundaries.
Concepts are discussed but their use lacks precision.
Level 1 (1–6 marks)
2.5m below ocean surface so hazards
limited
• Comparison with diverging boundaries
causing effusive eruptions occur here,
leading to shield volcanoes which are often
erupting under the ocean, and have little
effect on people.
• Earthquakes tend to be shallow with less
strength caused as magma rises through
the chamber and the vent.
• However, Eyafjallajökull, Iceland 2010 (VEI
4), which disrupted European airports shut
for several days in April 2010 costing
airlines £130 million a day, tourists
stranded, many goods spoiled as fruit and
flowers were left to rot in exporting nations
in Africa and the Caribbean.
• Comparison with hazards created at
conservative boundaries e.g. San Andreas
Fault. People here experience earthquakes
on a regular basis, in July 2019
earthquakes were occurring once a minute,
with one at 7.1, and one at 6.4 on the
Richter scale. No major impacts reported.
• Measures of ‘more damaging’ must be
linked to people e.g. accept environmental
impacts that are discussed in terms of use
by people e.g. recreation / tourism61
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide a simple analysis that shows limited
accuracy of whether tectonic hazards created at convergent
plate boundaries are the most damaging to people compared
with hazards created at other plate boundaries.
Demonstrates basic application of knowledge and
understanding to provide an un-supported evaluation that offers
simple conclusions as to the extent to which tectonic hazards
created at convergent plate boundaries are the most damaging
to people compared with hazards created at other plate
boundaries.
Concepts are not discussed or are so inaccurately.
0 marks
No response or no response worthy of credit.
Quality of extended response
Level 4
There is a well-developed line of reasoning which is clear and
logically structured. The information presented is relevant and
substantiated.
Level 3
There is a line of reasoning presented with some structure. The
information presented is in the most-part relevant and
supported by some evidence.
Level 2
The information has some relevance and is presented with
limited structure. The information is supported by limited
evidence.
Level 1
The information is basic and communicated in an unstructured
way. The information is supported by limited evidence and the
relationship to the evidence may not be clear.OCR (Oxford Cambridge and RSA Examinations)
The Triangle Building
Shaftesbury Road
Cambridge
CB2 8EA
[Show More]