• •
• Module Leader, SIM 335.
• University of Sunderland.
•
[email protected]
SIM sim 335
Managing Projects Planning and Monitoring Tools and Techniques
◦ Project Feasibility
◦ Project Life Cycle
◦ Project Objectives
◦ Planning the Project
◦ SequencingActivities
◦ PCs and Project Management SoftwareThe Management of Project Cost
Financial Project Appraisal
Payback
Net Present Value (NPV)
The Internal Rate of Return
Estimating Methods
Putting Together the Detailed Project Budget
Common Causes of Cost Problems
Unit 5 StructureFinancial Project Appraisal
•Clear project objectives and a project definition
document are essential to the success of the project.
• Investment decision, is a decision on:
• Whether or not to undertake an investment.
•When there are alternative choices for an investment,
selecting which of the mutual exclusive investment to
undertake.
•When capital for spending is in short supply, deciding
which investments to undertake with the money that is
available.Financial Project Appraisal
• Investment decisions need to be considered in the
light of strategic and tactical plans of the company.
• Most companies have a formal business case
system in place that includes a financial
appraisal of the project in one form or
another.
• Financial appraisal techniques include;
• Payback.
• Net Present Value (NPV)
• Internal Rate of Return (IRR)• Payback period
• Time taken to break even
• i.e. payback initial investment
• Projects with short payback periods are preferred
nowadays
• Does not consider income or expenditure after break
even point is reachedPayback period
Year Project 1 Project 2 Project 3 Project 4
0 -100,000 -1,000,000 -100,000 -120,000
1 10,000 200.000 30,000 30,000
2 10,000 200.000 30,000 30,000
3 10,000 200.000 30,000 30,000
4 20,000 200.000 30,000 30,000
5 100,000 300.000 30,000 75,000
Net Profit 50,000 100,000 50,000 75,000
Payback in 5th year
Payback in 4th year
Time taken to ‘break even’ i.e. payback initial investmentYear Project A Project B
0 (£35,000) (£35,000)
1 £20,000 £10,000
2 £15,000 £10,000
3 £10,000 £15,000
4 £10,000 £20,000
Payback Period 2 years 3 yearsMethod Advantages Disadvantages
Payback Simple and easy to
understand and
use
Objective – using cash flows
Liquidity – commercially
realistic
Cautious & risk averse –
ignores
later cash flows
Ignores the time
value
of money
Ignores cash flows
after the payback
period
Cost-Benefit Evaluation TechniquesDiscounted cash flow methods (DCF) NPV & IRR
• Take into account the change in value of money
over time due to inflation
• If this is not carried out, future cash flows are
distorted and do not reflect the true value of the
return
• Two main methods ‘net present value’ NPV and
‘internal rate of return’ IRR.• Net present value (NPV)
• Considers the profitability of a project
• Takes account of the time element
• NPV discounts future cash flows to current money
values it does this using a percentage rate called
the discount ratePV - Receiving a £1000 now, would be worth more
than receiving a £1000 in 5 years as this could be
reinvested with an additional rate of return being
received over the five years.
FV – Value of cash at a specified date in the future
that is equivalent in value to a specified sum today A
present value is the amount that would need to be
invested now to earn the future cash flow if the
money is invested at the “cost of capital”• NPV - The formula for net present values of future
cash flows is :-
• Present value = value in year t / (1+r)t
• where r is the discount expressed as a decimal value
• and t is the number of years in the future
• but it is simpler to use discount tables
• Present value = value in year t x discount factorAssuming a 10% discount rate, what is the NPV for project
1.
Year Project 1
cash flow
(£)
Discount
factor @
10%
Discounted
cash flow
(£)
0 -100,000 1.0000 -100,000
1 10,000 0.9091 9,091
2 10,000 0.8264 8,264
3 10,000 0.7513 7,513
4 20,000 0.6830 13,660
5 100,000 0.6209 62,090
Net Profit 50,000 NPV:£618And for a 12% discount factor, the NPV for project 1 was
-£6560
Year Project 1
cash flow
(£)
D iscount
factor @
5 %
D iscounted
cash flow
(£)
0 -100,000 1.0000 -100,000
1 10,000 0.893 8930
2 10,000 0.797 7970
3 10,000 0.712 7120
4 20,000 0.636 12720
5 100,000 0.567 56700
Net Profit 50,000 N P V : -£6560The NPV for all four projects.
