NR511_Peer Reviewer Jessica Fiehler.docx
Exceptional
Outstanding or
highest level of
performance
Exceeds
Very good
or high level
of
performanc
e
Meets
Satisfactory
level of
performanc
e
Needs
Improve
...
NR511_Peer Reviewer Jessica Fiehler.docx
Exceptional
Outstanding or
highest level of
performance
Exceeds
Very good
or high level
of
performanc
e
Meets
Satisfactory
level of
performanc
e
Needs
Improvemen
t
Poor or failing
level of
performance
Developing
Unsatisfactor
y level of
performance
Reviewer Comments
Peer reviewers should provide thoughtful
constructive feedback for each area.
*Constructive feedback implies that the student does not just
state vague or general comments such as “well done” or “I
agree”.
Content
Possible Points
= 135 pts
Exceptional
Outstanding or
highest level of
performance
Exceeds
Very good
or high level
of
performanc
e
Meets
Satisfactory
level of
performance
Needs
Improvemen
t
Poor or failing
level of
performance
Developing
Unsatisfactor
y level of
performance
Peer Reviewer: [Sara Martinez ]
Presenter: [Jessica Fiehler]
Acute otitis Externa
Disease & Background
Student: 1)
Identifies the
disease condition
2) Gives a brief
statement of
incidence and
prevalence in the
US 3) The student
briefly
summarizes the
disease
pathophysiology
15 Points 13 Points 12 Points 6 Points 0 Points PEER REVIEWER COMMENTS
Student identifies
the disease topic
AND
Student states
the incidence and
prevalence in the
US
AND
Student provides
a
pathophysiology
statement
AND
Student states
All four (4)
critical
elements
are present
but some
information
may be only
partially
addressed
or
inaccurate.
One to two
(1-2) critical
elements
are missing.
-3 critical elements
are missing
-
All four (4)
critical
elements are
missing.
Jessica you did a great job identifying the topic
of this CPG and stating the prevalence. I liked
that you included the loss of productivity as part
of your incidence prevalence section. Great job
on your typical presentation section.
Introduction slide and outlined what would be
presented. She identified the AOE disorder and
told how prevalent AOE is in the U.S (1 of 123
people affected) (44% being in seen in June
through August ). One slide was dedicated to the
pathophysiology of AOE.
All 15 points
[Show More]
.png)
