Latest 100% correct PS154KW-W20-
Syllabus-Writing Course-US
Government in Comparative
Perspective (MSTB 226-2-3.20)
.docClass Information
Instructor Information
Bernard GROFMAN
Email:
[email protected]
Phone: (949) 824-5143 (but I will only be answering this phone during my office hours)
DO NOT LEAVE MESSAGES ON THAT PHONE. USE E-MAIL INSTEAD! When
you do put send me messages PS154 as the first part of the heading so that I will know it
is course related. While I am happy to meet students, if you have questions or problems,
before you contact me please try to ask the TA for help first.
Office Location: Social Sciences Plaza B, Rm 5291
Office Hours: Tuesday, Thursday 3.45-4.50 and by (e-mail) appointment
TA Information:
Alexandra Marr;
[email protected] Thursdays 12:30-1:30 in SST 363 or by (e-mail)
appointment.
Samuel Morgan
[email protected] Wednesdays 11:00-12:00 in SST 663 and by
appointment (e-mail).
Course Overview
This course provides an introduction to the United States in comparative
perspective as a means to develop student writing skills. The goal is to improve ability to
synthesize information and research in drafting research papers and presentations and for
other types of writing, such as executive summaries. Skills needed for writing researchpapers and making presentations, such as outlining, spelling and grammar check tools in
WORD, bibliographic search and using library and on-line resources for research
purposes, structuring and formatting papers, and use of PowerPoint for presentations will
be emphasized. I will also work with students on vocabulary building and in reviewing
grammatical rules. I will also discuss literary devices that are common in writing
intended to persuade, such as similes, analogies, allusions, and synechdoches, as well as
presentational devices such as alliteration, so as to help students effectively add such
devices to their rhetorical repertoire. And I will identify rhetorical tricks often used in
persuasive writing but that are to be avoided in academic writing, such as ad hominem
attacks, appeals to emotion, and hyperbole, as well as discuss the fundamentals of
syllogistic logic. In addition I will discuss how to write essays that make use of numerical
information (e.g., creating summary tables and figures).1
REQUIRED READING
Paul Quirk (ed.), The U.S. and Canada, Oxford University Press, 2019
(available for purchase at the bookstore; but suggested instead for purchase on Amazon
Kindle) will serve as the main textbook, and will be read in its entirety. It primarily will
be used for writing assignments that require you to carefully read and clearly
summarize/outline various chapters in it, and the instructor will also draw on it for lecture
material. Read chapters as assigned.
SUGGESTED READING
Taylor, Shugart, Lijphart and Grofman, A Different Democracy: U.S.
Government in Comparative Perspective: Yale, 2014 (abbreviated TSLG) is
suggested but not required additional reading . Some of my lecture material will be
drawn from this book, and it provides a general reference for how both the U.S. and
Canada and your assigned country compare to other nations vis-à-vis institutional
1 For this purpose, material from Jane E. Miller, The Chicago Guide to Writing about
Numbers. University of Chicago Press, 2004 will be discussed by the instructor.features. It available for purchase at the bookstore; but suggested instead for purchase
on Amazon Kindle.
Dahl, Robert. How Democratic is the U.S. Constitution? Yale University
Press, 2001 is suggested but not required additional reading. It available for purchase at
the bookstore; suggested instead for purchase on Amazon Kindle.
READING ASSIGNMENTS FROM QUIRK
week QUIRK
1 1
2 2, 9
3 11
4 3
5 4
6 reread 4
7 6
8 5, 7
9 8, 10
10 12
I will often lecture using PowerPoints to outline the lecture topics, though my oral
presentation will add considerable material not in the PowerPoints. Previous week’s
PowerPoints will normally be posted to the website within one week from my lecture.
THE INSTRUCTOR’S CLASS LECTURE POWERPOINTS AND OTHERLECTURE NOTES SHOULD ALSO BE REGARDED AS REQUIRED
(re)READING.
