M
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 1 of 62
Week 4: The Cold War - Discussion
The Cold War: Who Shot First? (graded)
...
M
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 1 of 62
Week 4: The Cold War - Discussion
The Cold War: Who Shot First? (graded)
The United States accused the Soviet Union of breaking all its wartime pledges and holding Eastern Europe
hostage while trying to subvert governments in the west. The Soviet Union accused the US and its allies of
trying surround and ultimately destroy it. War of words? Or was somebody telling the truth? And where do
our 'Isms' fit in? In particular nationalism?
Responses
Response Author Date/Time
Causes of the Cold War Professor Jones 5/20/2016 12:37:56 PM
As we begin our discussion of the Cold War, we want to begin first by focusing on why this event
happened. After two world wars, the world fell into another conflict. Why?
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Marguerite Fogham 5/22/2016 7:55:51 AM
Modified:5/22/2016 8:07 AM
WWII had a devastating effect on the world. Leaving millions dead in its wake. It
also left two of the most powerful superpowers the world has ever seen. Both
superpowers having the most powerful weapons ever to exist on Earth. This situation
would be tense under the best of circumstances, but with the opposing views between
the United States and The USSR, the atmosphere was absolutely hostile. “Stalin's
insistence on maintaining a Soviet sphere of influence would dictate American policy
for the next forty years.” (CCN, 2016). The world was torn between the spheres of
influence of the two superpowers. The citizens of the world, waited with their breath
held, having witnessed the destruction wrought by two of these weapons. The
possibly of dozens or even hundreds of them raining down, filled these times with
melancholy.
References
CCN, 2016
Chamberlain School of Nursing (CSN), (2016): Lesson 4: The Cold War and the
Struggle for Freedom
RE: Causes of theTopic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 2 of 62
Cold War
Muhammad Ghaffar 5/22/2016 10:34:48 PM
Modified:5/22/2016 10:48 PM
Professor and class,
The Cold War was an ideological confrontation between the Liberal Democratic, Capitalist,Free
Market Economy West (led by USA), and the Totalitarian,Communist, Command Economy
Eastern Bloc (led by the Soviet Union).
Each side wanted to impose their social model as the dominant one globally.
The Cold War began as WW2 ended; Stalin didn't keep promises made at the Yalta Conference
(February 1945) about holding free elections in countries occupied by the Soviet Army at the
end of WW2. Instead, pro Russian Communist puppet governments were set up in these
countries by force. USA therefore decided that Stalin and the Soviet Union couldn't be trusted.
USA refused to share A-bomb technology with the Soviet Union.This scared the Russians, who
thought the USA might launch a nuclear attack on Russia while they still had a monopoly on
such weapons. Stalin therefore decided USA couldn't be trusted.
Muhammad
Brower, Daniel R., Sanders, T. (07/2013). The World in the
Twentieth Century, 7th Edition.
[VitalSource Bookshelf Online]. Retrieved from
https://devry.vitalsource.com/#/books/9781323183472/
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/23/2016 6:00:15 AM
Some would argue the most significant cause of the Cold War was not the
ideological enmity between the US and the USSR but the existence of nuclear
weapons and the use of the same by the US in war. How important were nuclear
weapons to the Cold War? Could the Cold War have happened without them?
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Rebekah Kang 5/24/2016 11:05:48 AM
Professor,
I agree that the nuclear weapons was a significant cause of theTopic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 3 of 62
Cold War. Both the US and the USSR were nuclear armed powerful
nations fighting to the world super power. Nuclear force was key to
establish dominance over the other and it created problems. I
think if either only the US or the USSR had been nuclear armed, or
neither, this Cold War would still have happened. Both nations
were were competing so intensely to become the World Super
Power.
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Nnenna Brown 5/29/2016 3:01:00 PM
Hello Rebekah,
You are correct in stating that both nations were in battle for
leadership dominance and power.Nuclear weapons possed a
great threat in the line of defense and both nations had the
power to release the weapon.The Cold War was destined to
happen, do to desire to control and have power. The battle of
the nations was one that would effect all the people in a
negative way.
Thank you,
Nne-Nna
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Muhammad Ghaffar 5/24/2016 8:35:44 PM
Professor and class,
Both sides had sufficient nuclear arsenals to destroy one another. Each
was assured that any nuclear attack would result in a nuclear counter
attack which they could not survive. So there was a very strong
incentive to not start an open war between the two great powers. There
were small scale proxy wars like Vietnam and Afghanistan, but for the
most part the cold war remained cold because of mutually assured
destruction, which was only possible with massive arsenals of readily
usable nuclear weapons.Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 4 of 62
The reason that the cold war never went hot, in other words all out
fighting between Russia and the West was because both sides had loads
of nuclear weapons of all kinds pointed at each other.
This was known as "mutually assured destruction".
In other words if one side started something they could destroy the
other but would be destroyed themselves. If either side had not had the
atom bomb then a third world war would have most probably broken
out in the 50's or 60's. Perversely therefore nuclear weapons probably
stopped a war from happening, and saved millions of lives.
