Putting on Mock TrialsPoints of view or opinions in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily
represent the official policies or position of the American Bar Association.
Design by Pinckard-Gill
...
Putting on Mock TrialsPoints of view or opinions in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily
represent the official policies or position of the American Bar Association.
Design by Pinckard-Gill Creative
copyright © 2002 American Bar Association
ISBN Number: 1-59031-154-X1
Table of Contents
2 ■ Introduction
3 ■ Objectives of Mock Trials
4 ■ Mock Trials and Critical Thinking
4 ■ Types of Mock Trials
5 ■ How to Prepare for and Conduct Mock Trials in the Classroom
7 ■ The Playing Fields of Mock Trials
8 ■ Introducing the Trial Process and Steps in a Trial
9 ■ Roles in Criminal Trials
10 ■ Rules of Evidence
12 ■ Helpful Hints for Mock Trial Participants
14 ■ Direct and Cross-Examination Questions
16 ■ Mock Trial Judging Form
17 ■ Selecting, Preparing, and Using Judges
18 ■ Questions for Class Discussion Following Mock Trials
19 ■ Analyzing Your Mock Trial
20 ■ Moot Court (Appeal) Activities
21 ■ Going Beyond the Classroom
22 ■ Sample Mock Trials
23 ■ Elementary School Mock Trial—Big Bad Wolf v. Curly Pig
32 ■ Trial Based on Literature—Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (Grades 5–9)
33 ■ Middle School Trial (Grades 6–8)
35 ■ Mediation and the Adversary Process (Grades 5–8; 9–12)
37 ■ Small Claims Mock Hearings (Secondary)
38 ■ State v. Randall (Secondary)
40 ■ Historical Mock Trial—The Case of Galileo Galilei (Secondary)
45 ■ In the Matter of Toni Radcliffe (Secondary)
49 ■ Further Information and Materials About Mock Trials2 Putting on Mock Trials
This is a revised edition of a booklet first published in 1987 and often reprinted since then.
The original Putting on Mock Trials was one of the most popular publications ever offered by the
ABA’s Division for Public Education.
Now, mock trials are more popular than ever, the Internet has evolved as a terrific resource for all
kinds of mock trial questions, and there are many new mock trials. For all these reasons, we’ve
revised and expanded the original booklet, adding several new trials and plenty of helpful new
information.
Many people from all over the country contributed articles or trials to this work, and we acknowledge each of them after their entry.
Compiling and overseeing this revised edition was Margaret E. Fisher, an attorney/educator with
many years’ experience in teaching law to the public. She is an adjunct professor at the Seattle
University School of Law and also assists the state courts of Washington with educational programs.
Besides selecting a number of new contributions to the booklet, Professor Fisher saw that all existing
entries were reviewed and updated if necessary. Thanks to her hard work (and that of the booklet’s
original editor, Rick Roe of Georgetown University Law Center), this booklet will help anyone put
on exciting, stimulating mock trials that engage students while educating them.
So whether you’re contemplating doing your first mock trial or completing your one-hundredth,
you’ll find plenty of practical, hands-on help in these pages.
IntroductionObjectives of Mock Trials 3
Objectives of Mock Trials
What educational objectives can a mock trial
achieve? Through participation in mock trials
and analysis of the activity, students gain an
insider’s perspective on courtroom procedures.
Mock trials help students gain a basic understanding of the legal mechanism through which
society chooses to resolve many of its disputes.
While learning the details of the trial process,
students are also developing a number of skills
that are universally necessary: critical analysis
of problems, strategic thinking, questioning
skills, listening skills, skills in oral presentation
and extemporaneous argument, and skills in
preparing and organizing material.
Of particular interest is the high level of
cooperation among students needed for successful mock trials. Research findings indicate that
such cooperative learning activities encourage
significant cognitive achievement among students from a variety of backgrounds and also
improve students’ attitudes toward schools and
each other.
Participation in mock trials helps students
better understand the roles that the various
actors play in the justice system and the difficult conflicts those persons must resolve daily
in performing their jobs. As such, mock trials
also provide excellent exposure to a wide variety of law-related careers. On a more complex
level, mock trials provide students with an
excellent vehicle for the study of such fundamental law-related concepts as authority and
fairness.
Mock trials provide valuable performance
assessment activities and are extremely effective
in teaching important outcomes in social studies, reading, writing, and communication. Mock
trial activities provide ideal opportunities for
students to demonstrate important outcomes
required by school reform.
Mock trials also provide a natural opportunity to incorporate field experiences and community resource persons into the school curriculum. Trips to the local courts to observe real
attorneys, witnesses, and judges in action are
a natural prelude to or follow-up activity for
the mock trial. In addition, mock trials are a
great way for attorneys, law students, and
judges to
contribute to
school
programs.
Community
resources who
come into
classrooms to
help students
prepare, act as
judges, or
debrief the
trial are
performing a valuable service, which will easily
lead to further cooperation with the schools.
This interaction with actual people in the legal
system can go a long way toward changing the
negative attitudes of some toward the legal profession. In addition, these resource people will
often develop more positive attitudes toward
students from their experience with mock trials.
Finally, the mock trial experience can serve
to prepare students for possible future involvement as parties, witnesses, or jurors in trials.
Their participation can reduce fear and help
provide the knowledge and motivation needed
to perform these roles more effectively.
Adapted by Margaret Fisher from the Street Law Mock
Trial Manual of Street Law, Inc., available from Social
Studies School Service, 10200 Jefferson Blvd., Dept. A3,
P.O. Box 802, Culver City, CA 90230; 800/421-4246;
www.socialstudies.com; Order Code Z33-WEB.
A cross the country, exercises are going on that look like trials. They deal with real facts and common situations. They feature judges, lawyers, witnesses, and jurors. Everything is as
realistic as possible—except that the participants are youngsters who are learning about law and the
legal system through a simulation known as the mock trial.
Why is it that the trial—something that for years was considered solely the province of the legal
profession—has become such a popular educational experience for students?
Part of the mock trial’s appeal lies in the fun involved in preparing for and participating in the
simulated trial. Who doesn’t want to become—if only for a brief time—a member of The Practice,
a zealous prosecutor, a distinguished judge, or the aggrieved plaintiff demanding justice? While television’s depiction of trials often distorts the reality of legal procedures, the courtroom dramas that
come into our homes several times each week surely heighten the mock trial experience for students
[Show More]