ACTG 4P11 EXTRA QUETIOSNS
1. If there is no stock price reaction to an earnings announcement, does that mean that accounting is not useful?
• The information approach demonstrates some usefulness of accounting informat
...
ACTG 4P11 EXTRA QUETIOSNS
1. If there is no stock price reaction to an earnings announcement, does that mean that accounting is not useful?
• The information approach demonstrates some usefulness of accounting information in that both stock price and
trading volume increase when earnings are released.
• However, accounting earnings only explain a small fraction of the changes in share price. In regressions of changes in
accounting on stock returns, R2
, which is a measure of the proportion of share return explained by accounting
information, is quite low (2 – 5%)
• While the effect of accounting information on share price can be statistically significant, it is practically insignificant.
• This suggests the scope to improve financial reporting
• One way to increase decision usefulness over that of the information approach would be to adopt the measurement
approach which tries to make better predictions about how investors make decisions.
2. Chapter 5 10.X Ltd is a growth firm that uses conservative accounting policies. Y Ltd is growing more slowly and
uses fair value accounting for its capital assets. Otherwise, they have the same size, betas and capital structure.
They both report good news in earnings this year. Which should have a higher ERC and why?
The reasons for differential market response by the measurement of ERC (Earning Response Coefficients) are:
beta, capital structure, earnings persistence, earning quality, growth opportunities, The Similarity of Investor
Expectations, and The Informativeness of Price. X and Y Ltd have the same size, betas and capital structure and both
report good news in earnings. Y grows slower suggests that the ERC will be higher.
However, since X Ltd uses conservative accounting policies, it has Higher persistence in general, which
suggest Higher ERC.
A reasonable conclusion is that X have a higher ERC if we accept the impact of the accounting policies
outweighed that of the growing opportunities.
Earning Response Coefficients
In general P&L (Historic cost) versus OCI (Fair value)
Historic cost: recognize transactions and earnings/good news that is expected to persist (think about accounting
conservatism) (ERC > 1)
- Measurement under the historic cost accounting does not consider all future cash flows in regards to $1 of
earning. So, $1 of unexpected earning in this period might produce another $1 earning next period
Fair value: recognize the change in value of the assets and liabilities (ERC = 1)
- $1 of earning will result in $1 of abnormal market return. All expected future cash flows are already taken into
account.
- So, fair value uses exit price (price at which buyer wants to buy PPE after calculating its future expected cash
flows)
- Assuming markets are efficient and prices follow a random walk
SOLUTION: X Ltd. would be expected to have a higher ERC. First, it uses conservative accounting policies.
Consequently, a given dollar of GN has higher implications for future profitability and returns than for Y Ltd. Second,
Y’s reported net income may have lower reliability than X because it uses current value accounting for its capital
assets. Readily available and well-working market values may not exist for capital assets, requiring extensive
estimates, introducing the possibility of error and bias. The market would be less responsive to unreliable
information, other things equal.
Note: IAS 16 allows firms to use fair value accounting for property, plant, and equipment, providing that this can be done reliably. Third, X Ltd. is
a growth firm. Theory and evidence exists that firms with growth opportunities have higher ERCs than non-growth firms.
3. Chapter 5 Q22. The methodology used to evaluate the value relevance of financial statement information can also
be used to evaluate security market reaction to other events affecting firm value.
For example, on April 30, 2012, financial media reported that Apple Inc. sold $19 billion of bonds of various
maturities. The proceeds were to help finance a $100 billion cash return to shareholders, including a share buyback
of $60 billion. In this way, Apple was attempting to increase its share price, which had fallen from $705 in September
2012 to $385 in mid-April 2013. Also, Apple was taking advantage of low interest rates in the economy. For example,
the interest rate on the 10-year portion of its bond issue was only 2.4%.
Apple’s share price increased by 9.02% for the week ended April 30, 2013, closing at $442.78. Its beta at the time, as
per Reuters, was .99. Apple’s shares trade on the NASDAQ exchange. For the week ended April 30, 2013, the NASDAQ
Composite Index closed at 3,328.79, after opening the week at 3,262.21. The U.S. Federal Funds Rate at the time was
0.15% per annum.
a. Did the market for Apple’s shares react favourably or unfavourably to the bond issue during the week ended
April 30, 2013? Take calculations to four decimal places. Note that aj in the market model formula is equivalent to
in the CAPM, where Rf is proxied by the weekly Federal Funds Rate.