Muhammad
Brower, Daniel R., Sanders, T. (07/2013). The World in the Twentieth
Century, 7th Edition.
[VitalSource Bookshelf Online]. Retrieved from
https://devry.vitalsource.com/#/books/9781323183472/
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/25/2016 5:48:22 AM
Another term associated with the Cold War was mutually
assured destruction as you note. The acronym for this is MAD.
Hmmm...One might argue this is a telling acronym and
perhaps an appropriate one.
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Amanda Poppen 5/25/2016 5:36:22 PM
Greetings Professor Jones and classmates,Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 5 of 62
Maybe the existence of nuclear weapons that motivated the Cold
War between the US and USSR actually prevented the onset of
another large scale world war. If there were no nuclear weapons,
perhaps the ideological enmity between the US and USSR would
have been exacerbated and resulted in a hot war.
Best regards,
Mandy
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Andrea Whetsell 5/26/2016 7:35:20 AM
Hi Mandy,
Great post! I definitely agree that the existence of nuclear
weapons, which motivated the Cold War, perhaps prevented a
"hot war" as you stated. As we know, neither side held
confidence in the other, and the possibility of a "what if"
perhaps spared many lives.
Andrea
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/26/2016 1:09:38 PM
Certainly the idea that was at least for some that
there was or is a nuclear deterrent. That said, one
might argue this is or was an alarming idea.
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Lakisha Williams 5/23/2016 2:21:21 PM
Modified:5/23/2016 2:23 PM
Hello Professor and class. The cold war was a result of fear and distrust between the
United States and the USSR. They were known as the superpowers after WWII. Each
feared attack by the other, and each side wanted to make their way of life more
dominant than the others. According to Brower & Sanders (2014) the term Cold War
"captured the ominous character of the hostile relations between the two sides, not
actually at war but mobilizing their military and diplomatic forces in anticipation of a new
conflict in Europe" (p. 192).Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 6 of 62
Thank You, Lakisha
Brower, D.R. & Sanders, T. (2014). The World in the Twentieth Century: From
Empires to Nations (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson.
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/23/2016 11:06:48 PM
The US actually had and used nuclear weapons before the Soviets had them.
Does this suggest the Soviets got nuclear weapons to preempt American action
against them?
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Rebekah Kang 5/27/2016 3:22:37 AM
Professor,
I think this may be called the nuclear arms race. The US created the
first nuclear weapons during WWII to use against the Axis powers. In
result, the scientists of the Soviet Union did research and saw the
potential of nuclear weapons and created them. So yes, this suggests
that the Soviets got nuclear weapons to preempt American action agains
them.
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/28/2016 12:52:15 PM
This might make the US at fault. Hmmm...
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Dana Allen 5/24/2016 8:42:38 PM
The Cold War was the geopolitical, ideological, and economic struggle between two world
superpowers, the USA and the USSR, that started in 1947 at the end of the Second World
War and lasted until the dissolution of the Soviet Union on December 26, 1991. The Cold
War was marked by continuous rivalry between the two former World War II allies.Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 7 of 62
http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2013/11/cold-war-start-end/
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Tasia Thomas 5/24/2016 9:59:09 PM
The world fell into another conflict for many different reasons. America was afraid of the
communist trying to take over. Truman didn't like Stalin and America also refused to share
nuclear secrets. USSR expanded into Eastern Europe when they weren't suppose to. USSR
was afraid of the atomic bomb.
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/25/2016 5:50:17 AM
I used the phrase fell into conflict to attempt not to lead us to the idea that the
Cold War was necessarily a deliberate choice. That said, one might argue it most
certainly was a deliberate choice by some. Do you think some in the US or the
USSR or even other countries deliberately led us into the Cold War. First, is this a
fair argument and who would you blame for the deliberate choice?
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Kendra Cardoza 5/24/2016 10:01:02 PM
Professor and class,
After WW2, the only two countries who came out remaining powerful was Russia and the
USA. Because of this, they both viewed each other as a potential threat. Until this point,
countries were constantly looking for expansion, to grow and take over other countries,
and form colonies. Because of this, "..Soviet sphere of influence would dictate American
policy for the next forty years" (CCN, 2016). Our lesson states, "..America was to
constrain Russia's expansionist tendencies through a policy of containment" (CCN, 2016).
Although it did not appear that Russia's goal was to try to take over America, they would
definitely and most understandably be attempting to increase their weaponry, atomic
bombs. Especially after America had just dropped two bombs in Japan to win the war. The
United States and Russia would continue strategically backing one another into a corner
with the option of war if the other did not comply for over forty years.
Thanks,
Kendra
Chamberlain College of Nursing. (2016). HIST 410 Contemporary History. Week 4.
Downers Grove, IL: DeVry Education Group.Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 8 of 62
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Nadia Nimbona 5/25/2016 12:18:54 AM
The Cold War was marked by continuous rivalry between the two former
World War II allies. Conflict spanned from subtle espionage in the biggest cities of
the world to violent combat in the tropical jungles of Vietnam. One of the earliest
events in the origin of the Cold War arose from the anti-Communism remarks of
British leader Winston Churchill (Theodoros, 2013). For example, In Greece, the
Cold War with the revolutionary uprising by the strong guerrilla movement of Greek
Communist Party. In 1946, it had to mobilize its troops, arm and train in the war
against the Germans, in a civil war to seize power from the conservative government.