Year Discount
factor @
10% Project 1
Discounted
Project 2
Cash flo
Project 3
w (£)
Project 4
0 1.0000 -100,000 -1,000,000 -100,000 -120,000
1 0.9091 9,091 181,820 27,273 27,273
2 0.8264 8,264 165,280 24,792 24,792
3 0.7513 7,513 150,260 22,539 22,539
4 0.6830 13,660 136,600 20,490 20,490
5 0.6209 62,090 186,270 18,627 46,568
NPV 618 -179,770 13,721 21,662• This example clearly shows the benefit of NPV:
• Project 4 provides the best rate of return.
• Projects 1 and 2 would not be considered any further
• Benefits
• Introduces time value of money into decision making process
• Expresses future cash-flows in today’s values
• Looks at whole project
• Tables exist for discounting factors
• Disadvantages
• Limited accuracy due to forecast of interest/inflationrates
• Not comparable with other investments/cost of borrowing capital
• An alternative would be to use Internal Rate of Return - IRR What’s the difference between £1 now and £1 in a year’s
time?
Factors change the value of money
Interest cost
Inflation
Time Value of MoneyMethod Advantages Disadvantages
NPV Takes account of the time
value of money
Concerns of shareholder
wealth
Takes account of risk
Looks at the whole life of
the project
Difficult to be
understood by
managers
Adverse effects on
accounting profits in the
short run
How to choose
discount rate?• The IRR method of discounted cash flow involves finding the percentage
rate of interest which, when used to discount the future cash flows, will
produce a zero net present value for a capital investmentproject,
• Provides a profitability measure as a percentage return
• This is directly comparable to an interest rate
• IRR is used in conjunction with NPV• The interest rate is determined by trial and error to
achieve a zero NPV. The higher the percentage
used to discount the lower will be the present
value.
• Calculation of IRR is by trial and error
• It can also be estimated using a graphical
approach• The idea here is to work out two values of NPV for a given
project, ones which are +ve and -ve
• And then plot these co-ordinates on a graph
• So, for the Project 1 example• Using the graphical method
NPV (£)
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
-2000
-1000
0
1000
2000
4000
3000
PROJECT 1
IRR (%)
-3000
- 4000
- 5000
- 6000
- 7000
IRR for project 1 approximately
10.2% The process of gathering data to develop an estimate for the
Project.
Estimating Methods include:
Parametric Modelling: Uses mathematical techniques to help with
costing estimates; for example, in the building industry square metre (£
per square metre) metrics are used.
Bottom Up: Estimates the activities at the bottom of the WBS first and
then works up through the WBS.
Analogous Method: Looks at the costs of similar projects and other
historical information
Simulation: Used on large or complex projects, software
calculates many costs or durations with different assumptions. The process of allocating the cost estimates to work items to
establish a cost baseline for measuring project performance.
Top Down Budgeting.
Based on collective judgments and experiences of top
and middle managers. Overall project cost estimated by
estimating costs of major tasks.
Bottom-Up Budgeting:
WBS or action plan identifies elemental tasks.
Those responsible for executing these tasks estimate
resource requirements. Detailed estimation of cost is called budgeting and is the
process of allocating the cost estimates to the activities
To prepare a project budget do the following:
Total the costs from each activity.
Total the direct costs from each activity estimate sheet.
Remember to include project management costs
Total indirect costs (overhead costs if your organisation
requires they be included in your budget).
Total cumulative costs. Basing estimates on poor information rather than detailed
specifications of the project at hand.
Failure to allow contingency, failure to correctly estimate
research and development activities.
Indiscriminate use of the contingency budget by activities or
people, who overrun their budget.
Receiving information too late to take corrective action. Burke, R. (2003) Project Management, Planning and Control
Techniques. John Wiley and Sons.
Field, M., Keller, L. (2007) Project Management. Open
University
Jordan, E.W. and Machesky, J.J. (1990) Evaluation, Design, and
Implementation, Boston, MA, PWS-Kent
Pinto, J. K. (2013) Project Management: Achieving
Competitive Advantage. Harlow: Pearson Education
Richman, L. (2002) Project Management Step-by-Step.
AMACOM.
Weiss, J and Wysocki, R. (1992) 5 Phase Project
Management:APractical Planning and Implementation Guide.
Cambridge MA: Perseus BooksThank You