Laws3100 T05 Xinyu Pu 43973099
1 At SAFPL, the relationship between David and Jason is becoming very acrimonious. David
says to Jason that he should ‘stop making trouble’ in the company. David is confident that
Patric
...
Laws3100 T05 Xinyu Pu 43973099
1 At SAFPL, the relationship between David and Jason is becoming very acrimonious. David
says to Jason that he should ‘stop making trouble’ in the company. David is confident that
Patricia and Nick will always support him in decisions relating to the company and that
(because Steven never attends meetings of SAFPL) he will always have enough votes to
control the general meeting. So David tells Jason that if he keeps making trouble he will ask
his siblings to approve the transfer of the profitable durum wheat business to a new
company, in which the Henry grandchildren have no financial interest. Could David, Patricia
and Nick pass such a resolution at a general meeting of SAFPL?
No, because of the equitable limitation on majority voting power. The laws will endeavour to
prevent the following actions:
Amend the company's constitution in a way that disadvantage the minority
Alter the share capital of the company in a way that disadvantages the minority
Vote to approve the sales of assets of the company to themselves at a price which is
below that of the market value of the assets
Amend the company's constitution with the objectives of forcing the minority to sell
some or all of their shares at an unfair price
Vote to approve certain benefits to themselves that are not available to the minority
Where the court finds that the majority has breached the equitable limitation , the action of
the majority is invalid.
2 An AMGL beneficiary owns 92% of the issued shares in a company called Tech Ltd. The
remaining 8% of the shares are held by five individuals, including a Mr Owen who owns 0.5%
of the issued shares. Mr Owen is a high profile individual who has at times been critical of
the Chinese government’s activities in the South China Sea. AMGL is concerned that its
ongoing association (through Tech) with Mr Owen may harm its prospects in the new China
venture. At a meeting of Tech, a resolution is passed amending the constitution of Tech, to
allow any member who was entitled to at least 90% of the issued shares of Tech to acquire
compulsorily the shares of any other member at a price of $20.00 per share. Tech shares
have recently been valued by an independent expert at $15.78. Mr Owen does not attend
this meeting and the majority shareholder (AMGL) does not vote. The resolution is passed
unanimously by the four other minority shareholders. Mr Owen is challenging the validity of
the amendment. Having regard to the decision in Gambotto, will his challenge succeed?
Yes. Based on the decision on Gambotto, The High Court laid down new tests that apply in
determining the validity of amendments to the constitution of a company where those
amendments give rise to conflict between members. Those tests distinguish between two
categories.
1. Where amendments to a constitution are proposed that, if passed, allow expropriation
by the majority of the shares of the minority or of valuable proprietary rights attached to
the shares.
2. Where amendments to the constitution are proposed that involve conflicts of interest
but do not involve expropriation.
This study source was downloaded by 100000819946675 from CourseHero.com on 03-26-2021 03:58:41 GMT -05:00
https://www.coursehero.com/file/32610215/Tutorial-5-week-6-questionsdocx/
This study resource was
shared via Course
[Show More]