CCJ4614 Criminal and Delinquent
Behavior Exam 1 (Space and Crime)
Distinction between total crime and crime rates - ✔✔It's is important to use crime rates (not total
crime) when discussing spatial and temporal variati
...
CCJ4614 Criminal and Delinquent
Behavior Exam 1 (Space and Crime)
Distinction between total crime and crime rates - ✔✔It's is important to use crime rates (not total
crime) when discussing spatial and temporal variation.
Because we need to account for differences in population sizes across AREAS and over TIME.
(Ex. Big city will have higher total crime than a small city because there are more people).
How is crime distributed over space? - ✔✔Spatial variation and crime refers to the geographic or
spatial distribution of crime. The goal is to understand whether (and why) some AREAS have
higher rates than other areas.
This is very difficult from the way we typically study crime, which involves individuals or
people.
When we think about crime, we usually think about crime. It is about understanding why certain
people as opposed to others become criminals.
What method is the only one that provides geographic info about crime? - ✔✔UCR
How is Space Defined? - ✔✔UCR provides crime data at 5 spatial units
5 spatial units of crime data from UCR - ✔✔National
Region
State
City (large cities defined as with a population of 100,000 or more. In U.S. about 300 fall under
this category)
County (over 3000 in US)
How does crime vary at different geographic units? - ✔✔Within the US there are dramatic
geographic differences in crime rates. When determining ranking keep in mind that this is based
on the average amount of crime rates being turned in.
Regions - ✔✔Crime rates are HIGHEST in South and West and LOWEST in Mid-West and
North-East. This is the case for both violent and property crime.
States - ✔✔Violent Crime:
1) Highest in South Carolina, Tennessee, and Florida
2) Lowest in Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire
Property Crime:
1) Highest in Arizona, South Carolina, New Mexico
2) Lowest in South Dakota, North Dakota, New York
Cities - ✔✔Violent Crime:
1) Highest in Detroit, St. Louis, Memphis
2) Lowest in Irvine, Naperville, Cary
Property Crime:
1) Highest in St. Louis, Springfield, Little Rock (AK)
2) Lowest in Thousand Oaks (Ca), Simi Valley (Ca), and Naperville (IL)
Counties - ✔✔Violent and Property Crime:
Highest: Urban areas
Lowest: Rural areas
Relationship is not perfect but pretty strong.
Spatial variation in crime within cities - ✔✔Early studies done with single city using push pins
on a map (ex. Chicago)
-Crime is not randomly distributed across neighborhoods rather it is concentrated in certain
neighborhoods.
Later studies use police agency data and crime mapping software
-Neighborhoods=consensus tracts
-Used as proxies for the neighborhoods
How does crime vary within cities? - ✔✔Crime is typically concentrated in a small number of
neighborhoods (i.e. consensus tracts) within a city.
High crime neighborhoods tend to be clustered together in space.
Explanations for spatial variation in crime: - ✔✔Some factors are only relevant to one unit of
analysis but other factors are relevant across unit of analysis:
1) Economic Deprevation
2) Residential Instability
3) Family Disruption
Economic Deprivation - ✔✔High rate of poverty, unemployment, people receiving government
assistance, low rate of educational attainment
Residential Instability - ✔✔People are frequently moving into and out of the area, reduces social
interactions between neighbors.
No one knows one another, people are less likely to question supervision of strangers and to look
out after one another.
Family disruption - ✔✔High % of female headed households, high rate of divorce with single
parent households= less time to supervise children and teenagers=more opportunity to engage in
crimes.
How does crime vary over TIME? - ✔✔Temporal variation in crime=crime trends
The goal is to understand whether (and why) the national-level crime rate is going up, down, or
staying the same over time
We will cover HISTORIC and CONTEMPORARY crime trends
Historic Crime Trends - ✔✔Crime trends from 1790s-1959
Mostly limited to studying contemporary crime trends
Exception: homicide is one crime that was recorded consistent enough to examine prior to 1960.
NYC starting in the 1790s, Chicago starting in the 1860's. Boston and Philadelphia follow
similar trends but we will focus on these 2.
3 generalizations about US historic crime trends - ✔✔1) Homicide fluctuated greatly between
1797 and 1959.
2) There was a large spike in homicide rates in 1860s for NYC (Boston and Philadelphia)
3) Large spike in homicide rate in the 1920s and 30s in Chicago
What led to the large spike in homicide in 1860s NYC? - ✔✔Historians contribute it to the Civil
War
Rapid population growth in NYC (Large waive of Irish and German immigrants coming to fight
for civil war)
Birth of the revolver
-Firearms that had to be loaded from the muzzle which took a while to load. Average person 3-5
minutes to load a musket or pistol version. You get 1 shot. Revolver has 6 shots, person much
less likely to get away.
