Supreme Court Case Study 53
The Right to Search Students New Jersey v. T.L.O.,
1985
★ ★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Background of the Case ★★★★★★★★★★★★★
A New Jersey high school teacher discovered a 14-year-old freshman, whom
the c
...
Supreme Court Case Study 53
The Right to Search Students New Jersey v. T.L.O.,
1985
★ ★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Background of the Case ★★★★★★★★★★★★★
A New Jersey high school teacher discovered a 14-year-old freshman, whom
the courts later referred to by her initials, T.L.O., smoking in a school lavatory.
Since smoking was a violation of school rules, T.L.O. was taken to the assistant
vice-principal’s office.
When questioned by the assistant vice-principal, T.L.O. denied that she had been smoking.
The assistant vice-principal then searched her purse. There he found a pack of
cigarettes along with rolling papers commonly used for smoking marijuana. He
then searched the purse more thoroughly and found marijuana, a pipe, plastic
bags, a large amount of money, an index card listing students who owed T.L.O.
money, and “two letters that implicated T.L.O. in marijuana 'dealing.”
The assistant vice-principal notified the girl’s mother and turned the evidence
of drug dealing over to the police. T.L.O. was charged, as a juvenile, with criminal
activity. T.L.O., in turn, claimed the evidence of drug dealing found in her purse
could not be used in court as evidence because it had been obtained through an
illegal search and seizure. T.L.O.’s attorneys claimed that the Fourth Amendment
protects against unreasonable search and seizure. They maintained that the
Fourth Amendment requirements for a warrant and probable cause applied to
T.L.O. while in high school as a student. After appeals in lower courts, the case
eventually reached the United States Supreme Court.
Constitutional Issue ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
T.L.O.’s case raised the question of whether the Fourth Amendment
required school officials, when conducting searches of students’ property in
school, to meet the same strict standards as police officials. In most instances
police officers must have probable cause to believe that the subject of a
search has violated or is violating the law, and generally must obtain a
warrant issued by a neutral judicial officer. If these standards are not met by
the police, evidence they have gathered from a search can be excluded as
evidence of guilt in a criminal trial.
★ ★★★★★★★★★★ The Supreme Court’s Decision
★★★★★★★★★★★★★★
Justice Byron R. White wrote the Court’s 6-to-3 decision, which ruled against
T.L.O. The Court concluded that the Fourth Amendment ban on unreasonable
searches and seizures applies to searches conducted by school officials but that
the search of T.L.O. was reasonable.
The Court also ruled that school officials do not have to meet the same standards
as police officers when conducting searches.
Justice White wrote that students have a real need to bring personal property
into school md have “legitimate expectations of privacy” while in school. At the
same time, however,
Supreme Court Case Studies 105 This study source was downloaded by 100000824368823 from CourseHero.com on 11-04-2022 08:44:45 GMT -05:00
https://www.coursehero.com/file/37342104/TLO-v-NJdocx/
Name ________________________________________ Date ___________________ Class
Supreme Court Case Study 53 (continued)
administrators in maintaining discipline in the classroom and on school grounds.” The Court
devised a plan to ease for school officials the Fourth Amendment requirements for a lawful
search. Because of the significance of the school’s interests, the Court ruled that school
officials
need not obtain a search warrant before searching a student who is under their supervision.
“The warrant requirement,” the Court held, “is unsuited to the school environment... [and]
would unduly interfere with the maintenance of the swift and informal disciplinary
procedures
needed in the schools.”
Next, the Court ruled that school officials do not have to be held to the same
strict probable
cause standard that applies to the police when conducting searches. In earlier
cases the Court
had ruled that “probable cause” meant that the police must have solid
information that there is
a real chance the person being searched has violated or is violating the law.
Declining to apply
this standard to public school officials, the Court said that school officials may
search a student
as long as “there are reasonable grounds for suspecting that the search will turn
up evidence that
the student has violated or is violating either the law or the rules of the school.”
Thus, the Court
DIRECTIONS: Answer the following questions on a separate sheet of paper.
1. In what way does the Court differentiate between the standard set for a school official
and that for a police officer regarding a search and seizure?
School officials must follow the same rules that police officers have to follow under
the 4th amendment. This means that they cannot search T.L.O’s bag without probable
evidence or a search warrant.
2. Why did the Court give school officials more freedom than the police to conduct searches?
I think that the Court gave school officials more freedom than the police to conduct searches
because in school you are under their law and their protection.
3. Do you think the assistant vice-principal’s search was “reasonable”? Explain.
I don’t think that the assistant vice-principal’s search was reasonable because they did not
have probable cause or a search warrant. This breaks the 4th amendment.
4. Under the Court’s ruling, do you think a school official has the right to search a student
any time he or she wishes? Give reasons for your answer.
I don’t think that they have the right to search whenever he or she wishes but I think
when there is suspicion then they can search the lockers.
5. Do you agree with the Court’s decision or with the dissenting opinion? Explain.
I agree with the dissenting opinion because school officials should have to follow the same
rules that official police officers have to follow. This would make it so they would have need a
106 Supreme Court Case Studies
[Show More]