Calculate the expected return on Apple shares for the week ended April 30, 2013:
where M is the NASDAQ Composite Index. Actual return on Apple for the week was .0902
Abnormal return on Apple shares for the week was thus .0902 - .0202 = .0700, or about 7%
It seems that the equity market reacted favourably to Apple’s bond issue
b. A market analyst at the time was quoted as saying that, generally speaking, it is not wise to buy bonds used to
finance a share buyback. Do you agree or disagree? Give reasons.
Reasons why it may be unwise to buy bonds used to finance a share buyback:
• The money raised from the bond issue leaves the company. Thus there is less of a “cushion” of net assets to
provide bondholder security.
• The share buyback may indicate that the company does not have a productive use for additional capital.
That is, the proceeds of the bond issue are not used to invest in new capital assets.
• To the extent that the share buyback is motivated by a desire to increase the firm’s share price, it is
possible/likely that share price has been falling. A falling share price may indicate that the firm is heading for
financial distress, further increasing the bondholders’ risk.
• The firm incurs a major new fixed cost (i.e., interest payments). This reduces cash flow available to finance
interest and investment.
Reasons why it may not be unwise:
• Low interest rates. Since, as indicated by the low Federal Funds Rate, interest rates in the economy are low,
the firm can obtain debt financing at relatively low cost. This reduces the strain on the firm’s cash flow to
meet interest payments.
• While interest rates on the new debt issues are low, they are likely considerably greater than interest rates
on risk-free debt due to the low interest rate environment. Since investors are risk averse and thus trade-off
risk and return, the rate on the new bonds may be sufficiently high to overcome bondholders’ concerns
about the security underlying the bonds.
• There may be few or no bonds already outstanding. If so, the risks to the new bondholders are reduced.
• Interest payments are tax deductible, further reducing the strain on cash flow. A reasonable conclusion is
that while the reasons it is unwise to invest in bonds used to finance a share buyback are persuasive in
general, the fact that the bond issue was successful suggests that the reasons in favour of investing in Apple
bonds dominated the reasons against. The low interest rate environment and the size and reputation of
Apple Inc. seem to have overcome the concerns. This episode illustrates the saying that “it is the exception
that proves the rule.”
ACTG 4P11 Ch 5 Pr
2. Refer to the separation of market-wide and firm-specific (i.e., abnormal) security returns as shown in Figure
5.2 . Which factors could reduce the accuracy of the estimate of firm-specific returns?
One factor that could adversely affect the accuracy of the estimate of abnormal returns is the estimate of beta,
particularly if the firm’s beta changes over time. If the slope of the regression line in Figure 5.2 is not correct, or if
beta has changed subsequent to the period over which it was estimated, this will affect the abnormal returns
estimate.
Another problem is the identification of the date the market first became aware of the earnings news. Usually, this is
taken as the date the announcement appeared in the financial press or company conference call. However, if this
date is not accurate, then the wrong RMt is used to establish the expected stock return. This would throw off the
calculation of abnormal return.
There may be other information affecting the firm’s share price on the day of its earnings announcement. For
example, the firm may have also announced a change in its dividend. Unless such firms are excluded from the
sample, any abnormal return will be ascribed to the GN or BN in earnings rather than the other information.
A more fundamental problem is that investors may not necessarily make investment decisions the way that the
theory developed in Section 3.3 suggests. Investment decisions may not be fully or even partially diversified, in which
case beta is not the only relevant risk measure. Or, investors may have some other method of making investment
decisions, in which case the market model and CAPM may not provide good estimates of expected and abnormal
return. (However, since empirical research has shown that abnormal returns as calculated in Figure 5.2 do relate to
GN or BN in earnings, it seems that the investment theory underlying this figure reasonably predicts the decision
processes of the average rational investor.)
The CAPM makes a number of assumptions. For example, it does not take information asymmetry and resulting
estimation risk into account. Consequently, investors may not react to earnings information exactly as the CAPM
predicts. For example, they may be concerned about inside information and/or low quality reporting including
possible manager manipulation of the financial statements (these possibilities are discussed in later chapters). This
could dampen their reaction to the reported earnings.
