Laws3100 T05 Xinyu Pu 43973099
1 At SAFPL, David remains concerned about the level of dissent and discontent Jason is stirring up among the
Henry grandchildren. He decides to contact Steven and offer to acquire Steven’
...
Laws3100 T05 Xinyu Pu 43973099
1 At SAFPL, David remains concerned about the level of dissent and discontent Jason is stirring up among the
Henry grandchildren. He decides to contact Steven and offer to acquire Steven’s shares in SAFPL. As
managing director, David knows there is a good chance that the company will soon enter into a supply
agreement with a major food processor in the United States that will greatly enhance the value of the
business. He believes now is the right time to make an offer for Steven’s shares, before the deal is finalised
and announced. David knows that, as a director of SAFPL, he owes duties to the company. But does he owe
any duties to Steven in these circumstances?
2 JV Investor Pty Ltd is 50% owned by AMGL. In 2009, AMGL was approached by Blue Ltd, the other
shareholder in JV Investor, to make a further major investment in JV Investor, to enable it to develop a new
and highly prospective technology based on blockchain. The then directors of AMGL delegated to others,
including a computer expert, the task of obtaining the technical information about the prospects of the
technology. The report prepared for the directors indicates that the proposed investment should be very
successful. Queried by his fellow directors about the optimistic forecasts, Mr Chester (who has an
information technology qualification) assures them that all appears to be in order. However, some of the
information has been negligently prepared. This means that, when the directors rely on the report and
invest AMGL’s funds in the technology, the investment will not be as successful as the report indicates.
Have the directors of AMGL (or any of them) breached their duty of care?
3 Gina Gunter is the company secretary and general counsel of AMGL. In 2009, she was the executive
responsible for conducting the negotiations with JV Investor and Blue Ltd. She formulated the proposal
that came to the AMGL board, supervised the due diligence, retained the IT experts and settled the
relevant contracts. She was an enthusiastic supporter of the project and was keen to ‘get it done’. Did Ms
Gunter owe a duty of care to AMGL? To JV Investor? If so, did she breach that duty?
4 Once the problems with JV investor become apparent, AMGL’s advisers prepare a draft notice to be sent to
the ASX in compliance with AMGL’s continuous disclosure obligations under ASX Listing Rule 3.1. The
notice states that disappointing results at the JV Investor project are not expected to impact on AMGL’s
financial performance for the relevant year. In fact, this is not correct, and this would have been apparent
from a careful reading of the monthly management accounts and projections. The directors of AMGL say
that they never saw the draft notice and, if they had seen it, they would not have approved it. However
the board minutes suggest that the directors saw and approved the notice. It is sent to the ASX
immediately after the board meeting. The directors do nothing to correct the notice once it is released.
Have the directors (or any of them) breached their duty of care?
[Show More]