What led to the large spike in homicide in 1920's and 30's Chicago? - ✔✔Great Depression
(1929-1930s) unemployment extremely high up to 30% of nation unemployed
Prohibition/ Organized Crime
-Mobster families fighting for turf, etc.
Rapid Population growth
Contemporary Crime Trends - ✔✔Crime trends from 1960s to present
Data availability:
1) UCR data 1930-present but not reliable until 1960
2) NCVS data 1973-present
3 generalizations about US contemporary crime trends - ✔✔1) A dramatic increase in crime
from 1960s to 1980s
2) A dramatic decrease in crime from 1991-1999. (Crim decreased by 30-40%)
3) Since 2000 crime rates have remained low and even declined.
Do the UCR and NCVS crime trends agree/disagree? - ✔✔Depends on the specific offense in
question.
Similar patterns for robbery, burglary, and motor vehicle theft. Differ in level of crime at each
year but follow basic trend as one goes up so does the other and vice versa. Crime trends are
similar not perfect, but relatively close.
Dissimilar patterns for rape and aggravated assault. For rape, police become more aware of how
they managed rape cases. Women's movement made police agencies change that.
Temporal Variation in Crime - ✔✔Contemporary crime trends pattern:
Both UCR and NCVS data show large decline in crime starting in the early 1900s through early
2000s.
Factors that may explain the 1990s crime drop - ✔✔1) Criminal Justice Practices
2) Social Factors
3) Demographic Factors
Criminal Justice Practices that led to 1990s crime drop - ✔✔1) Larger police force size
a) more officers were hired in an effort to combat crime
b) more police= reduction in crime
i) detterence= certainty of being caught goes up as number of officers go up= less crime being
committed
2) Police tactics
a) ex. Zero-tolerance, constant, hotspot
b) stop and frisk (simple practices done for minor arrests to deter larger crme)
3) Incarceration
a) introduction of several punitive sentencing laws aimed at reducing crime (ex. 3 strikes law)
Social Factors that led to 1990s crime drop - ✔✔1)Improved economic conditions
a) low unemployment and higher wages
2) Illicit drug markets stabilized (ex Crack)...believe it is due to decline of drug use and
manufacturing of crack
Demographic Factors that led to 1990s crime drop - ✔✔1) Fewer People in crime prone years
(ages 15-24)
a) this is the age range where people are at the highest risk of committing crime
2) Reduction in high risk births (e.g. Roe v Wade)
a) Book freakonomics explanation by Levitt was given in 2001. Argues that half of 1990s crime
drop was the overturn of previous ban on abortion so more abortions/terminations occurred.
Children born to unwanted mothers or single mothers are at an increased risk of criminal
behavior once they hit that 15-24 age range. Roe V Wade legalized abortion.
b) subsequent research has come out where one study looked at the effect of being born into an
unwanted family throughout life into adulthood. Children born into unwanted family had slightly
elevated risk of committing crimes and becoming criminals but not in early adulthood. He
speculated that there was no way it could account for 50% worth of crime drop in 1990s.
Seasonal Variation in Crime Background - ✔✔Within a given year, crim trends follow seasonal
patterns.
NCVS and UCR both come to the same conclusion: Crime PEAKS in the summer months and
(drops) TROUGHS in the winter months
Certain crimes less subject to seasonal variation (eg robbery)
Seasonal variation in crime is less pronounce in areas with stable year round temperatures (eg
FL, CA, WA)
Theoretical explanations for seasonal crime patterns - ✔✔1) Temperature aggression theory
(psych theory)
2) Routine Activities theory
Temperature aggression theory (psych theory) - ✔✔a) people become increasingly irritable and
aggressive as heat and humidity levels increase in summer, increasing the likelihood that people
will commit crime during this time.
b) health induced discomfort causes aggression during summer
c) less applicable to property crime
Routine Activities Theory - ✔✔1) Holds that crime is likely to occur when 3 key elements occur:
motivated offender, suitable target, absence of a capable guardian
2) Ex. Pleasant weather in summer encourages people to spend more time away from home
which increases victimization risks.
a) increase burglary while home is unoccupied
b) increased risks of assaults, thefts, etc. while out in public.
3) Other routine activities: summer vacations, schools out for the summer.
[Show More]