Substantive content of the course
The organization of the substantive component of the course is in terms of three
aspects of national differences: values, institutions and public policies (the VIP
principle). I also sometimes present results in terms of the VIIIP principle, with the extra
I’s being “ideas” and “interests. After the week 1 general introduction, weeks 2-3 focus
on values; weeks 4-7 on institutions, and weeks 8-9 on policies, with week 10 providing
an overview and wrap-up.
As noted above, Quirk is the textbook . A central focus of the chapters in Quirk is
on similarities and differences between the U.S. and Canada. Week 1 we focus on how to
make comparisons and on the concept of exceptionalism. Week 2 we deal with political
culture and values. Week 3 we look at issues of race, citizenship and immigration. Week
4 we look at elections, Week 5 we will identify some basic features of institutional
design, and provide some overview data about general features of institutions in the
United States and other countries, and look specifically at how executives are organized.
Week 6 we look in more detail at constitutional choices, and discuss legislative structure.
Week 7 we consider the basic structure of governments, with a comparison of federal and
unitary systems. Week 8 begins our discussion of policy choice. We will pay particular
attention to the interrelated “puzzles” of U.S. exceptionalism with respect to low
proportion of GDP collected in taxes by government and low share of government
spending devoted to social welfare. Week 9 looks at specific policy arenas, with a focus
on environment and health. Week 10 will deal with patterns of institutional choices that
allow us to categorize countries into different types, focusing on the two-dimensional
typology offered by Lijphart (1999) and attempts to modify or replace that typology, and
we also look at issues in international politics such as the notion of the U.S. as an empire,
and America’s changing place in the world economy.HOMEWORKS and IN-CLASS EXERCISES
Each student is assigned one country from the list of 30 whose institutions and
policies are covered in TSLG and comparisons between that country, the U.S. and
Canada, will be the basis of near weekly assignments. You must pick one country
from the three options given and inform the TAs and the instructor by e-mail which
country you have chosen by the end of the first week. The number you use is the 2nd
digit of your student ID.
0 Australia, Austria, Belgium
1 Columbia, Denmark, France
2 Finland, Germany, Switzerland
3. Greece, India, Israel
4. Italy, Japan, Netherlands
5. Portugal, Spain, Sweden
6. Switzerland, UK, Argentina
7. Brazil, Chile, Czech Republic
8. Hungary, Mexico, Poland
9. South Africa, South Korea, UK
In addition to (near weekly) assignments from Quirk in which you will be
required to outline the material in a chapter in that volume, additional homework
assignments may be based on sources such as the Federalist Papers, presidential
speeches, and essays and op-eds from sources such as the Washington Post and the
Wall Street Journal, or Politico and the Daily Signal, dealing with contemporary political
issues from different ideological points of view. Readings will be used to create writing
assignments that emphasize and develop particular writing skills. (Co-authoring is
increasingly common in the social sciences and it is a useful skill to be familiar with both
in terms of its advantages and disadvantages, and I may assign one writing assignment
as a team project.)There will be four main types of writing assignments in this class.
(1) short assignments asking you identify features of your country and to
compare those to the U.S. and Canada. Later in the course these assignments may also
contain a second portion requiring a short essay addressing the question of whether value
or institutional differences among the countries might explain other differences (e.g., in
policy outcomes) between your country and the other two.
I provide below an illustrative example of such a writing assignment.
Illustrative Short Answer and Short Essay Writing Assignment
Party Competition
PART I
1. What are the major political parties in your country’s last election?
2. Which of these parties is in the governing coalition in your country?
3 Is there a “populist” (anti-immigrant, anti-foreigner, or anti-EU) party in
your country? If so, what has been the trajectory of its vote support over the last
few elections?
4. More generally, in no more than a paragraph or two, explain how the party
system in your country has changed over the entire Post-WWII period or, for new
democracies, in the period since democratization .
PART II
5. Write a short essay (2-4 paragraphs) in which you compare the results for
your country for questions 3 and 4 with what you have learned about the U.S.
and Canada and answer the question of why you think that these cross-country
differences occur.
In particular, would you say that the reasons for the differences you find
stem primarily from a difference in values, or differences in institutions, or
something else, such as a difference in political history?
This essay can be as few as two or three paragraphs, but it can also be longer.