Medicine
Evidence Based...
Doctors/ medical professionals decide what is best for the patient
The conscientious, explicit and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual
...
Medicine
Evidence Based...
Doctors/ medical professionals decide what is best for the patient
The conscientious, explicit and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients
Requires the integration of individual clinical expertise with the best available external clinical evidence from systemic research and our patient's unique values and circumstances
Practice
Evidence Based...
Doctors/ medical professionals decide what is best for the patient based on/ in accordance with the patient's request/wishes
An approach to decision making in which the clinician uses the best scientific evidence available, in consultation with the patient, to decide upon the option which suits the patient best
Patient is an active 'agent' in the decision-making process, collective discussion before a decision is made
Phase 1
Clinical Trial
Pharmacokinetics and toxicology trial → what happens to a drug in the body?
Phase 2
Clinical Trial
Different dosages and affect → what's the effect of different dosages?
Phase 3
Clinical trial
Effectiveness in comparison to standard therapies → is this better than what we've already got?
Phase 4
Clinical trial
Post-market monitoring → adverse effects, how does this affect various populations?
Avicenna
History of Drug Research and Evidence-based Medicines
Drug must have a specific mode of action
Must be tested on a well defined single disease
Time of action must be observed
The effect of the drug must occur constantly and not transient
Testing a drug on a lion or a horse might be different from its effect on man
Lind
History of Drug Research and Evidence-based Medicines
A Scottish physician, on board of HMS Salisbury, divided 12 sailors with scurvy into 6 groups of 2 sailors and given one of the following treatments:
Cider
Elixir vitriol
Vinegar
Seawater
Nutmeg plus a mixture of garlic and mustard
Fresh fruit (2 oranges and 1 lemon daily for 6 days)
“Propose nothing dictated merely from theory; but shall confirm all by experience and facts, the surest and most unerring of guides”
Recieving
... enquiries
Enquirer → layperson v Health
Care Professional
Time available → immediate v
Delayed
Other → legal issues, ethical issues, consequences of response
Classify
... enquiries
Stability and compatibility
Drug therapy (dose/indication etc)
Specific therapy areas (for extra information)
Antibiotics, psych, renal, paediatric, neonatal, oncology, immunisation, haematology
Formulae
Drug interactions
Foreign medications
Complementary medicines
Adverse drug reactions
Search strategies
Enquiries
Develop a search strategy based on the enquiry
Perform search strategy
Ensure validity of information acquired
Check reference
Time of update
Multiple references searched
Tertiary
Information sources
an index or textual consolidation of primary and secondary sources - textbooks, review articles
e.g. AusDI, MIMS online, AMH, eTG, MedicinesComplete etc
Secondary
Information sources
document or recording that relates or discusses information originally presented elsewhere - Abstracts, databases
Large databases → electronic searching essential
Type of database
Searching system used
Controlled vocabulary
Thesaurus
Term combining → BOOLEAN operators (e.g. using 'and' or 'or')
Primary
Information sources
Serves as an original source of information about the topic - original research publications
NMP; National medicines policy
Quality use of medicines→ how do you ensure that a patient is able to use their medicines correctly, appropriately and safely?
