Phylogenetic Trees
Biology 180 Name
The table below summarizes key evolutionary innovations found in some major groups of animals. A “1” indicates
that the trait is present; a “0” indicates that it is absent. Assum
...
Phylogenetic Trees
Biology 180 Name
The table below summarizes key evolutionary innovations found in some major groups of animals. A “1” indicates
that the trait is present; a “0” indicates that it is absent. Assume that each of the traits is homologous in the groups
listed—for example, that the limbs of lizards and mammals are derived from limbs found in a common ancestor.
*Some snakes have vestigial hind limbs as embryos or as adults.
Use these data to estimate the evolutionary tree, or phylogeny, of the groups. Work backwards in time, like this:
1. Note that fur and lactation are found only in
mammals. Start drawing your tree by adding a
branch on the far right leading to mammals. Mark
the appearance of fur & lactation on the lineage
leading to mammals. We’ve done this for you.
2. Note that only lizards and snakes have scales
with keratin—meaning that they should be found
next to each other on the tree, joined by a
common ancestor that had scales with keratin.
Draw lines leading to lizards and snakes and
connect them to make a U-shaped bracket, then
add a line for their common ancestor ( ).
Add a “Scales” label to indicate when scales with
keratin evolved.
3. Now look at the “Amniotic egg” column. Only
lizards, mammals, and snakes have this trait; the
other groups do not. Thus, the amniotic egg is a
synapomorphy (shared derived trait) that defines
lizards+snakes+mammals as a monophyletic
group (branch on the tree). Use this information to
connect mammals to lizards+snakes. Add an
ancestral branch and “amniotic egg” label to show
where the trait evolved.
4. Examine the table again, and find
synapomorphies that will allow you to add rayfinned fish and amphibians to your tree. Label
where each synapomorphy evolved.
5. Notice that lampreys have none of the derived
traits in the table. Add a 6th branch leading to
“Lampreys” as an outgroup.
1
Jaws Limbs Amniotic egg Fur & lactation Scales with keratin
Lizards
Ray-finned fish
Mammals
Lampreys
Snakes 1
Amphibians
Mammals
Fur & lactation
Key
Scales
Lizards
Snakes
Amphibians
Limbs lost
Limbs
Ray-finned fish
Jaws
Lampreys
Amniotic
egg
Note: Your tree may loo
Which group is most closely related to the amphibians: lizards or lampreys? (This is the same as asking
which of the two groups shares a more recent common ancestor with amphibians.) Explain your reasoning
Which group is most closely related to the lampreys: Lizards or ray-finned fish? Explain your reasoning
From Aristotle to Lamarck (and even now!), people have claimed that mammals are “higher beings” than
amphibians. According to your evolutionary tree, is this correct? Explain why or why not Snakes don’t have limbs. Do they really belong in a monophyletic group with vertebrates that do have limbs?
Explain why or why not. (If appropriate, add a “limbs lost” label to your tree.) Relative to the last common ancestor of all the jawed vertebrates (meaning, the last common ancestor of all
of the groups on the tree except for lampreys), which of the jawed vertebrates on your tree has been evolving
for the longest amount of time? Explain your reasoning Lampreys don’t have jaws; they have a funnel-shaped sucking mouth studded with sharp teeth. Is either of
the following statements correct? Explain why or why not.
a) Lampreys are a basal (you could also say “primitive” or “ancestral”) group relative to the jawed vertebrates. Jawless mouths are a basal (you could also say “primitive” or “ancestral”) trait relative to the jawed mouths
of jawed vertebrates
[Show More]