In the end the Greek Communists took inspiration and received military aid from
Tito’s communist regime in Yugoslavia (Brower & Sanders, 2013).
Nadia
References:
Brower, Daniel R., Sanders, T. (07/2013). The World in the Twentieth Century, 7th
Edition. [VitalSource Bookshelf Online]. Retrieved from
https://devry.vitalsource.com/#/books/9781323183472/
Theodoros II. (2013, November 12). How Did the Cold War Start and End? Retrieved
May 25, 2016, from http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2013/11/coldwar-start-end/
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/25/2016 5:51:28 AM
We often see the Cold War described as a conflict between capitalism and
communism. Of course, the USSR was not the only communist country in the
world. What about China? What was her role in the Cold War?Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 9 of 62
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Brittney Yontz 5/29/2016 6:55:15 PM
China had a good relationship with the US during the cold war. Reagan
worked hard to maintain their relationship. It was toward the end of the
cold war when they had put up the Berlin wall when their relationship
started to go down hill.
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Alivea VanDyke 5/25/2016 10:11:37 AM
The United States and Soviet Union worked together during WWll against the Axis Powers.
Although they worked as allies, it was a disagreeing one. They didn't believe in the same
views or the powers of one another's. America didn't want to involve the USSR as part of
the community and the Soviet Union did not like that. Tension rose and mutual distrust
became. America thought Russia was taking over as the Soviet Union expanded. It was a
very hostile environment. After all this, the Cold War began.
History.com Staff. (2009). Cold War History. Retrieved May 25, 2016, from
http://www.history.com/topics/cold-war/cold-war-history
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/26/2016 1:10:29 PM
Ah, the enemy of my enemy is my friend scenario. One wonders how solid such
a "friendship" might be. Hmmm..
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Kendra Cardoza 5/28/2016 10:36:04 PM
Hi Alivea,
I think it's amazing that they were able to work together to accomplish many
things including winning ww2. Our book states, "What is remarkable about the
USSR in the Second World War, though, is the extent of voluntary participation
and sacrifice" (Brower, Sanders, 2013, p. 174). It shows how even though you
can be completely different, have many disagreements, you can still work
together professionally to work toward a common goal. A lot of people have a
hard time doing such a thing in the work atmosphere, imagine having to do that
when it comes to such a large war!
Thanks,Topic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…scending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 10 of 62
Kendra
Brower, Daniel R., (2013). The World in The Twentieth Century, 7th Edition.
Retrieved from http https://decry.vitalsource.com/#/books/9781323183472/
RE:
Causes
of the
Cold
War
Professor Jones 5/29/2016 6:24:27 AM
Both the US and the USSR were brought into WW2 by invasion. The
Japanese attacked the US and the USSR invaded by its alleged ally
Germany. This might explain part of the degree of participation in the
war.
RE: Causes of the
Cold War Harpreeth Kamdar 5/25/2016 2:40:28 PM
Modified:5/26/2016 12:08 PM
Prof Jones and classmates,
I believe that if I were to explain the whole conflict in a sentence, it would be a complete
lack of trust and the fundamental difference in the governing Ideology between the united
states and Russia.
In 1945 the Cold War began and lasted about 45 years. There were no direct military
campaigns between the two main antagonists, the United States and the Soviet Union. Yet
billions of dollars and millions of lives were lost in the fight(ushistory.org, copy right
2016).
The US did not agree with the communist rule in Russia and were afraid that communism
may take root in the US, the Businesses and Industry were very vary of that. The US had
become very successful and the economic conditions in US were much better than that of
Russia. America and its allies struggled to keep the communist, totalitarian Soviet Union
from expanding into Europe, Asia, and Africa. Theaters as remote as Korea and Vietnam,
Cuba and Grenada, Afghanistan and Angola, became battlegrounds between the two
ideologies (ushistory.org, copy right 2016).
There was hostility on the Soviet side as well. Twenty million Russian citizens perished
during World War II. Stalin was enraged that the Americans and British had waited so long
to open a front in France. This would have relieved pressure on the Soviet Union from the
attacking Germans. Further, The United States terminated Lend-Lease aid to the Soviet
Union before the war was complete. Finally, the Soviet Union believed in
communism(ushistory.org, copy right 2016).
Reference:
http://www.ushistory.org/us/52a.aspTopic Print View 6/6/16, 10:39 PM
http://threadcontent.next.ecollege.com/(NEXT(3c3bee7f86e642b292f…Ascending&isViewSelected=False&checkedIds=&isPrntVwSortReq=False Page 11 of 62
RE: Causes
of the Cold
War
Lydia Lebron 5/25/2016 11:30:36 PM
Hello Harpreeth I really enjoyed reading your post very informative and detailed. I also
agree with you US was very successful and was in a better economic conditions then
Russia. Look forward to your future posting.
Thanks
Lydia Lebron
-
-
-
-
Continued
[Show More]