Provide appropriate advice and counselling to people around health, disease and medicine specific questions
PSA Competency Standards
Communicate respectfully and with tact
Express thoughts clearly
Use a communication style appropriate to the audience and the material
Check that information provided has been received and understood
Communication skills
Establish rapport with your patients (and colleagues)
Effective listening skills
Be able to ask open ended questions, and know when they are appropriate
Asked closed questions appropriately
Be able to summarise information received and given
Use lay language
Appropriate non-verbal language
Demonstrate empathy
Communication
Conferring through speech, writing, or non-verbal means (including body language) to create a shared meaning
2 way process→ ensuring that they understand you and you have understood them
Effective communication: when what people intended to say has been heard and the people involved have reached a point of shared meaning
Just because you have said it doesn't mean that the person has heard and understood it
Poor communication
Ignores customer calling out for assistance
Talks to another pharmacist whilst the customer is talking, multiple times
Questions whether the customer has heartburn, comparing it his own experience
Talks over the customer when she is giving him details of the patient
Asks the customer questions about the pain, despite her trying to tell him that it's not for her, and repeatedly asks without waiting for an answer→ poor questioner
Makes negative comments about a customer to another pharmacist as if she is not there
Inappropriate, unfriendly body language: hands on hips, leans on the table, hands up to assert superiority and to say that she is the one not listening
Missed her non-verbal cues of feeling ignored
Failed to summarise back to the patient what was heard, poor listener
Professional
Relationship type
Planned, formal- (e.g. specific health issues)Adaptive to the client's needs
Educational
Often brief and short term, can be superficial
Uses technical language
Often less self disclosure
Different boundaries to a friendship, i.e. confidentiality ethical and privacy issues covered by law
Potential power imbalance
Social
Relationship type
Spontaneous or planned
Focused on your needs, not the pharmacists (e.g. cheaper for patient, not more money for pharmacy)
Language less formal, technical but can be jargonised, i.e. use of text (c u @ 6)
Often involves a deeper level of self disclosure and intimacy
Can last for many years
Choice, you can't choose your patients
Agressive
Behavioural style
Does not respect rights, beliefs, values of others
Physically and/ or verbally dominating→ verbal and body language
E.g. interrupts, loud, ‘stand-over’ tactics, blames, criticizes, threatening
Example: What would an aggressive senior pharmacist speaking to a junior pharmacist who has made a dispensing error sound and look like? What sorts of things would they say?
Questions what the junior knows
Blame the junior without hearing what happened
Demeaning, rude language: e.g. you’re never going to be a good pharmacist
Yelling, invade personal space
Assertive
Behavioural style
Respects rights beliefs, values of self and others
Use ‘i’ statements
Expect to be respected and respects others
Willing to communicate
‘Own’ their feelings and ideas
Example: What would an assertive senior pharmacist speaking to a junior pharmacist who has made a dispensing error sound and look like? What sorts of things would they say?
Asks what went wrong
Figures out how they can help their junior learn for next time
“I'd like to find out what's happened and how i can help you prevent this from happening again”
No blaming, though will be more assertive to them doing wrong if it occurs repeatedly
Passive
Behavioural style
Belief that do not have the right to express own thoughts and beliefs
Will 'do as told'
Allow others to make decisions/choices
Active listening
Body language
Eye contact
‘Interest’! (alertness, focus on patient)
Open body (e.g. no crossed arms)
Smiles, looks of concern where appropriate
a careful and attentive listener
Picks up differences in words vs body language
Reads ‘between the lines’
Can identify and summarise (paraphrase) key points
Summarising/ Paraphrasing
Ensures that patient and pharmacist are on ‘the same page’
E.g. “so just let me check that i’ve got this right… you’ve been having these symptoms for about a week and the pain has slowly worsened, especially when eating since you started this new medication”
Empathy
Crucial to building effective therapeutic alliance
Involves an ‘attitude’ as well as ‘action’
Not the same as sympathy (don’t pity them)
Attitude
To attempt to share the experience of the other
Some emotional identification with the experience
Non-judgemental and non-evaluative
To be genuine
To be open to the experience of others
Action
Communicate your understanding
Active listening: asking open ended questions, conveying interest and concern, acknowledging concerns
Provide active and practical support where possible
Problem solve issues; e.g.
Home delivery of medicines if patient/ carer incapacitated
Referral to community health centre/ physician
Organisation of hire of aids etc. not available through your pharmacy
Open questions
Open ended
Encourage patient to respond in their own way
Encourage elaboration and help people to expand on what they have said
Useful when gathering information about the patient’s ‘story’
Examples
“Tell me about any over the counter medicines you are taking now”
“Describe your symptoms”
“Tell me about the hay fever medications you’ve used in the past”
“Apart from medications, what else do you currently do to help your headaches?”
Note: avoid ‘why’ questions → criticism, value judgement
Close questions
A question which is direct and close-ended
Requires single word reply by respondent (e.g. yes/no)
Enables the provision of specific information
Good to ask at the end of the interaction
Be careful → can ‘prevent’ patients from disclosing accurate information, e.g. “Do you know how to use your nasal spray?” INSTEAD → “If you have your puffer with you, could you please show me how you use it?”
