Gender Inequalities
1. How does the concept of gender differ from the concept of sex? (L)
2. What is sexism? What are the global consequences of sexism? What are the consequences of sexism
in the United States? How do
...
Gender Inequalities
1. How does the concept of gender differ from the concept of sex? (L)
2. What is sexism? What are the global consequences of sexism? What are the consequences of sexism
in the United States? How does the gender gap in the U.S. compare to that in other countries? (L)
Sexism:
• Belief that one sex is superior to the other sex as a result of innate differences
o Prejudice
Negative, irrational stereotypes used to prejudge females or males
o Discrimination
Treating a person differently because of their gender
Global Consequences of Sexism:
• Female infanticide
o 60 million “missing” female babies
• Rape
o 1 in 3 females worldwide has been forced to have sex
• Sex Slaves
o 2 million females forced into sex trade each year
• Genital mutilation
• Restricted gender roles
• Political discrimination
o In many countries, females have no right to vote.
• Females perform 2/3 of the world’s work but…
o Earn 1/10 of the world’s income
o Own less than 1% of the world’s property
• Lack of education
o 2/3 of the world’s women are illiterate
Consequences of Sexism in the US:
• 1 in 5 females will be raped
• Spousal abuse
o Females are 6X more likely to be battered
• Political representation
o In the US, females are disproportionately underrepresented in political offices
o US Political Positions
Females 52% of population
Females elected in 2010
• 33% in Senate
• 16% in House
• 12% woman governors
The US is not in the top 10 in terms of gender gap rating.
• We are number 17.
• We are very low in female economic opportunity.
3. How do the income earnings of full-time employed females compare with those of full-time
employed males according to the data reported in class? What accounts for this disparity in income
earnings? In answering the latter question, give the explanations of human capital theory, including
differences in education and other assets, sex-typed occupations, the devaluation theory, employer
discrimination, including the glass ceiling, and differential visibility (discussed in your reading).
What are the problems with human capital theory? (L,R)
• Full time employed females earned 77% of full time employed male earnings in 2009.
• What accounts for this disparity?
o Human Capital Theory
Women view fewer assets to the job
US Educational Attainment (2008)
• Females were more likely to graduate HS
• Females slightly less likely to graduate college
o Since 1980, women more likely to earn degree
Degrees Earned 2008
• Females earned more…
o Associate
o Bachelor
o Masters
o Doctorates
• Males earned more…
o Professional
• 2009 College Enrollment
o More females enrolled in…
Undergrad programs (57%)
Graduate programs (59%)
o Problem:
Females earn less than males for the same amount of
education
Other Assets:
• Females have less work experience. Why?
o Less seniority
Females more likely to interrupt careers and to promote
husband’s career
BUT…
After age 40, females are less likely to quit than males
o Females choose to accommodate their family
Work fewer hours
Chose jobs that offer good hours that fit children’s
schedule
Choose jobs closer to home
Choose jobs that do not require travel
• Sex Typed Jobs
o “Pink Collar Ghetto”
Most females employed in:
• Predominately female occupations
• Nurturing occupations
o Devaluation Hypothesis
Nurturing fields are devalued (pay less)
↑
Belief that anyone can do the job
Belief that these jobs are not as important
o Discrimination
Overt discrimination
• Not receiving a job, promotion, or pay raise because of gender
o Glass-Ceiling
Females are less likely to be promoted to high power positions
↑
• Males are likely to be in positions to promote
• Male bosses view females less capable of high power positions
• Females socialized to be less assertive
• Females often satisfied to be in medium-level power positions
o Differential Visibility
Members of numerical minorities are more conspicuously visible (ex: Fs in M
occupation)
• Are always center stage
• More likely to fail because:
o “Boundary heightening” by majority (Ms)
Exaggerate masculine characteristics to make females
feel different
↓
o Isolates females
Less informal networking for information and help
o Prejudged based on performance of previous females
Members that make up less than 50% of a workplace possess a risk because they
stand out.
The risk exists because minorities are conspicuously visible.
One of the problems with being a minority member is that people judge the
performance of your entire group on your personal performance.
When minority managers fail as a result of an inability to avoid visibility or the
heightening of boundaries by members of the network, their failure becomes part
of a corporate myth.
Sometimes a minority will succeed, then that group will be acceptable hires
again.
Female propositions are more likely to occur when there is a limited minority of
female supervisors.
Differential visibility is an appealing theory. However, it cannot be a general
explanation of low female occupational status.
Human capital theory has attempted to explain women’s concentration in low status positions in
terms of female domestic obligations preventing them from obtaining the skills they need for superior
jobs. The synthetic turnover model would explain this phenomenon in terms of the need to encourage
turnover in settings where long job tenures raise costs for management. Differential visibility theory
explains status segregation in terms of organizational pressures on minorities; these pressures impede
objective performance and make minorities less objectively qualified for promotion. Employee
discrimination models explain women’s concentration in low status positions in terms of the
superior capacity of male skilled workers to use worker power to exclude women. Human capital
theory is extremely problematic in this regard. The other three theories make some contribution and they
also apply to specific times and places. Overall, however, employee discrimination is the most
universally observed phenomenon and probably the most important contributor to maintaining
gendered status differentials.
The human capital theory argues that workers are more productive if they have received training. The
productivity-enhancing powers of skills induce economists to refer to them as “human capital”. “Capital”
is anything that increases the yield produced by labor power, and the “human” means that skills are
located within people and not out in some storage shed.
Problems with the human capital theory: Human capital theory argues that the world consists of two
types of workers: low-turnover men and high-turnover women. Jobs are divided into male and female
based on this. But in actuality, turnover does not divide the labor force into two sets of workers, one male
and one female. It divides them into two different pools, younger women in prime reproductive age, and
others, meaning men and women past the age of childbearing. The primary reason that women
supposedly drop out of the labor force is to care for children at home. This is not relevant for a 55 year
old woman. Men have higher quit rates than women. Women are more loyal than men. Another
problem with human capital theory is that it assumes that firms obsess about the costs associated with the
loss of firm-specific capital. No company ever wants to get rid of skilled workers because of the
presumably prohibitive expenses associated with training a replacement. Empirically, human capital
theory has not done well when tested as an explanation for occupational sex-typing or gender differences
in job holding. The standard test for a human capital explanation of anything is to assess whether that
phenomenon can be explained by differentials in education and experience. Human capital theorists
argue, frequently with justification, that skills come from schooling and from experience on the job.
Sophisticated tests differentiate between experience in the current firm and experience in other firms in
the labor market.
*4. POSSIBLE ESSAY: What was the evidence and legal argument of Ms. Evan’s complaint of
discrimination in your article about the glass ceiling? What would be her employer’s position? What
are Ms. Evans options for legal recourse? (R)
5. Why do women have less wealth than men? Why is it important for wo
[Show More]