Hypothetical Development
Approach
Feasibility StudiesThe feasibility assessments of a proposed project
can be determined using either the;
q Hypothetical Development Approach
q Discounted Cash Flow Approach
Develo
...
Hypothetical Development
Approach
Feasibility StudiesThe feasibility assessments of a proposed project
can be determined using either the;
q Hypothetical Development Approach
q Discounted Cash Flow Approach
Development FeasibilityHDA (Profit & Risk / Development Margin)
Vs
Discounted Cash Flow (Discount Rate / IRR)
The developer is purchasing a property today which will be sold in 2
years time - Assume all development costs occur at the time of
purchase.
Today Year 1 Year 2
Present Value $100,000 Future Value $120,000
Future Revenue $ 120,000
Present Cost $ 100,000
Investment Term 2 Years
1. Development Margin 20%
2. Discount Rate (IRR) 9.54%Residual Land Value (RLV)
The Residual Land Value is the maximum price that a hypothetical
developer would pay for the land to achieve acceptable returns
based on the most probable development option for the land.
Two primary methods of calculating the RLV are:
1. Hypothetical Development method; and
2. Discounted Cash Flow methodPROFIT & RISK FACTOR
The PROFIT & RISK FACTOR
• is the desired DEVELOPMENT PROFIT expressed as a percentage of
DEVELOPMENT COSTS
• in retail contexts we would simply call this factor a MARK UP on COST
However
• We deduct non (developer) funded selling costs from Gross Realisation to
calculate the Net Realisation – these costs are selling costs which are paid
from the purchaser’s deposit moneys on settlement (usually whole or part of
the agents & solicitors fees for transacting the sale to the end purchaser/s)
• we add interest charges into the development cost calculation assuming
100% borrowing of development costsUsing HDA method to determine Site Value
• Often we use the Hypothetical Development Method to estimate the
raw value of a site or development opportunity
• Usually we are considering the purchase of the site
• In order to complete the HDA calculations we need to know
• The Profit & Risk Factor (or Development Margin) that the prospective
purchaser needs to achieve to be interested in taking on the development
• NOTE: The smaller / faster / simpler the proposed development, generally the
lower that P&R or DM factor will be - as the development risks are lower and
additionally a greater number of people will have the skills and financial resources
to undertake the development – these factors lead to greater competition to
purchase the siteSAMPLE - HDA APPROACH TO CALCULATE RESIDUAL LAND VALUE
GROSS REALISATION
Settlement Commissions
Solicitors fees
$ 8,000,000
$ 160,000
$ 40,000
NET REALISATION $ 7,800,000
Less
PROFIT & RISK (20%) $ 7,800,000 / 120 X 20 $ 1,300,000
Residual Balance $ 6,500,000
DEVELOPMENT COSTS $ 3,465,000
Professional Fees
Construction
Marketing / Pre-sale commissions
Interest on Development Costs
$ 200,000
$ 3,000,000
$ 100,000
$ 165,000
Residual Balance $ 3,035,000
LAND COSTS
Interest - Land & Acqn Costs @ 10% ($3,035,000 / 110 X 10)
Residual Balance
$ 275,909
$ 2,759,090
Land Acquisition Costs 7% ($2,759,901 / 107 x 7) $ 180,501
RESIDUAL LAND VALUE $ 2,578,589Calculating the
DEVELOPMENT MARGIN
1. Estimate the net realisation (gross sales revenue less unfunded
selling costs = net realisation)
2. Estimate the total development cost for a project in current dollars
(non inflated) including interest on these costs, assuming 100%
borrowings
3. Calculate the net profit by subtracting total development cost from
the net realisation
4. Calculate the development margin (or P&R factor) by dividing net
profit by total development cost
Profit & Risk Factor (or DM) = Net Profit
Total Development CostLAND COSTS $ 1,360,000
Purchase Price
Acquisition costs 7%
Professional fees 2%
Interest on Land Costs
$ 1,000,000
$ 140,000
$ 90,000
$ 123,000
DEVELOPMENT COSTS $ 2,572,500
Demolition / Excavation
Professional Fees
Construction
Marketing / Pre-sale commissions
Interest on Development Costs
$ 150,000
$ 100,000
$ 2,000,000
$ 200,000
$ 122,500
NET REALISATION $ 4,700,000
Gross Realisation (sales revenue)
Settlement Commissions
Solicitors fees
$ 5,000,000
$ 250,000
$ 50,000
DEVELOPMENT PROFIT $ 767,500
Net Realisation
Less
TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
Development Costs
Land Costs
$ 4,700,000
$ 3,932,500
$ 2,572,500
$ 1,360,000
DM / P&R
Calculation
$ 767,500
$ 3,932,500
= 19.51%CALCULATING INTEREST ON DEVELOPMENT COSTS
• The HDA method assumes 100% financing on all land and
development costs
• Land Costs are assumed to be paid in full at the commencement of
the development period and so full interest on land and acquisition
costs applies over the whole of the development period
• Other Development Costs however are NOT paid in full up front.
• Normally the developer seeks to obtain a line of credit to fund the
other development costs (professional fees / construction / etc)
• Establishing a line of credit normally involves
• an establishment fee
• an annual “Line Fee”
• INTEREST HOWEVER ONLY ACCRUES AS MONEY IS DRAWN DOWNCALCULATING INTEREST ON DEVELOPMENT COSTS
“S” CURVE DRAWDOWN
Development Funding
only attracts interest
charges once they are
drawn down
As such we use a rule of
thumb to determine initial
estimates of the related
interest charges
In this subject allow -
FULL INTEREST for
HALF THE
DEVELOPMENT PERIODCLASSIFICATION OF DEVELOPMENT COSTS
HARDS COSTS
Land Purchase Price
Excavation / Site Works
Construction Costs
Statutory Development Contributions
“SENIOR LENDERS” will often limit funding to a % of Hard Costs
SOFT COSTS
Stamp duty & professional fees on purchase of site
Holding charges (Council Rates / Water Rates / Land Tax / Insurances)
Professional Fees (Planning, Architect, Engineer, Surveyor, Legal, etc)
Application Fees (loans, building works, planning approvals)
Marketing Costs
NOTE:
This is indicative – some lenders may have a slightly different viewAdvantages
ØVery easy and quick to calculate.
ØGood for analysing similar projects on similar time frames
Disadvantages
ØThe Development Margin Method does not account for the time value
of money and as such is considered an unreliable project performance
measure on projects over 2 years
ØIt is difficult to compare projects on different time spans and different
investment opportunities
Hypothetical Development ApproachREFER TO TOPIC SUPPORTING NOTES
AND THEN COMPLETE
THE HYPOTHETICAL DEVELOPMENT
QUIZ
[Show More]