Examples
“Are you taking any medications at the moment?”
“What type of antihistamine do you currently use?”
“How long have you been using this?”
Benefits
... of patient-focused communication
Patients will come back, trusting the pharmacist and feeling understood
All of the patient's questions have been answered
Patient is informed more of their disease and how different medications could help them
Skills checklist
Introduces self
Puts the focus of attention on the speaker
Demonstrates attentive body language
Uses open ended questions
Uses closed questions
Avoids judgemental comments
Demonstrates patience
Does not talk about themselves
Summarises what has been said
Repeats final instructions/ decisions
WWHAM
Assessment questions
W → Who is the patient?
W → What are the symptoms?
H → How long have the symptoms been presented?
A → Action taken? Allergies?
M → Medication being taken? Medical history?
WWHAM analysis
Advantages and Disadvantages
Establishes the presenting complaint and what the patient has done about it
Fails to consider
General appearance
Social/ lifestyle factors
Family history
Previous symptoms
Doesn’t provide information to ensure safe supply
Literature→ WWHAM protocol correlates with appropriate non-prescription medication supply in the UK, more questions= more appropriate outcomes
ASMETHOD
Assessment questions
A→ Age/ appearance
S→ Self or someone else?
M→ Medication?
E→ Extra medicines?
T→ Time persisting?
H→ History?
O→ Other Symptoms?
D→ Danger Symptoms?
What Stop Go
Assessment questions
Who is the patient?
How long have symptoms been present?
Actual symptoms – what are they?
Treatment for this or any other condition?
Symptoms or side effects caused by other conditions/meds?
Totally sure – any special patient needs or circumstances?
Overuse/Abuse – how often has the patient been taking the medication or self-treating?
Pharmacist Only – always refer to the pharmacist.
GO – supply medicine if appropriate and provide advice
ASMETHOD analysis
Establishes presenting complaint, AND if the patient has had it before
Exact symptoms and severity?
No social/ lifestyle factors? Family history?
Sit Down Sir
S→ Site or location
I→ Intensity or severity
T→ Type or nature
D→ Duration
O→ Onset
W→ With? (other symptoms)
N→ Annoyed or aggravated (????)
S→ Spread or radiation
I→ Incidence or frequency, pattern?
R→ Relieved by?
Sit Down Sir analysis
Establishes severity, nature and previous history
More details elicited?
No social/ lifestyle factors? Family history?
Does not consider general appearance
communication barriers
The physical environment
Counters
Beds
Noise/interruptions
Pharmacist
Attitudes and prejudices
Poor communications skills
Patient
Attitudes, lack of knowledge or understanding
Communications skills
Interruptions
Other patients
Staff
Phones
Prescriptions pressure
Communication solutions
Come out from behind the counter
Sit next to the bed, don't stand
Privacy??
Find a corner
Draw the curtain
Sit down if at all possible for counselling
'One thing at a time'
Pharmacist barriers
Disinterest
Devalues efficacy of good communications skills
Lack of confidence
Absence of skills
Lack of practice
Time/other work pressures
Embarrassment talking about sensitive/ personal issues
Jargon
Communicating with patients who are cognitively impaired
Temporary or permanent impairment
Mental health (depression; schizophrenia)
Pharmacist solutions
Get comfortable
The more you talk about it the less embarrassed you will be
Get informed
Learn about how mental health issues, stroke or dementia can impair patient cognition
Use communication aids
Verbal + written
Include carers/family members
Patient barriers
Poor interpersonal skills in communication
Too busy/in a rush
Does not perceive potential value of pharmacist based care
Physical/intellectual/social disabilities
Language difficulties
Literacy
Health literacy
Patient solutions
Adopting a patient-focused approach to communications helps to prevent the patient
Feeling they are wasting your time
Omitting details they deem unimportant
Embarrassment at mentioning things they think will place them in an unfavourable light
Not understanding medical terms
Believing you haven't really listened
Care
[Show More]