2. Board Meeting And General
Meeting Procedure
Board Meeting Decision Process p.15-19
Company Decisions Table p.20-28
General Meeting Process p.29-34
Shareholders Written Resolutions p.35-36
Shareholder Powers Tabl
...
2. Board Meeting And General
Meeting Procedure
Board Meeting Decision Process p.15-19
Company Decisions Table p.20-28
General Meeting Process p.29-34
Shareholders Written Resolutions p.35-36
Shareholder Powers Table p.37
Loans to Directors p.38-39
Substantial Property Transactions p.40-41© LPC Buddy
© LPC Buddy
16
Board Meeting Decision Process
❖ Business Law & Practice, 8.4
Overview ❖ A company cannot make decisions on its own; decisions are made on the company’s
behalf by either (a) the shareholders of the company (the company’s owners), or (b) the
company’s directors (the company’s managers).
❖ The majority of decisions are within the jurisdiction of the company’s directors. Where
directors make decisions, they may do so by two means:
➢ Holding a vote at a Board Meeting.
➢ Passing a directors’ written resolution.
❖ Passing decisions by vote at a Board Meeting requires the directors to comply with
certain procedural rules required by the Model Articles and CA 2006. These are outlined
below.
Exam
Technique
❖ A common examinable topic is for students to be presented with a range of decisions to
be taken and asked to advise on how these decisions may be carried out. When
preparing answers to exam questions on this subject, it is advisable to follow the
following structure:
❖ NQVA
➢ Notice
➢ Quorum
➢ Voting
➢ Administration
❖ The key is to (a) explain the law, but (b) always apply this to the facts of the particular
question you are asked.
Notice
Model Article
9
❖ A director may call a board meeting by “giving notice of the meeting to the directors”
(MA9(1)).
➢ The directors may, alternatively, authorise the company secretary to give
notice (MA9(1)).
➢ However you should only highlight this if relevant on the facts.
❖ Notice must be “Reasonable”:
➢ Re Homer District Consolidated Mines, Ex parte Smith (1888) 39 Ch D 546:
▪ What amount to reasonable notice depends on the circumstances.
▪ For small companies, just a few minutes might suffice.
▪ The key question is: have the directors had a reasonable opportunity to
attend?
▪ Apply to the facts; what is “reasonable” in the circumstances?© LPC Buddy
© LPC Buddy
17
❖ Contents of the Notice:
➢ Model Article 9(2): The notice must include:
▪ The proposed date and time of the meeting.
▪ The location.© LPC Buddy
© LPC Buddy
18
▪ How the directors will communicate if they are not in the same place.
❖ “Need not be in writing” (MA 9(3)).
➢ Oral notice is fine (Browne v La Trinidad (1887) 37 ChD 1 (CA))
❖ APPLICATION – CONSIDER:
➢ Who is calling the meeting and giving notice?
➢ Who must he serve the notice upon?
➢ The notice must be reasonable… What is “reasonable” in the circumstances?
➢ Are there any specific factors which might indicate that a lengthier notice is
appropriate, or are the directors all together, indicating a shorter notice is
appropriate?
Quorum
Model Article
11
❖ A “quorum” must be present at a board meeting for proposals to be voted upon.
➢ “Unless a quorum is participating, no proposal is to be voted on” at the meeting
(MA 11(1)).
❖ The “quorum” is the minimum number of directors who are required by the company’s
articles to be present for valid decisions to be taken at the meeting.
➢ This will not necessarily require all of the company’s directors to attend; the
key question is whether the minimum number have attended i.e. is the meeting
“quorate”.
❖ The quorum “must never be less than two” (MA 11(2)).
➢ Unless the total number of company directors is one, in which case one
director will suffice:
▪ (Model Article 7(2) provides that a single director can take decisions
“without regard to any of the provisions of the articles relating to
directors’ decision-making”).
▪ Only mention this if relevant.
➢ Note: a quorum is made up of directors only.
❖ APPLICATION - CONSIDER:
➢ Do we have a sufficient number of directors to constitute a quorum?
➢ Is there any reason why a director might be unable to attend?
➢ How will that impact on the resolution passing?
➢ If a director does not want a decision to go through, will his own absence prevent
it?
➢ Will there still be a quorum without him?
Conflicts of Interest:
❖ Even if a director can be/is present at the meeting, if:
➢ The vote concerns a transaction in which the director is interested
➢ He will be unable to participate in the quorum (MA14).
❖ Model Article 14(1): if the board are voting on an “actual or proposed transaction or
arrangement with the company in which a director is interested, that director is not to
be counted as participating in the decision-making process”.© LPC Buddy
© LPC Buddy
19
❖ Exception:
➢ If the decision in which a director is conflicted only requires approval by the
shareholders (e.g. approving an SPT);
➢ The conflicted director MAY count in the quorum to call the GM, as the decision
to call the GM is purely procedural (Business Law & Practice, 8.7.3.1)
❖ HOWEVER, check the following:
➢ Has Model Article 14 has been disapplied by a special article?
▪ The directors may have previously agreed to modify the company’s
constitution to disapply Model Article 14.
➢ Alternatively, do the exceptions in Model Article 14(3) and 14(4) apply?
▪ A director will not be prevented from participating in the quorum if:
• MA 14(3): His interest “cannot reasonably be regarded as likely to
give rise to a conflict of interest”.
• MA14(4)(a): the vote concerns a guarantee given to or by the
Director for an obligation of the company.
• MA 14(4)(b): the vote concerns a contract with the director to
buy shares in the company.
o E.g. WS 16, Task 1, Q4: Anna and Isabel sold their
partnership to a newly constituted company, Chapter Two
Books Ltd, of which they are the only directors. They
sought to issue themselves shares in the company as
consideration for the sale of the partnership to C2B Ltd.
o Although issuing shares to themselves is an interest in a
proposed transaction prohibited by MA14, the exception
in MA14(4)(b) applies.
➢ Alternatively, the shareholders may, by ordinary resolution, temporarily
disapply MA 14(1) under MA 14(3) which will allow D to count in the quorum.
❖ APPLICATION - CONSIDER:
➢ Are any directors prevents from voting, having regard to any conflicts of interest
and whether MA14 applies?
➢ Do any exceptions to MA14 apply?
➢ Do we have enough directors who are able to participate in the quorum to pass
the resolution?
Declarations ❖ If a director is, in any way, directly or indirectly interested in a proposed transaction, he
must declare the nature and extent of this by making a declaration at the board
meeting, or by written notice to the directors before the company enters into the
contract (s177).
Voting
Model Article
7
[Show More]