Solution Manual For
SM Business Law Today, Comprehensive, 13th Edition Roger LeRoy Miller
Text & Cases 13e, 9780357634783;
Chapter 01: Law and Legal Reasoning
Table of Contents
Critical Thinking Questions in Featu
...
Solution Manual For
SM Business Law Today, Comprehensive, 13th Edition Roger LeRoy Miller
Text & Cases 13e, 9780357634783;
Chapter 01: Law and Legal Reasoning
Table of Contents
Critical Thinking Questions in Features ..................................................................................................................1
Managerial Strategy—Business Questions................................................................................................ 1
Chapter Review................................................................................................................................................................2
Practice and Review ..................................................................................................................................2
Practice and Review: Debate This .............................................................................................................2
Issue Spotters............................................................................................................................................3
Business Scenarios and Case Problems.....................................................................................................3
Critical Thinking and Writing Assignments................................................................................................ 7
Appendix Exhibit........................................................................................................................................8
Critical Thinking Questions in Features
Managerial Strategy—Business Questions
1. ―When faced with a clearly erroneous precedent, my rule is simple,‖ writes Supreme Court Justice
Clarence Thomas. ―We should not follow it.‖ How do these words offer a cautionary tale for
managers relying on stare decisis to make business decisions?
Solution
Simply put, the doctrine of stare decisis applies in all instances, except when it does not. As noted
in the text, a court is able to depart from precedent if it feels that legal, social, or technological
changes have rendered the previous decision untenable. In this case, just because the United
State Supreme Court believes, at present, that automobile salespeople are exempt from the
overtime rules of the FLSA, there is a possibility that the Court could reverse itself in the future. In
this context, managers need to be aware that (1) any decision they make based on a court
decision is subject to change, and (2) if they believe that a previous business law-related court
decision is flawed, they can challenge it in court.
2. Should Roberta consider paying her salespeople overtime even though it is not required by
federal law? Why or why not?
Solution
Just because Roberta is legally able to avoid paying the salespeople at her new used car
dealership overtime, should she? As with so many managerial decisions, the answer to this
question involves the tricky determination of costs and benefits. On the one hand, Roberta‘s costs
will be lower if she does not have to pay overtime to the salespeople. On the other hand, the
[Show More]