Yet another factor is the significance of industry effects, in addition to market-wide and firm-specific components of
return. For example, firm j may be in an industry that is expected to benefit greatly from a reduction of trade
barriers. If this reduction was announced around the date that firm j announced its current earnings, the abnormal
return around the date of earnings release could be attributed to this industry effect rather than to earnings.
3. Is the market’s anticipation of the GN/BN in earnings during 12 months prior to the month of release of the
earnings release, as Ball and Brown found in Figure 5.3 , consistent with a correlation or a causation argument for
the effect of accounting information on abnormal stock returns? Explain. With which argument is the market
response during month 0 most consistent? Explain.
This anticipation up to a year ahead is consistent with the correlation argument. If the firm in an economic sense is
doing well, the efficient market learns of this from more timely sources, and responds by bidding up its share price.
That is, its abnormal share return rises over the course of the year. Come year-end, the firm reports GN in its
earnings, since net income also captures (with a lag) good economic performance
Thus, GN will be associated with increasing abnormal returns over the year, but does not cause the market reaction.
A similar pattern occurs when firms are doing poorly.
The market response in month 0 is consistent with the causation argument. Since a well-designed experiment will
remove from the sample firms other firm-specific factors affecting share return, such as dividend announcements
and stock splits. Then, the only other firm-specific effect on share return during the narrow window of one month is
the release of earnings information. Then, it can be argued that the accounting information caused the market
reaction. Of course, this reaction is reduced to the extent the market has anticipated the GN or BN in earnings during
the year leading up to the earnings announcement. But, Ball and Brown showed that not all the GN or BN was
anticipated, thus causing a market reaction for the month 0.
Note: Ball and Brown did not have daily security return data available to them in1968.Consequently, their narrow
window is a month. The onus is on the researchers to delete all firms in their sample with non-accounting events
affecting share returns. Since a lot can happen during a month that affects these returns, it can be difficult to remove
them all. If not all are removed, the findings in month 0 could be consistent with a correlation argument.
5. Explain why it is desirable to find the exact time that the market first became aware of an item of accounting
information if any security price reaction to this information is to be detected. Can such a time always be found?
Explain why or why not. What can researchers do when the exact time the market first became aware of the
information cannot be isolated?
3-day window or 5-day window, define which one is more appropriate
It is desirable to identify the moment when the market became aware of such information because of
securities market efficiency. An efficient market will react quickly to new information. Consequently, if the researcher
looks for a market reaction even a few days too early or late, no reaction may be found, although one may have
existed.
The exact time can be found sometimes, but not always. For firms’ earnings announcements, the date of
publication of earnings in the financial press, or the date of a press conference or conference call announcing current
earnings, seem to be acceptable event dates. However, the exact date on which the market first became aware of
information in the financial statements proper can be difficult or impossible to find. When does the market first learn
of balance sheet and supplementary information, for example, given the information provided in quarterly reports,
forecasts, news reports, and speeches by company officials? There are many such “leaks,” whereby the market may
learn of the information early. Then, the exact time may be impossible to find.
When an exact date cannot be identified, the narrow window over which the share price response is
evaluated can be widened somewhat. For example, a 3 or 5-day window centred around day 0 may be used to
capture the possibility that the market may have learned the earnings information a day or two early or late.
Alternatively, the researcher may evaluate market response over a wide window of weeks or months leading up to,
and possibly following, the formal information release. Then, it may be claimed that there is at least a correlation
between abnormal market return and unexpected accounting information.
20. On September 13, 2005, the shares of Best Buy Co. fell $5.14 to $45.22 on the New York Stock Exchange, a
decline of 10.2%. The decline followed the release of its second quarter 2005 financial results. Best Buy is a large
North American retailer of consumer electronics and appliances, with over 700 stores in the United States and
Canada, including the Future Shop chain. Best Buy reported earnings of 37 cents per share, compared with 30 cents
for the same quarter of 2004. However, its 2005 earnings included an expense for stock-based compensation. If the
second quarter of 2004 had included this expense, earnings for that 2004 quarter would have been 26 cents per
share. Sales revenue rose 10% for the quarter, including a 3.5% increase in same-store sales. (Same-store sales, which
exclude the effects of new store openings, are a closely watched indicator of retail company performance.) Its gross
profit rose to 25.5% of sales from 24.2%
[Show More]