Self-assessment activity 1.1
Write down your initial answers to the following questions:
What do you understand by ‘theories’, ‘religion’ and ‘theories of religion’?
Which questions or issues do you expect to stud
...
Self-assessment activity 1.1
Write down your initial answers to the following questions:
What do you understand by ‘theories’, ‘religion’ and ‘theories of religion’?
Which questions or issues do you expect to study in this module?
Please write down the answers that you would give to the questions above. At the
end of this module, you will be in a position to return to your initial answers and think
about ways in which you would like to adapt your initial formulations.
In this module, as its title Introducing Theories of Religion indicates, you will be
introduced to major theories of religion. Note, therefore, the three key terms in the title,
which may be given the following content at the beginning of this module and that you
may revisit and give further content as you work through the module:
(1) By an introduction to theories of religion we intend at first year level an orientation
on the most important theories of studying religion in the past 150 years (ie since
about 1870).
(2) By theories we mean ways in which religion has been seen (the technical term
‘theory’ is derived from the Greek verb theorein ‘to see’), understood and
Downloaded by Jayden Mbugguz (
[email protected])
lOMoARcPSD|8637614RST1502/102
6
explained. As indicated under the previous point, our focus will be on theories of
religion since the second half of the 19th century.
(3) For religion we may take as working definition
the sociological definition of Durkheim according to which all religions consist of
beliefs and practices that are sacred (‘set apart’) in such a way that they unite
adherents into a group, and
adapt it by foregrounding asymmetrical power relations of class, gender and race
that are legitimated or challenged by religions and religious movements.
In the course of this module you will encounter many definitions of religion as you study
different theories of and approaches to religion. By using this proposed working
definition as point of reference, however, you will be able to debate and assess the
diverse theories. You might, of course, as you work through this module, wish to adapt
the working definition suggested here by offering your own that could be employed for
analytical purposes.
Note the term analytical, derived from Greek analysis ‘breaking up’, which means here
the breaking up of religion into its smaller, constituent parts. This is what Durkheim did
by identifying beliefs (including dogmas and myths or sacred narratives), practices
(including rituals and festivals as collective rituals) and unified communities as elements
of religion, just as we may break down a sentence into smaller units of verbs, nouns,
adjectives, adverbs etc, when we analyse a sentence. Understanding a religion or
sentence, of course, requires that one put these pieces together again by relating them
to each other (or synthesising them, from Greek synthesis ‘put together’).
Which questions will we foreground in this module? We may, on the basis of the
definitions above, formulate and further elaborate a few related questions that we will
think about in this module.
Our main question will be the following:
How have scholars of religion seen, understood and explained religion in
the past 150 years?
This question will be discussed in Tutorial Letter 501 and its sequel Tutorial Letter 102:
- How have white scholars in imperial European metropoles around the 1870s and
at the turn and beginning of the 20th century constructed their theories of
religion? We intend to show you how these theories have been constructed by
means of a threefold process of mediation: indigenous knowledge about African
indigenous religion was reported by colonial middlemen (case studies will be
taken from southern Africa), which was then abstracted from its colonial context
and appropriated by scholars in Europe to construct mostly evolutionary theories
Downloaded by Jayden Mbugguz (
[email protected])
lOMoARcPSD|8637614RST1502/102
7
of religion that served to justify a civilising mission to subjugated, colonised
peoples. This is the thread running through Tutorial Letter 501.
- How have 20th century phenomenological and critical scholars seen, understood
and explained religion? While phenomenologists claimed to describe religious
phenomena objectively as they appear (phenomenology is derived from Greek
phainomai ‘appear’), and to identify recurrent patterns across religions, critical
scholars of religion have argued that such claims to objective description were
never neutral but masked unequal relations of gender, class and race. The
critical theorists focus, therefore, precisely on the latter problematic functions of
religion. This will be the focus of Tutorial Letter 102 that you will receive as a
follow-up to Tutorial Letter 501.
1.2. Syllabus
Self-assessment activity 1.2
Consider the following statement on the purpose of this module, which simultaneously
gives an indication of the syllabus of the module:
The purpose of this module is to provide insight into major theories of religion
including the role of Africa in theory formation. Students who successfully
complete this module will be able to demonstrate knowledge of the nature of
religion as defined by leading theorists of religion; can demonstrate knowledge
of and assess linguistic, anthropological, sociological, psychological,
phenomenological and critical approaches toward religion.
Which major theories and theorists of religion do you hope to encounter in this
module?
Take a look at the Table of Contents of Tutorial Letter 501. Which theories and
theorists of religion are listed here? Can you think of major phenomenological and
critical theorists of religion that you might encounter in Tutorial Letter 102 (the sequel
to Tutorial Letter 501)?
You will notice that we begin in the next study unit (study unit 2) with different definitions
of religion, and then distinguish between three different types of comparative religion,
namely interfaith, theosophical and critical. The purpose of the latter distinctions is to
distinguish the comparative study of religion within the academy on the one hand, from
comparisons of religions by proponents for interreligious dialogues and by theosophists
on the other hand. These distinctions are crucially made by David Chidester in his
groundbreaking Empire of Religion: Imperialism and comparative religion (2014), which
is the primary source for the study units in Tutorial Letter 501.
Downloaded by Jayden Mbugguz (jaymbugguz91@